This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by stuckinbristol
Eden, can I ask, and I'm not trying to be inflammatory, why would you be worried about this? Fair question - my worry stems from the amount of power and control that the government would have, should you not comply with (whatever they may request) then your permissions and access rights could be reduced or indeed cancelled. Despite being a middle aged bloke who has a fairly comfortable lifestyle who has previously voted Conservative for 40 years (though never again) I do do trust this Government one bit and do not like the thought that they could have incredible control over all of us when I do not believe they act in our interest. The tracking we have currently does not bother me - I have nothing to hide (my life is pretty boring!) but digital ID is another ballgame.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eden Eagle
Fair question - my worry stems from the amount of power and control that the government would have, should you not comply with (whatever they may request) then your permissions and access rights could be reduced or indeed cancelled. Despite being a middle aged bloke who has a fairly comfortable lifestyle who has previously voted Conservative for 40 years (though never again) I do do trust this Government one bit and do not like the thought that they could have incredible control over all of us when I do not believe they act in our interest. The tracking we have currently does not bother me - I have nothing to hide (my life is pretty boring!) but digital ID is another ballgame. This passport is out of the governments hands tbh.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
This passport is out of the governments hands tbh. Exactly, if establishments (and countries) want to provide a safer environment for customers and reduce the impact of covid to their business they should be able to do so. If other establishments aren't interested then fine they should go with that option. The latter will largely attract masses of teenagers at little risk, and people who are unconcerned with other peoples health. Lovely atmosphere I'm sure.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Exactly, if establishments (and countries) want to provide a safer environment for customers and reduce the impact of covid to their business they should be able to do so. If other establishments aren't interested then fine they should go with that option. The latter will largely attract masses of teenagers at little risk, and people who are unconcerned with other peoples health. Lovely atmosphere I'm sure. BJ - why do you assume that someone who is against having to show a digital ID pass to enter an establishment is unconcerned about people’s health? This seems like very lazy stereotyping by you...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eden Eagle
Fair question - my worry stems from the amount of power and control that the government would have, should you not comply with (whatever they may request) then your permissions and access rights could be reduced or indeed cancelled. Despite being a middle aged bloke who has a fairly comfortable lifestyle who has previously voted Conservative for 40 years (though never again) I do do trust this Government one bit and do not like the thought that they could have incredible control over all of us when I do not believe they act in our interest. The tracking we have currently does not bother me - I have nothing to hide (my life is pretty boring!) but digital ID is another ballgame. If you feel that you are someone who the government would even be bothered to track, then dump your mobile phone and credit/debit cards as they could track you via these...not to mention the hundreds if not thousands of CCTV everywhere....personally I couldnt care less if they want to track me (although I cant imagine why they would want to).....Nothing to hide nothing to worry about
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You haven't got anything verifiable and I've already explained one reason why the precision here is difficult. It's been said on these forums many times before despite you apparently claiming otherwise. All you have is an 'appeal to authority' argument. I don't believe the accuracy of the statistics you promote and as for 'pipe down', go jump in a lake. Of course you can’t pipe down An empty drum I wonder why you are so poor at simple research.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eden Eagle
BJ - why do you assume that someone who is against having to show a digital ID pass to enter an establishment is unconcerned about people’s health? This seems like very lazy stereotyping by you... It's a bit of a generalisation no doubt. However since being vaccinated both reduces the chance of contracting covid, spreading it (and seriousness of it when you do) it would make sense that having this check prior would provide a safer environment currently. It should be down to the individual venues but places that don't require being vaccinated would logically attract a significant number of unvaccinated individuals. We have no way of knowing the risk of those individuals, beyond self assessment. There is a significant risk to those who are vulnerable but do not perceive themselves to be from others in the venue. Where some are vaccinated fair enough, they've done their bit, but where they aren't, it doesn't strike me that they're all that interested in others well being. Funnily enough I see the digital tracking that you're more comfortable with as much more of a problem. Governments being able to track peoples movements by the second 24/7, and build a complete profile of who they, who they know, their politics, and so on is much more open to china style 'social credit' abuse down the line than having a check before walking into a pub. Being placed in a digital cage makes us more like zoo animals than being vaccinated ever will. Governments lurch this way and that, and today's upstanding citizen could be tomorrow villain ( [Link] [Link] no doubt there are examples across the political spectrum). It's open to exploitation as those in power (or journalism etc) in the coming decades will have effectively lived online both at home and on the move, and it's certainly possible to attempt to politically and otherwise exploit, control, or paint them in a certain light if they go against the politics of the day. There are of course legitimate uses of these powers too though so it's a difficult balance. Governments take advantage of that and routinely play left and right against one another to push this ongoing erosion of civil liberties through, but it eventually acts to the detriment of everybody.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Of course you can’t pipe down An empty drum I wonder why you are so poor at simple research. While both of these links refer to Covid and flu, neither of them seem related to the accuracy of your previous statistics.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
I see it's still the same old people who if some one does not agree with them they are attacked. Why even continue this thread all it is now is people attacking each other just what the power players wont people turning on each other. People that have been in a system lets say NHS are brainwashed they listen to everything the company states I can see this with some peoples comments I was the same back in the US you are in the system and the training you receive or are told is always the facts. No its not its what suits their agenda. This is why I got out it's a broken system which is nothing to do with the truth or human health. Posting up links to pseudoscience is waste of time ever wonder why their is so many published papers or so called studies its simple $$$ you are forced to do them even when they are offering nothing. This whole covid-19 has turned into a big scam is it real yes does it kill millions no it doesn't People who claim to know science or have research show us covid-19 being the causes of 1 human death (you can't no evidence of causality if you had learnt about human physiology you would know this it's many other factors one massive one being lack of Vitamin D some genetics as well) People did die while infected this is not being denied but it was other factors that was the issue. Look up world death rates for everything you will see they are not extremely high in line with normal times yet we are suppose to be having a world pandemic. Other stats to look at is the ones regarding the lockdowns and now claims the numbers are reducing because of vaccine/lockdowns again lies the real data does not show this the declines had been happening before hand regarding lockdowns. If you are a person who is going to have the vaccine load up on Vitamin D before and after not so called RDA amounts but around 25000iu (do not do this if you have medical issues regarding kidney/liver) also use a good source not cheap pills supermarkets sell with lots of useless fillers oil based ones are recommended type either as an oil or caplet Edited by grumpymort (11 Mar 2021 1.00am) If the ones that died while infected, wernt infected would they have died. Are you assuming that they would still have died at that same time in their life no matter. I did post that all of us imo have an underlying health issue however small, we are not machines; and covid finds that and bingo. Death in some,a small some yes but still caused by catching this virus. I'm on fultium D already so maybe had some protection from the off.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
It's a bit of a generalisation no doubt. However since being vaccinated both reduces the chance of contracting covid, spreading it (and seriousness of it when you do) it would make sense that having this check prior would provide a safer environment currently. It should be down to the individual venues but places that don't require being vaccinated would logically attract a significant number of unvaccinated individuals. We have no way of knowing the risk of those individuals, beyond self assessment. There is a significant risk to those who are vulnerable but do not perceive themselves to be from others in the venue. Where some are vaccinated fair enough, they've done their bit, but where they aren't, it doesn't strike me that they're all that interested in others well being. Funnily enough I see the digital tracking that you're more comfortable with as much more of a problem. Governments being able to track peoples movements by the second 24/7, and build a complete profile of who they, who they know, their politics, and so on is much more open to china style 'social credit' abuse down the line than having a check before walking into a pub. Being placed in a digital cage makes us more like zoo animals than being vaccinated ever will. Governments lurch this way and that, and today's upstanding citizen could be tomorrow villain ( [Link] [Link] no doubt there are examples across the political spectrum). It's open to exploitation as those in power (or journalism etc) in the coming decades will have effectively lived online both at home and on the move, and it's certainly possible to attempt to politically and otherwise exploit, control, or paint them in a certain light if they go against the politics of the day. There are of course legitimate uses of these powers too though so it's a difficult balance. Governments take advantage of that and routinely play left and right against one another to push this ongoing erosion of civil liberties through, but it eventually acts to the detriment of everybody.
I have made no reference to not getting vaccinated - people should be free to choose whether they wish for this or not. My concern is exactly what you raise as a potential issue which is the introduction of a Chinese style “social credit” system which a digital ID vaccine pass is the start of this road. For clarity I know that we can be currently tracked via CCTV, phone records, bank transactions etc however this is very different from having to “show your papers” every time you want to go into a shop, cinema, restaurant, football match etc. If you think this is far fetched then look at what is happening in Israel right now. Would you trust Johnson, Hancock and the rest of the Tory government with this sort of power over your lives? If that is a society that people want to live in so be it but it fills me with dread.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
On Thursday, Her Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire and Rescue Services (HMICFRS) published its plans for the future of policing protests, two days after the government announced proposed new laws granting more powers to officers and the home secretary. Among other things, the police, crime, sentencing and courts bill will give Priti Patel powers to create laws to define “serious disruption” to communities and organisations, which police can then rely on to impose conditions on protests. This is the post-covid police state, the government will never go back to normal imo. Sounds like they will start policing rampaging mobs - good.
|
|
|
The government will keep as many of their emergency powers as they can. I don't think we will return to what it was only a year ago.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eden Eagle
I have made no reference to not getting vaccinated - people should be free to choose whether they wish for this or not. My concern is exactly what you raise as a potential issue which is the introduction of a Chinese style “social credit” system which a digital ID vaccine pass is the start of this road. For clarity I know that we can be currently tracked via CCTV, phone records, bank transactions etc however this is very different from having to “show your papers” every time you want to go into a shop, cinema, restaurant, football match etc. If you think this is far fetched then look at what is happening in Israel right now. Would you trust Johnson, Hancock and the rest of the Tory government with this sort of power over your lives? If that is a society that people want to live in so be it but it fills me with dread. The government will only formalise and regulate what the people as a whole expect. The motivation will come from us. If more of us feel safer knowing that those we are mixing with are vaccinated than those who don't then commercial pressures will determine that identification is required. I see nothing at all to either fear, or dread, in choosing to be safe. Those who fear a lessening of our freedoms are missing the point. We all have freedoms, but they aren't all identical freedoms. Some include being free of the freedoms that others seek.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The government will only formalise and regulate what the people as a whole expect. The motivation will come from us. If more of us feel safer knowing that those we are mixing with are vaccinated than those who don't then commercial pressures will determine that identification is required. I see nothing at all to either fear, or dread, in choosing to be safe. Those who fear a lessening of our freedoms are missing the point. We all have freedoms, but they aren't all identical freedoms. Some include being free of the freedoms that others seek. With respect WE I am not missing the point - it is my opinion and I am entitled to hold a different one from you. It is strange how so many left leaning (not literally) people are happy to surrender their personal freedoms and liberties as long as they are “kept safe by the government” People who cannot stand the tories are quick to believe them now that they have their best interest at heart - very odd.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Eden Eagle
I have made no reference to not getting vaccinated - people should be free to choose whether they wish for this or not. My concern is exactly what you raise as a potential issue which is the introduction of a Chinese style “social credit” system which a digital ID vaccine pass is the start of this road. For clarity I know that we can be currently tracked via CCTV, phone records, bank transactions etc however this is very different from having to “show your papers” every time you want to go into a shop, cinema, restaurant, football match etc. If you think this is far fetched then look at what is happening in Israel right now. Would you trust Johnson, Hancock and the rest of the Tory government with this sort of power over your lives? If that is a society that people want to live in so be it but it fills me with dread. I appreciate your view, we just have differences in what is most concerning to us in terms of civil liberties. To my mind what is behind the scenes already is more concerning than actively having to opt into a venue or prove vaccination to get on a flight etc. Edited by BlueJay (11 Mar 2021 1.36pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The government will keep as many of their emergency powers as they can. I don't think we will return to what it was only a year ago. It's a concern that I share with you. I hope we are both mistaken....and I do think their are genuine political voices who will also make these points if liberties aren't returned. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2021 2.21pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.