This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
200k a week on a 4 year deal offered. A replacement will be 30-40 million on 120k plus a week. I think it's a good deal for all parties. But...would we be paying £30-40m for a 30 year old....I think not
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
But...would we be paying £30-40m for a 30 year old....I think not Thats true. We could pay that amount for a 24 year old and he would be a flop? Didint we pay 32 million for benteke / sahko and got 1 or 2 good seasons out of them when they were in thier mid late 20s?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
That's a recipe for disaster as he would never pass the ball to a team mate and risk losing £100,000 and he would prefer to try for goal himself even if someone else is better placed. Anyway why would he accept such a package when other teams are likely to offer more with the prospect of European football thrown in No big change there so Mids
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Zaha's English options don't look great at the moment. On the fact that he plays left of a front 3. All the top teams have really strong depth, I havent looked at it this closely before but that position seams seriously sacked. City Arsenal Man U Liverpool Spurs They aint offering 100+ for a 3rd choice. So IMO his only real options are the top of the midfield (traditionally speaking). Brighton, but is he better than Mitoma. Newcastle, but have ASM, and spent big on Gordon. Villa, Brentford, Fulham..... Chelsea would definitely be stupid enough to offer this.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Zaha's English options don't look great at the moment. On the fact that he plays left of a front 3. All the top teams have really strong depth, I havent looked at it this closely before but that position seams seriously sacked. City Arsenal Man U Liverpool Spurs They aint offering 100+ for a 3rd choice. So IMO his only real options are the top of the midfield (traditionally speaking). Brighton, but is he better than Mitoma. Newcastle, but have ASM, and spent big on Gordon. Villa, Brentford, Fulham..... I think Arsenal are in need of more strength in depth, that could be an option for him. I think he's better than Sessegnon and Perisic, although a different kind of player than either of them, so Spurs a possibility. Chelsea like to have a lot of different options but are unlikely to be able to offer European football next season. Although it's hard to envisage Wilf moving North, Newcastle can afford his wages, offer European football and I think they are likely to sell ASM... As for suggesting Brighton....
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Zaha127
Good discussion on Talksport today with Simon Jordan. £200k on a 5 year contract would cost around £18m extra over 5 years from his current salary. It is hard to find a good winger for under £20m now. Plus you got a new player's wages as well. Zaha knows the EPL. If Palace keep Zaha and improve their squad (e.g. new RB, another midfielder and striker) they could easily come top 10 next year. Edited by Zaha127 (17 May 2023 1.55pm) I wouldn't be hopeful of getting 5 years worth of good play from someone who is already suffering increasingly frequent non-contact injuries at 30 years of age.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
This is a £42m gamble on the state of Wilf's body, a body that has been high impact twisting and turning for roughly 25 years (since he started as a child). And it is a gamble we don't need to take. This is exactly the moment to say thanks so much for everything, good luck. It screams lack of confidence in our scouting. Scouting that really has started to come good of late. And it creates envy I'd still offer him a contract. He's still one of he first names on the team sheet. But not 200k for 5 years. Current salary'ish for 2+1 feels reasonable. But as you said we have shown that we can find players for cheaper, with huge sell on potential. Olise - 8m fee + 12m salary but we also make mistakes: Edouard 18m fee + 20m salary
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
This is a £42m gamble on the state of Wilf's body, a body that has been high impact twisting and turning for roughly 25 years (since he started as a child). And it is a gamble we don't need to take. This is exactly the moment to say thanks so much for everything, good luck. It screams lack of confidence in our scouting. Scouting that really has started to come good of late. And it creates envy Couldn't disagree more. A gamble? You mean like money spent on the likes of Edouard or Mateta? I'd rather wilf has an injury every now and then, than be a total sack of spuds on the pitch. He costs nothing in buying him, he is still very skillful and puts in a shift most of the time. He draws fouls, draws players to him, knows the team inside and out, knows the ethos of Palace, has a go at players who aren't putting in the effort, he is a role model to the younger players we are getting in, he has carried this team for years before this season, you need to keep some of the older players to instill a mindset and attitude for playing for Palace. Once Ward goes... there really isn't any of the old squad left from promotion (at least who I can think of) who knows what it takes to fight to keep a squad up. I think he puts I far more than just a goal or 2. Look at other clubs who just buy a load of players in. The new players don't usually gives 2 turds as to what the club is about nor care if they stay up. You can buy in loads of young talent but it doesn't mean they'll be able to cut it in the Premier league as well as being far more likely to be prone to making errors and having lapses in concentration. In any case, I think it's a good decision.
|
|
|
Get him signed up. It would cost 30/40 million to buy a player half the calibre of Wilf.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
No big change there so Mids Just a quick reminder for Midlands about Zaha’s pass for Eze last Saturday.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Just a quick reminder for Midlands about Zaha’s pass for Eze last Saturday. Dont mention the hundreds of times he should have taken the easier option and passed instead of trying to take on just that one player too many only to blast it into the upper Homelsdale.
|
|
|
It’s not just his value on the pitch Players like Eze and Olise will learn from him and may be more inclined to stick around.
|
|
|
Originally posted by becky
I wouldn't be hopeful of getting 5 years worth of good play from someone who is already suffering increasingly frequent non-contact injuries at 30 years of age. On the other hand we shouldn't underestimate him, his genuine love of Palace, and his physical resilience? He has several months to do his rehab now... if he does stay at Palace he could be back to his best for a couple of years? Time will tell
|
|
|
Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1
Couldn't disagree more. A gamble? You mean like money spent on the likes of Edouard or Mateta? I'd rather wilf has an injury every now and then, than be a total sack of spuds on the pitch. He costs nothing in buying him, he is still very skillful and puts in a shift most of the time. He draws fouls, draws players to him, knows the team inside and out, knows the ethos of Palace, has a go at players who aren't putting in the effort, he is a role model to the younger players we are getting in, he has carried this team for years before this season, you need to keep some of the older players to instill a mindset and attitude for playing for Palace. Once Ward goes... there really isn't any of the old squad left from promotion (at least who I can think of) who knows what it takes to fight to keep a squad up. I think he puts I far more than just a goal or 2. Look at other clubs who just buy a load of players in. The new players don't usually gives 2 turds as to what the club is about nor care if they stay up. You can buy in loads of young talent but it doesn't mean they'll be able to cut it in the Premier league as well as being far more likely to be prone to making errors and having lapses in concentration. In any case, I think it's a good decision. Very good post. Well put
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
This is a £42m gamble on the state of Wilf's body, a body that has been high impact twisting and turning for roughly 25 years (since he started as a child). And it is a gamble we don't need to take. This is exactly the moment to say thanks so much for everything, good luck. It screams lack of confidence in our scouting. Scouting that really has started to come good of late. And it creates envy You could say exactly the same about ANY incoming expensive signing. Only difference is Palace know ALL of Zaha's medical history already so any risk is way smaller than if he left and we had to sign an expensive replacement.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
But my point was would he have done that if he was on £100,000 per goal as was suggested
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.