This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
No one argues that Parish done a good Job originally, but the outside investment is always on his terms, he doesn't own the club, and the ridiculous voting system has made the board impotent IIRC SP always made it clear that he saw himself as a custodian of the club and he wouldn't jeopardise the club by handing control to new investors too readily. Evidence regarding Textor in particular suggests he's been right.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
IIRC SP always made it clear that he saw himself as a custodian of the club and he wouldn't jeopardise the club by handing control to new investors too readily. Eevidence regarding Textor in particular suggests he's been right. He cannot hide behind that one, it was he who choose the investors and gave them the green light to come in at Crystal Palace. The facts are his decision making is likely to cost this club its place in the EPL in the coming weeks unless there is drastic change in our fortunes. He cannot keep dining out on 2010. It's Crystal clear he has used the Club over the years to boost his own image for egotistical reasons as well as paying himself pocket money for not doing such a good job. He is not going to change and this club can only progress if he goes!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
He cannot hide behind that one, it was he who choose the investors and gave them the green light to come in at Crystal Palace. The facts are his decision making is likely to cost this club its place in the EPL in the coming weeks unless there is drastic change in our fortunes. He cannot keep dining out on 2010. It's Crystal clear he has used the Club over the years to boost his own image for egotistical reasons as well as paying himself pocket money for not doing such a good job. He is not going to change and this club can only progress if he goes! I don't disagree with what you're saying ..SP has been the architect and I find references back to 2010 equally irritating Just trying to rationalise why we're where we are. With regard to all three American investors we'd have been back in the Championship a long time ago without their money. At the same time I'm not sure I'd be comfortable with any of them owning / controlling the club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
He cannot hide behind that one, it was he who choose the investors and gave them the green light to come in at Crystal Palace. The facts are his decision making is likely to cost this club its place in the EPL in the coming weeks unless there is drastic change in our fortunes. He cannot keep dining out on 2010. It's Crystal clear he has used the Club over the years to boost his own image for egotistical reasons as well as paying himself pocket money for not doing such a good job. He is not going to change and this club can only progress if he goes! Crystal clear in your own mind... The only thing crystal clear is your distaste of Parish. The devil incarnate, here to make sure he does a terrible job and to bring down the club he supports because he's on an ego trip of how many nuts supporters he can gather who will put up banners and shout abuse at him and threaten his family (it's happened in the past.) Every year the same people pop up in this forum whenever something is going wrong and it's Parish fault, hes to blame, terrible job. Give it a rest... there are so many factors as to why things aren't going our way. The ample injuries, the lack of squad rotation, the lack of tactical change, the missed wins from letting in goals within the dying minutes, sheer bad luck, squad concentration being abysmal in the first few minutes of a game, players in odd positions, yes you could suggest squad depth but then again we have fresh players watching paint dry most games as Roy has a disposition for playing his favourites, you can then add disharmony with the shareholders albeit 1 shareholder who should be nicknamed Delboy of the US, FFP being far more involved as of late.
|
|
|
Originally posted by auk
Much of the reason for our current woes is the uncertainty about Roy. SP could end the endless speculation by stating unequivocally that we’re all in this together and Roy stays until the end of the season. Instead Roy is shilly-shallying and allowing the media to set the agenda which is demoralising both to Roy and to the team. Bringing in a new manager at this stage of the season would be reckless beyond belief. I disagree with it being reckless to replace Roy, but I totally agree that Parish needs to show leadership and come out and publicly back Roy if he is indeed being kept on.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1
Crystal clear in your own mind... The only thing crystal clear is your distaste of Parish. The devil incarnate, here to make sure he does a terrible job and to bring down the club he supports because he's on an ego trip of how many nuts supporters he can gather who will put up banners and shout abuse at him and threaten his family (it's happened in the past.) Every year the same people pop up in this forum whenever something is going wrong and it's Parish fault, hes to blame, terrible job. Give it a rest... there are so many factors as to why things aren't going our way. The ample injuries, the lack of squad rotation, the lack of tactical change, the missed wins from letting in goals within the dying minutes, sheer bad luck, squad concentration being abysmal in the first few minutes of a game, players in odd positions, yes you could suggest squad depth but then again we have fresh players watching paint dry most games as Roy has a disposition for playing his favourites, you can then add disharmony with the shareholders albeit 1 shareholder who should be nicknamed Delboy of the US, FFP being far more involved as of late. I certainly have no '' distaste '' for Parish. In fact, as somebody that has a friend who is one of Parish's best mates I find it easier to empathise with him than critisise. However, it's virtually a football fact of life that when things go wrong it's the owners and/or the manager that fingers get pointed at. When Steve re-hired Roy I feared the worst. Not because I don't like Hodgson, I think I have proved that on here. But because it wasn't a progressive step. Appointing a 76 year old on a 12 month deal is the worst kind of short termism. Yes, there have been mitigating circumstances such as the injuries. But there has definitely been a less than joined up approach to hiring that manager and the resulting recruitment. The disharmony within the Board...you have to speculate on what due diligence was done on Textor or was it just a case of getting the money in the bank and dealing with that later ?
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1
Crystal clear in your own mind... The only thing crystal clear is your distaste of Parish. The devil incarnate, here to make sure he does a terrible job and to bring down the club he supports because he's on an ego trip of how many nuts supporters he can gather who will put up banners and shout abuse at him and threaten his family (it's happened in the past.) Every year the same people pop up in this forum whenever something is going wrong and it's Parish fault, hes to blame, terrible job. Give it a rest... there are so many factors as to why things aren't going our way. The ample injuries, the lack of squad rotation, the lack of tactical change, the missed wins from letting in goals within the dying minutes, sheer bad luck, squad concentration being abysmal in the first few minutes of a game, players in odd positions, yes you could suggest squad depth but then again we have fresh players watching paint dry most games as Roy has a disposition for playing his favourites, you can then add disharmony with the shareholders albeit 1 shareholder who should be nicknamed Delboy of the US, FFP being far more involved as of late. Clearly we have disagree on Parish, the facts are there for all to see. I do not think anyone will disagree that what Parish and his fellow directors did in 2010 was truly outstanding, however that was 2010 or 14 years ago. What I am talking about is today and the future, Parish has allowed the squad depth to dwindle so much that at least half of those on the bench and in the current would not stand up in the championship or maybe even in L1. The options outside the top 7/8 players is very limited and even more so when
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I certainly have no '' distaste '' for Parish. In fact, as somebody that has a friend who is one of Parish's best mates I find it easier to empathise with him than critisise. However, it's virtually a football fact of life that when things go wrong it's the owners and/or the manager that fingers get pointed at. When Steve re-hired Roy I feared the worst. Not because I don't like Hodgson, I think I have proved that on here. But because it wasn't a progressive step. Appointing a 76 year old on a 12 month deal is the worst kind of short termism. Yes, there have been mitigating circumstances such as the injuries. But there has definitely been a less than joined up approach to hiring that manager and the resulting recruitment. The disharmony within the Board...you have to speculate on what due diligence was done on Textor or was it just a case of getting the money in the bank and dealing with that later ? Hindsights a great thing, before Xmas we didn't look too bad and it's very easy to pop up and say "told ya so" when things aren't going well, further into the season. Hodgson from last season did a fine job when I thought he wouldn't and there was no reason to think differently this season until we had injuries and Roy reverted back to negative football. Was Parish meant to know injuries would mean that Roy went back to previous form? We have no real idea what happens in the boardroom and Textor I'm sure is wise enough to know how a football club. I appreciate the different perspective though Neillo.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Clearly we have disagree on Parish, the facts are there for all to see. I do not think anyone will disagree that what Parish and his fellow directors did in 2010 was truly outstanding, however that was 2010 or 14 years ago. What I am talking about is today and the future, Parish has allowed the squad depth to dwindle so much that at least half of those on the bench and in the current would not stand up in the championship or maybe even in L1. The options outside the top 7/8 players is very limited and even more so when Again Den I respect your point of view. I just don't think any of it is that easy to get right and within the constraints of FFP for Palace. We sell next to nobody.We have a stadium that's in need of an upgrade or 6 and the squad depth I don't think is as bad as its made out. Franca hasn't been given a good chance, Holding is on the injury list and Henderson ....I agree wasn't worth £20 mill and agreed that was a bad use of money. The other lads need to be given some time to play when we aren't 3-0 down or 5 mins from the end. I hope we will be ok this season and if we are, then I expect the team once we don't have all the players injured. It will look not as bad.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SurbsEagle
The Premier League is not the be all and end all of football. Clubs who have fantastic owners have been relegated from the Premier League before and will again. Without harking on about it but, given where we were in 2010 - relegation is not the worst thing that COULD happen to this football club. I, of course, don't want it to happen and also don't think it will happen this season. We have a brilliant training facility, top class academy, prospects of an improved stadium, the infrastructure around the club has vastly improved since the owners took over and we also have the highest squad value we've ever had. Because football fans are emotionally reactive to say the least and often lack the longer term thinking/perspective an owner may hold, in fact quite the opposite, a bad loss to a rival for instance. You've made some really good points the SurbsEagle apropos the state of things outside of the players/performances on the pitch. I am still of the 'careful what you wish for' mindset with regards to Parish. He's done wonders for our club but I do believe that can exist simultaneously alongside discontent with the core essence of it, what we see week in/week out on a football pitch. I wouldn't mind some more pointed criticism however when I see 'Parish Out' banners, and I know it's an infuriating response, I can't help but think 'and what will that achieve?'. I'd rather, for instance, see banners displayed saying 'buy a f**king winger to replace Wilf', 'stop spending money on youngsters whilst the first XI is struggling' or 'change the depressing football'. I could always do an Arsenal and get some A4 sheets printed out I suppose
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by CpfcWeTrust1
Again Den I respect your point of view. I just don't think any of it is that easy to get right and within the constraints of FFP for Palace. We sell next to nobody.We have a stadium that's in need of an upgrade or 6 and the squad depth I don't think is as bad as its made out. Franca hasn't been given a good chance, Holding is on the injury list and Henderson ....I agree wasn't worth £20 mill and agreed that was a bad use of money. The other lads need to be given some time to play when we aren't 3-0 down or 5 mins from the end. I hope we will be ok this season and if we are, then I expect the team once we don't have all the players injured. It will look not as bad. I think that's part of the problem. I totally get that you don't want to lose your best players, and in an ideal world we would build a team around them. Only we can't afford to. And there is no conveyor belt of young players coming through. So you might have to sell one in order to fund the purchase of another two. I know that's not as easy as it sounds but at the moment we aren't trying either of those options.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Because football fans are emotionally reactive to say the least and often lack the longer term thinking/perspective an owner may hold, in fact quite the opposite, a bad loss to a rival for instance. You've made some really good points the SurbsEagle apropos the state of things outside of the players/performances on the pitch. I am still of the 'careful what you wish for' mindset with regards to Parish. He's done wonders for our club but I do believe that can exist simultaneously alongside discontent with the core essence of it, what we see week in/week out on a football pitch. I wouldn't mind some more pointed criticism however when I see 'Parish Out' banners, and I know it's an infuriating response, I can't help but think 'and what will that achieve?'. I'd rather, for instance, see banners displayed saying 'buy a f**king winger to replace Wilf', 'stop spending money on youngsters whilst the first XI is struggling' or 'change the depressing football'. I could always do an Arsenal and get some A4 sheets printed out I suppose I completely agree with everything you have said to be honest. Parish isn't perfect, nor is anyone really, but he has and continues to do a very good job of growing Crystal Palace in stature - which I assume would be his only objective over any singular result. The football is absolutely dire and we have had to sit through Pulis, Allardyce and Warnock era's since being in the Prem so that is saying something! Roy Hodgson should not be manager of CPFC in 2024 and that is blatantly obvious for anyone to see. Aside from that, I think everything else pinned on Parish at the moment wouldn't be quite as dramatic if we were in a better position in the league.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I think that's part of the problem. I totally get that you don't want to lose your best players, and in an ideal world we would build a team around them. Only we can't afford to. And there is no conveyor belt of young players coming through. So you might have to sell one in order to fund the purchase of another two. I know that's not as easy as it sounds but at the moment we aren't trying either of those options. 100%
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
It just takes one or two bad windows to drag a club downward. Like Parish said, if you're staying still, you're falling behind. I think what we're missing most right now is 1-2 strong veteran leaders, who keep everyone in line, and who have been through some wars in the past. Our current squad is so lightweight, with really no leaders. It's a squad of mostly "Type B" personalities. Signing Olise, Eze, Doucoure, and Guehi was a masterstroke by the club, but after that, I think they went too far in the direction of prospective gambling on young players (Franca, Ahamada, you can even say Munoz and Wharton, although I think they were both good signings) when they should have been signing a couple older more established players to balance things out. Lerma is an example of a player we could use more of. He's older and has no resell value, but he has been very valuable on the pitch this season. Also, I have no idea what is going on with our goalkeepers, but that has turned into a bizarre and expensive mistake. So I guess in general, since we hit the lottery on Eze, Olise, Doucoure, and Guehi, we got complacent and thought we could do no wrong. Edited by Wilbraham413 (06 Feb 2024 11.42pm) Some very insightful post on this thread..... While Wilf was a bit of a moaner he was also very animated and clearly showed frustration, not necessarily the best leadership qualities, but it was a display of passion for all to see! Similarly, I noted Olise getting frustrated with his colleagues on the pitch - the good players versus the mediocre. We need that leadership, vocal, galvanizing belief and total passion on the pitch. Witness the commitment of Dunk, who epitomized the rivalry that these days is absent from our lot. Another failure of Hodgson teams, (and said of Viera as well when he was under pressure), is that of a lack of overall team identity. You are not quite sure what you are going to get when the team goes on. Ayew puts in a good shift for sure, and recently Mateta has run his socks off and Olise definitely has a go, but the rest seem to be ambivalent. We used to be known as a solid defending team with counter-attacking that could do damage, but all that seems to have evaporated now. This, for me, is the primary reason Roy and Co must GO!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.