This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
so what your Saying is as the intention of the passer is to pass to the offside player, it should be ruled Offside, regardless of the 'active' Status of the receiving player? Essentially yes. I don't think defenders should be accountable for calling an offside (within reason). In a perfect world the linesman's flag would go up immediately and everybody would know that it is an offside. Plus, that would be given as a FK long before the defender would even touch the ball would it not?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Law 11 : A player in an offside position receiving the ball from an opponent who deliberately plays the ball, including by deliberate handball, is not considered to have gained an advantage, unless it was a deliberate save by any opponent. Precisely. It's nonsense in the situation I described.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Essentially yes. I don't think defenders should be accountable for calling an offside (within reason). In a perfect world the linesman's flag would go up immediately and everybody would know that it is an offside. Plus, that would be given as a FK long before the defender would even touch the ball would it not? I agree with you entirely, however the flag going up or not going up is irrelevant ie in a slightly less perfect world VAR should rule it offside in any event.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
I agree with you entirely, however the flag going up or not going up is irrelevant ie in a slightly less perfect world VAR should rule it offside in any event. Thank you YT.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Essentially yes. I don't think defenders should be accountable for calling an offside (within reason). In a perfect world the linesman's flag would go up immediately and everybody would know that it is an offside. Plus, that would be given as a FK long before the defender would even touch the ball would it not? Currently of course as Law 11 stands a player is not offside for merely being in an offside position. Edited by Willo (14 Feb 2023 12.49pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Currently of course as Law 11 stands a player is not offside for merely being in an offside position. Edited by Willo (14 Feb 2023 12.49pm) That doesn't make any sense whatsoever unless I am missing something.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Currently of course as Law 11 stands a player is not offside for merely being in an offside position. Edited by Willo (14 Feb 2023 12.49pm) It's a debate worth having. It would prevent situations like that with Rashford the other week.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Automated (or semi-automated as they like to call it) offsides will be in for next season. This will massively reduce the chance of time taken and errors made. Things like the Rashford goal (interfering or not?) will still be left to officials to make the final decision though, so there will still be room to bleat. People carp on about VAR and 'can't we go back to refs making the decisions' but ultimately it was brought in to do one job, and that was to significantly reduce the amount of serious mistakes in the game. It's done that. If you want to bin it off you're saying I want there to be more critical mistakes made in games. I want more teams to lose out to goals that should/should not have stood, players sent off when they shouldn't have been etc. All for the sake of some romantic ideal. Madness. If there was only a marginal difference in errors I'd reconsider my opinion but it's significant, in some cases from 82% > 95%, which at elite level is massive. Automate offsides and the main issue of time taken to make decisions also reduces drastically... it will get there. What you can't do is completely eliminate human error, but you can continue to reduce the chance of it happening. The system will become better and better over time. In the Rashford incident, the Law, as it stands, was correctly applied. I totally agree that in football as in life one simply cannot eliminate human errors, perfection is not in the human gift.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
In the Rashford incident, the Law, as it stands, was correctly applied. I totally agree that in football as in life one simply cannot eliminate human errors, perfection is not in the human gift. That's up for debate, and rightly so. That incident came down to someones interpretation of the law... there's certainly a case to say that shadowing the ball is affecting the decision making and therefore behaviour of the defenders around you, therefore interfering and therefore offside. I could be wrong but I don't think the law states a player has to have touched the ball to be interfering – eg. blocking a keepers line of sight is classed as interfering. It comes down to the application of the law and who is applying it and is more subjective than other more black and white laws Essentially, both decisions could potentially be correct in that scenario.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Automated (or semi-automated as they like to call it) offsides will be in for next season. This will massively reduce the chance of time taken and errors made. Things like the Rashford goal (interfering or not?) will still be left to officials to make the final decision though, so there will still be room to bleat. People carp on about VAR and 'can't we go back to refs making the decisions' but ultimately it was brought in to do one job, and that was to significantly reduce the amount of serious mistakes in the game. It's done that. If you want to bin it off you're saying I want there to be more critical mistakes made in games. I want more teams to lose out to goals that should/should not have stood, players sent off when they shouldn't have been etc. All for the sake of some romantic ideal. Madness. If there was only a marginal difference in errors I'd reconsider my opinion but it's significant, in some cases from 82% > 95%, which at elite level is massive. Automate offsides and the main issue of time taken to make decisions also reduces drastically... it will get there. What you can't do is completely eliminate human error, but you can continue to reduce the chance of it happening. The system will become better and better over time. Why not do away with the players and have all matches on PlayStation? Cheaper, more comfortable and no travel involved.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Why not do away with the players and have all matches on PlayStation? Cheaper, more comfortable and no travel involved. haha. Such an overreaction
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
I have read this thread with interest and some amusement. The new 'supremo' Howard Webb is having a 'crisis meeting' of all PL refs and VAR participants today to try and get some unanimity in interpretations and decisions. Lets hope it will improve matters. I understand there is an increased demand to use the semi-automated VAR used in the World Cup but it seems FIFA have not released it yet for general use. The VAR decisions were much clearer particularly the graphics. Nine PL grounds (but not Selhurst) already have the necessary Hawkeye installation to implement the FIFA system. Principally this requires extra cameras and a chip in the ball. Obviously there is a cost element and possible conflict with Adidas balls (used in WC) and Nike's in the PL. This should improve things but it is 'semi automated' which means the human element will still be a factor. Overall, I don't agree scrapping VAR altogether will be a good thing but it might sharpen up a ref's eyesight at bit and cease relying on the VAR to spot something he hasn't! The West Ham handball being missed by the ref. and VAR was incomprehensible. Not specifically about VAR but can someone explain to me why a linesman (sorry, ref's assistant) cannot raise his flag for offside until the conclusion of the move? Makes no sense to me. Delaying the raising of the flag in a situation where the official feels an offside offence has occurred is done to avoid robbing a side of a goal in the case of human error. VAR is here, most optimistically, to correct mistakes; it can only do so if something plays out. Once a flag is raised, play is impacted, and VAR has nothing that it can review even if the assistant was wrong. Accordingly because VAR cannot award a hypothetical goal, assistants delay the flag — even if it seems obvious to us, they know all too well it is always possible that they’ve seen the alignment incorrectly. Prior to last season the PL issued a new directive whereby assistants should only delay in cases when there is both a clear goalscoring opportunity and the call is a tight one. If a chance of a goal is not obvious,for instance play is headed out to the wings, or the assistant feels sure of the offside call they will flag immediately. Edited by Willo (14 Feb 2023 2.26pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
I have read this thread with interest and some amusement. The new 'supremo' Howard Webb is having a 'crisis meeting' of all PL refs and VAR participants today to try and get some unanimity in interpretations and decisions. Lets hope it will improve matters. I understand there is an increased demand to use the semi-automated VAR used in the World Cup but it seems FIFA have not released it yet for general use. The VAR decisions were much clearer particularly the graphics. Nine PL grounds (but not Selhurst) already have the necessary Hawkeye installation to implement the FIFA system. Principally this requires extra cameras and a chip in the ball. Obviously there is a cost element and possible conflict with Adidas balls (used in WC) and Nike's in the PL. This should improve things but it is 'semi automated' which means the human element will still be a factor. Overall, I don't agree scrapping VAR altogether will be a good thing but it might sharpen up a ref's eyesight at bit and cease relying on the VAR to spot something he hasn't! The West Ham handball being missed by the ref. and VAR was incomprehensible. Not specifically about VAR but can someone explain to me why a linesman (sorry, ref's assistant) cannot raise his flag for offside until the conclusion of the move? Makes no sense to me. Apparently there are different levels of installation with the automated offsides – chip in ball is not mandatory. Extra cameras are, though. Re. linesman flagging, it's for tight calls to ensure that whatever decision is made (offside/onside) the phase of play finishes rather than gets stopped prematurely. Why? In case a player is put through and scores. In the old system the linesman would flag and the ref would stop the game before the goal went in. New system, if the flag goes up once the ball goes in the net, it can be checked and awarded if the lino was wrong. Means in that instance the attacking team isn't incorrectly penalised.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Delaying the raising of the flag in a situation where the official feels an offside offence has occurred is done to avoid robbing a side of a goal in the case of human error. VAR is here, most optimistically, to correct mistakes; it can only do so if something plays out. Once a flag is raised, play is impacted, and VAR has nothing that it can review even if the assistant was wrong. Accordingly because VAR cannot award a hypothetical goal, assistants delay the flag — even if it seems obvious to us, they know all too well it is always possible that they’ve seen the alignment incorrectly. Doesn't that raise the possibility of a player getting injured in attempting to score or prevent a goal which wouldn't have counted anyway?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Delaying the raising of the flag in a situation where the official feels an offside offence has occurred is done to avoid robbing a side of a goal in the case of human error. VAR is here, most optimistically, to correct mistakes; it can only do so if something plays out. Once a flag is raised, play is impacted, and VAR has nothing that it can review even if the assistant was wrong. Accordingly because VAR cannot award a hypothetical goal, assistants delay the flag — even if it seems obvious to us, they know all too well it is always possible that they’ve seen the alignment incorrectly. A tidier explanation.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Or a joke.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Doesn't that raise the possibility of a player getting injured in attempting to score or prevent a goal which wouldn't have counted anyway? There is a 'School of thought' that players are no more likely to get injured in these instances than any other times. This does not logically refute the need for a late flag, as injury could take place at any time. This does not seem to outweigh the potential of deserved goals being overruled.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Doesn't that raise the possibility of a player getting injured in attempting to score or prevent a goal which wouldn't have counted anyway? Yep. Although rather obviously it also allows the player to potentially score and have that goal upheld, or make a goal saving tackle against a goal that would have stood etc etc etc It would be interesting to see the stats re. injuries as a result of continuation of play vs. goals scored or saved. I'd assume that injuries would be the least likely outcome. Goals are also the most important aspect of football... so it makes sense to create an environment where you increase the probability of them being scored.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.