You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 9.05pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 438 of 753 < 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 28 Nov 20 11.58am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I've played no part in this thread up to now so apologies if I'm about to retread old ground and congratulations for reaching 700+ pages. Nugent-esque.

However, I'm increasingly being swayed by the view of Mike Yeadon and others who argue that the PCR tests are wildly inaccurate and churning out thousands of false positives per day.

I simply don't see how a disease that is supposedly twice as infectious as seasonal flu, which itself usually takes around 4-5 months to get round the country, has taken twice as long to infect far fewer people. Something just doesn't add up.

It's also striking how few excess deaths there have been since the peak back in April/May when it obviously was rampaging round.

Minimal excess deaths, hospitals actually less full than this time last year, yet apparently we have tens of thousands of cases per day and should be cowering away in our homes. So what gives?

There is mounting evidence that Covid is far less deadly than previously thought, with the latest suggestion being that it kills 0.4% of cases or fewer and I honestly believe that there are far, far fewer cases than we're being told.

I'm in a difficult position as my grandmother, brother and mother in law are all classed as 'vulnerable' owing to medical conditions so, even though I believe all this, I would never put them at risk by acting on it and get short shrift from my wife for even discussing it.

However, for me something isn't right so I'd love someone on here to explain why my views are nonsense and put me at ease that this crappy Christmas with no boozing in the pub is going to be worth it.

PCR tests are capable of being pretty inaccurate, yes

60-90% range

A lot of factors determine which percentage you fall into - eg you are at the mercy of the competence of the individual poking around in your face, for example

And at home swabs are likely to be even worse - I’ve been tested multiple times and I know how deep that thing has to go! No positives though.

The rapid tests are far worse. 40-70%, only good for catching people with high viral loads. Will false neg anyone with lower levels of virus which is not ideal

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Nov 20 12.00pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

PCR tests are capable of being pretty inaccurate, yes

60-90% range

A lot of factors determine which percentage you fall into - eg you are at the mercy of the competence of the individual poking around in your face, for example

And at home swabs are likely to be even worse - I’ve been tested multiple times and I know how deep that thing has to go! No positives though.

The rapid tests are far worse. 40-70%, only good for catching people with high viral loads. Will false neg anyone with lower levels of virus which is not ideal

Test symptomatic people only. End this nonsense.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Nov 20 1.13pm

Live coverage of London protests

[Link]

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Nov 20 2.42pm

 


COYP

Eden Eagle Flag Kent 28 Nov 20 3.33pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Interesting that one or two or you perhaps feel similarly to me about it.

It's a tricky stance to take because suggesting that the pandemic is being overblown, or is perhaps even over, to someone who might have lost a loved one to it inevitably can come across as insensitive. I'm just very concerned that we are destroying our economy and sleepwalking in a far more severe period of austerity based on misinformation.

I'm not denying the initial impact of Coronavirus or even that it still lives among us, I merely believe that we have huge issues when it comes to categorising Covid deaths (classing anyone who has died of any reason as a Covid death if they have tested positive within 28 days) coupled with a testing system that is highly faulty. These are clearly problematic when seismic decisions affecting the economy and people's lives are being made.

From what I understand, the PCR test was never designed to be the front line of testing for a disease, it was supposed to offer confirmation once a clinical diagnosis had already been made. It was also supposed to be carried out in a controlled lab environment, not on an industrial scale in giant testing centres before being transported in huge batches around the country.

Supposedly, the test is known to produce an absolute minimum of 2% false positives, or 20,000 for every 1,000,000 tests carried out. When you add in the potential for cross contamination from the sheer industrial scale in which the tests are now being carried out, it becomes a guessing game as to how high that number actually is. Especially as the government have thus far refused to give a figure.

Interestingly the Portuguese Court of Appeal have now ruled that the PCR test “is unable to determine, beyond reasonable doubt, that a positive result corresponds, in fact, to the infection of a person by the SARS-CoV-2 virus”. You can read about that here: [Link]

Another development which I notedwith interest was that John Ioannidis, a professor of epidemiology at Stanford University, has published a paper stating that our initial predictions surrounding the death rate of this virus, and therefore our reaction to it, were wildly overegged. That paper has actually been peer reviewed now and was published by the WHO as a result. I can't share a link but if you Google 'John Ioannidis WHO paper' it's the top result.


Edited by Canterbury Palace (28 Nov 2020 10.59am)

Many more people are waking up now to what appears to be going on yet the lockdown fanatics just want longer/deeper lockdowns with no concern around the collateral damage of non diagnosed cancers, thousands of businesses closed, millions unemployed, increased poverty, eye watering debt being built up by the Govt etc.

What amazes me is that over Brexit many people say that Johnson, Gove etc lied and cheated yet with CV19 they believe every word they say - ignoring how much money they have given to their chums for contracts etc.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Nov 20 3.54pm

Blimey mate.

Yet when it's BLM the activists get to chase them down the streets while a good number of them kneel to them.

Deface Churchill or the cenotaph....their managers have them chilled and laid back.

I've no respect, nor time for Plod anymore.

Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Nov 2020 3.56pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Nov 20 4.00pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Blimey mate.

Yet when it's BLM the activists get to chase them down the streets while a good number of them kneel to them.

Deface Churchill or the cenotaph....their managers have them chilled and laid back.

I've no respect, nor time for Plod anymore.

Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Nov 2020 3.56pm)

Blimey mate you’re good at this game

 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Nov 20 4.22pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Blimey mate you’re good at this game

I'm just like you mate, p1ssed off with it all.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 28 Nov 20 6.15pm

what i really dont like about this, is under the covid regulations we are not allowed to protest, this is as bad as east germany in the 70's

Edited by thegreatlardino (28 Nov 2020 6.15pm)

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Nov 20 8.13pm

Originally posted by thegreatlardino

what i really dont like about this, is under the covid regulations we are not allowed to protest, this is as bad as east germany in the 70's

Edited by thegreatlardino (28 Nov 2020 6.15pm)

Difference is they were good at it. Still time for these w@nkers to catch up if these vaccines are another lie to give the scared masses hope. I won’t be surprised if this goes on a lot longer than people are believing.

 


COYP

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Nov 20 11.03pm

I wonder, how many of you are actually directly financially affected by the restrictions, both now and next week?

Making sure that the people, and businesses, that are impacted are compensated is very important. Are you? Shops will reopen, lots are working at home, construction is busy. Are you?

To describe what has happened/will happen as a lockdown seems inaccurate to me when what we really have are restrictions on what we can do, with the promise of them being eased back if we all co-operate and eliminated as a vaccination programme gets established.

Moaning about the accuracy of testing, or the only partial success of track and trace, doesn't change or help, anyone or anything.

The whole point of doing this is to try and ensure we modify our behaviour so as to limit the spread of a highly infectious and dangerous virus before a vaccine becomes available. Not just to prevent deaths, important though that is, but to ensure that our health services remain able to treat all the other things we rely on it for at the time of year when it is normally busiest. Overload the NHS with C19 cases and there would be severe consequences. There have already been some, but it would likely be much worse. Many NHS staff are already suffering from burnout.

Some believe that the cure is worse than the disease but I don't believe that's true. It's easy to claim because it hasn't been seen and the grass is always greener on the other side. The economic impacts will be significant but they can be handled and recovered from, as we have always recovered in the past.

So after comparing the balance of expert opinion with the amateurs pontificating here I think we all ought to follow the advice and just get on with it. I am.

I am lucky. We are in Tier 1 from the start. Get it right and others can be too quite soon.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Nov 20 11.20pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I wonder, how many of you are actually directly financially affected by the restrictions, both now and next week?

Making sure that the people, and businesses, that are impacted are compensated is very important. Are you? Shops will reopen, lots are working at home, construction is busy. Are you?

To describe what has happened/will happen as a lockdown seems inaccurate to me when what we really have are restrictions on what we can do, with the promise of them being eased back if we all co-operate and eliminated as a vaccination programme gets established.

Moaning about the accuracy of testing, or the only partial success of track and trace, doesn't change or help, anyone or anything.

The whole point of doing this is to try and ensure we modify our behaviour so as to limit the spread of a highly infectious and dangerous virus before a vaccine becomes available. Not just to prevent deaths, important though that is, but to ensure that our health services remain able to treat all the other things we rely on it for at the time of year when it is normally busiest. Overload the NHS with C19 cases and there would be severe consequences. There have already been some, but it would likely be much worse. Many NHS staff are already suffering from burnout.

Some believe that the cure is worse than the disease but I don't believe that's true. It's easy to claim because it hasn't been seen and the grass is always greener on the other side. The economic impacts will be significant but they can be handled and recovered from, as we have always recovered in the past.

So after comparing the balance of expert opinion with the amateurs pontificating here I think we all ought to follow the advice and just get on with it. I am.

I am lucky. We are in Tier 1 from the start. Get it right and others can be too quite soon.

The problem is that many people have followed the advice and are still being told they can’t mix with others, go to the pub or have much of a Christmas. The current restrictions will probably be in place for months to come and after 8 months have achieved nothing except protecting the NHS. Leaving aside the damage to the economy the mental health problems this is causing will be felt for many years.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 28 Nov 20 11.39pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

The problem is that many people have followed the advice and are still being told they can’t mix with others, go to the pub or have much of a Christmas. The current restrictions will probably be in place for months to come and after 8 months have achieved nothing except protecting the NHS. Leaving aside the damage to the economy the mental health problems this is causing will be felt for many years.

I do believe that was the main aim all along to be fair (NHS). So...

I still find it bizarre that people are expecting things to be normal, then surprised when they aren’t

Providing these vaccines are up to the job, as I said months ago, looking at it realistically it will be spring/summer of 2022 before things really start to feel normal again. But I can see winters remaining dicey for a few years - and people certainly won’t be letting go of the paranoia of contact for a long time. That will be hard to shift - vaccines don’t mean this thing goes away. It just becomes yet another flu virus, albeit a far more infectious one that will remain in circulation ad infinitum

As with all things we’ll eventually get used to it and learn to live with it, understand it and become complacent about it all again. But that doesn’t take months, it takes years

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 28 Nov 20 11.40pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I wonder, how many of you are actually directly financially affected by the restrictions, both now and next week?

Making sure that the people, and businesses, that are impacted are compensated is very important. Are you? Shops will reopen, lots are working at home, construction is busy. Are you?

To describe what has happened/will happen as a lockdown seems inaccurate to me when what we really have are restrictions on what we can do, with the promise of them being eased back if we all co-operate and eliminated as a vaccination programme gets established.

Moaning about the accuracy of testing, or the only partial success of track and trace, doesn't change or help, anyone or anything.

The whole point of doing this is to try and ensure we modify our behaviour so as to limit the spread of a highly infectious and dangerous virus before a vaccine becomes available. Not just to prevent deaths, important though that is, but to ensure that our health services remain able to treat all the other things we rely on it for at the time of year when it is normally busiest. Overload the NHS with C19 cases and there would be severe consequences. There have already been some, but it would likely be much worse. Many NHS staff are already suffering from burnout.

Some believe that the cure is worse than the disease but I don't believe that's true. It's easy to claim because it hasn't been seen and the grass is always greener on the other side. The economic impacts will be significant but they can be handled and recovered from, as we have always recovered in the past.

So after comparing the balance of expert opinion with the amateurs pontificating here I think we all ought to follow the advice and just get on with it. I am.

I am lucky. We are in Tier 1 from the start. Get it right and others can be too quite soon.

As have been the deaths from known cases of pandemics of the past. Without lockdowns or vaccines. There is no 'second wave'. Pandemics/epidemics do not have second waves. It's a fact. This is a coronavirus. Different from all other coronaviruses, but behaving exactly the same. The pandemic ended in this country in April/May. Hospitals are nowhere near capacity. If they were, the Nightingale field hospitals would be busy. How many patients in those?

Stop believing the bollox spouted by the Gov and main stream media and do some real research.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Nov 20 11.41pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

The problem is that many people have followed the advice and are still being told they can’t mix with others, go to the pub or have much of a Christmas. The current restrictions will probably be in place for months to come and after 8 months have achieved nothing except protecting the NHS. Leaving aside the damage to the economy the mental health problems this is causing will be felt for many years.

Not everyone though has followed the advice, have they? Some resisted from the start whilst others have become disaffected as time passed. It's tough, but it's necessary. I know some folk who could be spending Christmas with their family but won't, because they remain fearful. The mental health issues are very real, but if we overload the NHS wards will need to be reallocated and even less treatment available. There are no easy answers. Nothing solves the problems and difficult choices are having to be made which will always find those who disagree.

The important thing surely is that whether we agree or not we all just do it. We must support each other.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Nov 20 11.56pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Not everyone though has followed the advice, have they? Some resisted from the start whilst others have become disaffected as time passed. It's tough, but it's necessary. I know some folk who could be spending Christmas with their family but won't, because they remain fearful. The mental health issues are very real, but if we overload the NHS wards will need to be reallocated and even less treatment available. There are no easy answers. Nothing solves the problems and difficult choices are having to be made which will always find those who disagree.

The important thing surely is that whether we agree or not we all just do it. We must support each other.

Lots of people won’t be spending Christmas with their families not out of fear but because they’ve been told they can’t. Similarly the mental health issues are largely down to feelings of isolation as well as worries over job security. Many people on their own in one bedroom flats are having a very hard time.
The longer the restrictions remain the more people will resist them. Young people who don’t think they’ll be badly affected by the virus won’t abide by these regulations.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 29 Nov 20 12.57am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I wonder, how many of you are actually directly financially affected by the restrictions, both now and next week?

Making sure that the people, and businesses, that are impacted are compensated is very important. Are you? Shops will reopen, lots are working at home, construction is busy. Are you?

To describe what has happened/will happen as a lockdown seems inaccurate to me when what we really have are restrictions on what we can do, with the promise of them being eased back if we all co-operate and eliminated as a vaccination programme gets established.

Moaning about the accuracy of testing, or the only partial success of track and trace, doesn't change or help, anyone or anything.

The whole point of doing this is to try and ensure we modify our behaviour so as to limit the spread of a highly infectious and dangerous virus before a vaccine becomes available. Not just to prevent deaths, important though that is, but to ensure that our health services remain able to treat all the other things we rely on it for at the time of year when it is normally busiest. Overload the NHS with C19 cases and there would be severe consequences. There have already been some, but it would likely be much worse. Many NHS staff are already suffering from burnout.

Some believe that the cure is worse than the disease but I don't believe that's true. It's easy to claim because it hasn't been seen and the grass is always greener on the other side. The economic impacts will be significant but they can be handled and recovered from, as we have always recovered in the past.

So after comparing the balance of expert opinion with the amateurs pontificating here I think we all ought to follow the advice and just get on with it. I am.

I am lucky. We are in Tier 1 from the start. Get it right and others can be too quite soon.


Unfortunately your argument falls flat at the point when you mislabel the debate as expert opinion vs amateur pontification. There are actually 'experts' arguing both sides so really it's a question of whose experts are correct.

I have decided I no longer have faith in the expertise of Boris Johnson who has leapt from one incoherent strategy to the next on an almost weekly basis whilst helping us over the £2 trillion national debt threshold. Nor do I have any particular trust in SAGE, whose deputy chair has revealed that their shambolic early modelling used data taken from Wikipedia. And let's not get started on Whitty and Vallance whose doomsday prediction of 4000 deaths per day throughout the autumn was repeated by the Prime Minister in the Commons days after it was debunked as utter nonsense.

The question marks over the accuracy of the testing aren't really question marks, it is known unequivocally that they are inaccurate to a certain degree and, as I posted a couple of pages ago, the Portuguese courts have officially labelled them as being unreliable. Really the only question is how badly wrong they are but it is expected that a sizeable percentage of the cases are false.

You might not think questioning that accuracy benefits anyone but I'd suggest that the hundreds of thousands of staff in the hospitality industry facing a loss of their livelihoods, the cancer and heart patients who are missing being diagnosed and treated, the mentally vulnerable who are stuck in isolation due to restrictions on household mixing and so on might feel differently if there was a legitimate, strong argument that these draconian measures are all in vain.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Nov 20 1.06am

 


COYP

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 29 Nov 20 1.09am


Get them to vote it through and then hope they all forget when you don't end it in nine weeks.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Nov 20 1.14am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


Get them to vote it through and then hope they all forget when you don't end it in nine weeks.

It’ll get voted through again because of flu and usual winter workload in hospitals plus the backlog. Why were the hospitals empty in all of July-October?

Plus the government want to avoid having to provide a cost benefit analysis. They either do t have one or it doesn’t back these policies.

Anyone for this definitely isn’t suffering any financial or work/future issues. I even speak to old people who think it’s absurd and unfair on families and young people who will pay the price in the end. ‘We must cover them financially.’ That never really happens and won’t this time either. In the end they’ll get shafted, just too many of them aren’t aware of it.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (29 Nov 2020 1.20am)

 


COYP

Page 438 of 753 < 434 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic