You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 47 of 91 < 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 15 Jan 20 9.06pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Good read.

A complete oversimplification would say we've got the 9th highest wage bill and we are 9th in the league.

This looks like our situation point for the time being unless we can find a comparative advange elsewhere.

To progress, we will need, a larger matchday income. Which can only really be achieved through stadium improvements

We also need a way of lowering the wage bill, bring through more young players, better training facilities/coaches to get more out of what we have. Better scouting network to find better deals.

Otherwise we are pretty much stuck, being stuck at your optimum level with the resources you have is a massive achievement. Especially when you look at all the massive clubs below us, not just those above us.

There's too much sense being spoken.

 

nead1 Flag 15 Jan 20 9.38pm

I think you are entirely correct which is why the investment in Selhurst and the Academy is so critical. Equally, it is is entirely understandable that any spending will be minimal and very prudent.
There was an interesting piece in the FT last weekend on the model adopted by Lille. They only have revs of Euros 53.9 vis a vis CPFC at £150m but basically follow exactly the same model - invest heavily in the academy, sell on players like Pepe for E80m and attract significant private equity investment. Lille reckon they have made a net transfer profit of almost E200m these past 2 years - certainly food for thought.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Jan 20 9.53pm

Originally posted by silvertop

There's too much sense being spoken.

It’s funny because it’s true!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 15 Jan 20 10.24pm

Originally posted by nead1

I think you are entirely correct which is why the investment in Selhurst and the Academy is so critical. Equally, it is is entirely understandable that any spending will be minimal and very prudent.
There was an interesting piece in the FT last weekend on the model adopted by Lille. They only have revs of Euros 53.9 vis a vis CPFC at £150m but basically follow exactly the same model - invest heavily in the academy, sell on players like Pepe for E80m and attract significant private equity investment. Lille reckon they have made a net transfer profit of almost E200m these past 2 years - certainly food for thought.

Absolutely, in these days of crazy transfer prices and player wages, clubs like ours need to invest in our academy and attract better younger players for development through to our own first team. it is inevitable that some of such academy players will end up at one of the bigger clubs in the EPL.

 

jeeagles Flag 16 Jan 20 8.33am

On getting to that approach, the grounds being improved (allegedly), proposals are in place for the training ground, so we are working on the physical infrastructure. That will be an asset which will help increase the value of the club and something that we wont lose if we get relegated.

No idea what's going on with scouting. I'm not sure Freedman is to blame. I think Roy has shown a lack of interest in transfers.

In terms of playing youngsters, we have 3 problems. 1) A manager that wont play anyone that's not 100% first team ready. 2) A manager that wont bring on subs. 3) No comfortable victories where we can bring players on without any pressure, Burnley is the only game where we've been 2-0 up with 10 minutes left.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 16 Jan 20 10.58am

Originally posted by jeeagles

On getting to that approach, the grounds being improved (allegedly), proposals are in place for the training ground, so we are working on the physical infrastructure. That will be an asset which will help increase the value of the club and something that we wont lose if we get relegated.

No idea what's going on with scouting. I'm not sure Freedman is to blame. I think Roy has shown a lack of interest in transfers.

In terms of playing youngsters, we have 3 problems. 1) A manager that wont play anyone that's not 100% first team ready. 2) A manager that wont bring on subs. 3) No comfortable victories where we can bring players on without any pressure, Burnley is the only game where we've been 2-0 up with 10 minutes left.


Your post has a lot of truth in it and is saying what I have been saying for a long time. Roy is set in his ways and will not change, he has his favourites and does not try different players he has at hand. He has shown no interest in transfers and that's his excuse for whining about lack of incoming players. I do not believe for one minute that SP and Dougie get players in without consulting him. He will not try the youngsters when if he did he might be really surprised at what they can achieve. As I have said Roy is too set in his ways and will only play defensive football hoping for a break to go forward. He needs to try playing attacking football for a change as other teams can read him like a book and we get pinned back all the time. Roy is keeping us in the top league but that's about it I am afraid. No decent player wants to come to us looking at how he sets up our team.
Its a pity because we have a good set of players that could do so much better with a new plan B.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Glazier#1 Flag 16 Jan 20 12.34pm

Originally posted by susmik


Your post has a lot of truth in it and is saying what I have been saying for a long time. Roy is set in his ways and will not change, he has his favourites and does not try different players he has at hand. He has shown no interest in transfers and that's his excuse for whining about lack of incoming players. I do not believe for one minute that SP and Dougie get players in without consulting him. He will not try the youngsters when if he did he might be really surprised at what they can achieve. As I have said Roy is too set in his ways and will only play defensive football hoping for a break to go forward. He needs to try playing attacking football for a change as other teams can read him like a book and we get pinned back all the time. Roy is keeping us in the top league but that's about it I am afraid. No decent player wants to come to us looking at how he sets up our team.
Its a pity because we have a good set of players that could do so much better with a new plan B.


Do you have some inside track on the football club? Are you a 'fly on the wall' who is privy the the innermost conversations in the club? What a supposition. 'No interest in' the transfers. How do you know this? then to suppose that what you write is fact, you accuse Roy of Whining'. Biased, I think.

Then you say write that Roy sets us up defensively and then that this means that teams 'pin us back'. How can they 'pin us back' when we've been set up to defend and break/ Contradiction, my friend.

Can't go with these incomplete and biased ramblings, I'm afraid.


Sorry.

Good on Roy. He works miracles with very little resources. Genius manager of men and resources. That, I should add, is my opinion, not fact, .

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 16 Jan 20 12.48pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1


Do you have some inside track on the football club? Are you a 'fly on the wall' who is privy the the innermost conversations in the club? What a supposition. 'No interest in' the transfers. How do you know this? then to suppose that what you write is fact, you accuse Roy of Whining'. Biased, I think.

Then you say write that Roy sets us up defensively and then that this means that teams 'pin us back'. How can they 'pin us back' when we've been set up to defend and break/ Contradiction, my friend.

Can't go with these incomplete and biased ramblings, I'm afraid.


Sorry.

Good on Roy. He works miracles with very little resources. Genius manager of men and resources. That, I should add, is my opinion, not fact, .

It seems that I am NOT alone in my thinking if you had bothered to read the whole thread. I am sorry if your views are not like mine but you need to rein in on your replies and appreciate that we do not all have the same views as you do and you need to think before you post your replies. You tend to nick pick to try and justify your points and twist things around.
As for me being biased I think that comes under the heading Pot calling kettle black. You seem to think we should all toe the line and think like you do....well sorry I have my ideas and you have yours and you need to accept it.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Glazier#1 Flag 16 Jan 20 12.53pm

Really?

I can't understand how anyone can state that Roy is not interested in transfers. That seems a wild claim to me.

As for nit picking, I can't see that at all. I'm responding to a statement that Roy isn't interested in transfers. He's the team coach, for goodness sake. Why wouldn't he be interested. And the choice of 'Whining' to describe his comments on transfers when we are beset with injuries and very little transfer activity in the summer seems unfair and biased to suit your argument/opinion.

Originally posted by susmik

It seems that I am NOT alone in my thinking if you had bothered to read the whole thread. I am sorry if your views are not like mine but you need to rein in on your replies and appreciate that we do not all have the same views as you do and you need to think before you post your replies. You tend to nick pick to try and justify your points and twist things around.
As for me being biased I think that comes under the heading Pot calling kettle black. You seem to think we should all toe the line and think like you do....well sorry I have my ideas and you have yours and you need to accept it.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 16 Jan 20 12.56pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Really?

I can't understand how anyone can state that Roy is not interested in transfers. That seems a wild claim to me.

As for nit picking, I can't see that at all. I'm responding to a statement that Roy isn't interested in transfers. He's the team coach, for goodness sake. Why wouldn't he be interested. And the choice of 'Whining' to describe his comments on transfers when we are beset with injuries and very little transfer activity in the summer seems unfair and biased to suit your argument/opinion.

Oh, and while we're not reading posts/threads, you seem to have missed that what I've written is my opinion, not fact. It is you who have made supposition and dressed it up as fact, which I think is wrong and therefore have expressed my opinion to that effect.

 

jeeagles Flag 16 Jan 20 1.05pm

There seems to be blind protection for Roy on these forums, keeping us mid table is not a miracle. As stated in my first post, we have the 9th highest wage bill in the league, that should translate into a fairly safe league position.

He knows how to keep us safe, and he knows how to keep his job.

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 16 Jan 20 1.23pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

There seems to be blind protection for Roy on these forums, keeping us mid table is not a miracle. As stated in my first post, we have the 9th highest wage bill in the league, that should translate into a fairly safe league position.

He knows how to keep us safe, and he knows how to keep his job.

9th maybe?
[Link]

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 16 Jan 20 1.24pm

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

9th maybe?
[Link]

Go to league table.

 

jeeagles Flag 16 Jan 20 2.05pm

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

Go to league table.

[Link]

Read back before being a smartarse.

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 16 Jan 20 2.12pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

[Link]

Read back before being a smartarse.

Yep, I know. Totally puerile. But made me laugh so....

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Jan 20 2.19pm

I don't know how good or otherwise a manager Roy is, as neither am I an expert in football management, nor am I privy to what goes on during the week and behind closed doors.
What I do know (as oppose to 'believe' is that after two and a half seasons of Roy we are comfortably placed in the table at this time. Yes it could easily go pear-shaped at any moment but I believe that this is unlikely given the way the team is set up, i.e. difficult to break down.
I would like to see more attacking football, especially at home, and especially in the first half I'm still waiting to see my first Palace goal at the Whitehorse Lane end - I was away for the Norwich game), but in order to do that we need players who can deliver a more attacking approach and we don't, in my opinion, currently have them.
One day, and it may be after Roy has gone, we will get our wish for more attacking football (hopefully with a good balance regarding defensive responsibilities, so no, not a return to the Pardew days). in the meantime, I will continue to enjoy watching Premier League football at Selhurst Park (and the odd away game here in the Midlands).

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 16 Jan 20 2.22pm

The discussion re RH and his input into transfers is an interesting one, whether he has input or not. Who can explain the acquisition of Sorloth, Jach, Camarasa, and that other fellow I can't remember the name of, he was here for so little time.
There must be a serious disconnect along the line somewhere...

 

scuffy Flag orpington 16 Jan 20 2.54pm

Your analysis is all doom and gloom yet the facts tell us Roy led us to our record Premier League points total last year despite limited resources and is on track to do the same again. His record at Palace (points per game) is far superior to Dyche at Burnley or Howe at Bournemouth who some people advocate as successors. The suggestion he's not interested in transfers is laughable. He's been explicit about the need to bring in players this window. The youngsters will break through if they are good enough as we saw with AWB.

Originally posted by susmik


Your post has a lot of truth in it and is saying what I have been saying for a long time. Roy is set in his ways and will not change, he has his favourites and does not try different players he has at hand. He has shown no interest in transfers and that's his excuse for whining about lack of incoming players. I do not believe for one minute that SP and Dougie get players in without consulting him. He will not try the youngsters when if he did he might be really surprised at what they can achieve. As I have said Roy is too set in his ways and will only play defensive football hoping for a break to go forward. He needs to try playing attacking football for a change as other teams can read him like a book and we get pinned back all the time. Roy is keeping us in the top league but that's about it I am afraid. No decent player wants to come to us looking at how he sets up our team.
Its a pity because we have a good set of players that could do so much better with a new plan B.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Jan 20 3.02pm

Originally posted by scuffy

Your analysis is all doom and gloom yet the facts tell us Roy led us to our record Premier League points total last year despite limited resources and is on track to do the same again. His record at Palace (points per game) is far superior to Dyche at Burnley or Howe at Bournemouth who some people advocate as successors. The suggestion he's not interested in transfers is laughable. He's been explicit about the need to bring in players this window. The youngsters will break through if they are good enough as we saw with AWB.

I have no actual knowledge of this it is just what I have assumed from various sources but it seems as though Roy doesn't have a massive say if any on transfers and probably like most managers wishes he did! At the very least he has looked to be fuming at our lack of activity however has carried on doing his job, quite well, in spite of this.

If someone shoots down this theory, as mentioned, I would not argue back with them that's just what I have inferred.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Therealeaglestilidie Flag 16 Jan 20 3.27pm

"The youngsters will break through if they are good enough as we saw with AWB"

Worryingly we were apparently about to ship AWB out on loan just before Ward got injured, so we couldn't see talent when it was right under our noses.

 


I'm so Palace I don't even know it

Page 47 of 91 < 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread