This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 06 Sep 2015 9.17pm
Quote Kermit8 at 06 Sep 2015 8.28pm
There was no big anti-Falklands War sentiment in 1982 from any significant political group or leaning. It was generally felt to be a just war at the time. It was the sinking of the Belgrano that cast a shadow.
Doesn't stop it being a 'war crime' though. Remains a contestable issue, probably in the best interests of the UK forces, but questionable whether it was within the rules of the conflict (remember it wasn't a declaration of war, so anything outside the exclusion zone was an unlawful engagement - I think it was the right decision militarily, but it may well have been a war crime objectively speaking).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 06 Sep 2015 10.30pm
Quote legaleagle at 06 Sep 2015 10.23pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Sep 2015 9.19pm
It is of course nonsense to say that Thatcher won the 1983 General Election primarily because of the Falklands victory. People don't vote for a government to reward the leader of a recent war, witness Churchill after World War II. They voted Tory because they did not want a Michael Foot led Labour government. It would have been like voting for a softly spoken Arthur Scargill. The electorate will take the same view of another softly spoken Scargill - Jeremy Corbyn - if he leads the Labour party.
Was Foot (and the highly effective and successful demonisation of him in the media) something to do with it? Yes.Was the formation of the SDP something to do with it? Yes.Was the Saatchi Bros' dominance of how to run a successful campaign something to do with it? Yes. But all somewhat lesser factors than the Falklands.If the Falklands had "gone wrong",she'd have likely been out the door. People reward successful war leaders in elections generally.Churchill was the exception not the rule,and that because of people's memories of the 30's and the high profile role of some Labour members of the wartime coalition government.Not to mention Churchill's inane suggestion during the election campaign that electing Labour would be akin to having the Gestapo. This is all very subjective. I would say that Labour would have lost the election anyway. Foot, much like Kinnock and Milliband was too easy to mock and far too weak in personality to become PM. The trend was against them in any case. I think its a certainty that if we'd lost the Falklands conflict, then the Conservative's would have lost the election, and that the victory gave them a boost. I don't think you can compare it to Churchill after the war, because Churchill wasn't in power before the war either (and was very much a 'War Prime Minister' not a peacetime candidate). Thatcher for me, did right by the people of the Falklands, and ironically accidently ended a Far Right Wing Junta in South America, and set in motion a series of events that ultimately led to a greater freedom of the left in South American politics.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 07 Sep 2015 9.24am
Quote legaleagle at 06 Sep 2015 10.23pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Sep 2015 9.19pm
It is of course nonsense to say that Thatcher won the 1983 General Election primarily because of the Falklands victory. People don't vote for a government to reward the leader of a recent war, witness Churchill after World War II. They voted Tory because they did not want a Michael Foot led Labour government. It would have been like voting for a softly spoken Arthur Scargill. The electorate will take the same view of another softly spoken Scargill - Jeremy Corbyn - if he leads the Labour party.
Was Foot (and the highly effective and successful demonisation of him in the media) something to do with it? Yes.Was the formation of the SDP something to do with it? Yes.Was the Saatchi Bros' dominance of how to run a successful campaign something to do with it? Yes. But all somewhat lesser factors than the Falklands.If the Falklands had "gone wrong",she'd have likely been out the door. People reward successful war leaders in elections generally.Churchill was the exception not the rule,and that because of people's memories of the 30's and the high profile role of some Labour members of the wartime coalition government.Not to mention Churchill's inane suggestion during the election campaign that electing Labour would be akin to having the Gestapo. It is worth looking at what Churchill said: Unfortunate use of the word 'Gestapo' of course, but he did say 'some form of'. However, the gist is correct concerning the state controlling everything, the state knows best, the state knows better than you what is good for you and your family. Ironically, that could be the battle cry of the Conservatives post war as well as Labour. Its also not been above the political parties of the UK to use the police and military as a means of enforcing control of its objectives, notably in response to strikes, protests etc. Even going so far as to use anti-terror legislation and national security, as a means of shielding itself from Transparancy and legal oversite. Ironically the UK government, has been complicit in acting as a Gestapo, notably in the acceptance of torture and rendition for torture of suspects without trial.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 07 Sep 2015 10.03am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Sep 2015 9.54am
Quote leggedstruggle at 07 Sep 2015 9.24am
Quote legaleagle at 06 Sep 2015 10.23pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 06 Sep 2015 9.19pm
It is of course nonsense to say that Thatcher won the 1983 General Election primarily because of the Falklands victory. People don't vote for a government to reward the leader of a recent war, witness Churchill after World War II. They voted Tory because they did not want a Michael Foot led Labour government. It would have been like voting for a softly spoken Arthur Scargill. The electorate will take the same view of another softly spoken Scargill - Jeremy Corbyn - if he leads the Labour party.
Was Foot (and the highly effective and successful demonisation of him in the media) something to do with it? Yes.Was the formation of the SDP something to do with it? Yes.Was the Saatchi Bros' dominance of how to run a successful campaign something to do with it? Yes. But all somewhat lesser factors than the Falklands.If the Falklands had "gone wrong",she'd have likely been out the door. People reward successful war leaders in elections generally.Churchill was the exception not the rule,and that because of people's memories of the 30's and the high profile role of some Labour members of the wartime coalition government.Not to mention Churchill's inane suggestion during the election campaign that electing Labour would be akin to having the Gestapo. It is worth looking at what Churchill said: Unfortunate use of the word 'Gestapo' of course, but he did say 'some form of'. However, the gist is correct concerning the state controlling everything, the state knows best, the state knows better than you what is good for you and your family. Ironically, that could be the battle cry of the Conservatives post war as well as Labour. Its also not been above the political parties of the UK to use the police and military as a means of enforcing control of its objectives, notably in response to strikes, protests etc. Even going so far as to use anti-terror legislation and national security, as a means of shielding itself from Transparancy and legal oversite. Ironically the UK government, has been complicit in acting as a Gestapo, notably in the acceptance of torture and rendition for torture of suspects without trial. Thanks for supporting my argument - that we need less government from all parties, less state control, as little as practical. I'd pretty much agree with that, but from a more left of center perspective. The role of state is the state, not individuals. Its only role with individuals is protecting the rights and freedoms of other individuals from a majority, or where a clear consensus exists (such as in law enforcement). The failure of successive systems of government has been in attempting to legislate how people should be and behave and to attempt to enforce morality laws popular with a majority, but in no way aligned to a strong consensus or rational basis.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 07 Sep 2015 10.22am
have you ever stopped to think that maybe thats what the British people were crying out for, A strong no bullsh1t leader with balls of steel (metaphorically speaking Can you imagine one of the current crop of politcal leaders (bar Farage) calling the SAS in to "end" a hostage situation like she did at the iranian Embassey. Tough times (N.Ire, Falklands) make tough leaders and she was just what the nation needed at the time, the unions were bringing the country to its knees. So up pops maggie with a no nonsense approach and the mojority loved her for it. As time changes a differenttype of leader is required, people chill out, the unions dealt with, the falklands won, N.I. heading towards talks not bombs, and the people decided she had served her purpose. Much the same happened to churchill. Zeitgiest and all that. I feel that at the time the UK was in a position where it was going one way or the other politically. I don't really think either side was necessarily the only decision. I don't think either Foot or Kinnock would necessarily have been s**t prime ministers, but that the outcome of the country we live in would be very different. With retrospect, we were looking at a transition from Industrial to Post Industrial Britain. Usually its a mistake to assume, that one decision was the only option, when you can only know one outcome. There were consequences for UK as well of Thatcherism. And she wasn't some universally loved figure, except for a tiny noisy minority, she was a very divisive figure nationally. As for NI, its worth noting that it was Thatcher's government that initiated communication with the IRA. They just did it in secret.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.