This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Agreed. The other issue is that the exploitation goes both ways... Big Pharma on one side and people making money out of misinformation on the other. Both exist because of the other and feed off each other. Not much that can be done about that, ultimately you will only get to the best possible conclusion on things if you (again) take a scientific and objective view rather than ideological or pre-determined one. On scale that's one hell of a comparison. What was 'misinformation' and what wasn't. Who was being honest and who was being manipulated....we had state sponsored 'nudge units' and projections deliberately designed....not to deliver objective truth, but to control desired behaviour. Adults treated like children. We literally went through the state telling people to 'stay home to save lives'. So please forgive me if I take this 'misinformation' and any easy differentiation on who is making money from what kind of advice with a pinch of salt. Objectivity is by its nature unbiased. As we are all human it's almost impossible but that doesn't mean it shouldn't always be the aim. When you refer to 'science' I'm a little concerned that you perhaps view this as an incorruptible and unquestionable as a source. Any student of history knows that isn't so. He who pays the piper, calls the tune. Science is littered with studies and conclusions that were overturned and is by its nature evolving and questioning. Scientists are human and as such subject to all the same problems. I've long since become sceptical over the events of the last two years. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Jan 2023 9.07pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
On scale that's one hell of a comparison. We literally went through the state telling people to 'stay home to save lives'. So please forgive me if I take this 'misinformation' and any easy differentiation on who is making money from what kind of advice with a pinch of salt. Objectivity by its nature unbiased. As we are all human it's almost impossible but that doesn't mean it shouldn't always be the aim. When you refer to 'science' I'm a little concerned that you perhaps view this as an incorruptible and unquestionable source. Any student of history knows that isn't so. He who pays the piper, calls the tune. Science is littered with studies and conclusions that were overturned and is by its nature evolving and questioning. Scientists are human as as such subject to all the same problems. I've long since become sceptical over the events of the last two years. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Jan 2023 8.58pm) It's not an equivalence. But it is a fact that the two exist and feed off each other, and that a lot of people make a lot of money from that on both sides. Just like it takes work to weed out the good from the bad on the scientific/pharma side, the same applies to those questioning it. Can't just latch on to the most popular mouthpiece or the one that you happen to agree with. As should be evident from my previous post re. Ben Goldacre, it's rather obviously not an incorruptible and unquestionable source and that is of course therefore not my viewpoint at all. Also by definition science literally can't be unquestionable otherwise it ceases to become scientific. The nuance here is whether certain lines of questioning hold up to scrutiny or not. Anyone can take a pop but it requires rigour and proof to change consensus, and certainly a lot more than carefully baited and hacked together tiktoks (note, some people do provide some valuable balance and decent content, Brand is a good example as you've shared before but even he can get a bit excited sometimes). To your point, science evolves. Therefore views should evolve with it as things change, and as things change and evolve one should also do the same. That's my viewpoint. To do anything else is unscientific. If in 10 years consensus showed that actually we never needed a vaccine at all and it had no real impact, then I'd have to go with that. Why wouldn't you? The difference here is that I'd wager a lot of people on here would never shift their viewpoint regardless of topic – that's a very odd way to exist in my opinion.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
On scale that's one hell of a comparison. What was 'misinformation' and what wasn't. Who was being honest and who was being manipulated....we had state sponsored 'nudge units' and projections deliberately designed....not to deliver objective truth, but to control desired behaviour. Adults treated like children. We literally went through the state telling people to 'stay home to save lives'. So please forgive me if I take this 'misinformation' and any easy differentiation on who is making money from what kind of advice with a pinch of salt. Objectivity is by its nature unbiased. As we are all human it's almost impossible but that doesn't mean it shouldn't always be the aim. When you refer to 'science' I'm a little concerned that you perhaps view this as an incorruptible and unquestionable as a source. Any student of history knows that isn't so. He who pays the piper, calls the tune. Science is littered with studies and conclusions that were overturned and is by its nature evolving and questioning. Scientists are human and as such subject to all the same problems. I've long since become sceptical over the events of the last two years. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Jan 2023 9.07pm) Surely you have to be sceptical to everything, at all times though? Not just the things you ideologically feel more sceptical about. Recency bias and preconception/assumption isn't particularly useful beyond creating a hypothesis Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Jan 2023 9.30pm)
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Pretty sure it's only the vulnerable etc. or older age groups (just like flu, again) that have been invited to take the booster. So on that basis deciding against it as a vulnerable person, on balance, would actually be against the science and research and certainly higher risk than not taking it at all. For what it's worth I see no reason for me to pay to get another shot until the science suggests it's actually necessary. I do tend to get the flu jab annually but like most people I often forget or don't bother, but I know the risk vs benefit means I should really get it. Which brings me back to your original post. I’m not sure how I missed this but you can’t write something as reductive (and untrue) as ‘People who are vaccinated still carry and spread covid just as much as someone who is unvaccinated' then sign off with ‘science’ and expect to not get slammed. Based on the available information your point of view is in fact more emotive and ideological than scientific and logical. And to be clear there’s nothing wrong with that, just don't try to claim your viewpoint and statement is in any way scientifically aligned, because it's currently not. If you actually followed the science you'd always go with the least risky option. Hahahahahahaha I completely rest my case now!
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Hahahahahahaha I completely rest my case now! Misses the point for a third time. Oh well, I tried
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
It's not an equivalence. But it is a fact that the two exist and feed off each other, and that a lot of people make a lot of money from that on both sides. Just like it takes work to weed out the good from the bad on the scientific/pharma side, the same applies to those questioning it. Can't just latch on to the most popular mouthpiece or the one that you happen to agree with. As should be evident from my previous post re. Ben Goldacre, it's rather obviously not an incorruptible and unquestionable source and that is of course therefore not my viewpoint at all. Also by definition science literally can't be unquestionable otherwise it ceases to become scientific. The nuance here is whether certain lines of questioning hold up to scrutiny or not. Anyone can take a pop but it requires rigour and proof to change consensus, and certainly a lot more than carefully baited and hacked together tiktoks (note, some people do provide some valuable balance and decent content, Brand is a good example as you've shared before but even he can get a bit excited sometimes). To your point, science evolves. Therefore views should evolve with it as things change, and as things change and evolve one should also do the same. That's my viewpoint. To do anything else is unscientific. If in 10 years consensus showed that actually we never needed a vaccine at all and it had no real impact, then I'd have to go with that. Why wouldn't you? The difference here is that I'd wager a lot of people on here would never shift their viewpoint regardless of topic – that's a very odd way to exist in my opinion.
I think it's a good point that ultimately we all should be open to changing our mind once something is proven by objective sources (that prove themselves) rather than holding onto an opinion due to a stubborn ego. We will all be wrong on something(s) and will have believed something that events later showed was highly questionable....for example I was once a convinced neo con who listened to Christopher Hitchens and the like over the Iraq war. While I never and still don't buy into the original objections to that war, oil for example, I do freely admit that I was wrong to support it for the typical neo con reasons given. It's just healthy to keep in mind that none of us holds the path to divine truth and that our interpretation is always a best guess. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Jan 2023 10.26pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Surely you have to be sceptical to everything, at all times though? Not just the things you ideologically feel more sceptical about. Recency bias and preconception/assumption isn't particularly useful beyond creating a hypothesis Edited by SW19 CPFC (10 Jan 2023 9.30pm) Yep, I have become quite cynical about most things. I think you can have foundational beliefs based upon life experience....for example, being sceptical is one of them (foundational beliefs can still be wrong but it's going to be rarer). Beyond that I think we all have to accept that it all becomes degrees of opinion. I suppose we could just take a position where we don't have a view. Perhaps that's not always such a terrible position to take. But the unfortunate and sometimes annoying reality of our lives is that often we don't have that luxury and we are sometimes compelled to make decisions. I suppose the covid situation was one of those. It's also a truism that often there isn't a clear cut binary right or wrong. Real life isn't mathematics and often answers are on a scale or spectrum and are more about worldview. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Jan 2023 10.55pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
In one sense you're right, but at the same time would you refuse the wide range of medical treatment and breakthroughs for yourself where they may be able to save your life, or would you say 'it's time to go!'. There's little impulse greater than wanting to stay alive, and while that can certainly lead to bad decisions, and significant missteps too, as could be argued with covid, in general peoples problems with modern medicine or preference for chewing on some leaves and hoping for the best soon switch when they have a significant health concern. If I can freely chew on some leaves, then I have no problem. If the government are making me pay to do that, I do.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
There's certainly truth to that. Their legally endorsed my way or the highway approach - which of course they did not follow themselves - has created knock on health crises and done in countless businesses. Not giving proper thought to energy needs for decades is another disasater coming home to roost too. A further nail in the coffin on both counts. Indeed. As for the energy 'crisis', we all had a warning of that in the early 70's. Now, however, fifty odd years later, it seems that we, the public, will pay for that too. BTW, you post like a less aggressive previous poster.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Yes a lot of people who took the vaccine were misinformed of the side effects and adverse reactions and as to why they should take it. But now alot of them have done research and are informed and have chosen not to take the booster shot. You could argue that a great many who didn't were misinformed too but at this point in time it's been circulating long enough, that there's wide long term protection in the population. We are where we are with loss of confidence in government, a health crisis and businesses going under left, right and centre. Much of that was probably unavoidable, but it does likely mean that if something much worse than covid hits us people will do their own thing anyway.. so Tim's survival of the fitness scenario will come to the fore.
|
|
|
Interesting, especially in the light of the recent MP suspension. [Tweet Link]
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Interesting, especially in the light of the recent MP suspension. [Tweet Link]Who will ever object to an "investigation"? If it helps to reassure and lay to rest all the misinformation that's in circulation, especially that coming from those who ought to know better, that's all to the good. In the extremely unlikely event that something genuinely concerning is discovered, that's also to the good. I would lay extremely short odds on the first being proved correct and would lay very high odds on the second.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am going on holiday in a couple of weeks time and am delighted to see that the travel company are continuing to insist that all those travelling with them must be fully vaccinated unless they can show a medical exemption. I am glad to see common sense prevailing over commercial expediency. Although I wouldn't travel unless such arrangements were in place, so maybe there is also commercial expediency involved. Is this a cruise? If so it makes sense, if not then no it doesn't make sense.
One more point |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.