You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stadium Redevelopment
November 16 2026 3.59am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Stadium Redevelopment


Page 4 of 154 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
rikz Flag Croydon 20 Apr 16 10.48pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Are you deliberately obtuse or is it natural? I could post you a link to the definition if you like. Your deluded intelligence is quite amusing.

Get back to planning your £20 Pizza Express meal out and leave important stuff to the board. They know why they need to do it the way they are, just like SP knew we needed players yet AP though we were ok.

That's the whole point you donut. They didn't chose to do it this way, they have been forced to do it this way by the coucil, residents, sainsburys ect

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Apr 16 10.52pm

Originally posted by rikz

With tv money now days is that really the case.

Look you have your opinions and I have mine.

Regardless of what division we are in, our fans and the club deserve better facilities than what we currently have.

As well as tv money, corporates is what gives you the edge. You can only spend so much more every year out of tv money. This season it was £12mil for everyone. Next year I don't know. If you think we should wait for tv money to increase to progress you really are as naive as I thought.

We do deserve better but there are astute ways and then there's the rebuild and get relegated way we;ve seen so many times before.

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 20 Apr 16 10.54pm

Originally posted by palacer

Parish gave a really good interview at christmas. What he said he would like see was new directors boxes built over man stand and behind with hospitality. Then stand knocked down and more seating put in, like Anfield. He also said that they have historic permission to build above the whitehorse another tier of seating. He did say they were talking to Sainsburies. What was interesting I thought was that he said that he wanted symmetry so the new Whitehorse would match the Holmesdale. At least the roof would. This would balance the overal look. He then said that the Arthur had yet to be worked out.
It takes ages to get anything done with local councils and Sainsburies I reckon will be mercenary. Even though it is a pretty poor run down supermarket at the moment. We will have to wait and see. But he seems to really want this to happen.

Finally someone else who understands the situation. Whenever we do get permission to rebuild,it will because there will be a lot of mercenaries benefiting out of it.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 20 Apr 16 10.55pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

As well as tv money, corporates is what gives you the edge. You can only spend so much more every year out of tv money. This season it was £12mil for everyone. Next year I don't know. If you think we should wait for tv money to increase to progress you really are as naive as I thought.

We do deserve better but there are astute ways and then there's the rebuild and get relegated way we;ve seen so many times before.

You are living in dreamland if you think we will ever be exempt from relegation.

Where did I say we should wait for tv money to increase, I've said the complete opposite, like rebuilding regardless of what league we are in, your doing my head in now, like banging my head against a door trying to explain things to you

Edited by rikz (20 Apr 2016 10.59pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Apr 16 11.03pm

Originally posted by rikz

Finally someone else who understands the situation. Whenever we do get permission to rebuild,it will because there will be a lot of mercenaries benefiting out of it.

You don't get the concept of construction planning do you? To get permission you need a plan, or plans, if 1st one is turned down. To get a proper plan you need to hire surveyors and solicitors on several million pounds. And to do that you need to be sure you're not going to cancel the project, unless you don't mind wasting several millions.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Apr 16 11.08pm

Originally posted by rikz

You are living in dreamland if you think we will ever be exempt from relegation.

Where did I say we should wait for tv money to increase, I've said the complete opposite, like rebuilding regardless of what league we are in, your doing my head in now, like banging my head against a door trying to explain things to you

Edited by rikz (20 Apr 2016 10.59pm)

Building a stand fit for the Prem if we're in the champ is not having an edge either, which is why they want to maximise corporate revenue doing it that way.

Again, you don't get simple concepts. Minimising risk. Risk/reward, maximising investment.

You're clueless and you're now boring the f**ing life out of me. You're either deliberately obtuse or it's a natural struggle for you. At least those who know they're limited have a chance with you around. Go to bed, jog on, anything.

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Apr 16 6.30am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You don't get the concept of construction planning do you? To get permission you need a plan, or plans, if 1st one is turned down. To get a proper plan you need to hire surveyors and solicitors on several million pounds. And to do that you need to be sure you're not going to cancel the project, unless you don't mind wasting several millions.

No I get that completely, it's called paying someone to do a job.
You don't seem to understand that we have a big supermarket on our stadium who own a great big car park. For any redevelopment to happen, we would need to work with sainsburys. Therefore they will dig their feet in untill they get the best deal possible for them, they couldn't care about the club.

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 21 Apr 16 8.14am

As far as the Crystal Palace Park "plan," SP ruled that out some time ago due to overwhelming opposition from the Bromley Council and residents in that area, most of them very well endowed in the pocketbook. As soon as those "plans" were announced, the residents formed an lobbying group determined to keep Palace out. Therefore, it's useless to talk about that unless something changes radically. That residents group is even opposed to building a new Crystal Palace to replace the one that gave that area its name. They are the very definition of NIMBY.

The 1924 Main Stand needs replacement badly. There are still wooden beams in the structure, which means the safety certificate for Selhurst requires a waiver. The Goldberg and Jordan regimes didn't own the ground, which made getting planning approval more difficult.

An example of an old stadium being redeveloped is what happened with Fenway Park in Boston, originally built in 1912 and rebuilt in 1934 after a fire. When the present ownership (John Henry & Tom Werner, who now own Liverpool as part of Fenway Sports Group) took over in 2002, they hired an architect who laid out a ten year plan to rebuild Fenway in sections during the off season. There were several season in that 10 year period that the Red Sox were in the post season, which cut a month from the available time for construction. Palace would do well to follow that example, taking their time especially since the close season is shorter, even though it is in the summer months while baseball's is in the fall and winter. While the Main Stand lends itself to a Liverpool style rebuild, the Arthur Wait, also in need of major work, could be done over the span of two or three years. It might look funky for a while but the final result should be worth it.

Edited by kenbarr (21 Apr 2016 8.15am)

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 21 Apr 16 8.37am

In regard to any opposition (NIMBYs) to SP redevelopment, from a civic point of view, I think there is a strong case to argue for the ground's rehabilitation. Can these people honestly say that the current facility is preferable to a new stadium? It's not as if there is an effing flora and flora reserve there at present! It's a frigging eyesore! Having a home next to an EPL standard stadium as opposed to what is currently there seems a no-brainer to me. Also, as far as lobby groups and lobbying goes, I'd put my money on a group composed of CPFC supporters against a bunch of troglodite tossers any day.

 


[Link]

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 21 Apr 16 8.53am

Parchmore, the NIMBY I was referring to were the ones at Crystal Palace Park, not the residents of Whitehorse Lane, Park and Holmesdale roads. they also have mounted opposition to any redevelopment of Selhurst Park claiming they would be deprived of "sunshine." Judging from what I've read on the web, those concerns are being addressed through a series of meetings between the club and the residents groups. CPFC2010 seem to have a better relationship with community that either Noades, Goldberg or Jordan Brothers. Dominic Jordan outright insulted them, which any politician will tell you is not a great way of winning friends and influencing people (my source is the late Ron Greatorex, who D. Jprdan fired as Chief Steward over refusing to pay him in a timely manner). Whatever you think of the residents, they vote in Croydon Council and Parliamentary elections in the constituencies that surround SP. How many Palace fans do that? A great many come from outside the area and vote elsewhere. remember, the two rules in elective politics are:

1. Get elected.

2. Stay elected.

If it could be demonstrated that Palace supporters could decisively affect the councillors and MPs ability to hold office, that would move things along. Charlton supporters were able to do that by forming The Valley Party back in the 1990s, which may be the last time they won anything.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 21 Apr 16 9.14am

Still on the topic of stadium re-development, but on a slightly different theme, I was wondering about the old issue of what capacity a re-developed stadium should be.

Should we read anything into the fact that a week before the FA Cup semi we still hadn't sold all of 32,000 allocation? Perhaps that is because a number of fans can't be bothered with the Cup, or don't like the idea of the Semi-Final being played at Wembley.

But it has got me thinking as to how likely it would be that we would fill a 35,000 seater stadium, let alone a 40,000 seater. Yes, possibly for the visits of the big names, but what about games against Stoke or Swansea ( and that's assuming we are still in the Premier).

I'd be interested to know at the moment, with our 25,000 limit, how many matches are completely sold out, and how many more tickets could have been sold if the stadium was larger.

I appreciate that their needs to be room for ambition and the possibility that on-going success might bring greater demand. But, in the short to medium term, I really cannot see how we are going to regularly fill a 35,000 to 40,000 seater ground.

Anyone like to re-assure me that we could?

 

Dweeb Flag East London 21 Apr 16 9.21am

The locals are bound up in their own bitterness of the park's past development, and their parking spaces. They detest the tower block that was built in there and clearly do NOT care about the rundown of the NSC or the minimalist attention paid to the park.

If they had thought about it they could have asked for a annual contribution from the club towards improvement of the park for say 25 years or longer but....

 


Taking the bungy jump since 1964. Never to see John Jackson in a shirt again

Sorry to see Lee Hills go, did we ever see Alex Marrow? We did January 2013

Dweeb Flag East London 21 Apr 16 9.27am

Originally posted by Pete53

Still on the topic of stadium re-development, but on a slightly different theme, I was wondering about the old issue of what capacity a re-developed stadium should be.

Should we read anything into the fact that a week before the FA Cup semi we still hadn't sold all of 32,000 allocation? Perhaps that is because a number of fans can't be bothered with the Cup, or don't like the idea of the Semi-Final being played at Wembley.

But it has got me thinking as to how likely it would be that we would fill a 35,000 seater stadium, let alone a 40,000 seater. Yes, possibly for the visits of the big names, but what about games against Stoke or Swansea ( and that's assuming we are still in the Premier).

I'd be interested to know at the moment, with our 25,000 limit, how many matches are completely sold out, and how many more tickets could have been sold if the stadium was larger.

I appreciate that their needs to be room for ambition and the possibility that on-going success might bring greater demand. But, in the short to medium term, I really cannot see how we are going to regularly fill a 35,000 to 40,000 seater ground.

Anyone like to re-assure me that we could?

Good questions. The reality of our club is that we have a core of about 12,000 - 15,000 supporters as indicated by the first half of our promotion season. The rest are plastics, once we get relegated they will be gone faster than when a cockroach sees the light. That means the present stadium's capacity is probably about right for us, but we need it in a more modern context with possible somme temporary capcity for our forays into the Premiership.

I hear that current proposals are to start with and build over the top of the existing main stand during a closed season. So logically once done those of us who reside tehre will be booted upstairs and then they will do the work on the lower level during the next one. But I have not seen any planning applications around the club so I can't see it being done this closed season.

Edited by Dweeb (21 Apr 2016 9.29am)

 


Taking the bungy jump since 1964. Never to see John Jackson in a shirt again

Sorry to see Lee Hills go, did we ever see Alex Marrow? We did January 2013

cpvoice Flag 21 Apr 16 9.30am

It's been mentioned before, but another site, albeit with problems there, would be part of the Croydon Airport site, off Purley Way opposite the football pitches (with good road/bus links, but Purley and Waddon being the closest stations).

Problems? Two Councils involved - Sutton and Croydon. But if those two can build an large controversial incinerator on Council borders, then a stadium for CP would be a minor build.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 21 Apr 16 9.34am

The residents in the area of CPP are not interested, in the slightest, in the welfare of the park. They are opposed to any development that results in thousands of people turning up on a regular basis, taking up parking spaces, leaving litter and pissing in their gardens. Looked at from their angle, they do have a point. NIMBYs they may be, but I'm not sure I'd want it in my back yard either.

The residents surrounding SP are on weaker ground as there was a football stadium there when they moved in (rather like the residents who complain about Heathrow when they knew they were moving next to an airport).

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 21 Apr 16 9.38am

Originally posted by Pete53

Still on the topic of stadium re-development, but on a slightly different theme, I was wondering about the old issue of what capacity a re-developed stadium should be.

Should we read anything into the fact that a week before the FA Cup semi we still hadn't sold all of 32,000 allocation? Perhaps that is because a number of fans can't be bothered with the Cup, or don't like the idea of the Semi-Final being played at Wembley.

But it has got me thinking as to how likely it would be that we would fill a 35,000 seater stadium, let alone a 40,000 seater. Yes, possibly for the visits of the big names, but what about games against Stoke or Swansea ( and that's assuming we are still in the Premier).

I'd be interested to know at the moment, with our 25,000 limit, how many matches are completely sold out, and how many more tickets could have been sold if the stadium was larger.

I appreciate that their needs to be room for ambition and the possibility that on-going success might bring greater demand. But, in the short to medium term, I really cannot see how we are going to regularly fill a 35,000 to 40,000 seater ground.

Anyone like to re-assure me that we could?

I just checked the Palace online ticket office and the only available are in blocks 519, 520 and 521 costing stlg 32.50/22.50 with concessions. Perhaps supporters don't want to sit in nosebleed country.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 16 10.23am

Originally posted by rikz

No I get that completely, it's called paying someone to do a job.
You don't seem to understand that we have a big supermarket on our stadium who own a great big car park. For any redevelopment to happen, we would need to work with sainsburys. Therefore they will dig their feet in untill they get the best deal possible for them, they couldn't care about the club.

No it is not. It is not like a simple case of paying a tradesman to turn up and give a quote. It takes a lot of time and SP is no doubt being very meticulous. For a number or reasons. Whenever anyone submits planning applications it's presented to those surrounding it. A neighbour puts in a new window and they have to apply for it if it's on the side of the house. So don't try and claim this or those around SP are any different.

And nah, can't say I've noticed the supermarket and car park, flats behind the WH end and row of houses built across from The Clifton Arms in the decades I've been going to Selhurst since before you were soiling your training pants in juniors. Do me a favour.

On the subject of the car park. The Sainsbury's car park starts on WH Lane and ends where the main stand ends. The CPFC car park starts there.

Parish is not being meticulous because Sainsbury's are being obstinate or will be driving hard bargains. He could be going about things carefully so that they or residents do not have the opportunity to object to the plans or one of the plans we're going to submit to the council. It is not all black and white.

Again, SP has said before about the significant costs of the professional plans and progressing the plans before even an agreement has been reached and a spade is dug. It costs several million before you get plans agreed.

I hear SP has some drawings of what he'd like to do with the main stand but isn't releasing anything until he's confident it's going to get the go ahead. Again, that project I wouldn't be surprised if it's been altered since knowing we'd have £50million plus of cash to spend on it rather than a 20 year mortgage and at a cost to our abilities in surviving Prem football or gaining promotion from Champ football.

Of course there's planning issues, there is everywhere, but what you were trying to imply was that finances were not an issue, or more specifically, what the real reason was for the delay as there was a plan, which was incidentally a 'concept' idea 6 years ago. If you don't think the delay since 6 years ago has anything to do with Parish/CPFC not having the money and needing a 20 year mortgage in a business that was losing £5mil a year in the Champ and struggling in each season after promotion for a significant time then each to their own.

With the US investment that all changes. No debt from before or with ground building, no interest from previous debt or ground building and the opportunity to maximise the corporate revenue which gives you the revenue you're allowed to increase wages. It is a completely different opportunity and that changed when the US investment was signed off, only 4 months ago.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (21 Apr 2016 11.21am)

 


COYP

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 21 Apr 16 10.26am


Here we go again, about the lack of support not encouraging a bigger stadium. Ok then, lets go back to the Nest, 15,000 capacity that was rarely filled. The only reason the capacity hasn't been filled recently is is many-fold. Firstly, Palace have to put aside a section for visitors and if that isn't filled the police will not allow the tickets to be put on general sale. Secondly, because there is a chance you will never get a ticket going up to Selhurst on the day means many don't take that chance. Then there's the price. We all know that one.
The simple answer is for Palace to get busy and
get a bigger stadium. Do that or go nowhere. Not interested, then give up on any ambition fort Palace becoming one of the big clubs, or even the equivalent of a WBA, Brum or even Brighton. Imagine, there are some on here who would accept that. Not me pal.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 16 10.35am

Originally posted by adrian b


Here we go again, about the lack of support not encouraging a bigger stadium. Ok then, lets go back to the Nest, 15,000 capacity that was rarely filled. The only reason the capacity hasn't been filled recently is is many-fold. Firstly, Palace have to put aside a section for visitors and if that isn't filled the police will not allow the tickets to be put on general sale. Secondly, because there is a chance you will never get a ticket going up to Selhurst on the day means many don't take that chance. Then there's the price. We all know that one.
The simple answer is for Palace to get busy and
get a bigger stadium. Do that or go nowhere. Not interested, then give up on any ambition fort Palace becoming one of the big clubs, or even the equivalent of a WBA, Brum or even Brighton. Imagine, there are some on here who would accept that. Not me pal.

Every club builds a shiny new impressive stadium and people flock to it like moths to a light bulb. There's only 2 clubs where that's failed. Coventry and someone else right down near the bottom of the football league. Everywhere else the overhauls have held attendances higher than before. Where we're in a healthy situation is:

No debt. No repayments. No interest.

Where we will benefit is charging the suit and ties and London companies buying boxes and corporate seats inflated prices whereas we below or to the side of them get on with being real fans.

It's the sign of the times. People are materialistic. As long as people get their affordable little home comforts with mass production it stops them doing things like voting for a different party that might change futile governments.

 


COYP

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 21 Apr 16 10.55am

Doesn't the Premier League have a minimum stadium capacity requirement? If so, what is it? How long does a club have to increase capacity to meet that requirement?

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Page 4 of 154 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stadium Redevelopment