You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 10.43pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 4 of 44 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 30 Nov 16 6.41pm

I think the strikes are bang out of order

However (generally) unions should be able to retain the right to strike

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 30 Nov 16 6.53pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

correction, the image of trade unions, as put forward by the media, is out of date.

There just is no socialist daily paper so unless you have an understanding with tory rags like TB did then how do labour put their view across?

 

Paul67 Flag 30 Nov 16 7.16pm

So who thinks its safe trying to get on a 4 carriage train with just a driver at Norwood Junction or Selhurst 20 minutes after a match.
Imagine that rush hour everyday
Southern need to have their franchise taken away before people are killed (if they haven't been already)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 30 Nov 16 7.43pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Stop talking bollocks.

They have been told they'll move to other roles but they're striking as they know people won't be kept, or new people re-employed, in a needless job forever. Eventually the number of jobs will reduce, like they will in every sector of work.

I suggest you stop thinking unions have done anything for everyone.

Quite agree, having just retired from the public sector, in a job where strike action was completely undermined by the Govt, perhaps Southern should be nationalised and the staff be considered public sector workers. Living in the Southern region this is making life for me and my kids unbearable, 30% of trains nationally have this operation with the blessing of ASLEF, this is a them and us situation, perhaps they should sack them all, it can't be any worse (now awaiting the lefties to attack!)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Nov 16 8.04pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

1. Anyone who has ever had paid holiday can thank unions.

2. I beg to differ.

3. What are you scared of?

Not everyone then. They didn't invent paid holiday either.

Feel free to, but you act like nothing in the world would ever change without them when it does all the time.

Not much that I can think of. Getting a new car the day it snowed like a b****** was probably the last time.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Nov 16 8.27pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Quite agree, having just retired from the public sector, in a job where strike action was completely undermined by the Govt, perhaps Southern should be nationalised and the staff be considered public sector workers. Living in the Southern region this is making life for me and my kids unbearable, 30% of trains nationally have this operation with the blessing of ASLEF, this is a them and us situation, perhaps they should sack them all, it can't be any worse (now awaiting the lefties to attack!)

Their argument is like a supermarket checkout worker striking over self-service. And you know what the supermarket would respond with... more self-service tills.

I'd love to know how the striking workers would feel if they came home and found they had no power or gas because their supplier's employees were on strike?

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Nov 16 9.08pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Their argument is like a supermarket checkout worker striking over self-service. And you know what the supermarket would respond with... more self-service tills.

I'd love to know how the striking workers would feel if they came home and found they had no power or gas because their supplier's employees were on strike?

They'd go and join the picket line in an act of solidarity.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 30 Nov 16 9.31pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

They'd go and join the picket line in an act of solidarity.

Which just goes to show what self-serving c*nts they all are.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Nov 16 9.38pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Which just goes to show what self-serving c*nts they all are.

An injury to one is an injury to all.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 30 Nov 16 9.41pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

An injury to one is an injury to all.

You were born 50 odd years too late, Nick. The Boulting brothers would have had you in a starring role in 'I'm Alright, Jack'.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Nov 16 9.44pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

You were born 50 odd years too late, Nick. The Boulting brothers would have had you in a starring role in 'I'm Alright, Jack'.

And they have been odd years

 

Stuk Flag Top half 30 Nov 16 10.03pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

They'd go and join the picket line in an act of solidarity.

No they wouldn't, and you know it. They'd be just as pissed off as every other person suffering because employees of a monopoly service have decided to f*** them over, to vicariously inflict their employer.

 


Optimistic as ever

legaleagle Flag 30 Nov 16 10.10pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

You were born 50 odd years too late, Nick. The Boulting brothers would have had you in a starring role in 'I'm Alright, Jack'.

Given the two starring roles (boss and union rep, equally lampooned)were both played by the great Peter Sellers,I think it would be a compliment to be put up for it,Nick...Maybe Cucking could do the Terry Thomas awful personnel manager character

Edited by legaleagle (30 Nov 2016 10.12pm)

 

deanoeagle Flag Lindfield 30 Nov 16 10.13pm

Only if they didn't have to rely on getting a train to get there.

Originally posted by nickgusset

They'd go and join the picket line in an act of solidarity.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 30 Nov 16 10.57pm

As a long suffering and captive commuter, here's my view.

1. Southern Rail are unable to fulfil their timetable obligations as they don't have enough drivers. And they rely on those they have got to do overtime.

2. The union - who I originally sympathised with - have painted themselves into a corner. There are no negotiations left to be had with Southern. They are just embarrassing themselves now. 30 people outside Brighton station on their picket line last week when the weather was ok. No presence at all the next day when it was cold and wet...w***ers.

3. Southern are an odious company. Their industrial relations skills are non-existant. Launching a PR scheme encouraging the travelling public to vent their anger at union workers being a prime example.They are also dishonest in what they tell their customers - on a daily basis. Their CEO, Charles Horton is the original ' Specialist in Failure. How he has kept his job is a total mystery.

4. The government have granted a £20m kitty to sort the mess out - well, how's that money being spent ? Things are getting worse by the day !

5. Daily cancellations and short trains are causing serious overcrowding both at stations and on trains. It's a miracle there hasn't been an accident - so much for the unions caring about our safety.

So, to conclude - I would happily line up Horton and Cash, one behind the other, and shoot them both with the same bullet.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 10.54am

I worked in HR for a TOC for many years. I will offer only facts not theories and I will let people make their own mind up.

TOC's aim is to operate DOO over the whole network. They want rid of guards. At the moment most trains need two staff on board to run, if one of 2 isn't available that train gets cancelled. It makes it financially appealing to get rid of the need for a 2nd person. The way to do that is to take away their safety critical role. I sat in a meeting where a boss said he wanted rid of guards, but the "fxcking liberals" won't allow it because of the DDA (disability discrimination act). No guards mean no wheelchair access.
Guards are trained in several safety procedures. The company I worked for tried to get these removed... so it could get rid. They instead wanted a small team of "train managers" to go round collecting revenue. We couldn't get this thru... getting someone to sign off something that makes the railway less safe is tricky. Our CEO had been in court over Paddington rail crash (I think) and was reluctant to put his name to it. We also encountered problems with the RSSB. We found them very difficult to deal with. My company then decided to hire a new CEO. This CEO had contacts with RSSB and had a good working relationship with the DfT. This CEO now sits on the board of the RSSB. He now has the power to push through the changes.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 10.54am

I worked in HR for a TOC for many years. I will offer only facts not theories and I will let people make their own mind up.

TOC's aim is to operate DOO over the whole network. They want rid of guards. At the moment most trains need two staff on board to run, if one of 2 isn't available that train gets cancelled. It makes it financially appealing to get rid of the need for a 2nd person. The way to do that is to take away their safety critical role. I sat in a meeting where a boss said he wanted rid of guards, but the "fxcking liberals" won't allow it because of the DDA (disability discrimination act). No guards mean no wheelchair access.
Guards are trained in several safety procedures. The company I worked for tried to get these removed... so it could get rid. They instead wanted a small team of "train managers" to go round collecting revenue. We couldn't get this thru... getting someone to sign off something that makes the railway less safe is tricky. Our CEO had been in court over Paddington rail crash (I think) and was reluctant to put his name to it. We also encountered problems with the RSSB. We found them very difficult to deal with. My company then decided to hire a new CEO. This CEO had contacts with RSSB and had a good working relationship with the DfT. This CEO now sits on the board of the RSSB. He now has the power to push through the changes.

 

wearegoingup Flag 02 Dec 16 11.07am

Originally posted by NEILLO

As a long suffering and captive commuter, here's my view.

1. Southern Rail are unable to fulfil their timetable obligations as they don't have enough drivers. And they rely on those they have got to do overtime.

2. The union - who I originally sympathised with - have painted themselves into a corner. There are no negotiations left to be had with Southern. They are just embarrassing themselves now. 30 people outside Brighton station on their picket line last week when the weather was ok. No presence at all the next day when it was cold and wet...w***ers.

3. Southern are an odious company. Their industrial relations skills are non-existant. Launching a PR scheme encouraging the travelling public to vent their anger at union workers being a prime example.They are also dishonest in what they tell their customers - on a daily basis. Their CEO, Charles Horton is the original ' Specialist in Failure. How he has kept his job is a total mystery.

4. The government have granted a £20m kitty to sort the mess out - well, how's that money being spent ? Things are getting worse by the day !

5. Daily cancellations and short trains are causing serious overcrowding both at stations and on trains. It's a miracle there hasn't been an accident - so much for the unions caring about our safety.

So, to conclude - I would happily line up Horton and Cash, one behind the other, and shoot them both with the same bullet.


Couldn't of put it better myself.

Anyone know what will happen when the drivers strike ? When the conductors strike they run a reduced service, will they still be able to do that or will the whole network come to a standstill?

 

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 11.11am

The one thing I will say. This is driven by DfT. A senior DfT employee went rogue at a meeting and let slip that he wanted to crush the union. My old boss went mental. They didn't want the unions warned. The changes will make the railway less safe... how much they do is subjective. Passenger numbers have doubled and cutting safety staff by 50% at the same time was a big ask. For us the RSSB was the big problem, but they seemed to have sorted it.


My opinion. Guards and drivers are right... the company know it. Anything that makes the railway less safe is going to be a hard sell. Southern will try dirty tricks, they will tell managers to go "hard" on staff. Southern will try to use media to water down changes. I've sat in meetings where I've heard top managers tell middle management to target union reps. I don't think the guards will win. This is coming from the DfT... it's almost ideological. If drivers go out, it may change things... they hold power, and management fvcking hate them because of it.

Edited by 7mins (02 Dec 2016 11.27am)

 

7mins Flag In the bush 02 Dec 16 11.16am

Part of me is sad that striking for safety is happening in 2016. I'm not gonna lie, a few years ago I was part of the problem. I sold my soul for £££
Some of the things we/I did when employed by a TOC were shameful. We screwed over cleaners... the lowest paid. We lied to staff we were planning to let go, then gave them minimal notice (catering staff we gave 3 days notice, we knew for 6 months they were going)

 

Page 4 of 44 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong