This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by silvertop
OK then, as the expert, educate me. How is pension credit calculated? Is it means tested? If so, at what level? That is, is it based on a line designed to ensure that those below it have the minimum dignified life that an elderly person deserves. If so, then that is the level I would set it at. The work has been done. And, to answer your question, I would not have basic state pension at all. It wouldn't exist. There would only be this benefit. It would have as its aim the lifting of retired people of limited means out of poverty. That is, what was always intended to be its purpose. I may be a lone voice and this view is VERY unpopular, especially on this site where many posters receive this money and believe they are entitled (your word) to it. However, I think there has been mission creep on state pensions where its role has morphed from safety net (the clue is in the words national INSURANCE) to entitlement (Badger misdescribed it as an "annuity" In a rapidly ageing population where the disposable income of the retired passed those of the workforce some years ago and then left it well behind, is it really appropriate to pay from a diminishing tax kitty somebody who has 2 houses, no dependents, no debts, a brand new car every 3 years and a dog, other than to retain their vote? And this time, please don't get smart and tell me that these people have this wealth as they have worked hard all their life etc. I know that. I just fail to see the fiscal justification for the workforce having to add to it. Like I said, I'm p1ssing in the wind. Pure electoral suicide. somebody who has 2 houses, no dependents, no debts, a brand new car every 3 years and a dog,
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Not your best argument but I can see a to and fro where we get nowhere. So, as for some reason you keep calling me a lefty (YT called me a "socialist"!!) I will say 2 areas where I am right of you and one where I think I may be right of you. 1. State pensions. Scrap 'em. Replace by means tested benefit. 2. NHS. Not sustainable as the population ages. Far more private sector involvement. 3. Free movement of EU labour. I am a free marketeer, not a protectionist, trade unionesque, crypto-Bolshevik like you! Discuss.
The NHS obviously needs a load taken off of it. Private health care should be made more affordable. I'm not against freedom of movement in Europe with limited visas but training our own population to fill vital jobs should be a priority.
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
this whole thread is rather depressing - let's knock the new govt on day 1 and get a right leaning pile on against anything Labour, however, this response is just pathetic. So after 14 years when the Tories have behaved disgracefully, all public services are now broken and we are in a cost of living crisis, yet we are paying the highest tax rates since the 2nd world war to bring this down to immigration is so sad. 'Illegal' immigration accounts for c5% of all immigrants coming into the UK and the Rwanda scheme is so costly and will account for c1% of those who do come in i'm not sure how this can be considered a deterrent. Cameron had told us he would get net migration down to the tens of thousands about 10 years ago and failed miserably as has every Tory govt since. I think Starmer has shown more statesmanship in 2 days than we have seen from the Tories in the last 10 years. There is a reasonable sized percentage of the population who will vote blue regardless of performance, policy or people - it's as ingrained as being a Palace fan is in us, and it's not remotely changeable. The fact the Tories still picked up nearly 7m votes this time round is testament to that - there were some willing to ditch them for Reform, but a staggering percentage remain loyal.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I'm not Willo but still voted Conservative on the basis that there was no credible alternative and there was no way that I would vote for Smash the Gangs Starmer as I didn't consider him to be a credible alternative Sounds like you would rather eat your own sh1t than support the alternatives. Doesn't say much for the options!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The NHS obviously needs a load taken off of it. Private health care should be made more affordable. I'm not against freedom of movement in Europe with limited visas but training our own population to fill vital jobs should be a priority. Damn, we're closer than I thought. On pensions, you need to have paid your stamps for 35 qualifying years. Claiming the dole can count as NI credit and will qualify that year. So dossing about for a lifetime may still land you a state pension. I understood the minimum qualifying years was designed to stop them pesky foreigners coming over here and claiming our benefits. Something else on which I suspect we have agreement. A+E and the emergency services should continue to be state funded. We do not want hospital bureaucrats rifling through people's purses to find their insurance cards to determine whether they are going to plug them into resus. This is not the USA. It is where they go after A+E and the op. It is the elective and out patient stuff where private funding needs to take more of a role.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
somebody who has 2 houses, no dependents, no debts, a brand new car every 3 years and a dog, That is an argument for paying us all more money. Now that is socialism!
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
I'm not his biggest fan, but it is clear we now have a grown up running the country. Clearly the Mail and the Telegraph will never like him, but they let the likes of Boris and Sunak literally get away with murder. Evidence? I think you should be more careful with your choice of words.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Damn, we're closer than I thought. On pensions, you need to have paid your stamps for 35 qualifying years. Claiming the dole can count as NI credit and will qualify that year. So dossing about for a lifetime may still land you a state pension. I understood the minimum qualifying years was designed to stop them pesky foreigners coming over here and claiming our benefits. Something else on which I suspect we have agreement. A+E and the emergency services should continue to be state funded. We do not want hospital bureaucrats rifling through people's purses to find their insurance cards to determine whether they are going to plug them into resus. This is not the USA. It is where they go after A+E and the op. It is the elective and out patient stuff where private funding needs to take more of a role. We definitely do not want the USA system; it is horrendous. The NHS should remain but it is the National Health Service, not the International Health Service.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Damn, we're closer than I thought. On pensions, you need to have paid your stamps for 35 qualifying years. Claiming the dole can count as NI credit and will qualify that year. So dossing about for a lifetime may still land you a state pension. I understood the minimum qualifying years was designed to stop them pesky foreigners coming over here and claiming our benefits. Something else on which I suspect we have agreement. A+E and the emergency services should continue to be state funded. We do not want hospital bureaucrats rifling through people's purses to find their insurance cards to determine whether they are going to plug them into resus. This is not the USA. It is where they go after A+E and the op. It is the elective and out patient stuff where private funding needs to take more of a role. Err...again your "understanding" is incorrect. It's 35 years of NI contributions for someone who potentially has a "full working life" in the UK, but the number of years is scaled back for someone who arrives in the UK later in life. Furthermore a 'stamp' hasn't existed since the 1960s.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Err...again your "understanding" is incorrect. It's 35 years of NI contributions for someone who potentially has a "full working life" in the UK, but the number of years is scaled back for someone who arrives in the UK later in life. Furthermore a 'stamp' hasn't existed since the 1960s. I know that, but it is still used as a comedic euphemism for qualifying year (like calling the US "the Colonies" or FBI agents "G-men" ) . If you are going to attack me, at least do so on the point I am making rather than on technical side points that do not have a material impact on what I am saying. Edited by silvertop (08 Jul 2024 12.47pm) Edited by silvertop (08 Jul 2024 12.47pm)
|
|
|
My first instinct would be that if they want to introduce means testing for pension qualification they will start ( as a way of getting the process introduced with minimum of fuss)by using an income / savings / property portfolio base line to establish / confirm full eligibility which seems reasonable to most people (with a sliding scale) & factor it in a couple years from now to give people enough time to mentally adjust to the prospect - Once its introduced then its just the thin end of the wedge & the parameters for qualification / sliding scale will be tightened on a semi regular basis. Originally posted by CrazyBadger
first Instincts is that this seems like a terrible Idea. The trouble is, everyone 'lives to their means', and you shouldn't be expected to live to a vastly lower means just because you have retired. As State pensions are based on your NI Contributions, the amount of which are in most cases not enough to retire on solely, and should be supplemented where possible so you are not in a position to have to downgrade your life. As you earn more, you are expected to save more for retirement so the more you earn less and less the State pension makes a difference to your retirement. From that angle, means testing seems a reasonable Idea. It's all about where the line is drawn. They'll be plenty of people who could be seen to be on 'higher income' have probably factored in and rely upon their projected state pension amount. If they suddenly remove it based on some arbitrary line drawn in the Sand, it could ruin Peoples retirement plans and piss a lot of people off in the process. Which in itself means that it has to begin by introducing means testing 40 years ahead of time, so those affected are those with the time to counter it by planning better.
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Emily Thornberry unceremoniously dumped by Starmer. I am conflicted on this, on one hand I wanted her to have a role where her arrogance and stupidity would get a good airing on TV. On the other, Starmer has shown a degree of sense in dumping her from higher office. Emily was confused why she did not get a role in government but my understanding was that this was due to austerity. Civil Servants pointed out that the biscuit budget would quadruple if she was in the cabinet.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
first Instincts is that this seems like a terrible Idea. The trouble is, everyone 'lives to their means', and you shouldn't be expected to live to a vastly lower means just because you have retired. As State pensions are based on your NI Contributions, the amount of which are in most cases not enough to retire on solely, and should be supplemented where possible so you are not in a position to have to downgrade your life. As you earn more, you are expected to save more for retirement so the more you earn less and less the State pension makes a difference to your retirement. From that angle, means testing seems a reasonable Idea. It's all about where the line is drawn. They'll be plenty of people who could be seen to be on 'higher income' have probably factored in and rely upon their projected state pension amount. If they suddenly remove it based on some arbitrary line drawn in the Sand, it could ruin Peoples retirement plans and piss a lot of people off in the process. Which in itself means that it has to begin by introducing means testing 40 years ahead of time, so those affected are those with the time to counter it by planning better. I'm not against means testing if it's strictly kept to someone's means.....However, hasn't this been looked into before as a policy...it probably costs more to administer than the savings made. People can talk about means testing for pensions but essentially we have to look at what the result is going to be.....if it isn't done carefully and we don't get mission creep....because mission creep is usually the way. I tend to find that the most vocal for this kind of thing are those people who don't have to worry about it. If you did this we are going to get an awful lot and I mean an awful lot of pensioner poverty. Most of these people can't really work, are at degrees of infirmity, have various medical or mental issues related to age and don't have families that help for various reasons (in many cases down to their own choices). Would government really put itself into a situation going to reduce their incomes?....Like Greece a few years back? Difficult to believe so....or is it? Unaffected people seem so enslaved to media messaging. People were worried about losing granny to covid and cheered on while the government spent 400 billion over two years just in case someone croaked who could have been saved. Well, if we are going to be sticking a lot of old elderly people into a situation where they aren't eating because they need to heat their home....s*** is going to get real very quick. These people would die a lot sooner than what the threat of covid gave them. There are structural problems that have been built up over many decades. I would need a lot of convincing on this. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jul 2024 9.50am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'm not against means testing if it's strictly kept to someone's means.....However, hasn't this been looked into before as a policy...it probably costs more to administer than the savings made. People can talk about means testing for pensions but essentially we have to look at what the result is going to be.....if it isn't done carefully and we don't get mission creep....because mission creep is usually the way. I tend to find that the most vocal for this kind of thing are those people who don't have to worry about it. If you did this we are going to get an awful lot and I mean an awful lot of pensioner poverty. Most of these people can't really work, are at degrees of infirmity, have various medical or mental issues related to age and don't have families that help for various reasons (in many cases down to their own choices). Would government really put itself into a situation going to reduce their incomes?....Like Greece a few years back? Difficult to believe so....or is it? Unaffected people seem so enslaved to media messaging. People were worried about losing granny to covid and cheered on while the government spent 400 billion over two years just in case someone croaked who could have been saved. Well, if we are going to be sticking a lot of old elderly people into a situation where they aren't eating because they need to heat their home....s*** is going to get real very quick. These people would die a lot sooner than what the threat of covid gave them. There are structural problems that have been built up over many decades. I would need a lot of convincing on this. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jul 2024 9.50am) Agree with all of this.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
Agree with all of this. Personally I'd have our bean counters looking into different forms of immigration over the last twenty five years. I'd advise deporting a lot of that third world immigration we brought in with their dependents. Unless a third world family is a net contributor I would kick them out. It's harsh but so is pensioner poverty. This country should never have been used as a welfare magnet for foreigners. We should only look after our own.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Personally I'd have our bean counters looking into different forms of immigration over the last twenty five years. I'd advise deporting a lot of that third world immigration we brought in with their dependents. Unless a third world family is a net contributor I would kick them out. It's harsh but so is pensioner poverty. This country should never have been used as a welfare magnet for foreigners. We should only look after our own. Well said Stirling - it's no surprise our prisons are overflowing and there's a housing shortage.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.