This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Protests in London following Conservative victory
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
johnfirewall 11 May 15 12.47pm |
|
|
Testament to the reduction in unemployment that this and the forthcoming protest next month are on the weekend.
|
The Sash Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 11 May 15 12.55pm |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 May 2015 10.05am
Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 8.21pm
The snooty responses on this thread make me want to go rioting.
Snooty responses?
Most people have expressed disgust that a war memorial has been desecrated and that losing a democratic vote process is hardly grounds for a riot.
Grow up.
Indeed Hoof - the little cock monkey who saw fit to daub 'f*** Tory Scum' over a memorial to the female contribution to WW2 should be stuck in f***ing stocks...
Rather than try to be so riiiight on and trendy with the anti-tory stuff perhaps they and the country would be better served with demonstrating about the ludicrous situation that two parties, UKIP and Green can get 12 and 4% respectively of a national vote and get 2 MP's between them whilst one party, the SNP can get 5% and over 50 MP's because they stood in only one part of the country..f*ck the Tories its the system that enables them (and Labour to be fair) to get elected with such a dubious FPP/Constituency based election system that people need to rail against.
Its un-democratic, archaic and ultimately unrepresentative
Edited by The Sash (11 May 2015 1.05pm)
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|
serial thriller The Promised Land 11 May 15 1.01pm |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 May 2015 10.05am
Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 8.21pm
The snooty responses on this thread make me want to go rioting.
Snooty responses?
Most people have expressed disgust that a war memorial has been desecrated and that losing a democratic vote process is hardly grounds for a riot.
Grow up.
The main sentiment has been the typical stereotyping of everyone on the demonstration being middle class student hippies who don't wash, which is as hackneyed as it is inaccurate.
The graffiti, while obviously not recommended, becomes the typical symbol with which cynics tar the whole movement with the same brush. Clearly one moron has got a bit excited, I doubt that it was a unanimous democratic decision to do so. But then focusing on that makes it so much easier to detract from the very legitimate concerns most on the demo were raising with our electoral system and the welfare cuts.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|
derben 11 May 15 1.15pm |
|
Quote serial thriller at 11 May 2015 1.01pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 May 2015 10.05am
Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 8.21pm
The snooty responses on this thread make me want to go rioting.
Snooty responses?
Most people have expressed disgust that a war memorial has been desecrated and that losing a democratic vote process is hardly grounds for a riot.
Grow up.
The main sentiment has been the typical stereotyping of everyone on the demonstration being middle class student hippies who don't wash, which is as hackneyed as it is inaccurate.
The graffiti, while obviously not recommended, becomes the typical symbol with which cynics tar the whole movement with the same brush. Clearly one moron has got a bit excited, I doubt that it was a unanimous democratic decision to do so. But then focusing on that makes it so much easier to detract from the very legitimate concerns most on the demo were raising with our electoral system and the welfare cuts.
Most of the placards used by the middle class student hippies were provided by the Socialist Workers party, an undemocratic Trotskyist bunch of nutters whose aim is to try to start a revolution rather than address 'legitimate concerns'. Of course, if their 'policies' were ever implemented, there would be many more legitimate concerns, not least the violent suppression of any 'counter-revolutionary elements'.
|
serial thriller The Promised Land 11 May 15 1.18pm |
|
Quote derben at 11 May 2015 1.15pm
Quote serial thriller at 11 May 2015 1.01pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 May 2015 10.05am
Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 8.21pm
The snooty responses on this thread make me want to go rioting.
Snooty responses?
Most people have expressed disgust that a war memorial has been desecrated and that losing a democratic vote process is hardly grounds for a riot.
Grow up.
The main sentiment has been the typical stereotyping of everyone on the demonstration being middle class student hippies who don't wash, which is as hackneyed as it is inaccurate.
The graffiti, while obviously not recommended, becomes the typical symbol with which cynics tar the whole movement with the same brush. Clearly one moron has got a bit excited, I doubt that it was a unanimous democratic decision to do so. But then focusing on that makes it so much easier to detract from the very legitimate concerns most on the demo were raising with our electoral system and the welfare cuts.
Most of the placards used by the middle class student hippies were provided by the Socialist Workers party, an undemocratic Trotskyist bunch of nutters whose aim is to try to start a revolution rather than address 'legitimate concerns'. Of course, if their 'policies' were ever implemented, there would be many more legitimate concerns, not least the violent suppression of any 'counter-revolutionary elements'.
As much as this will surprise you, I loathe the SWP more than you do. They are rape apologists who have little to no credibility with anyone on the far left, but still have a very active older membership willing to pay for placards etc.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|
npn Crowborough 11 May 15 1.29pm |
|
Quote serial thriller at 11 May 2015 1.01pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 May 2015 10.05am
Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 8.21pm
The snooty responses on this thread make me want to go rioting.
Snooty responses?
Most people have expressed disgust that a war memorial has been desecrated and that losing a democratic vote process is hardly grounds for a riot.
Grow up.
The main sentiment has been the typical stereotyping of everyone on the demonstration being middle class student hippies who don't wash, which is as hackneyed as it is inaccurate.
The graffiti, while obviously not recommended, becomes the typical symbol with which cynics tar the whole movement with the same brush. Clearly one moron has got a bit excited, I doubt that it was a unanimous democratic decision to do so. But then focusing on that makes it so much easier to detract from the very legitimate concerns most on the demo were raising with our electoral system and the welfare cuts.
Presumably if htere had been a democratic decision, they would then have ended up protesting against themselves!
I do agree, though, that the electoral system has to go - ironically of course this woukld have led to far more right wingers in government (assuming we're talking PR and not just "anything that gets the left in power"
|
The Sash Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 11 May 15 1.29pm |
|
Quote derben at 11 May 2015 1.15pm
Quote serial thriller at 11 May 2015 1.01pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 May 2015 10.05am
Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 8.21pm
The snooty responses on this thread make me want to go rioting.
Snooty responses?
Most people have expressed disgust that a war memorial has been desecrated and that losing a democratic vote process is hardly grounds for a riot.
Grow up.
The main sentiment has been the typical stereotyping of everyone on the demonstration being middle class student hippies who don't wash, which is as hackneyed as it is inaccurate.
The graffiti, while obviously not recommended, becomes the typical symbol with which cynics tar the whole movement with the same brush. Clearly one moron has got a bit excited, I doubt that it was a unanimous democratic decision to do so. But then focusing on that makes it so much easier to detract from the very legitimate concerns most on the demo were raising with our electoral system and the welfare cuts.
Most of the placards used by the middle class student hippies were provided by the Socialist Workers party, an undemocratic Trotskyist bunch of nutters whose aim is to try to start a revolution rather than address 'legitimate concerns'. Of course, if their 'policies' were ever implemented, there would be many more legitimate concerns, not least the violent suppression of any 'counter-revolutionary elements'.
and given their recent history a soft stance on rape and sexual assault....
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|
matt_himself Matataland 11 May 15 1.50pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 11 May 2015 12.33pm
Interesting. Matthew, you have never ever answered any points made in my lefty propaganda (from itv!) just said it's 'bum gravy'. Derben has a similar tack.
It would be nice from time to time if you could unpick and elaborate on what it is you disagree with.
It would be lovely if everyone was able to unpick everything you wrote. Sadly, we don't have the time. Likewise, sometimes your responses to my posts are, to put it mildly, bluffs. You could maybe practice what you preach.
Where did I say the above about what you said? Refresh my memory.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02
|
silvertop Portishead 11 May 15 2.06pm |
|
|
Tricky one this. I am not happy with the outcome of the election and believe it is a democratic right for people to protest in order to focus on certain issues.
I do not believe that rioting and desecrating war memorials will achieve that aim.
Likewise, when a black man dies in police custody something wrong has happened. There is a democratic right for people to express their views in order to encourage a change of police practise and procedure etc.
There is no democratic right to use the unlawful death at police hands of an innocent man to smash shop windows and steal plasma tellies, I-phones and sports wear.
I think the word I am looking for is hijacking.
|
Lyons550 Shirley 11 May 15 2.23pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 May 2015 10.42am
Quote Pussay Patrol at 10 May 2015 10.10am
Maybe their real angst is they don't have a party that represents them?
The fact that people in the Labour party are cut from the same cloth and just have modern liberal ideals.
If there is such great disillusionment Why doesn't a new socialist party evolve that fights for jobs, minimum wage, social housing, Education, student rights and fees, benefits. everyday Things that resonate with poor, ordinary people? Instead they get the Labour party. That's what they should fight for rather than the boring 'tories out' cliche
Because of the cost of campaigning in rigged elections, where 7.7% of the vote returns 8 seats, 12% returns 1 seat, and a 6% difference means a difference of other 100 seats.
Anyone who thinks the British system is really democratic, fair, impartial and representative of the people is deluded.
Wasn't there a referendum on keeping it or changing to PR only 18months or so ago...seems perfectly democratic to me
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World
|
dannyb1 Chichester 11 May 15 2.52pm |
|
|
This won't be the last rally/protest you will see in the next 5 years in this country I believe.
|
npn Crowborough 11 May 15 3.17pm |
|
Quote Lyons550 at 11 May 2015 2.23pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 May 2015 10.42am
Quote Pussay Patrol at 10 May 2015 10.10am
Maybe their real angst is they don't have a party that represents them?
The fact that people in the Labour party are cut from the same cloth and just have modern liberal ideals.
If there is such great disillusionment Why doesn't a new socialist party evolve that fights for jobs, minimum wage, social housing, Education, student rights and fees, benefits. everyday Things that resonate with poor, ordinary people? Instead they get the Labour party. That's what they should fight for rather than the boring 'tories out' cliche
Because of the cost of campaigning in rigged elections, where 7.7% of the vote returns 8 seats, 12% returns 1 seat, and a 6% difference means a difference of other 100 seats.
Anyone who thinks the British system is really democratic, fair, impartial and representative of the people is deluded.
Wasn't there a referendum on keeping it or changing to PR only 18months or so ago...seems perfectly democratic to me
Sadly, no there wasn't. There was a fererendum on changing to AV - which is a completely sh*t system, and not PR at all
|
johnno42000 11 May 15 3.20pm |
|
|
Everyone has a right to protest, and I'm glad a lot of the protesters seemed young as at least it shows that some youngsters have an interest in political issues.
The desecration of the war memorial is disgusting. No if's or buts.
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'
|
imbored UK 11 May 15 3.31pm |
|
Quote npn at 11 May 2015 3.17pm
Quote Lyons550 at 11 May 2015 2.23pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 May 2015 10.42am
Quote Pussay Patrol at 10 May 2015 10.10am
Maybe their real angst is they don't have a party that represents them?
The fact that people in the Labour party are cut from the same cloth and just have modern liberal ideals.
If there is such great disillusionment Why doesn't a new socialist party evolve that fights for jobs, minimum wage, social housing, Education, student rights and fees, benefits. everyday Things that resonate with poor, ordinary people? Instead they get the Labour party. That's what they should fight for rather than the boring 'tories out' cliche
Because of the cost of campaigning in rigged elections, where 7.7% of the vote returns 8 seats, 12% returns 1 seat, and a 6% difference means a difference of other 100 seats.
Anyone who thinks the British system is really democratic, fair, impartial and representative of the people is deluded.
Wasn't there a referendum on keeping it or changing to PR only 18months or so ago...seems perfectly democratic to me
Sadly, no there wasn't. There was a fererendum on changing to AV - which is a completely sh*t system, and not PR at all
True and as highlighted before the campaign to kill it off was deplorable.
Attachment: b.jpg (57.86Kb)
|
imbored UK 11 May 15 3.31pm |
|
|
and..
Attachment: a.jpg (259.03Kb)
|
dannyh wherever I lay my hat....... 11 May 15 3.54pm |
|
|
Questions for lefties among us.
Why is there never any riots when Labour win an election?
Why did the trustafarians riot when no such cuts to welfare have been sanctioned or passed through the house?
Why wasnt there the same criticism of the electoral system last time Labour won ?
And finally has anyone got a picture of Ed Ball's face when he heard he had lost his seat, just for my own amusement.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"
|
imbored UK 11 May 15 4.05pm |
|
Quote dannyh at 11 May 2015 3.54pm
Questions for lefties among us.
Why wasnt there the same criticism of the electoral system last time Labour won ?
With support from both Lib Dems and UKIP for electoral reform it's a cross party issue that has started to rear its head more on account of the diminishing percentage of the vote the major two parties return. It's quite stark. Check it out.
Attachment: percentage.png (21.70Kb)
|
derben 11 May 15 4.11pm |
|
Quote imbored at 11 May 2015 4.05pm
Quote dannyh at 11 May 2015 3.54pm
Questions for lefties among us.
Why wasnt there the same criticism of the electoral system last time Labour won ?
With support from both Lib Dems and UKIP for electoral reform it's a cross party issue that has started to rear its head more on account of the diminishing percentage of the vote the major two parties return. It's quite stark. Check it out.
So the 'protestors' with their Socialist Worker placards are out on the street because of the lack of proportional representation in the electoral system?
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 11 May 15 4.16pm |
|
Quote derben at 11 May 2015 4.11pm
Quote imbored at 11 May 2015 4.05pm
Quote dannyh at 11 May 2015 3.54pm
Questions for lefties among us.
Why wasnt there the same criticism of the electoral system last time Labour won ?
With support from both Lib Dems and UKIP for electoral reform it's a cross party issue that has started to rear its head more on account of the diminishing percentage of the vote the major two parties return. It's quite stark. Check it out.
So the 'protestors' with their Socialist Worker placards are out on the street because of the lack of proportional representation in the electoral system?
You obviously didn't read my post stating that it was an anti austerity demo. Selective reading, a bit like another poster.
Just like your doppelganger you ask trite questions that you know the answer to.
|
imbored UK 11 May 15 4.18pm |
|
Quote derben at 11 May 2015 4.11pm
Quote imbored at 11 May 2015 4.05pm
Quote dannyh at 11 May 2015 3.54pm
Questions for lefties among us.
Why wasnt there the same criticism of the electoral system last time Labour won ?
With support from both Lib Dems and UKIP for electoral reform it's a cross party issue that has started to rear its head more on account of the diminishing percentage of the vote the major two parties return. It's quite stark. Check it out.
So the 'protestors' with their Socialist Worker placards are out on the street because of the lack of proportional representation in the electoral system?
I didn't say that at all and I have no affinity for this bunch anyway. Even if it was a peaceful protest, which it wasn't, the timing is self indulgent and it attracted disruptive elements.
Someone brought up PR and I'm highlighting how it's a cross party issue. I know talking about aspects of commonality isn't popular here, but I presented facts and people can make of them what they will.
|