Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.43pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.37pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.33pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.26pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.25pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.23pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.20pm
Quote ghosteagle at 04 Aug 2015 6.16pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 04 Aug 2015 6.13pm
Quote nickgusset at 04 Aug 2015 5.58pm
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 5.36pm
Quote susmik at 04 Aug 2015 4.31pm
Quote crystal balls at 04 Aug 2015 4.24pm
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 11.10am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 11.05am
Quote The Sash at 04 Aug 2015 10.39am
Quote fed up eagle at 04 Aug 2015 10.20am
Quote Catfish at 04 Aug 2015 8.43am
Of interest, it would be helpful if posters could start by defining what they think immigration is.
Are you talking about anyone coming here to live, whether legally or not, of any nationality and for any reason?
If, on the other hand, you are talking about specific groups, nationalities, races, then please do say so up front. Saves so much time.
There is nothing wrong with people coming here to set up a legitimate attempt at a better life through work etc, not the people in Calais who are hell bent on coming here because of all the riches it brings. They aren't proper immigrants, they are economic migrants.
As are pretty much 99% of those here legally.
Lets be honest they don't come here for the weather or our sandy beaches
Maybe I didn't put my point across correctly so apologies. My main point is that the people in Calais have no skill, we have enough unskilled labour that should be put to work. The left's main argument is that these people are escaping war torn parts of the world, well if that was the case they should claim asylum in the first country they arrive in, not travel across 5-6 borders and demanding that it's here that they want to come. Doctors, scientists, engineers, nurses, footballers yes, unskilled people who want to be propped up by the state a definite NO.
Not actually true - there was an interview with a guy the other day on the Beeb - cant remember exact country of origin but he was a qualified accountant - now you could argue that accountancy isn't exactly an area where we need to welcome immigrants with CIMA qualifications with open arms but not everyone hopping the fence is here to grab as many benefits as they can and f*** our daughters...
For what its worth I totally agree on the asylum part - first 'safe' country you meet should mean that country have the obligation to grant you asylum and you take it or leave it.
Edited by The Sash (04 Aug 2015 11.11am)
The thing is, once an asylum seeker is granted asylum in any other EU country they will have the same rights to movement of labour as any other citizen throughout the EU, so could actually come here if they wanted.
Interestingly in the first quarter of the year around 250,000 people came to the EU to claim asylum; less than 10,000 came to the UK, over 70,000 went to Germany, with France and Italy receiving over 30,000 each. Even Hungary had 17,000 applicants.
The myth that immigrants all want to come to the UK just doesn't stack up. And the availability of benefits and the amount paid to immigrants is not appreciably different to most other EU countries.
I have noticed that it is only immigrants in France at Calais that are breaking down fences, boarding trains, running through the tunnel and breaking into cars and Lorries that are in the public eye. This is not happening in Germany or Hungary. I wonder why....could it be that we pay ANYONE who enters a pile of cash and give them a house and free healthcare which in turn brings the whole countries services to a critical state as it is now.....not to mention once some are in they bring their whole family tribe in????
Exacttly. You hit the nail on the head Sir.
No he hasn't. It's complete unsubstantiated bs.
It's not. Why else do they want to come here rather than, say, Germany, Holland, France, Belgium etc. which, (co-incidentally or not) are not so generous?
Work it out, mate.
Do you have any numbers handy? I have seen many posters claim this and many claim that actually they don't get more in the UK than Germany etc but nobody seems to be providing any actual evidence......
How many are there hanging round Calais? 7000? Ok, so that's 7000. Excluding those that are en route through other EU countries.
I was questioning the idea that the uk is more generous to immigrants than other EU countries. I had read that they got better benefits in Germany and Sweden.
Perhaps you should nip over to Calais and show them what you've read as they clearly believe otherwise.
Not necessarily, if true it means that their reasons for coming here are based on something other than a simple economic equation.
Not according to those who've been interviewed by Sky and Beeb reporters. The message, loud and clear, is that they believe they get housing, healthcare and money in the UK.
If that isn't true, then somebody needs to educate them (seeing as how nobody seems prepared to set about them with flamethrowers).
Quite. Well, i'm afraid i was looking for more concrete evidence than just a third hand report of what one immigrant might have said. I have seen such interviews, but i've also seen interviews where they talk of being 'safe' and seeing the uk as somewhere where they want to bring up families. I think some hard facts would be useful rather than dubious assertions.
It's not just one immigrant. Anyway, we're going round in circles. Why is the UK perceived to be 'safer' than, say, France or Germany, or any other EU country they've passed through? If they reject those countries, then there must be a more concrete reason for coming to the UK and that brings us back to the conclusion that they believe it's 'softer' here in the UK than elsewhere.
I feel that Catfish has provided a full and interesting answer. The idea that we hand out benefits to everyone who wants them has been disproved many times, but the idea that they find working in Britain easier seems logical. Also, both France and Germany take more immigrants than we do, so the vast majority of them don't pass through but have stayed in those countries. So, given that the immigrants do not come here to leech of the welfare state but are looking for work does this change how we should approach the problem? Should the government instead be concentrating on cracking down on employers who employ illegal immigrants?
|