This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by sprites
Okay, i'ma bow out. I still don't really understand why we can't settle on 'you believe this, I believe that, we don't agree, let's get on anyway and support the palace.' You're all kind of being dicks to me, which is unnecessary. Just because we don't believe the same thing. It's not on, really. Well You're a Christian, so forgive us.....it'll get you some more brownie points.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well You're a Christian, so forgive us.....it'll get you some more brownie points. Haha. Okay, you're forgiven.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Haha. Okay, you're forgiven.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Okay, i'ma bow out. I still don't really understand why we can't settle on 'you believe this, I believe that, we don't agree, let's get on anyway and support the palace.' You're all kind of being dicks to me, which is unnecessary. Just because we don't believe the same thing. It's not on, really.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Okay, i'ma bow out. I still don't really understand why we can't settle on 'you believe this, I believe that, we don't agree, let's get on anyway and support the palace.' You're all kind of being dicks to me, which is unnecessary. Just because we don't believe the same thing. It's not on, really. You can believe what you like. Just don't expect to be given preferential treatment just because you are religious. I don't do reverence.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You can believe what you like. Just don't expect to be given preferential treatment just because you are religious. I don't do reverence. You don't do a lot of things, by the sounds of it. Friendly, acceptance and open mindedness, to name a few. And I'm not sure at what point I asked for preferential treatment? You're putting words in my mouth. Anyway, let's leave it at that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
You don't do a lot of things, by the sounds of it. Friendly, acceptance and open mindedness, to name a few. And I'm not sure at what point I asked for preferential treatment? You're putting words in my mouth. Anyway, let's leave it at that. But you don't do you. Open-mindedness only stretches so far. Should I also believe in the tooth fairy? Or Father Christmas?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But you don't do you. Open-mindedness only stretches so far. Should I also believe in the tooth fairy? Or Father Christmas? No, of course not. They're completely fictitious, mad-mad ideas created largely for children's entertainment. Christianity on the other hand is based on historical fact. Jesus existed. There's more proof of that than William Shakespear existed. Scholars and experts, for the most part, all accept that. He was a real historical figure. Likewise, they're largely unanimous about the fact he via died via crucifixion on a cross. So the question then becomes...was he just some dude that said a lot of stuff but didn't follow through...or is he who he says he is...that being, the son of God. I (and millions of others, for varying reasons) choose to believe that he is who he said he was. And lots (including you and millions of others) don't. Which is absolutely fine. I have no issue with that. What I have a slight issue with, is professing to be the former on here (which I was only doing in response do an original post anyway) and being ridiculed and mocked for it (mentally insecure / God botherer type comments). They're just not needed. (Yeah, sorry, I didn't leave it at that, did I. Oops) Edited by sprites (20 Jun 2018 6.44am)
|
|
| Park Road |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by sprites
No, of course not. They're completely fictitious, mad-mad ideas created largely for children's entertainment. Christianity on the other hand is based on historical fact. Jesus existed. There's more proof of that than William Shakespear existed. Scholars and experts, for the most part, all accept that. He was a real historical figure. Likewise, they're largely unanimous about the fact he via died via crucifixion on a cross. So the question then becomes...was he just some dude that said a lot of stuff but didn't follow through...or is he who he says he is...that being, the son of God. I (and millions of others, for varying reasons) choose to believe that he is who he said he was. And lots (including you and millions of others) don't. Which is absolutely fine. I have no issue with that. What I have a slight issue with, is professing to be the former on here (which I was only doing in response do an original post anyway) and being ridiculed and mocked for it (mentally insecure / God botherer type comments). They're just not needed. (Yeah, sorry, I didn't leave it at that, did I. Oops) Edited by sprites (20 Jun 2018 6.44am) Just like a child would. However, kids grow out of believing in tooth fairies and papa noel..yet a man from over 2000 years ago - like so many before and after him claims to be a son of a God, and you believe it?? Edited by Park Road (20 Jun 2018 7.38am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
No, of course not. They're completely fictitious, mad-mad ideas created largely for children's entertainment. Christianity on the other hand is based on historical fact. Jesus existed. There's more proof of that than William Shakespear existed. This simply isn't true. We have six signatures of Shakespeare on legal documents, detailed in the link below. We have the birth and death records of Shakespeare. His will. We have other records like the birth records of his children....but there's a limit to how much time I'll spend on this. Outside of the Gospels, none of which are written in Jesus's lifetime we only have patchy and short mentions of Jesus....or probably who is meant o be Jesus by independent sources. No reliable birth date, no reliable death date. No records written by him at all. So sorry, there is much more reliable evidence that Shakespeare existed. Originally posted by sprites
Scholars and experts, for the most part, all accept that. He was a real historical figure. Likewise, they're largely unanimous about the fact he via died via crucifixion on a cross. 'largely unanimous'? that's a paradoxical statement right there. I know of two noted scholars who don't accept he existed (Dr Robert Carrier and Dr Robert Price) and this is only a partial interest area for me. Here is a debate by scholars on whether Jesus existed. A far more accurate summary of many scholars on this would be the description.....probably. However, there is no strong evidence. Originally posted by sprites
So the question then becomes...was he just some dude that said a lot of stuff but didn't follow through...or is he who he says he is...that being, the son of God. I (and millions of others, for varying reasons) choose to believe that he is who he said he was. And lots (including you and millions of others) don't. Which is absolutely fine. I have no issue with that. What I have a slight issue with, is professing to be the former on here (which I was only doing in response do an original post anyway) and being ridiculed and mocked for it (mentally insecure / God botherer type comments). They're just not needed. (Yeah, sorry, I didn't leave it at that, did I. Oops) Edited by sprites (20 Jun 2018 6.44am) Well, I kind of agree that what you believe is your business. The only problem for me is the reality that this belief system gets passed onto children. So essentially it's the passing of stories as fact onto minors. That was done onto me and for various reasons many of those children never go onto seriously question these ideas. Still, this is no worse than any other religion....but it's still not ideal in our modern age. There are a few other practical problems with religion like the activities of activists and their political interference but none of these are probably your interest area so it would be over the top to detail them here. As for you not liking the fact that you get ridiculed.....Well, you trust in a story that's been told to you that there is no way for you to test. I hardly think you can complain if others find that incredulous and should shut up about it. Still, you say it's a slight issue so fair enough...perhaps the ridicule is sometimes aggressive or deliberately insulting and again that's not ideal. There are a lot of good people within religion trying to do positive things. Though this is a whole topic itself. However, a lot of people do feel angry about religion in general for various reasons so we have to take that into account as well.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
No, of course not. They're completely fictitious, mad-mad ideas created largely for children's entertainment. Christianity on the other hand is based on historical fact. Jesus existed. There's more proof of that than William Shakespear existed. Scholars and experts, for the most part, all accept that. He was a real historical figure. Likewise, they're largely unanimous about the fact he via died via crucifixion on a cross. So the question then becomes...was he just some dude that said a lot of stuff but didn't follow through...or is he who he says he is...that being, the son of God. I (and millions of others, for varying reasons) choose to believe that he is who he said he was. And lots (including you and millions of others) don't. Which is absolutely fine. I have no issue with that. What I have a slight issue with, is professing to be the former on here (which I was only doing in response do an original post anyway) and being ridiculed and mocked for it (mentally insecure / God botherer type comments). They're just not needed. (Yeah, sorry, I didn't leave it at that, did I. Oops) Edited by sprites (20 Jun 2018 6.44am) When you start making accurate statements,I will bother to answer them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
Some of the borderline trolling of believers on this thread is a bit OTT. However, if an omnipotent ultra-being is responsible for willing the entire universe into existence, I'm pretty confident that it wasn't Christos The Rabble-rouser (read your classics) who did it. I hope not, he seems like a reasonable guy. Just chewing the fat. I certainly hopes he doesn't take offence. The more I learn about the the quantum eraser experiments the more evidence there appears to be for a kind of determinism operating in the universe. Which was a bit of a turn up for me. So while I completely reject the 'personal god' keeping score on how many times you choked the chicken this week....it certainly leaves the door open for something.....or not...it's peeping through a doorkey into a dark expanse and trying to understand what you see.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I hope not, he seems like a reasonable guy. Just chewing the fat. I certainly hopes he doesn't take offence. The more I learn about the the quantum eraser experiments the more evidence there appears to be for a kind of determinism operating in the universe. Which was a bit of a turn up for me. So while I completely reject the 'personal god' keeping score on how many times you choked the chicken this week....it certainly leaves the door open for something.....or not...it's peeping through a doorkey into a dark expanse and trying to understand what you see.
What do you mean by detirminism? Nature appears to have determinism. A series of random chances will appear that way given enough time.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
What do you mean by detirminism? Nature appears to have determinism. A series of random chances will appear that way given enough time. The consequences of the quantum eraser experiment appear to suggest that knowledge of something determines how particles behave.....and this is independent of time....in other words independent of when it happens.....that aspect is mind blowing. No knowledge of a system suggests that particles can then exist in many states and be undetermined. I'll point you to the video which explains this.....beware though, I had to watch this quite a few times until I 'understood' it as there's a lot going on. The suggested consequence that we are living in a universe that is only determined (exactly) when it is sensed doesn't close off the possibility of a creation. Determinism seems to me more like a huge computer program or some sort of pre-defined logic process.......Don't get me wrong....this is only my speculation. I'm not putting anything forward that's solid. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jun 2018 7.50pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The consequences of the quantum eraser experiment appear to suggest that knowledge of something determines how particles behave.....and this is independent of time....in other words independent of when it happens.....that aspect is mind blowing. No knowledge of a system suggests that particles can then exist in many states and be undetermined. I'll point you to the video which explains this.....beware though, I had to watch this quite a few times until I 'understood' it as there's a lot going on. The suggested consequence that we are living in a universe that is only determined (exactly) when it is sensed doesn't close off the possibility of a creation. Determinism seems to me more like a huge computer program or some sort of pre-defined logic process.......Don't get me wrong....this is only my speculation. I'm not putting anything forward that's solid. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jun 2018 7.50pm) I am familiar with the experiments but I have no idea what it means and nor does anyone else it seems.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I am familiar with the experiments but I have no idea what it means and nor does anyone else it seems. Perhaps you should download that video and watch it about twenty times like I did. It's freaking mind blowing. It's a piece of the puzzle. It suggests determinism. What that means as a larger picture?....well like we both agree, it's unknown at this time. What exactly is meant by determinism, and what this leads to.....Well, the generations to come have exciting times. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
What is important in the context of this thread is that it is science and not superstition. With respect Hrolf my friend, the thread is called 'Is the Devil good, and God evil?'. Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I am not really comfortable discussing creationism and science in the same conversation. The former is based on ignorance. Science is above what those with agendas make of discoveries. All that matters is the evidence. Speculation is fine, as long as it's presented as such. Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Jun 2018 9.29pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.