You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 439 of 753 < 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 >
Stirlingsays Flag 29 Nov 20 4.51am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It’ll get voted through again because of flu and usual winter workload in hospitals plus the backlog. Why were the hospitals empty in all of July-October?

Plus the government want to avoid having to provide a cost benefit analysis. They either do t have one or it doesn’t back these policies.

Anyone for this definitely isn’t suffering any financial or work/future issues. I even speak to old people who think it’s absurd and unfair on families and young people who will pay the price in the end. ‘We must cover them financially.’ That never really happens and won’t this time either. In the end they’ll get shafted, just too many of them aren’t aware of it.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (29 Nov 2020 1.20am)

Seconded.

It gives me nothing but sorrow to say that the price of these policies have only just started.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Nov 20 6.31am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Seconded.

It gives me nothing but sorrow to say that the price of these policies have only just started.

And the NHS will be able to cope?

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 29 Nov 20 7.31am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3578285]

As have been the deaths from known cases of pandemics of the past. Without lockdowns or vaccines. There is no 'second wave'. Pandemics/epidemics do not have second waves. It's a fact. This is a coronavirus. Different from all other coronaviruses, but behaving exactly the same. The pandemic ended in this country in April/May. Hospitals are nowhere near capacity. If they were, the Nightingale field hospitals would be busy. How many patients in those?

Stop believing the bollox spouted by the Gov and main stream media and do some real research.

I bet you are fun at parties, when you are allowed to go again. Wait a mo, you probably still are, as there isn't a second wave and those statistics we see are just made up!

The hospitals may not yet be near full capacity, but it's not peak season yet. The Nightingale hospitals are ready as a fallback position for worst-case scenarios and to shift the treatment of C19 patients away from some hospitals which cannot cope safely. A new one has just opened in Exeter just for that purpose and is already receiving patients.

I bet you are also a climate change denier and think that vaccines are a control mechanism developed by Bill Gates, George Soros and the WHO to implant microchips in our brains. Believe in Q too? That's the real bollox.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 29 Nov 20 7.41am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Lots of people won’t be spending Christmas with their families not out of fear but because they’ve been told they can’t. Similarly the mental health issues are largely down to feelings of isolation as well as worries over job security. Many people on their own in one bedroom flats are having a very hard time.
The longer the restrictions remain the more people will resist them. Young people who don’t think they’ll be badly affected by the virus won’t abide by these regulations.

Identifying issues doesn't solve them. There is no perfect solution and no-one wants to damage the economy or put people in one room flats through hard times. Finding ways to mitigate the impact on the most vulnerable is clearly needed.

And of course the longer it goes on the more some people will resist them. You have only to read the comments here to know that. Keeping that number to the lowest possible, either through education or control is the answer.

Doing what we are doing is destructive and painful. Not doing it would be worse. Both in my view and, it seems, in the majority of expert opinion not just in the UK but around the world.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Nov 20 7.41am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I wonder, how many of you are actually directly financially affected by the restrictions, both now and next week?

Making sure that the people, and businesses, that are impacted are compensated is very important. Are you? Shops will reopen, lots are working at home, construction is busy. Are you?

To describe what has happened/will happen as a lockdown seems inaccurate to me when what we really have are restrictions on what we can do, with the promise of them being eased back if we all co-operate and eliminated as a vaccination programme gets established.

Moaning about the accuracy of testing, or the only partial success of track and trace, doesn't change or help, anyone or anything.

The whole point of doing this is to try and ensure we modify our behaviour so as to limit the spread of a highly infectious and dangerous virus before a vaccine becomes available. Not just to prevent deaths, important though that is, but to ensure that our health services remain able to treat all the other things we rely on it for at the time of year when it is normally busiest. Overload the NHS with C19 cases and there would be severe consequences. There have already been some, but it would likely be much worse. Many NHS staff are already suffering from burnout.

Some believe that the cure is worse than the disease but I don't believe that's true. It's easy to claim because it hasn't been seen and the grass is always greener on the other side. The economic impacts will be significant but they can be handled and recovered from, as we have always recovered in the past.

So after comparing the balance of expert opinion with the amateurs pontificating here I think we all ought to follow the advice and just get on with it. I am.

I am lucky. We are in Tier 1 from the start. Get it right and others can be too quite soon.

Of course it is a lockdown, many shops still closed and being told only travel if really necessary, I have always followed the rules and have been ultra careful but to say it is not a lockdown is totally wrong. Try walking around deserted high streets and shopping centres in Tier2/3 area's

Yes you are lucky, we were in Tier1 and have been put into Tier 2 for no apparent reason, so we were getting it right and still that is not good enough. As was Maldon in Essex, one of lowest infection rates in the U.K. and they went from Tier1 to Tier 2
My son has been affected financially, he lost his job with no prospect of getting it back, now fully supported by us again, so yes as a family we are affected, nowhere near as bad as some but still affected.
Daughters boyfriend is unable to visit his family in the NW as they are in Tier 3.
I really don’t think you understand the strain this is putting on relationships and mental health, you will say you do, but really?
You still have to be rude about other posters, who have genuine valid points, while you sit in your Tier 1 haven.

Edited by Spiderman (29 Nov 2020 7.45am)

Edited by Spiderman (29 Nov 2020 8.07am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 29 Nov 20 8.08am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


Unfortunately your argument falls flat at the point when you mislabel the debate as expert opinion vs amateur pontification. There are actually 'experts' arguing both sides so really it's a question of whose experts are correct.

I have decided I no longer have faith in the expertise of Boris Johnson who has leapt from one incoherent strategy to the next on an almost weekly basis whilst helping us over the £2 trillion national debt threshold. Nor do I have any particular trust in SAGE, whose deputy chair has revealed that their shambolic early modelling used data taken from Wikipedia. And let's not get started on Whitty and Vallance whose doomsday prediction of 4000 deaths per day throughout the autumn was repeated by the Prime Minister in the Commons days after it was debunked as utter nonsense.

The question marks over the accuracy of the testing aren't really question marks, it is known unequivocally that they are inaccurate to a certain degree and, as I posted a couple of pages ago, the Portuguese courts have officially labelled them as being unreliable. Really the only question is how badly wrong they are but it is expected that a sizeable percentage of the cases are false.

You might not think questioning that accuracy benefits anyone but I'd suggest that the hundreds of thousands of staff in the hospitality industry facing a loss of their livelihoods, the cancer and heart patients who are missing being diagnosed and treated, the mentally vulnerable who are stuck in isolation due to restrictions on household mixing and so on might feel differently if there was a legitimate, strong argument that these draconian measures are all in vain.

There will always be a few rogue "experts" who take a different approach. There are in most fields. On balance though the consensus view of the specialists in this field, both here and around the world supports what we are doing.

So I would rather trust them than the ones cherry-picked by the amateurs on the Hol just because they happen to support their prejudices.

The testing might not be perfect but it's useful in identifying where high risks exist and enabling interventions to dampen them down. It's purpose is not to provide 100% guidance to individuals.

The hospitality industry, and it's staff must be adequately supported if they bear a disproportionate cost. Just because one sector of the economy gets hit harder than another is not an excuse for a lack of action. It's a reason to look after them properly.

It's to ensure that cancer patients, and all the other treatments we rely on the NHS for, including elective surgery, don't get hit again that we are having to face these restrictions. There's not an endless supply of doctors and nurses available. If the need to treat people with C19 increases then surgical wards close just so the staff can be reallocated.

The impact on mental health cannot be underestimated or ignored and I am quite sure it is all part of the overall equation when seeking the optimum solution.

We all have a role to play in supporting those we know are isolated or otherwise vulnerable. I make phone calls to those I know, and arrange to meet people outside sometimes just to go for a walk together, socially distanced of course. Small things help and we can all do them.

If however those with really severe mental health issues need clinical support we must make sure the NHS remains open to them. Swamping it with C19 won't do that.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Nov 20 8.13am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Of course it is a lockdown, many shops still closed and being told only travel if really necessary, I have always followed the rules and have been ultra careful but to say it is not a lockdown is totally wrong. Try walking around deserted high streets and shopping centres in Tier2/3 area's

Yes you are lucky, we were in Tier1 and have been put into Tier 2 for no apparent reason, so we were getting it right and still that is not good enough.
My son has been affected financially, he lost his job with no prospect of getting it back, now fully supported by us again, so yes as a family we are affected, nowhere near as bad as some but still affected.
Daughters boyfriend is unable to visit his family in the NW as they are in Tier 3.
I really don’t think you understand the strain this is putting on relationships and mental health, you will say you do, but really?
You still have to be rude about other posters, who have genuine valid points, while you sit in your Tier 1 haven.

Edited by Spiderman (29 Nov 2020 7.45am)

I have a birthday soon a couple of lady friends wanted to organise something for me e.g. lunch or a drink in the pub. However you cannot meet people in doors even if you are socially distancing so I have told them thanks but don't bother.

It's lockdown by any other name. It's not the tiers I have a problem with it how areas are allocated to them.

I also think that allowing people to meet in a pub or restaurant say max 6 should be allowed and would be fine if we had a curfew.

As for Christmas travel if any rail authorities are planing engineering works they should be sacked. We have just had a 1 month lockdown a perfect opporunity to do that work if further work is needed do it in January it aint going be busy.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 29 Nov 20 8.33am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Of course it is a lockdown, many shops still closed and being told only travel if really necessary, I have always followed the rules and have been ultra careful but to say it is not a lockdown is totally wrong. Try walking around deserted high streets and shopping centres in Tier2/3 area's

Yes you are lucky, we were in Tier1 and have been put into Tier 2 for no apparent reason, so we were getting it right and still that is not good enough. As was Maldon in Essex, one of lowest infection rates in the U.K. and they went from Tier1 to Tier 2
My son has been affected financially, he lost his job with no prospect of getting it back, now fully supported by us again, so yes as a family we are affected, nowhere near as bad as some but still affected.
Daughters boyfriend is unable to visit his family in the NW as they are in Tier 3.
I really don’t think you understand the strain this is putting on relationships and mental health, you will say you do, but really?
You still have to be rude about other posters, who have genuine valid points, while you sit in your Tier 1 haven.

Edited by Spiderman (29 Nov 2020 7.45am)

Edited by Spiderman (29 Nov 2020 8.07am)

No it's not a lockdown! Not like we had before. The schools remain open and next week all the shops will re-open. More activities remain active and people are working. Life is being restricted, primarily socially. No-one likes it, but it's not going to hurt too much not being able to go to the pub or to watch football. It's survivable and temporary.

People being isolated and vulnerable is the biggest concern I see. I am only too aware of the impact on people's mental health as it has hit my own family. One of my daughters was admitted as an emergency a few weeks ago. Thank goodness that the NHS was there for her.

The issues of which area is in which Tier and where the boundaries are completely separate arguments, which I won't pass comment on as I am not party to all the various considerations. We expected to be in Tier 2 and anticipate being moved up in December, so plenty of uncertainty remains for us too.

I am sorry to hear about your son, but presumably he got some redundancy payments and now universal credit. He is also safe and being cared for. He and you aren't alone and I know it's tough for everyone but things will get better. We just need to stay together.

Whether points are valid, or not, will always be a matter of opinion, just as whether something is rude or straightforward.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Nov 20 9.12am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No it's not a lockdown! Not like we had before. The schools remain open and next week all the shops will re-open. More activities remain active and people are working. Life is being restricted, primarily socially. No-one likes it, but it's not going to hurt too much not being able to go to the pub or to watch football. It's survivable and temporary.

People being isolated and vulnerable is the biggest concern I see. I am only too aware of the impact on people's mental health as it has hit my own family. One of my daughters was admitted as an emergency a few weeks ago. Thank goodness that the NHS was there for her.

The issues of which area is in which Tier and where the boundaries are completely separate arguments, which I won't pass comment on as I am not party to all the various considerations. We expected to be in Tier 2 and anticipate being moved up in December, so plenty of uncertainty remains for us too.

I am sorry to hear about your son, but presumably he got some redundancy payments and now universal credit. He is also safe and being cared for. He and you aren't alone and I know it's tough for everyone but things will get better. We just need to stay together.

Whether points are valid, or not, will always be a matter of opinion, just as whether something is rude or straightforward.

My son had a seasonal zero hour contract at a theme park last year. He had 1 day refresher training in March, the next day he was told that park would not be opening for the foreseeable. No redundancy and no furlough payments. He had some savings which have now been eradicated so has just applied for Universal credit.
It may not officially be a lockdown but imo I have no more “freedom” than during the official lockdown

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Nov 20 9.17am

Originally posted by Badger11

I have a birthday soon a couple of lady friends wanted to organise something for me e.g. lunch or a drink in the pub. However you cannot meet people in doors even if you are socially distancing so I have told them thanks but don't bother.

It's lockdown by any other name. It's not the tiers I have a problem with it how areas are allocated to them.

I also think that allowing people to meet in a pub or restaurant say max 6 should be allowed and would be fine if we had a curfew.

As for Christmas travel if any rail authorities are planing engineering works they should be sacked. We have just had a 1 month lockdown a perfect opporunity to do that work if further work is needed do it in January it aint going be busy.

Here we go, I agree with you absolute disgrace


[Link]

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 29 Nov 20 9.38am

Originally posted by Spiderman

My son had a seasonal zero hour contract at a theme park last year. He had 1 day refresher training in March, the next day he was told that park would not be opening for the foreseeable. No redundancy and no furlough payments. He had some savings which have now been eradicated so has just applied for Universal credit.
It may not officially be a lockdown but imo I have no more “freedom” than during the official lockdown


I am really sorry to hear of your son's experience. So if I understand correctly he wasn't employed during the winter and about to be re-employed when the pandemic scuppered it. I am not an expert on Universal Credit but am aware of the difficulties and delays that some suffer. I would though have thought he ought to have been entitled both during last winter and right up to now. It's worth him asking!

Everyone's experience obviously varies. I miss the pub and the company, but I'm walking more and socialising that way. The number of people running and cycling around here this year is quite remarkable.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Nov 20 9.51am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Here we go, I agree with you absolute disgrace


[Link]

I bang on about this every year. Many low paid workers have to work shift often late Christmas Eve and then early Boxing day or the day after. It must be a nightmare for them if they have to travel and get back in time for their next shift.

M&S refused to change my shift or allow me a day off for 3 years on the trot, I suspect many will tell a similar story.

It would make more sense for the rail companies to pick a weekend in January when nobody has any money and do the work then. If properly advertised and explained I think most people (including the rail maintenance crews) would rather accept an inconvenience in January than over the major holidays.

This year I would like to know what they have been doing during the lockdown.

Edited by Badger11 (29 Nov 2020 9.54am)

 


One more point

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Nov 20 9.54am

Originally posted by Badger11

I bang on about this every year. Many low paid workers have to work shift often late Christmas Eve and then early Boxing day or the day after. It must be a nightmare for them if they have to travel and get back in time for their next shift.

M&S refused to change my shift 3 years on the trot.

It would make more sense for the rail companies to pick a weekend in January when nobody has any money and do the work then. If properly advertised and explained I think most people would rather accept an inconvenience then than over the major holidays.

This year I would like to know what they have been doing during the lockdown.

Totally agree. When my daughter was a student she worked p/t in Accessorize. She was told to work until 8pm Christmas Eve and return again 9am Boxing Day.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Nov 20 10.03am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle


I am really sorry to hear of your son's experience. So if I understand correctly he wasn't employed during the winter and about to be re-employed when the pandemic scuppered it. I am not an expert on Universal Credit but am aware of the difficulties and delays that some suffer. I would though have thought he ought to have been entitled both during last winter and right up to now. It's worth him asking!

Everyone's experience obviously varies. I miss the pub and the company, but I'm walking more and socialising that way. The number of people running and cycling around here this year is quite remarkable.

Thank you. He did not previously apply as he was lucky enough to have £6000 in savings, so therefore did not qualify ( maybe we are too honest and shouldn’t have divulged the savings!). These have now gone and therefore he has just applied, we await with anticipation.
You are lucky to be able to walk/cycle locally. Our area is ok for such activities but my heart goes out to those in big towns/cities. Where cycling is probably more dangerous than Covid!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Nov 20 10.30am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Thank you. He did not previously apply as he was lucky enough to have £6000 in savings, so therefore did not qualify ( maybe we are too honest and shouldn’t have divulged the savings!). These have now gone and therefore he has just applied, we await with anticipation.
You are lucky to be able to walk/cycle locally. Our area is ok for such activities but my heart goes out to those in big towns/cities. Where cycling is probably more dangerous than Covid!

Never tell them about savings. And don't feel guilty, it's your own tax money. There's plenty getting loads who've never paid any tax in their life.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Nov 20 11.27am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

There will always be a few rogue "experts" who take a different approach. There are in most fields. On balance though the consensus view of the specialists in this field, both here and around the world supports what we are doing.

So I would rather trust them than the ones cherry-picked by the amateurs on the Hol just because they happen to support their prejudices.

The testing might not be perfect but it's useful in identifying where high risks exist and enabling interventions to dampen them down. It's purpose is not to provide 100% guidance to individuals.

The hospitality industry, and it's staff must be adequately supported if they bear a disproportionate cost. Just because one sector of the economy gets hit harder than another is not an excuse for a lack of action. It's a reason to look after them properly.

It's to ensure that cancer patients, and all the other treatments we rely on the NHS for, including elective surgery, don't get hit again that we are having to face these restrictions. There's not an endless supply of doctors and nurses available. If the need to treat people with C19 increases then surgical wards close just so the staff can be reallocated.

The impact on mental health cannot be underestimated or ignored and I am quite sure it is all part of the overall equation when seeking the optimum solution.

We all have a role to play in supporting those we know are isolated or otherwise vulnerable. I make phone calls to those I know, and arrange to meet people outside sometimes just to go for a walk together, socially distanced of course. Small things help and we can all do them.

If however those with really severe mental health issues need clinical support we must make sure the NHS remains open to them. Swamping it with C19 won't do that.

These ‘rogue experts’ as you, a wealthy retired man in tier 1 as if nothing is happening, describe them as, happen to have decades of experience in the fields in question. You just like large and undemocratic governments and political unions. They aren’t cherry picked by HOL but have gained a lot of nationwide attention because they expose the bull.

You can argue that the PCR tests show areas where positive tests are high, but they’re bundled in to be reported as a total of national cases, even with 2-3 results from the same person. This is what was happening a month or so ago. High positive tests, minimal deaths. Now it’s respiratory illness season the deaths have risen.

You keep saying those most affected and the hospitality industry must be supported. This isn’t a matter of covering £10 an hour for everyone. We’re talking about business owners, their businesses, the suppliers’ businesses and all the other contractors. The level of ‘support’ clearly won’t happen and will be unaffordable. It’ll be more like ‘Eat out to help out’ again or changes to taxes. That’ll only end up saving some.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Nov 20 11.28am

Originally posted by Badger11

I have a birthday soon a couple of lady friends wanted to organise something for me.

Pictures please.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Nov 20 11.35am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

No it's not a lockdown! Not like we had before. The schools remain open and next week all the shops will re-open. More activities remain active and people are working. Life is being restricted, primarily socially. No-one likes it, but it's not going to hurt too much not being able to go to the pub or to watch football. It's survivable and temporary.

People being isolated and vulnerable is the biggest concern I see. I am only too aware of the impact on people's mental health as it has hit my own family. One of my daughters was admitted as an emergency a few weeks ago. Thank goodness that the NHS was there for her.

The issues of which area is in which Tier and where the boundaries are completely separate arguments, which I won't pass comment on as I am not party to all the various considerations. We expected to be in Tier 2 and anticipate being moved up in December, so plenty of uncertainty remains for us too.

I am sorry to hear about your son, but presumably he got some redundancy payments and now universal credit. He is also safe and being cared for. He and you aren't alone and I know it's tough for everyone but things will get better. We just need to stay together.

Whether points are valid, or not, will always be a matter of opinion, just as whether something is rude or straightforward.

Lancaster has very very low cases and is in tier 3 but the next door town/borough has very very high cases and is in tier 2. I might have the towns the wrong way round but this has happened.

Oxted is in Surrey and is in tier 2. A couple of miles on the A25 and Westerham is in tier 3 because it’s in Kent. Guess how long it takes to get to Swale or Thanet on the east coast of Kent or Maidstone? Guess what happens in the evenings and weekends on the A25? Everyone drives to Oxted to eat and drink.

 


COYP

Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Nov 20 11.44am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Identifying issues doesn't solve them. There is no perfect solution and no-one wants to damage the economy or put people in one room flats through hard times. Finding ways to mitigate the impact on the most vulnerable is clearly needed.

And of course the longer it goes on the more some people will resist them. You have only to read the comments here to know that. Keeping that number to the lowest possible, either through education or control is the answer.

Doing what we are doing is destructive and painful. Not doing it would be worse. Both in my view and, it seems, in the majority of expert opinion not just in the UK but around the world.

This is the point; lots of people don’t see any mitigation. In the Eighties many unemployed people went into the service industries which are now laying them off. This is why they are afraid - not of the virus but of how they’re going to get a job when this is finally over and their bills and mortgages still have to be paid.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Nov 20 12.05pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Pictures please.

Rudi, indeed

 

Page 439 of 753 < 435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic