This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
I shall not respond to any more comments about this matter. Edited by Willo (13 Jul 2019 5.29pm) So much for this...:rolleyes:
|
|
|
99.9% of football clubs are feeders for the "top 10" Palace ain't top ten. Get used to it
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Lay off willo please.
|
|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
"Wilson oversees 20 full-time members of staff at Southampton’s Staplewood Campus, plus a further 30 scouts, including Bill Green, the influential international scout. Wilson chairs a five-strong recruitment committee which includes the heads of analysis and youth recruitment, and which meets regularly. He has talked of how his team profile prospective signings on technical and psychological levels. “At any one time we might have 20 in the mix for one position,” Wilson says. “Then we narrow it down to three or four.” Willo, if you're going to plagiarise the work of others (without giving them credit), in this case the Guardian's David Hytner, at least make the effort to get the spelling correct; it's "oversees" not "overseas".
Willo just scrolls through google all day to appear supreme leader. Having said that, he always appears very cool, calm and collected.
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by rednblu
I would feel happier if someone could tell me what the club's structure is and how it works. Without giving away names or targets surely it is possible? E.G. We have a scouting system where we receive feedback from........,reports are considered by......, bids are made after...... The system has x scouts. The strategy is....... to establish a mix of young talent from lower leagues and mix with signings considered surplus by higher level clubs. Why do you feel the need to be involved in what I expect they don't want other clubs to know.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Why do you feel the need to be involved in what I expect they don't want other clubs to know. This is a Palace discussion forum and transfers are the major topic of discussion in this and every other football forum during the closed season. The question is why you feel the need to defend Parish and the club on every given occasion no matter what the subject
|
|
|
Originally posted by rednblu
I would feel happier if someone could tell me what the club's structure is and how it works. Without giving away names or targets surely it is possible? E.G. We have a scouting system where we receive feedback from........,reports are considered by......, bids are made after...... The system has x scouts. The strategy is....... to establish a mix of young talent from lower leagues and mix with signings considered surplus by higher level clubs. I don't know the ins and outs of it but I think the recruitment is carried out by a combination of Omar Yabroudi and Ben Stevens who report into Freedman, which goes to Hodgson and Parish and then Parish leaves the reports in his in tray until deadline day where we stick them all up on a wall, blind fold Ray Lewington and stick him on a spinning chair. Brighty gives him a good spin, then the Americans come in with some semi-automatics and Ray is left to shoot at the wall with whatever he hits we bid for.
|
|
|
How much is Freedman paid?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
How much is Freedman paid? Too much!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
In bygone days if signings didn't prove a success, the manager was subject to much ordure.I get the impression that if our signings in this window, come into this category Messrs Parish and Freedman will be the subject of vituperation and not Hodgson.
I'm not sure that it's an era thing but each club does things differently. Sean Dyche is rumoured to have complete control over all footballing matters including transfers and I can't imagine Alex Ferguson quietly putting up with a player being foisted upon him that he didn't want. I think that it's a Palace thing where the manager gives the Sporting Director and Chairman a list of whom he wants and they get him someone else. Or did Hodgson really ask for Jach and Radip
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I'm not sure that it's an era thing but each club does things differently. Sean Dyche is rumoured to have complete control over all footballing matters including transfers and I can't imagine Alex Ferguson quietly putting up with a player being foisted upon him that he didn't want. I think that it's a Palace thing where the manager gives the Sporting Director and Chairman a list of whom he wants and they get him someone else. Or did Hodgson really ask for Jach and Radip I really don't know if these rumours reflect the actualite. All I know is that last season Burnley had a Technical Director as well as a Head of Recruitment. Clubs of course operate differently but software tools such as 'WyScout' and 'Scout7' were simply not around in bygone days and often managers used to travel many miles,often in adverse weather conditions, to watch a player in an evening game.Statistics play a huge part these days with the introduction of modern technology.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
The scouting structure - as told to me via an agent - is this. Team of 10 full time reporting into DF. 3 technical data analysts lead by Ben Stevens 7 full time scouts covering UK and Europe 5 regional part time UK scouts Which on one hand is great as it highlights fifteen people involved in recruitment (not including the Manager, assistants, coaching staff and DF) On the other hand it is frightening, considering some of what they have come up with in recent transfer windows; Sorloth, Rakip, Jach, Riedewald, Ayew plus the re-signing of Sako etc.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
The scouting structure - as told to me via an agent - is this. Team of 10 full time reporting into DF. 3 technical data analysts lead by Ben Stevens 7 full time scouts covering UK and Europe 5 regional part time UK scouts Maybe they should just employ Mattteo to write his lists and the other 14 to read them
|
|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Which on one hand is great as it highlights fifteen people involved in recruitment (not including the Manager, assistants, coaching staff and DF) On the other hand it is frightening, considering some of what they have come up with in recent transfer windows; Sorloth, Rakip, Jach, Riedewald, Ayew plus the re-signing of Sako etc. I don't know if its the same now, but when the Harris brothers were on the books at Palace, their Dad was employed as a part time scout. Whether that was as an incentive to get them to sign at the time or not I don't know but it wouldn't surprise me if some of the part time scouts are similar set ups.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I'm not sure that it's an era thing but each club does things differently. Sean Dyche is rumoured to have complete control over all footballing matters including transfers and I can't imagine Alex Ferguson quietly putting up with a player being foisted upon him that he didn't want. I think that it's a Palace thing where the manager gives the Sporting Director and Chairman a list of whom he wants and they get him someone else. Or did Hodgson really ask for Jach and Radip my turn to pull you up on your spelling … Rakip not Radip … you have him halfway to being a 'radish' this may have been a Freudian slip and as such was a valid contribution to this thread however
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
This is a Palace discussion forum and transfers are the major topic of discussion in this and every other football forum during the closed season. The question is why you feel the need to defend Parish and the club on every given occasion no matter what the subject It's not a case of defending Parish,he is quiet capable of doing that himself, but doesn't seem to appear on podcasts now. As everything he says is twisted to suit some people's agenda.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.