You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 5.14am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 53 of 91 < 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 >
est1905 Flag 22 Jan 20 5.20pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

With the number of players who can travel with the ball injured and the imbalanced teams we’ve been fielding the surprise has been the number of points we’ve nicked over the last few weeks rather than result tonight.

Kelly has looked vulnerable in recent weeks and my main criticism of Roy would be that he didn’t put Ward straight back in.

I don’t think th3 ten points we need to stay up are a given and the owners need to sort their lives out and get some quicker players in who’ll bring some intensity and quality.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (22 Jan 2020 12.23am)

Kelly is not a full back. He is a centre half and if he cant play centre half he should stay on the bench. Last night proved this.

 

est1905 Flag 22 Jan 20 5.22pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Our current league position flatters us beyond belief. Hopefully what will save us from relegation this year is three worse teams. However having said that, given that there aren’t three worse teams than us, perhaps three less lucky teams will save us.

When you look at Villa Norwich, Burnley, Brighton, Watford, Southampton, Newcastle Bournemouth and West Ham I can’t find 3 teams worse than us and the worrying stat is that they are all starting to win matches. 38 points won’t be enough this year. 40 points is the minimum.

My goodness you talk hysterical rubbish. Are you honestly saying that all of the teams you list above are better than us? Really?
Whatever you tell yourself pal, the league table doesn't lie.

 

est1905 Flag 22 Jan 20 5.23pm

Originally posted by Ian-VI

With a much needed break that will rest the players who played basically 8 matches in a month, and with a few more players coming back from injury we'll be on 40 points by mid March.

This

 

est1905 Flag 22 Jan 20 5.28pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Ray Lewington said some months ago that Roy always plays the same way regardless of the opposition.
The implication seemed to be that this simplified the game for the players and they had no excuses for not knowing their roles.
Problem is that it also simplifies the game for the opposition and there is no danger of them being confused or surprised by our tactics.
I’ve heard of the expression protecting a lead.
Under Hodgson we seem to play to protect a 1-0 loss when we fall behind.
Bizarre.

Hmm, if you actually believe that ask yourself how come RH is still managing/coaching at the top level 40 years on from when he started. He gets results.
Its laughable how when we do well on here its just luck and when we do badly its a big fat I told you so.
Recruitment is an issue, our squad is getting old and the club is not keeping pace with that issue but this is a Parish/Freedman problem not a RH one.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jan 20 5.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

Liverpool have a throw-in coach by the name of Thomas Gronnemark.

Honestly - they have a coach for throw ins? We don't seem to practice any set-pieces.
Sack the board if we don't have a throw in coach. We want a throw-in coach. We want a throw-in coach!

 


Red and Blue Army!

scuffy Flag orpington 22 Jan 20 5.32pm

Roy is averaging close to 1.3 points per game with Palace. Compare that to Howe at Bournemouth (1.1) or Dyche at Burnley (1.1) and you can see how good a job he is doing since those clubs resources are at least comparable to us. A few people mention we apparently have the 9th highest wage bill, but that doesn't necessarily mean we have the 9th best squad. We have an imbalanced squad and are wasting fortunes on the likes of Benteke (shot) and Sakho (rarely fit). That's not Roy's fault.

 

est1905 Flag 22 Jan 20 5.32pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

An interesting concept. To be eligible for a spot would mean winning games to climb the league. To win games you need to score goals. We are currently the lowest scorers.
Conclusion: unlikely.

That was when we were relying on Ayew and Benteke and everyone else was injured. Tosun IS a goalscorer like it or not (despite the chance he missed last night) and Wickham will also score goals if he stays fit.
We are the amongst the lowest goal scorers. What cancels that out is we are also conceding the fewest.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Jan 20 5.37pm

Originally posted by est1905

That was when we were relying on Ayew and Benteke and everyone else was injured. Tosun IS a goalscorer like it or not (despite the chance he missed last night) and Wickham will also score goals if he stays fit.
We are the amongst the lowest goal scorers. What cancels that out is we are also conceding the fewest.

Your post is based on conjecture and hope, not fact, that is for future games to prove. We shall see.

 

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 22 Jan 20 5.37pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Our current league position flatters us beyond belief. Hopefully what will save us from relegation this year is three worse teams. However having said that, given that there aren’t three worse teams than us, perhaps three less lucky teams will save us.

When you look at Villa Norwich, Burnley, Brighton, Watford, Southampton, Newcastle Bournemouth and West Ham I can’t find 3 teams worse than us and the worrying stat is that they are all starting to win matches. 38 points won’t be enough this year. 40 points is the minimum.


Of those teams only maybe West Ham has a stronger 11 than our, but only slightly.
Go on the forums of all teams, write down our best 11 and ask them if they would keep their team or swap it.

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Jan 20 5.46pm

Originally posted by Ian-VI


Of those teams only maybe West Ham has a stronger 11 than our, but only slightly.
Go on the forums of all teams, write down our best 11 and ask them if they would keep their team or swap it.

I tell you what, you do it and let me know how it goes. It doesn’t matter how good your 11 are if they are not allowed past the half way line.

 

scuffy Flag orpington 22 Jan 20 5.57pm

We won't be anywhere near relegation. We'll be 10 points clear, minimum. Trust me!

Originally posted by Ian-VI


Of those teams only maybe West Ham has a stronger 11 than our, but only slightly.
Go on the forums of all teams, write down our best 11 and ask them if they would keep their team or swap it.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Jan 20 6.00pm

Originally posted by scuffy

We won't be anywhere near relegation. We'll be 10 points clear, minimum. Trust me!

That’s 50 minimum, are you sure Scuffy looking at our last 6 matches?

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 22 Jan 20 7.02pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I tell you what, you do it and let me know how it goes. It doesn’t matter how good your 11 are if they are not allowed past the half way line.

Bollux. PVA scores goals, Schlupp has scored a few. Tompkins has scored, Jimmy Mac has scored, Chahill laid on a goal at City and Kouyate has scored AND they are all defenders. .

Edited by PZ Eagle (22 Jan 2020 7.03pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Jan 20 7.12pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Bollux. PVA scores goals, Schlupp has scored a few. Tompkins has scored, Jimmy Mac has scored, Chahill laid on a goal at City and Kouyate has scored AND they are all defenders. .

Edited by PZ Eagle (22 Jan 2020 7.03pm)

Do one PZ you are a total jerk. Do you not get irony ?

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 22 Jan 20 7.28pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Do one PZ you are a total jerk. Do you not get irony ?

If it was the first time maybe but you know so little about football and are never ending in your criticism of Roy you are the pillock so you go and do one.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

jeeagles Flag 22 Jan 20 7.36pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Honestly - they have a coach for throw ins? We don't seem to practice any set-pieces.
Sack the board if we don't have a throw in coach. We want a throw-in coach. We want a throw-in coach!

We have the man who got Harry Kane to take corners.

Saturday was our first goal from a corner.
Southampton away was our first goal from an indirect free kick.

If your struggling for goals, surely you have to get your set pieces nailed on?

 

scuffy Flag orpington 22 Jan 20 8.29pm

I think 38 will be enough to stay up. It nearly always is. I think we'll finish on 48-50 which requires 18 to 20 from the remaining 14 games. That's doable.

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

That’s 50 minimum, are you sure Scuffy looking at our last 6 matches?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Jan 20 8.39pm

Originally posted by scuffy

I think 38 will be enough to stay up. It nearly always is. I think we'll finish on 48-50 which requires 18 to 20 from the remaining 14 games. That's doable.

I have a feeling 40 is going to be the magic number this year, just because no team is totally detached from the rest. It could go down to the last week and involve 5 or 6 teams.

I hope you are right with our number but I think we will finish closer to 40 points than to. 50

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 22 Jan 20 9.20pm

Originally posted by Ian-VI

When we had Loftus-Cheek Roy used him as an attacking midfielder, and we were playing him with Cabaye, Andros, Wilf and a striker, and we produced some of the best attacking football we played recently (ex. 3-0 vs Leicester).
If he has an attacking midfielder, he'd play him, but he hasn't got it.
Unless you're trying to tell me that Meyer is at Loftus-Cheek level, because it's like comparing a Fiat Panda with a Porsche...

Well said. Many were predicting relegation for us before we kicked a ball this season after the lack of summer investment and AWB’s departure. Most would have snatched your hand off if offered 30 pts at this stage .

Don’t get me wrong last night was dire and I’d certainly not be complacent about the ten more points we need but some very short memories on this board.

 

south coast eagle Flag Rustington West Sussex 23 Jan 20 10.49am

Originally posted by PatrickA

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Hodgesaraus your time is up.' by Midlands Eagle

I have some sympathy with Gribbo’s view - and not just based on last night.
We have struggled all season as an attacking force and for Hodgson to hide behind the injuries is not to my mind a valid excuse.
Earlier in the season with Schlupp, Townsend and Benteke available we still looked toothless in attack and still played with ten behind the ball.
When Roy has taken the handbrake off against Villa and Liverpool (oddly) we have looked all the better for it.
His negativity is so frustrating,and I can see where those who claim it is ‘anti football are coming from.’

Plus when you look the last three seasons last home games we have scored 5 against Bournemouth and Leicester and 4 against Hull, so these players are capable if allowed and us fans would see some entertaining football more than in the last home game of the season

 


Forever Palace

Page 53 of 91 < 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread