You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 7.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 399 of 753 < 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 >
BlueJay Flag UK 01 Nov 20 4.58pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

And here we again get to excess deaths being no different. But I can imagine you can create a perfectly good explanation as to why the excess deaths are the same but mainly elderly people with underlying health conditions are dying of Covid but not the other illnesses.


You've just completely ignored the fact that something you believe and have posted multiple times was entirely and provably inaccurate and misleading. You just change the subject when realities you don't like are highlighted, as if stating nonsense is fine if it props up outlook that you hold. If a person doesn't have the awareness (or more likely concern) that what they're posting is misleading or fabricated, nor the integrity to admit that once it's pointed out, then there is little point discussing anything with them.


So again with regard to the flu info you posted:

- The propoganda image and data excludes certain lower number years
- The author purposefully used an entirely different measure for this year than prior years to distort the data
- One set (PHE) is an 'estimates' (something you fob off in an instant when it relates to the coronavirus) the other death certificate deaths (ONS)
-If actual deaths are use there are multiple years that are already 'lower' than this year
-If PHE data is used we are early in the flu season and so the inference on the image that this years number is in, is entirely false
- the pneumonia info stated is also 'fantasyland'

There is no quality control, because you patently don't care if what you say is true, as absolutely anything that fits your idea that you're being misled by the government ticks the only box that matters for you. Ironically in adopting such a fervent and blinkered approach you are both the person who is misleading, and the person being misled.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Nov 20 4.58pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I agree. I was joking.

I realised that but some on here need it to be stressed more imo. Wonder how many truthfully wanted a total ban on air travel? And I don’t mean just between Gatwick and Newquay

Edited by Spiderman (01 Nov 2020 5.01pm)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 01 Nov 20 5.00pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

We should have had a total lockdown in March, ie all airports shut except for repatriation, to be receiving flights from China whilst we couldn’t visit family was totally unacceptable. Even now we are allowing foreign travellers in with absolutely no way of checking they are self- isolating. Please don’t say we have that ability because we don’t, no way of checking addresses before they leave the airport. Brits refusing to give details and EU nationals coming to stay in caravans are a daily occurrence

I must admit it did seem rather mad at the time that we were playing covid whack-a-mole when people were breezing in from Italy with the virus in their droves. Countries like New Zealand clearly made the right call at least in terms of local lives and business functioning as normal.

Even Australia and their tough measures really appear to have made a serious dent in the progress of the virus (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-54768038 ), which can make all the difference when better treatments and vaccines may be on the horizon. Better to have bought time with travel restrictions and localised apoproaches rather than endless late in the day nationwide lockdowns.

Edited by BlueJay (01 Nov 2020 5.00pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Nov 20 5.02pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

I must admit it did seem rather mad at the time that we were playing covid whack-a-mole when people were breezing in from Italy with the virus in their droves. Countries like New Zealand clearly made the right call at least in terms of local lives and business functioning as normal.

Even Australia and their tough measures really appear to have made a serious dent in the progress of the virus (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-australia-54768038 ), which can make all the difference when better treatments and vaccines may be on the horizon. Better to have bought time with travel restrictions and localised apoproaches rather than endless late in the day nationwide lockdowns.

Edited by BlueJay (01 Nov 2020 5.00pm)

At least a month into lockdown we were still having inbound flights from mainland China ffs! No excuses for that

 

BlueJay Flag UK 01 Nov 20 5.06pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

At least a month into lockdown we were still having inbound flights from mainland China ffs! No excuses for that

Yes, it was ridiculous. Logically that decision alone have us no way out.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 01 Nov 20 5.09pm

Antibodies produced by COVID-19 patients to fight disease have more staying power than once thought - [Link]


Quote A new study of 30,000 COVID-19 patients suggests that the antibodies people produce to fight off the virus last longer than previously believed.

The finding should help vaccine makers as well as researchers who have been trying to determine whether COVID-19 survivors can become reinfected.

"Some (studies) reported declines in antibodies the first few weeks and first months and that isn't what we have seen," said Ania Wajnberg, lead author of the new study and medical director of Mount Sinai's clinical antibody testing program.

"We see a slight decline, but overall a stable level."

The paper, published this week in the journal Science, reported that most people with mild to moderate COVID-19 produce antibodies that are still effective five months after the onset of symptoms.

Roughly 92% of the patients produce sufficient antibody levels to continue fighting the new coronavirus.

Past studies found that antibody levels seemed to drop off faster. The other studies focused on antibodies produced in response to a viral protein known as NP. But it turns out NP may not be a good measure because it has membranes that shield it from the antibodies created by our immune system.

The team at Mount Sinai in New York focused instead on the infamous Spike protein, which allows viral cells to attach themselves to human cells.

After measuring antibody response in the entire group of 30,000 COVID-19 patients, scientists then followed a smaller subset. This second group consisted of 121 patients, who went on to donate plasma to help others fight COVID-19.

When researchers measured antibody levels in the group of 121 they found only a slight drop between three months and five months after symptoms. There was a larger decline at about 148 days, but the antibody levels were still high enough to neutralize the virus. Wajnberg said the Mount Sinai team plans to follow the 121 plasma donors for at least a full year.

The study suggests that vaccine makers should target the Spike protein because it spurs a much stronger immune response than the NP protein.

A new study in contrast (using a different measure) to the other antibody related study which suggested short term immunity. Here "Roughly 92% of the patients produce sufficient antibody levels to continue fighting the new coronavirus" after 5 months. And that of course is before we get to T Cell immune response. If it turns out that immunity is commonly a year + or more that bodes well for our natural response and possibly the prospects and design of vaccines.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Nov 20 5.44pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

First, there are excess deaths. In Week 42, the number of deaths registered was 6.8% above the five-year average (669 deaths higher).

In addition, Dementia and Alzheimers have seen deaths lower than expected for 19 consecutive weeks with 139 (12%) fewer deaths than expected this week. There are also notably fewer deaths for chronic lower respiratory conditions, other respiratory conditions and acute respiratory infections.

So we are seeing a reduction on illnesses due to other factors, surprise surprise when people are being really careful they don't get ill so often.

How can this make sense? You state that excess deaths are high according to the average. And other deaths from illnesses are lower because people are being really careful. So, if people are being really careful and not getting ill, how come C-19 is supposedly increasing. You can't have it both ways.

Also quoting average excess deaths is pointless as it is measured over 5 years for a reason, specifically the high one year, low the next phenomenon which is largely unbroken year on year. So 6.8% is meaningless anyway.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Nov 20 6.08pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

We should have had a total lockdown in March, ie all airports shut except for repatriation, to be receiving flights from China whilst we couldn’t visit family was totally unacceptable. Even now we are allowing foreign travellers in with absolutely no way of checking they are self- isolating. Please don’t say we have that ability because we don’t, no way of checking addresses before they leave the airport. Brits refusing to give details and EU nationals coming to stay in caravans are a daily occurrence

I agree, the freedom of movement at airports, whilst everyone else was in lockdown is bizarre, as many government policies have been.
If UK nationals wanted to come back to the UK, they should have been made to self isolate at all the empty hotels near the airports at their own cost, to ensure they abide by the rules. Anyone else wanting to come into the UK must provide a Covid test taken in the prior 7 days to be granted entry.
It may seem harsh, but this is the deal in Thailand and all residents have lived without restrictions, they do something similar in Australia and New Zealand.
WE decided to lockdown all our nationals and let foreigners in at will. It appears we are being led by clueless idiots, who have removed Parliamentary debate and do as they want.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 01 Nov 20 6.12pm

Cynics among us will recognise a situation where the government miraculously engineers a lock-down exit in time for Christmas.

They reason, correctly, that the public are dumb enough to believe anything.

Like believing this lockdown was necessary in the first place.

Viruses are always present and they can floor you for months if not years.

If you are elderly or weakened by a health condition then this nasty little germ is very dangerous, but not otherwise.

A total over-reaction mirroring the hysteria of modern Britain.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 01 Nov 20 6.17pm

Originally posted by Eden Eagle

Oh dear...

I have not suggested any course of action (though I do believe that the economic damage should be taken into account) and we are in agreement that there are no good choices.

If you get 5 minutes to reflect - please review your previous comments and you will see that they did not display any empathy towards the loss of jobs/livelihoods/ homes etc it was just “economies recover dead people don’t “.

But you have now clarified your position on this point - so thank you for that.

There really is nothing to be gained through further comment (from either of us) on this point as we are now in agreement, so best wishes to you.

My "economies recover, dead people don't" isn't meant to be anything other than an attention-grabbing headline. This debate has existed for months and when the subject of how to provide financial support was the focus I was always in favour of making sure people did not feel under pressure because we are all in this together. Even the anti-lockdown renegades who seem determined to make things harder.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

BlueJay Flag UK 01 Nov 20 6.22pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3570689]

How can this make sense? You state that excess deaths are high according to the average. And other deaths from illnesses are lower because people are being really careful. So, if people are being really careful and not getting ill, how come C-19 is supposedly increasing. You can't have it both ways.

Not all illnesses and disease are identical. Covid-19 is very contagious... as pandemics tend to be... so it may well be both harder to avoid and also easier to be impacted by (death rate) than most other respiratory illnesses for instance.

And beyond that, people are clearly dying of covid in large numbers. Earlier, I highlighted why the 'flu and pneumonia are being bunged in as covid enmasse' theory was inaccurate and precisely how those numbers were both false and misleading. This is along the same lines in that it's part of an endless effort from various angles to both underplay and undercount the tens of thousands people that have died of this horrible virus.

Edited by BlueJay (01 Nov 2020 6.33pm)

 

Eden Eagle Flag Kent 01 Nov 20 6.28pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

My "economies recover, dead people don't" isn't meant to be anything other than an attention-grabbing headline. This debate has existed for months and when the subject of how to provide financial support was the focus I was always in favour of making sure people did not feel under pressure because we are all in this together. Even the anti-lockdown renegades who seem determined to make things harder.

We are in agreement - best wishes..

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 01 Nov 20 7.09pm

There is a big difference in the way countries gather their data, and how they manipulate that into statistics.
Australia recorded no new CV19 infections today, but then who did they test, and what numbers ?

Clearly the track-and-trace stystem in the UK needs to be made fit for purpose, as it clearly seems to be having minimal effect.

Chris Whitty needs an enema, cos he is so full of 5hlt. The "We just have to make up measures as we go along" line was so disheartening from a Professor.

Any measures previously introduced have been done too late, resulting in loads of deaths. Now the rate of infections is increasing and deaths are only at a plateau at the moment because all the really old and sick people are dead already.

At least wetherspoons are selling Real Ale up until lockdown for only 99p a pint. It's nice to know someone is learning how to cope better with the disease.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Nov 20 7.10pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Cynics among us will recognise a situation where the government miraculously engineers a lock-down exit in time for Christmas.

They reason, correctly, that the public are dumb enough to believe anything.

Like believing this lockdown was necessary in the first place.

Viruses are always present and they can floor you for months if not years.

If you are elderly or weakened by a health condition then this nasty little germ is very dangerous, but not otherwise.

A total over-reaction mirroring the hysteria of modern Britain.

I seldom agree with your politics Steeleye, but I tip my hat to this post. Well stated.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Nov 20 7.11pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3570689]

How can this make sense? You state that excess deaths are high according to the average. And other deaths from illnesses are lower because people are being really careful. So, if people are being really careful and not getting ill, how come C-19 is supposedly increasing. You can't have it both ways.

Also quoting average excess deaths is pointless as it is measured over 5 years for a reason, specifically the high one year, low the next phenomenon which is largely unbroken year on year. So 6.8% is meaningless anyway.

First, this is all published information from reliable sources. So I don't have to explain anything, these are facts.

If you want my guess though as to why: 1) not everyone is being careful; 2) the SARS COV2 virus is spectacularly good at spreading and 3) there is so much misinformation being bandied about that many people don't know what to think or do. There are plenty of facts to support all three points.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Nov 20 7.17pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Cynics among us will recognise a situation where the government miraculously engineers a lock-down exit in time for Christmas.

They reason, correctly, that the public are dumb enough to believe anything.

Like believing this lockdown was necessary in the first place.

Viruses are always present and they can floor you for months if not years.

If you are elderly or weakened by a health condition then this nasty little germ is very dangerous, but not otherwise.

A total over-reaction mirroring the hysteria of modern Britain.

Presumably you don't know anyone that has Long Covid. 5% of the population is over 3 million.

In addition, had this been left to run there would have been many, many deaths. And as a result more people would have been hit by a high virus load, even the fittest generally don't cope well with that.

Why do people on here think that the NHS and PHE, plus the WHO and every medical function in the world agree lock-downs are needed? Ah, because they are not nearly as clever as you.

Do you also refuse to accept that climate change is man-made? Is the Earth really round? Do bears really sh*t on Popes and are the woods Catholic?

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Nov 20 7.21pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Not all illnesses and disease are identical. Covid-19 is very contagious... as pandemics tend to be... so it may well be both harder to avoid and also easier to be impacted by (death rate) than most other respiratory illnesses for instance.

And beyond that, people are clearly dying of covid in large numbers. Earlier, I highlighted why the 'flu and pneumonia are being bunged in as covid enmasse' theory was inaccurate and precisely how those numbers were both false and misleading. This is along the same lines in that it's part of an endless effort from various angles to both underplay and undercount the tens of thousands people that have died of this horrible virus.

Edited by BlueJay (01 Nov 2020 6.33pm)

Wow. Is that a fact? Who would have though that?

The reason I have stopped replying to you by the way, is because you constantly divert from the post. Address what I posted, not what you feel you want to say. How can illnesses be falling because of being more careful, at the same time as one illness, namely C-19 is rising. It's either both or neither, however you want to twist it.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Nov 20 7.30pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

First, this is all published information from reliable sources. So I don't have to explain anything, these are facts.

If you want my guess though as to why: 1) not everyone is being careful; 2) the SARS COV2 virus is spectacularly good at spreading and 3) there is so much misinformation being bandied about that many people don't know what to think or do. There are plenty of facts to support all three points.

How can numbers of deaths be up in one sentence, but down three sentences later? Maybe the "reliable sources" are not so reliable. The three points might be valid, if the point you make about why other illnesses are down was untrue. You cannot have both.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 01 Nov 20 7.39pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Presumably you don't know anyone that has Long Covid. 5% of the population is over 3 million.

In addition, had this been left to run there would have been many, many deaths. And as a result more people would have been hit by a high virus load, even the fittest generally don't cope well with that.

Why do people on here think that the NHS and PHE, plus the WHO and every medical function in the world agree lock-downs are needed? Ah, because they are not nearly as clever as you.

Do you also refuse to accept that climate change is man-made? Is the Earth really round? Do bears really sh*t on Popes and are the woods Catholic?

There's nothing like a reasoned reply.

And that is nothing like a reasoned reply.

The first two paragraphs are speculation. The third is open for debate by all, but many seem to not hear, or deliberately ignore other scientist's views. Chosing to accept whatever the gov. tells them (which is usually unthinkable). And then you derailed.....

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 01 Nov 20 8.38pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Presumably you don't know anyone that has Long Covid. 5% of the population is over 3 million.

In addition, had this been left to run there would have been many, many deaths. And as a result more people would have been hit by a high virus load, even the fittest generally don't cope well with that.

Why do people on here think that the NHS and PHE, plus the WHO and every medical function in the world agree lock-downs are needed? Ah, because they are not nearly as clever as you.

Do you also refuse to accept that climate change is man-made? Is the Earth really round? Do bears really sh*t on Popes and are the woods Catholic?

Regards Maple.

But 'long covid' is the latest designer label b*****s from the medical establishement.

I have personal experience of a long viral illness and symptoms of acute fatigue anxiety depression lethargy are quite normal.

In my case about 2 years.

At the time I remember debates about whether 'post-viral syndrome' 'chronic fatigue syndrome' etc. were actual illnesses.

Basically you are flattened by a virus and the body may take months or years to recover.

We know about covid19 and what we must do, what we lack is a solution.

Ok if you want to kick the can down the road but you are ruining lives as well as saving them.

All the best.

 

Page 399 of 753 < 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic