You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Can we adopt our 1861 date of birth?
November 22 2026 2.06pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Can we adopt our 1861 date of birth?


Page 5 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Apr 20 7.53am

Are there a set of FA rules that this claim can be tested against?

If there isn't then this just becomes a talking point and no doubt other clubs will also dig up their claims for changing their start date.

Edited by Badger11 (22 Apr 2020 7.53am)

 


One more point

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Apr 20 9.23am

Originally posted by Elpis

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace 1861 ?!' by bexleydave

Im of the opinion that we should claim the honour of being the Worlds oldest club even if the history was a bit disjointed back in the 19th C .
The only current club name to appear in the first ever FA cup will do for me .The professional takeover in 1905 is akin to a club being brought out of administration with a new board . It doesn't mean the club did not exist before .
I think the previous owners have missed a trick here , the marketing opportunities worldwide are enormous

Sorry but who cares worldwide if it’s us or Sheffield Utd are the oldest clubs in the country, world or universe? If you can’t win the premier league you’re almost irrelevant.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Apr 20 9.33am

I agree with Bexleydave on this. Leave it as it is and concentrate on today. There’s a 30 year gap anyway and let’s not give more reason to be a laughing stock.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Apr 20 10.23am

Can the club get a new main stand built to replace the one built in 1924 after announcing it would? Maybe concentrate on getting this done might be more beneficial.

 


COYP

Beastie Flag 22 Apr 20 2.06pm

I think the club are doing the right thing. They know we’re going to get slagged off for it but who cares. Once the dust settles, we’ll have taken back an important part of our history. Well done.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 22 Apr 20 2.49pm

Originally posted by Beastie

I think the club are doing the right thing. They know we’re going to get slagged off for it but who cares. Once the dust settles, we’ll have taken back an important part of our history. Well done.

Have a look at what Parish actually said to the Evening Standard:

Palace chairman, Steve Parish, said: "As a lifelong supporter of Crystal Palace, it’s amazing that we have a legitimate claim to be the oldest professional league club still in existence, that we were in the very first FA meetings, and that our history dates all the way back to the Victorian cricketers of 1861 at the Palace even involving the great W.G. Grace"

"I would like to thank Peter Manning for the incredible work he has undertaken researching the definitive history of the club. It’s a fascinating tale and one I hope supporters will very much enjoy seeing brought to life in this film."

For once he has used his undoubted PR genius for the right reasons. There's no football in the foreseeable future and he knows full well that to rubbish the story ("tale") at such a time would serve no positive purpose. He also knows that there are some massive lumps of disappointment to come, not least of which there isn't going to be a new Main Stand anytime soon.

To dismiss any harmless distraction at such a time would be a PR disaster so he's paid some lip service to it whilst committing to absolutely nothing. He's not going to change the club crest or press for the FA to change their records. He won't make any further comment on it and will just allow it to fade away until there's something more important to talk about.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Apr 20 2.53pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

He won't make any further comment on it and will just allow it to fade away until there's something more important to talk about.

The accounts?

 

roman eagle Flag South London 22 Apr 20 3.02pm

I haven't read Peter Manning's book yet (Palace at the Palace) so I'll reserve judgement on whether there is a credible link between the amateur and professional clubs. But, unlike some on here I'm prepared to look at the evidence before making my mind up.

I don't really understand some of the negativity on here - apparently we are a laughing stock even before this issue was raised - How so?

If the case holds water it would amazing to think our club was one of the original founders of football, and no doubt worth a few marketing opportunities too. The history of a club is extremely important for many fans and this new research could open up a whole new chapter in the history of CPFC.

 


Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC)

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 22 Apr 20 4.25pm

Originally posted by Matov

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Palace 1861 ?!' by bexleydave

Mixed feelings. Whilst I adore the history aspect, and 1861 just scans lovely, I struggle with the Blue & White. I mean both Millwall AND Brighton?

Would take a lot of getting used to.

It's a different blue and also halves. Also the team was playing in these colours 40 years before Brighton were formed.

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 22 Apr 20 4.28pm

Another good thing about the claim to be the oldest league club in the world is it might help attract a wealthy foreign investor...

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Apr 20 6.42pm

somebody got to the bottom of their paperwork tray, tidied up their emails & looked in the drawer for things they decided to ignore for years.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Apr 20 7.00pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

Another good thing about the claim to be the oldest league club in the world is it might help attract a wealthy foreign investor...

I doubt it.

 


COYP

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 22 Apr 20 7.19pm

I give the OP a thumbs up. Talons up

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 22 Apr 20 7.23pm

From To the Palace for the Cup: "At this point [after their final FA Cup game] Crystal Palace seem to have disappeared from the football scene. Even the Crystal Palace company had no record of their demise. One journalist from the Croydon Advertiser in 1945 even consulted Sir Henry Buckland, General Manager of the Crystal Palace, who scanned the archives and made enquiries without finding any record of the club."

If the guy in charge of the Crystal Palace company in the early 1900s has no knowledge and can find no evidence of the team involved in anything after 1876 from the company's archives, then the link is broken.

The club are guessing the kit is blue and white halves as the only evidence I see is "blue and White with blue shorts". Quite possibly be horizontal stripes like other shirts of the era.

And what about Crystal Palace Rovers who played against the Pilgrims in January 1883?

Edited by Penge Eagle (22 Apr 2020 7.27pm)

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 23 Apr 20 11.12am

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

It's a different blue and also halves. Also the team was playing in these colours 40 years before Brighton were formed.

Indeed. More like Uruguay or Argentina....

 

stujii Flag 23 Apr 20 12.26pm

Originally posted by Penge Eagle

From To the Palace for the Cup: "At this point [after their final FA Cup game] Crystal Palace seem to have disappeared from the football scene. Even the Crystal Palace company had no record of their demise. One journalist from the Croydon Advertiser in 1945 even consulted Sir Henry Buckland, General Manager of the Crystal Palace, who scanned the archives and made enquiries without finding any record of the club."

If the guy in charge of the Crystal Palace company in the early 1900s has no knowledge and can find no evidence of the team involved in anything after 1876 from the company's archives, then the link is broken.

The club are guessing the kit is blue and white halves as the only evidence I see is "blue and White with blue shorts". Quite possibly be horizontal stripes like other shirts of the era.

And what about Crystal Palace Rovers who played against the Pilgrims in January 1883?

Edited by Penge Eagle (22 Apr 2020 7.27pm)

That’s the theory, we became known as Crystal Palace Rovers when nomadic..we need to find out more about this which may become easier as more Victorian news articles become digitised

 

Palace_Guard Flag Kyiv 23 Apr 20 5.29pm

reading this thread is like watching a crime investigation series which included one of your loved ones!

really fascinating stuff! The video the club put on youTube is very well done and provides lots of little bits of evidence that has very much convinced me!

I hope opening it up to the public now, we will get even more information and evidence to back this theory up.

It seemed that there a gap where the club did not play football was quite common during those times, to save the cricket pitch, because of finances, not history found because there weren't many games played....it doesn not mean the club officially folded.

 


Live in Melbourne or Victoria, Australia?
Support Crystal Palace?

Well join the Crystal Palace Melbourne Supporters Club:
[Link]

Adelaide, South Australia? Join here:
[Link]

jeeagles Flag 24 Apr 20 9.49am

Originally posted by Palace_Guard

reading this thread is like watching a crime investigation series which included one of your loved ones!

really fascinating stuff! The video the club put on youTube is very well done and provides lots of little bits of evidence that has very much convinced me!

I hope opening it up to the public now, we will get even more information and evidence to back this theory up.

It seemed that there a gap where the club did not play football was quite common during those times, to save the cricket pitch, because of finances, not history found because there weren't many games played....it doesn not mean the club officially folded.

Are you saying that the burden of proof should be on others now to prove the club folded and didn't play any games?

Just because there is no record of matches in that 20 year period doesnt mean they didn't happen.

It could be argued that continuity should be assumed unless there is an official record in Crystal Palace company records, players diarys, newspapers that say CPFC 1861 officially cease to exist in around 1885. Or a official record from around 1905 which says that the team which applied to join the league then was categorically a different entity.

Our former tennents AFC Wimbledon or MK Dons may have an interest in this story as they have a despute over who the clubs history belongs to.

There's probably other teams with claims that could rival Sheffield FC and Notts County. The Royal Engineers and Civil Service clubs both claim to be founded in 1863, but probably existed in some form before that.

It's a tenuous claim, but no one can claim that a Crystal Palace team didn't exist in 1861, and no one can prove there is not a direct link between the team that entered the league in 1905.... this could go on for years. Great lockdown story.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 24 Apr 20 11.14am

A team with a link to the big glass building in upper norwood.

That is us and them. Like in "who do you think you are" the links are often tenuous but the continuity is there.

Publish the date on the scarves and the nay-sayers can be damned.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

stujii Flag 24 Apr 20 12.50pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Are you saying that the burden of proof should be on others now to prove the club folded and didn't play any games?

Just because there is no record of matches in that 20 year period doesnt mean they didn't happen.

It could be argued that continuity should be assumed unless there is an official record in Crystal Palace company records, players diarys, newspapers that say CPFC 1861 officially cease to exist in around 1885. Or a official record from around 1905 which says that the team which applied to join the league then was categorically a different entity.

Our former tennents AFC Wimbledon or MK Dons may have an interest in this story as they have a despute over who the clubs history belongs to.

There's probably other teams with claims that could rival Sheffield FC and Notts County. The Royal Engineers and Civil Service clubs both claim to be founded in 1863, but probably existed in some form before that.

It's a tenuous claim, but no one can claim that a Crystal Palace team didn't exist in 1861, and no one can prove there is not a direct link between the team that entered the league in 1905.... this could go on for years. Great lockdown story.

AFC Wimbledon have already officially been granted the history of Wimbledon FC/ MKDons. They have far less claim then us and a precedent has now been set with this case

Totally agree the burden of proof should now be on the nay sayers

 

Page 5 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Can we adopt our 1861 date of birth?