You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Just Wanna Say...
November 19 2026 5.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Just Wanna Say...


Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 17 Jan 03 10.09am

Quote Petealiator at 17 Jan 2003 9:40am

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 17 Jan 2003 8:41am

Most of you are essentially espousing vigilantism, and saying that it's alright for us to take the law into our own hands. Fair enough, if that's what you believe -- but where do you draw the line? What about the example quoted of an abused wife, would you prosecute? What if a bus driver ran over and killed someone for swearing at them, is that OK? After all, they could claim they were in fear of being attacked... Where does it stop?

Oh come on Slugs, you know what we're all talking about here is the sanctity of one's home, an Englishman's home is his castle etc, if you want to call vigilantism, fair enough, I'd call it self defence - which it is the minute they step into your home and threaten your safety. It stops there, simple. We should be able to use whatever means available to protect ourselves from, as you said, knives, guns, dirty needles, whatever, just as Tony Martin did, the only thing he at hand had that was gonna turn around his situation was a gun, so he blasted the b****** into the darkness. He couldn't run, there was no back way out of the house. I take your point and agree, Tony Martin should be in a hospital getting the help he needs not banged up with hardened criminals. If the vermin hadn't entered his home, he'd be out tending his farm now with his dogs at his side, not sitting in a cold cell. HE'S THE VICTIM!

Despotic, good post, I thought you'd following the predictable left-wing red-brick road on this one, jumping to the defence of the REAL criminals in this case, but I was wrong, nice one.

All the threads that Slugs had a moan about aren’t about hatred or politics, Christ, all people want is to feel safe on their own streets and safe in their homes, is that really too much to ask for?

I understand your point Pete, but my question remains... where do you draw the line? You obviously feel it is acceptable to take a life in certain circumstances, and clearly you would go further than the law allows. But how far?

Don't you see? One man's limit is another man's fair game. Not everyone is as level-headed as you, and Martin is a perfect example -- an unbalanced mind frozen with fear, and a deadly weapon. Not a good combination, I'm sure you'll agree. Matt with a big lump of metal is scary enough.

Incidentally, was his gun held legally? A genuine question, I just wondered.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

matt_the_eagle Flag Tulse Thrill 17 Jan 03 10.36am

Quote Bexter at 17 Jan 2003 10:08am

I'm not against using force against a b****** burgler, but not a loaded gun UNLESS he was threatening my life or anyone elses, which most burglers don't do they? they are scum, you have every right to batter them, but i cannot see how you can justify killing someone if they pose no threat to anyones elses life. And no one has mentioned his family and friends who will miss him for the rest of their lives. No one has answered my question that if one of your relatives was burgling and got shot and killed - would you think he had deserved it?


Fair comment, I know I wouldn't kill them, just knock them out.

 


I think Keith Murray said it best when he rapped
"If you aint fly you cant play with my yo-yo".

I'm sure you'll agree.

matt_the_eagle Flag Tulse Thrill 17 Jan 03 10.37am

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 17 Jan 2003 10:09am

Quote Petealiator at 17 Jan 2003 9:40am

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 17 Jan 2003 8:41am

Most of you are essentially espousing vigilantism, and saying that it's alright for us to take the law into our own hands. Fair enough, if that's what you believe -- but where do you draw the line? What about the example quoted of an abused wife, would you prosecute? What if a bus driver ran over and killed someone for swearing at them, is that OK? After all, they could claim they were in fear of being attacked... Where does it stop?

Oh come on Slugs, you know what we're all talking about here is the sanctity of one's home, an Englishman's home is his castle etc, if you want to call vigilantism, fair enough, I'd call it self defence - which it is the minute they step into your home and threaten your safety. It stops there, simple. We should be able to use whatever means available to protect ourselves from, as you said, knives, guns, dirty needles, whatever, just as Tony Martin did, the only thing he at hand had that was gonna turn around his situation was a gun, so he blasted the b****** into the darkness. He couldn't run, there was no back way out of the house. I take your point and agree, Tony Martin should be in a hospital getting the help he needs not banged up with hardened criminals. If the vermin hadn't entered his home, he'd be out tending his farm now with his dogs at his side, not sitting in a cold cell. HE'S THE VICTIM!

Despotic, good post, I thought you'd following the predictable left-wing red-brick road on this one, jumping to the defence of the REAL criminals in this case, but I was wrong, nice one.

All the threads that Slugs had a moan about aren’t about hatred or politics, Christ, all people want is to feel safe on their own streets and safe in their homes, is that really too much to ask for?

I understand your point Pete, but my question remains... where do you draw the line? You obviously feel it is acceptable to take a life in certain circumstances, and clearly you would go further than the law allows. But how far?

Don't you see? One man's limit is another man's fair game. Not everyone is as level-headed as you, and Martin is a perfect example -- an unbalanced mind frozen with fear, and a deadly weapon. Not a good combination, I'm sure you'll agree. Matt with a big lump of metal is scary enough.

Incidentally, was his gun held legally? A genuine question, I just wondered.


Particularly with my new hair cut.

 


I think Keith Murray said it best when he rapped
"If you aint fly you cant play with my yo-yo".

I'm sure you'll agree.

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 17 Jan 03 10.42am

Quote Bexter at 17 Jan 2003 10:08am

I'm not against using force against a b****** burgler, but not a loaded gun UNLESS he was threatening my life or anyone elses, which most burglers don't do they? they are scum, you have every right to batter them, but i cannot see how you can justify killing someone if they pose no threat to anyones elses life. And no one has mentioned his family and friends who will miss him for the rest of their lives. No one has answered my question that if one of your relatives was burgling and got shot and killed - would you think he had deserved it?

His argument was that he did consider his life to be threatened! And, if you're content to give someone a battering, what happens if the little git dies of his injuries afterwards? No-one mentions Tony Martin's family and friends, either, who'd have missed him as well if the original murder verdict had been upheld. And, in answer to your final point, anyone who goes in to a place with intent to rob places themself at risk that they may encounter someone even more violent than themselves so they can't really complain about the outcome, regardless of whether they're related to me or not.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Bexter Flag By the Sea 17 Jan 03 11.01am

sorry cucking, i thought the kid was shot in the back, i don't really know why he felt his life was in danger - was fred armed? why was his back to tony? burglary is a violent crime in that it's violent towards a persons property... but not them, except very rarely. Your relative would not be able to complain if they were fred would they? they'd be dead. Tony Martin would be missed by his family of course, but not forever.

Edited by Bexter (17 Jan 2003 11:01am)

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 17 Jan 03 11.03am

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 17 Jan 2003 10:09am

I understand your point Pete, but my question remains... where do you draw the line? You obviously feel it is acceptable to take a life in certain circumstances, and clearly you would go further than the law allows. But how far?

Don't you see? One man's limit is another man's fair game. Not everyone is as level-headed as you, and Martin is a perfect example -- an unbalanced mind frozen with fear, and a deadly weapon. Not a good combination, I'm sure you'll agree. Matt with a big lump of metal is scary enough.

Incidentally, was his gun held legally? A genuine question, I just wondered.

You draw the line at the doorstep of someone's home. I also sleep tooled-up - my enemies are many - I have a baseball bat next to the bed, a small baton tucked under the mattress just in case, and various hidden 'items' strategically placed around the house, believe me, if someone comes in uninvited they're gonna be leaving in an ambulance. I certainly wouldn't try to kill them, but I wouldn't be too careful how hard I hit 'em and if they die from injuries received, that's their own fault. In my book I would have used 'justified force'. OK, You can't justify actually killing in cold blood, but as it stands, we have no rights in our own home, you hurt the intruder, you get punished and possibly sued. The law must change and reflect our fears.


Yeah, it was legal, it's part of a farmer’s tool kit apparently.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Bexter Flag By the Sea 17 Jan 03 11.07am

at last i see where you are coming from. killing is not justified and yes, it's plain wrong that you cannot defend your own home without fear of imprisonment indeed. plain stupid.

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 17 Jan 03 11.11am

Quote Bexter at 17 Jan 2003 11:01am

sorry cucking, i thought the kid was shot in the back, i don't really know why he felt his life was in danger - was fred armed? why was his back to tony? burglary is a violent crime in that it's violent towards a persons property... but not them, except very rarely. Your relative would not be able to complain if they were fred would they? they'd be dead. Tony Martin would be missed by his family of course, but not forever.

Edited by Bexter (17 Jan 2003 11:01am)


Bloody Hell Bexter, will you listen to the facts and take them on board! The place was in TOTAL darkness, Martin couldn't even see the kid, he just blasted the darkness, the kid wasn't running away if that's what you're implying, he just happened to be facing the other way. I still don't see how you can't grasp the fact that Tony Martin's life WAS at risk, for all he knew they could have been crazed junkies!
'Hello, who's there? Could you tell me if you're armed and intend to kill me, coz if you aint, I'll let you just carry on, if you answer's yes, have some of this ya f***ers; Booom!'
Yeah right, that'll work!
'No Mr Farmer, you just toodle off to bed, we're only here for ya telly, night night!'

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 17 Jan 03 11.14am

Quote Bexter at 17 Jan 2003 11:01am

sorry cucking, i thought the kid was shot in the back, i don't really know why he felt his life was in danger - was fred armed? why was his back to tony? burglary is a violent crime in that it's violent towards a persons property... but not them, except very rarely. Your relative would not be able to complain if they were fred would they? they'd be dead. Tony Martin would be missed by his family of course, but not forever.

Edited by Bexter (17 Jan 2003 11:01am)

The gun was fired into the blackness of night. Tony martin had no idea whether the kid was armed or not. Given the fact that carrying arms seems to be de rigeur for many criminals nowadays, I, for one, would support him in making that assumption. What is beyond dispute, however, is that Tony Martin was absolutely terrified, having already been the victim of several other burglaries. Your contention that burglary seldom involves violence is, at best, debatable. The burglar takes the risk when he enters premises unlawfully. If you are acting unlawfully, it can be argued that you forfeit your right to the protection of the law. You can't disrespect it on one hand and then expect it to protect you on the other.


 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 17 Jan 03 11.19am

The reason the parole board didn't let Tony Martin out, I've just read, is that he's "a danger to burglars." This seems a bit of a harsh reason for keeping someone incarcerated for a good few years of his life.

 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

matt_the_eagle Flag Tulse Thrill 17 Jan 03 11.25am

Quote Cucking Funt at 17 Jan 2003 11:14am

Quote Bexter at 17 Jan 2003 11:01am

sorry cucking, i thought the kid was shot in the back, i don't really know why he felt his life was in danger - was fred armed? why was his back to tony? burglary is a violent crime in that it's violent towards a persons property... but not them, except very rarely. Your relative would not be able to complain if they were fred would they? they'd be dead. Tony Martin would be missed by his family of course, but not forever.

Edited by Bexter (17 Jan 2003 11:01am)

The gun was fired into the blackness of night. Tony martin had no idea whether the kid was armed or not. Given the fact that carrying arms seems to be de rigeur for many criminals nowadays, I, for one, would support him in making that assumption. What is beyond dispute, however, is that Tony Martin was absolutely terrified, having already been the victim of several other burglaries. Your contention that burglary seldom involves violence is, at best, debatable. The burglar takes the risk when he enters premises unlawfully. If you are acting unlawfully, it can be argued that you forfeit your right to the protection of the law. You can't disrespect it on one hand and then expect it to protect you on the other.

That's a really good point.


 


I think Keith Murray said it best when he rapped
"If you aint fly you cant play with my yo-yo".

I'm sure you'll agree.

Bexter Flag By the Sea 17 Jan 03 11.25am

they were both in the wrong. you can't burgle, it's despicable, you can't go shooting at people, both illegal though in this case one was punishable by death and one by a few years inside.

 

Standyc Flag New York 17 Jan 03 11.28am

Quote the despotic banana at 17 Jan 2003 11:19am

The reason the parole board didn't let Tony Martin out, I've just read, is that he's "a danger to burglars." This seems a bit of a harsh reason for keeping someone incarcerated for a good few years of his life.


then surely keeping him in prison with burglars is more dangerous!

oh but I forgot that burglars don't actually get punished under the joke that is British Law which makes the victims into the criminals. but that's ok with the 'go soft on the ciminals - it's not their fault' brigade. makes me f*cking sick

 


"I'm no respecter of tradition and I have no time for the Manchester Uniteds and Arsenals of this world."

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 17 Jan 03 11.28am

Quote the despotic banana at 17 Jan 2003 11:19am

The reason the parole board didn't let Tony Martin out, I've just read, is that he's "a danger to burglars." This seems a bit of a harsh reason for keeping someone incarcerated for a good few years of his life.

British justice...They make it up as they go along! It's sick!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Standyc Flag New York 17 Jan 03 11.34am

and I just read that big Dunc will receive no punishment for restraining that burglar.

[Link]

maybe there is some sense out there but it wouldn't have surprised me it they hadn't "made an example" out of him.

 


"I'm no respecter of tradition and I have no time for the Manchester Uniteds and Arsenals of this world."

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 17 Jan 03 12.55pm

One thing I've learned from this thread, is that I'm never going round Pete's place or Matt's place!! Boys... you are scary.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Eagle_Eye Flag Coulsdon 17 Jan 03 2.58pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 17 Jan 2003 12:55pm

One thing I've learned from this thread, is that I'm never going round Pete's place or Matt's place!! Boys... you are scary.


Only scary to burglars.

 


Extran Orange - The Best Hangover Cure in Europe

You boys are a credit to your club and your parents - Russell Hayward (Mount Pleasant B&B Blackpool)

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 17 Jan 03 3.37pm

Some of you seem to feel that burglary is a minor crime, just the theft of a few easily replaceable electrical items. Well to you it may be just that but to others, particularly the elderly or the isolated, it can be as psychologically damaging as a rape or a bereavement.

Tony Martin was repeatedly targeted by burglars and this played a major part in his increasing paranoia and mental instability.

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 17 Jan 03 4.50pm

Quote Meerkat 2 at 17 Jan 2003 3:37pm

Some of you seem to feel that burglary is a minor crime, just the theft of a few easily replaceable electrical items. Well to you it may be just that but to others, particularly the elderly or the isolated, it can be as psychologically damaging as a rape or a bereavement.

Tony Martin was repeatedly targeted by burglars and this played a major part in his increasing paranoia and mental instability.

Not so, Meerkat mate. It's just that some of us don't think that burglary is sufficiently serious to merit killing someone.

Yes, it is frightening and awful -- but 99% of the time your life is NOT in danger. And so killing for supposed self-defence seems to me to be something of an overreaction.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Bexter Flag By the Sea 17 Jan 03 4.51pm

i think you are on dodgy ground saying that it is as damaging as rape. and i don't believe in the death penalty for rape, burglary, or manslaughter, luckily for tony martin, not so luckily for fred barrass.

 

Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Just Wanna Say...