This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Always Something to do with a shrinking world maybe.?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
The same people investing their money, thoughts,love,and just about life into said club. Not at all, I certainly do. But I don't expect Parish, Freedman or Hodgson to pay any real attention to my views, and quite rightly so. It's not that they are more competent than me (though they might be), or that they have achieved enough to be above question (though they have achieved a huge amount). It's simply that they know the club, the business, the finances, the people, all to an extent I cannot possibly do.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
You’ve made some good posts on 1) Small clubs playing anti-football less likely to be relegated and small clubs playing pretty football more likely to be relegated and the issues with making the change and making that change in the top flight. 2) Interviewing Eddie Howe. 3) Your point above, only the immediate issue at the present time is something the whole football community can see, before how the owners run the club. We’ve gone from keeping it tight and 0-0 to try and nip a goal and hold out, to shipping goals in right after the opposition have had 12 touches of the ball. The players and management team need to sort it out and quickly before we get to facing that run in of matches. I agree completely, improvement in performances is needed, and effort seems a part of that. If we were in the ground on match days we could vent that, and the players would hear it, so I get the need to tell them in some other way. My concern is that the letter goes on to cover the wider running of the club, transfer policy, investment, tactics and stuff like that. I would expect the club to roll their eyes and ignore that stuff.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I agree completely, improvement in performances is needed, and effort seems a part of that. If we were in the ground on match days we could vent that, and the players would hear it, so I get the need to tell them in some other way. My concern is that the letter goes on to cover the wider running of the club, transfer policy, investment, tactics and stuff like that. I would expect the club to roll their eyes and ignore that stuff. I think the issues with the Manager and the players performances are the effect, and the way the club has been run, the cause. Yes, they can choose to ignore part if not all of the letter, but it needed to be said.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
I have been watching Palace since the fourth division days and Millwall were always without doubt the rivals, proper rivals and the crowds used to show up to confirm it.I remember 36000 at Selhurst before all seater days. Having spent most of my life supporting Palace in the lower leagues I have no fear of relegation if it means we can build on young players and passing football.
[Link] |
|
|
Originally posted by billtheglazier
I have been watching Palace since the fourth division days and Millwall were always without doubt the rivals, proper rivals and the crowds used to show up to confirm it.I remember 36000 at Selhurst before all seater days. Absolutely.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
The bit in the letter/statement about losing games without a fight, and a lack of leadership and pride on the pitch is fair on recent performances (and recent performances alone by the way), and I’m sure many of us would make a similar point, loudly, if in the ground this season. Otherwise, the statement certainly doesn’t speak for me, even though I think I’ve earned the title of a ‘committed supporter’ by now. I don’t want the ultras, or even the wider fan base having a say on formations or team selections thanks. We’ve all got our opinions, but that's all they are. Give youth a chance they cry! Not a single one of us has the experience, knowledge and access to say that a single one of our youth team would improve our first team. Not one. It’s a classic statement of its type: A big sweeping, crowd pleasing demand made from a position of absolutely no knowledge, or responsibility for the outcome. The idea of there being a ‘Palace way’ is odd. What's that then? Is it as meaningless and vague as the West Ham way, or the Spurs Way? Always thought that stuff sounded like total bollocks personally. Which youth was 'put front and centre' of the promotion side the statement cites as a true example of The Palace Way exactly? Zaha, and, um, oh that's right, nobody else at all. Salako and Shaw were the only youth players in the 1990 side. Dowie got us promoted without a single youth team graduate, and of that team only Black and Grey were even young. Still, it sounds good when you say it, so that'll do. The complaint of having no ambition or vision is just utter s***e. As several people have posted on here, the club has outlined, and made progress on a clearly defined, realistic long term strategy. One might not like the strategy, but to say it doesn’t exist is the kind of ridiculous ignorance that gets public opinion ignored. Personally I hope Parish sticks with his eminently sensible strategy come what may. He has achieved as much if not more than any chairman in palace history. Still, better to have a pop though eh? ‘We must...use this opportunity with so many expiring contracts to make substantial changes across the club’. Good idea. Lets release all 12 of them, and have whip round for the £70m or so it would cost to replace even half of them. Oh hang on, what's that calling us? Oh, it's the real world, asking us to come back...
Edited by TheBigToePunt (17 Feb 2021 4.49pm) Reasonable points. There's obviously a great sense of frustration at our uninspiring, half-hearted performances. Imagine if grounds were open and this protest found its way into the stadium? Banners unfurled, chants of Hodgson Out! Parish Out!? Who knows where it might lead. The management and players ought to take heed. It's easy for them to hide behind an empty stadium, yet it would be counter productive in the long run for any such protest to grow wings. I doubt it would make much a difference to those players whose contracts are up anyway, they already seem to have an eye on the exit door if their lack of effort is anything to go by. Edited by southnorwoodhill (17 Feb 2021 5.24pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
Think Ultras stood up for any true Palace fan. Well written - hope someone with power takes notice. I am a true Palace fan. They do not and never will speak for me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Absolutely. Agree, Roy is being paid to do a job and I imagine that job description is simple, keep the club in the division full stop.
|
|
|
Originally posted by est1905
I am a true Palace fan. They do not and never will speak for me. Are they not true palace fans with a different take on it.
|
|
|
No s*** !!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Reasonable points. There's obviously a great sense of frustration at our uninspiring, half-hearted performances. Imagine if grounds were open and this protest found its way into the stadium? Banners unfurled, chants of Hodgson Out! Parish Out!? Who knows where it might lead. The management and players ought to take heed. It's easy for them to hide behind an empty stadium, yet it would be counter productive in the long run for any such protest to grow wings. I doubt it would make much a difference to those players whose contracts are up anyway, they already seem to have an eye on the exit door if their lack of effort is anything to go by. Edited by southnorwoodhill (17 Feb 2021 5.24pm) Whether in the ground or not, I think the danger is that if a person or group has a reasonable point (in this case, an apparent lack of effort and heart in recent performances) but they sandwich it between a load of unreasonable points (as listed in my previous), then nobody really gives a s*** what they have to say. The reasonable point they had gets lost, and becomes mistaken for nonsense along the way. Which is a shame, as a lot of good, useful criticisms and ideas get lost that way, and people who ought to have had to face reasonable scrutiny (most of us from time to time in different ways) both want to, and get to, evade it. It would all be easier if we could currently lean over the hoarding at Selhurst and shout 'Luka! Benteke! Batshuyi! Run about a bit you f***ing lazy t***s!'. Now that, is a reasonable point. Edited by TheBigToePunt (17 Feb 2021 6.26pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Whether in the ground or not, I think the danger is that if a person or group has a reasonable point (in this case, an apparent lack of effort and heart in recent performances) but they sandwich it between a load of unreasonable points (as listed in my previous), then nobody really gives a s*** what they have to say. The reasonable point they had gets lost, and becomes mistaken for nonsense along the way. Which is a shame, as a lot of good, useful criticisms and ideas get lost that way, and a good few people get to evade reasonable points that they should have confronted. It would all be easier if we could currently lean over the hoarding at Selhurst and shout 'Luka! Benteke! Batshuyi! Run about a bit you f***ing lazy t***s!'. Now that, is a reasonable point. Yes, I suspect that the letter comes out of a frustration not to be able to air those very sentiments.
|
|
|
Originally posted by est1905
I am a true Palace fan. They do not and never will speak for me. Nor me!
Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes. |
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Yes, I suspect that the letter comes out of a frustration not to be able to air those very sentiments. I've always been under the impression that most of our players don't really give a flying monkey's about any rivalries even the Brighton games. I can't recall ever seeing them playing with any added enthusiasm which would suggest this and without the crowds I am not really expectant of this. I get the impression the fans are expecting a different performance based on the opposition and am not too sure this affects the players as they would wish. With regards to the 'Ultras', I didn't care too much to dissect what they have said, I am just hoping that the fact they said something might have some affect. As far as I am concerned they could have printed a 30ft long banner with boooooo! written across it.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Absolutely. Until we are relegated, then what? We have been fortunate during the past half dozen seasons or so but I fear lady luck may not so kind in the future.
"Billy Gilbert really is God" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.