You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Workers to pay for social care
November 21 2026 9.57pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Workers to pay for social care


Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
DanH Flag SW2 08 Sep 21 9.05pm

Originally posted by cryrst

But we are led to beleive that the fees payable for the education will allow you to earn at least 10% higher wages. That 9% is like a free hit. And I don't think the NI should be included as we all pay it. Basically it's 20 % tax like anyone under 50k. How much deposit is needed for a mortgage?

This is some really bizarre maths and logic. You need 20% typically for a deposit, although help to buy can reduce this if you qualify. Average house price for a one bedroom property in London is £485k. A 20% deposit is £97k. How is a young person taking home about £1,500 net a month supposed to pay their rent and bills and still save enough to even scratch the surface of that?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 08 Sep 21 9.06pm

Originally posted by DanH

Newly qualified graduates with student debt who earn over the £28k threshold now have a marginal tax rate of 42.25% with repayments taken into account. How is that generation ever meant to save to get on the housing ladder?

I agree. My daughter and her boyfriend are both Senior Spacecraft Engineers, so earn good money. My daughter left University with well over £50k in debt, which has interest added as well.
They work in Guildford so have to live within relatively easy reach, as they are on call. She has a flat (purchased with a mortgage and help from mum and dad) but they are struggling to upgrade to a house, even with their income

 

DanH Flag SW2 08 Sep 21 9.12pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

I agree. My daughter and her boyfriend are both Senior Spacecraft Engineers, so earn good money. My daughter left University with well over £50k in debt, which has interest added as well.
They work in Guildford so have to live within relatively easy reach, as they are on call. She has a flat (purchased with a mortgage and help from mum and dad) but they are struggling to upgrade to a house, even with their income

Cool jobs! Assume she gets her brains from her mother

Realistically the only way of getting on the housing ladder is with a helping hand from family or through inheritance. Saving up for a deposit is nigh on impossible unless you’re on silly money very early in your career.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 08 Sep 21 9.15pm

Originally posted by DanH

Cool jobs! Assume she gets her brains from her mother

Realistically the only way of getting on the housing ladder is with a helping hand from family or through inheritance. Saving up for a deposit is nigh on impossible unless you’re on silly money very early in your career.

Haha and her looks ( luckily). Yep would never have got on ladder without our help. Her boyfriend was paying £900 pm rent for a studio flat excluding bills. Even now trying to get a house is proving very difficult

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Sep 21 9.31pm

Originally posted by DanH

But they’re not excellent points are they? They’re a huge oversimplification of a hugely complex issue suited to his and your prejudices.

Blaming immigration solely is so, so lazy and all it does is highlight the kind of person you are rather than a rational, sensible grown up.

I think it is rather that you just cannot accept a simple reality because you have been conditioned to be in denial about it your whole life.
You think it is over simple because your belief system makes you try to find an alternative interpretation despite the evidence.
It is akin to religious indoctrination. You would rather believe in miracles than see the truth.

 

DanH Flag SW2 08 Sep 21 9.35pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I think it is rather that you just cannot accept a simple reality because you have been conditioned to be in denial about it your whole life.
You think it is over simple because your belief system makes you try to find an alternative interpretation despite the evidence.
It is akin to religious indoctrination. You would rather believe in miracles than see the truth.

Claiming someone has been ‘indoctrinated’ when there’s a wealth of academic studies out there on the housing market just makes you look like an arrogant and ignorant tit you realise, don’t you?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Sep 21 9.48pm

Originally posted by DanH

This is some really bizarre maths and logic. You need 20% typically for a deposit, although help to buy can reduce this if you qualify. Average house price for a one bedroom property in London is £485k. A 20% deposit is £97k. How is a young person taking home about £1,500 net a month supposed to pay their rent and bills and still save enough to even scratch the surface of that?

I moved out of London to afford a house.
Unfortunately sometimes sacrifices need to be made to get what you want. And my logic is bizarre sometimes but it doesn't make it less logical when you look at the bigger picture.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Sep 21 10.01pm

Originally posted by DanH

This is some really bizarre maths and logic. You need 20% typically for a deposit, although help to buy can reduce this if you qualify. Average house price for a one bedroom property in London is £485k. A 20% deposit is £97k. How is a young person taking home about £1,500 net a month supposed to pay their rent and bills and still save enough to even scratch the surface of that?

20% is on the high side. If you accept a higher interest rate over a longer term then 5% will work with some lenders. Again a lot in cash for a 400k house of 20k but easier than 80k. Remember that a mortgage is a marathon not a sprint. I always avoided looking at the total I would pay at the end as over 25 years it will be at least 2x what i borrowed . Over a 50 year term it could be far greater but the property value should cover it at the end.
My house has gone up 200% in 20 years so that's a good mark.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 08 Sep 21 10.02pm

Originally posted by DanH

This is some really bizarre maths and logic. You need 20% typically for a deposit, although help to buy can reduce this if you qualify. Average house price for a one bedroom property in London is £485k. A 20% deposit is £97k. How is a young person taking home about £1,500 net a month supposed to pay their rent and bills and still save enough to even scratch the surface of that?

Move to Scotland. A 3 bedroom detached house in a nice area will cost half as much.
A 20% deposit might not be essential.

[Link]

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Sep 21 10.14pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Move to Scotland. A 3 bedroom detached house in a nice area will cost half as much.
A 20% deposit might not be essential.

[Link]

Thank you
I beleive that hmg are a guaranteeing up to a 20% loss on a default. Not that bad then are they. Helping people to buy a property.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 08 Sep 21 10.38pm

Can the thread title be changed to "Why can't the young be given more money because house prices have gone up"? Or something similar.

Or maybe get back on topic....

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

jeeagles Flag 09 Sep 21 12.20am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I agree. My daughter and her boyfriend are both Senior Spacecraft Engineers, so earn good money. My daughter left University with well over £50k in debt, which has interest added as well.
They work in Guildford so have to live within relatively easy reach, as they are on call. She has a flat (purchased with a mortgage and help from mum and dad) but they are struggling to upgrade to a house, even with their income

It's a nice area. They've built a lot of flats round and about so young people can get on the housing ladder.... unfortunately, they haven't built any new houses so slightly less young people can't move out.

Then huge amounts of housing stock in the area is taken up by empty nesters. Looking at my parents roads, at least half the houses are 3/4 bedroom with retired couples in them.

Whilst I may be completely heartless, if my parents had to sell their house to fund care then it wouldn't be the end of the world. They have no mortgage left.

Another, option would be to refinance the house on an interest only mortgage to pay for funding, then sell it when they pop their clogs.

They are asset rich, it would help free up housing stock, it might slow down the constant rises in house prices, it would end this cycle where future generations would have to keep taking on the financial burdens of future generations.

Although, this idea might not work outside of the south east of England so may require some tweaking.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Sep 21 7.06am

Originally posted by jeeagles

It's a nice area. They've built a lot of flats round and about so young people can get on the housing ladder.... unfortunately, they haven't built any new houses so slightly less young people can't move out.

Then huge amounts of housing stock in the area is taken up by empty nesters. Looking at my parents roads, at least half the houses are 3/4 bedroom with retired couples in them.

Whilst I may be completely heartless, if my parents had to sell their house to fund care then it wouldn't be the end of the world. They have no mortgage left.

Another, option would be to refinance the house on an interest only mortgage to pay for funding, then sell it when they pop their clogs.

They are asset rich, it would help free up housing stock, it might slow down the constant rises in house prices, it would end this cycle where future generations would have to keep taking on the financial burdens of future generations.

Although, this idea might not work outside of the south east of England so may require some tweaking.

Your 2nd and 3rd paragraph are interesting, as we had a similar conversation recently. In our road I would estimate that 50% of the properties are occupied by 1/2 people, many 4 bed houses, several also own other properties as well. They indeed should finance their own care IMO. My 91 yo mother in law lives in a 3 bed detached house, obviously mortgage free, despite my wife losing her inheritance, we both agree any care should be self funded.
With regard to housing, Horsham District Council are planning even more large developments, but you never see the “affordable “ housing they promise

 

manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 09 Sep 21 7.59am

To be honest it was inevitable that some where down the line money was going to be clawed back and taxes would rise. What I cannot understand is companies like Amazon uk and others that pay very little tax but make huge profits in this country. If these mega companies paid their due then, I not saying it would cover tax hikes but it seems as always one rule for them another for the working class.
Morrison’s this morning have reported that food prices are going to rise because PROFITS have fallen 43% PROFITS so they still made 57% profit. They want to think themselves lucky I know two people who’s business has gone down the pan because in the height of the lockdowns the council still expected them to pay their rates and rent on time with no concessions.

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 09 Sep 21 8.09am

yet again, working people are being hit hardest.

There might be some crumbs of comfort if Social Care was going to operate as it was intended to.

Even screwing the working person, is inevitably going to lead to a sharp decline in social services as the rich get richer.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 Sep 21 9.38am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I agree. My daughter and her boyfriend are both Senior Spacecraft Engineers, so earn good money. My daughter left University with well over £50k in debt, which has interest added as well.
They work in Guildford so have to live within relatively easy reach, as they are on call. She has a flat (purchased with a mortgage and help from mum and dad) but they are struggling to upgrade to a house, even with their income

It's a really good example - if two people earning that well can't buy a house, there really is no hope for the vast majority.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Sep 21 9.50am

Originally posted by DanH

Claiming someone has been ‘indoctrinated’ when there’s a wealth of academic studies out there on the housing market just makes you look like an arrogant and ignorant tit you realise, don’t you?

Academic studies?

And what do they tell us?

Price is linked to demand, and demand is not being met. Therefore, prices are rising much more rapidly than wages, which have stood still because of high employment.

What is funny is that you were told this would happen with such a high influx of immigrants, and now it has, you still won't accept it.

By the way, have you notice that so called academic studies are not always entirely unbiased. I wonder why that could be.

 

DanH Flag SW2 09 Sep 21 10.11am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Academic studies?

And what do they tell us?

Price is linked to demand, and demand is not being met. Therefore, prices are rising much more rapidly than wages, which have stood still because of high employment.

What is funny is that you were told this would happen with such a high influx of immigrants, and now it has, you still won't accept it.

By the way, have you notice that so called academic studies are not always entirely unbiased. I wonder why that could be.

Price is linked to both demand and supply. There are many, many factors which impact both. It's basic economics, not rocket science.

Immigration is a factor which affects demand, which has a knock on effect on price, but it is by no means the only or even the strongest one.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Sep 21 10.23am

Originally posted by DanH

Price is linked to both demand and supply. There are many, many factors which impact both. It's basic economics, not rocket science.

Immigration is a factor which affects demand, which has a knock on effect on price, but it is by no means the only or even the strongest one.

But it is, because a town's worth of people arrive here every year. We cannot build houses fast enough.

If your ideological persuasions disallow you from seeing this, then I will not persuade you.

The people that need persuading are those that are capable of objectivity.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 09 Sep 21 10.26am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

yet again, working people are being hit hardest.

There might be some crumbs of comfort if Social Care was going to operate as it was intended to.

Even screwing the working person, is inevitably going to lead to a sharp decline in social services as the rich get richer.

Yes, I can't help but think there must be a better way of bringing this in that doesn't hit those on low wages. Government are definitely more concerned with not hitting their rich mates disproportionately, than they are the poor. The trouble is, it's not like any of the other parties are genuine parties of the working man either nowadays.

 

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Workers to pay for social care