This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by YT
This is surely the ultimate proof that football has gone mad. I predict that Silva will be either in, or looking for, his next job after Everton, 12 months from now. Much less that that; they will kick him out as soon as they realise how f***ing s***e he is.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
We seemed to be the only set of fans who would have been happy for him to continue. I thought our football was pretty decent under him and he got the best out of Benteke too. He also signed Luka and PVA so we have a lot to thank him for He joined us when we were one place above the 'Drop Zone' and steered us up to 14th so he did the job asked of him.Apart from Milivojevic and PVA he also brought in Sakho on Loan.Indeed we have a lot to thank him for.
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Much less that that; they will kick him out as soon as they realise how f***ing s***e he is. He won’t be short of options in the squad or transfer budget if he does go to Everton, like he did at Hull and Watford.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Qwijibo
I think only the Watford debacle would undermine his credentials - admittedly quite severely - everything else is pretty good. From what I recall, Hull's relegation wasn't his fault. I wonder if Sam was always filling in before they made a move on him again. Maybe there was a timescale before Silva could be employed again a la Pulis post Palace. I don't think Sam should have lost his job, and I am pretty sure his 8th place finish will be better than whatever Silva achieves. But then again, he's done incredibly well out of being fired. Incredibly well. Sam's been around the block and his demand for the 2 years has 100% justified itself. Didn’t Everton sack Koeman before Watford sacked Silva?
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Didn’t Everton sack Koeman before Watford sacked Silva? Yes. It has been said that Allardyce never saved Everton from the drop, the sacking of Koeman did that.Seems no credit at all for Allardyce "Oop north" !!!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I don't really understand why Silva is so highly rated. He doesn’t react well to bad runs and ruts. But he’s only been at clubs lacking in back ups. Hull were done when they had the 3 injuries vs us after losing at home to Sunderland and Watford had a lot of injuries as well. He could be going to a club with more resources and with some better defending at corners some people could end up with egg on their faces. He’s certainly not shyte but the jury is out on how good he is because the 2 jobs he’s had have been unique. Hull, going down. Watford, trigger happy. He’s always wanted this size club or bigger so we’ll see. And there’s a difference between finishing 6-8th anyway and threatening to breakthrough that barrier and possibly staying there. They’ve probably looked at Spurs at some point and recognised how they’ve got the football in order before stadium.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
We seemed to be the only set of fans who would have been happy for him to continue. I thought our football was pretty decent under him and he got the best out of Benteke too. He also signed Luka and PVA so we have a lot to thank him for Blunderland?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
He doesn’t react well to bad runs and ruts. But he’s only been at clubs lacking in back ups. Hull were done when they had the 3 injuries vs us after losing at home to Sunderland and Watford had a lot of injuries as well. He could be going to a club with more resources and with some better defending at corners some people could end up with egg on their faces. He’s certainly not shyte but the jury is out on how good he is because the 2 jobs he’s had have been unique. Hull, going down. Watford, trigger happy. He’s always wanted this size club or bigger so we’ll see. And there’s a difference between finishing 6-8th anyway and threatening to breakthrough that barrier and possibly staying there. They’ve probably looked at Spurs at some point and recognised how they’ve got the football in order before stadium. Yes the jury is out on him. I was just thinking hypothetically - If Hodgson had announced his retirement and Silva was being linked with us what do you think would be the reaction of our supporters ? Would they look at his record at Hull and Watford and cast aspersions or would they see him in a positive vein ? This is not a rhetorical question and I have no view either way. Edited by Willo (16 May 2018 10.52am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Chubskip
Everton wanted him for 7 months to dig them out of a hole. Fair play he got a longer contract and I guess he will get another payout, more fool Everton's board. They may now get Silva but Sam won't help them out if there in trouble again Christmas. Arsenal may be his next club? Never say never!
He's getting about £6m to leave the job early. Well done to him. He will have no shortage of offers to save another club once managers start getting the sack in October next season. With the bonuses to stay up and the payoffs he'll be rolling in it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
He's getting about £6m to leave the job early. Well done to him. He will have no shortage of offers to save another club once managers start getting the sack in October next season. With the bonuses to stay up and the payoffs he'll be rolling in it. Absolutely, I couldn't agree more.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
He doesn’t react well to bad runs and ruts. But he’s only been at clubs lacking in back ups. Hull were done when they had the 3 injuries vs us after losing at home to Sunderland and Watford had a lot of injuries as well. He could be going to a club with more resources and with some better defending at corners some people could end up with egg on their faces. He’s certainly not shyte but the jury is out on how good he is because the 2 jobs he’s had have been unique. Hull, going down. Watford, trigger happy. He’s always wanted this size club or bigger so we’ll see. And there’s a difference between finishing 6-8th anyway and threatening to breakthrough that barrier and possibly staying there. They’ve probably looked at Spurs at some point and recognised how they’ve got the football in order before stadium. Pulis managed to train Delaney, Dann, Ward, Mariappa, Jedi, Leadley, Jerome, Chamakh to defend corners. Silva had no excuse for how abject Hull were at defending set pieces. We conceded 1 goal from set pieces I believe under Pulis. Hull conceded about 20 under Silva in a similar time frame. He may well do well at Everton, but he's still not brilliant and I'm glad he's not our manager.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Pulis managed to train Delaney, Dann, Ward, Mariappa, Jedi, Leadley, Jerome, Chamakh to defend corners. Silva had no excuse for how abject Hull were at defending set pieces. We conceded 1 goal from set pieces I believe under Pulis. Hull conceded about 20 under Silva in a similar time frame. He may well do well at Everton, but he's still not brilliant and I'm glad he's not our manager. A defensive coach can sort that out pretty quickly. His track record is continental football so it’s hardly surprising in this league that his teams were targeted at corners successfully. No one can tell how he’ll do at Everton is the truth of it.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Pulis managed to train Delaney, Dann, Ward, Mariappa, Jedi, Leadley, Jerome, Chamakh to defend corners. Silva had no excuse for how abject Hull were at defending set pieces. We conceded 1 goal from set pieces I believe under Pulis. Hull conceded about 20 under Silva in a similar time frame. He may well do well at Everton, but he's still not brilliant and I'm glad he's not our manager. Yes he might given the financial backing he will be given in the transfer market. One thing seems clear - if he fails at Everton, given his previous failures at Hull and Watford his reputation will take a hammering and he will probably have to go abroad to seek employment.Time will tell of course !
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
He's getting about £6m to leave the job early. Well done to him. He will have no shortage of offers to save another club once managers start getting the sack in October next season. With the bonuses to stay up and the payoffs he'll be rolling in it. Yes I don’t begrudge him doing what he does. The money losses involved are huge and he provides a service in demand. Take the money out of football and this might change and so might survive with whatever football it takes.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Yes the jury is out on him. I was just thinking hypothetically - If Hodgson had announced his retirement and Silva was being linked with us what do you think would be the reaction of our supporters ? Would they look at his record at Hull and Watford and cast aspersions or would they see him in a positive vein ? This is not a rhetorical question and I have no view either way. Edited by Willo (16 May 2018 10.52am) Possibly not a good choice with regards to our squad depth but he’d be taking over a disciplined team behind the ball and confident in possession so it would suit him more than people think. He was always the best choice out of the younger and fashionable ones available last summer but almost everyone ignored the best in Roy.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Absolutely, I couldn't agree more. Will be appointed the USA coach. You heard it here first!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.