You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 6 of 27 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
palace99 Flag New Mills 11 Nov 18 7.58pm

whilst Max is being played out of position he is now reminding me of Barry Bannan, but with less creativity.

He is too small and not overly fast so the game seems to pass him by.

If we had more possession he might start having an influence on the game but this will rarely happen.

Either play him in the middle or not at all

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Nov 18 8.34pm

Originally posted by BuckinghamshireEagle

Meyer is the one player in our squad who can pick a pass. The problem is that due to our inability to score, we have to defend with all 11 players when we don’t have the ball in our half. So when we regain the ball there is no one ahead of him to pass to. In this situation we need a player like RLC with the physical strength to hold the ball until one or two players can get upfield.

Sorry but Meyer was highlighted on BT last night for continually passing sideways or backwards, when a ball over the top of their defence was needed for Ayew and Townsend to run onto. RLC dint hold the ball up, not his game, its Benteke we are missing up top, regardless of his scoring woes, he holds the ball up and offers a target.
Meyer is being bullied in this league, not strong enough.

 

herefordeagle Flag Hereford 11 Nov 18 10.14pm

He's not strong enough? A bit like Pedro and David Silva!?

 


"It's ok postman , he'll lick you to death" "That isn't really that comforting , I still end up dead !!"

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 11 Nov 18 11.45pm

Originally posted by Painter

Sorry but Meyer was highlighted on BT last night for continually passing sideways or backwards, when a ball over the top of their defence was needed for Ayew and Townsend to run onto. RLC dint hold the ball up, not his game, its Benteke we are missing up top, regardless of his scoring woes, he holds the ball up and offers a target.
Meyer is being bullied in this league, not strong enough.

Almost every time he got the ball he seemed to look up the pitch but had nothing to aim for - considering how much running Ayew does, his movement up front is awful. Oh to have a striker (or even a midfielder) that can run the channels or diagonals.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Mr Fenandes Flag 12 Nov 18 10.14am

Amazing the variety in opinions, including that from Roy:

[Link]

It's incredible he should say this, Meyer played several killer through balls that our dopey front line weren't aware of, I can't remember him playing a duff pass and he was being played well out of position.

It surprises me someone with Roy's experience would come out and make statements like this, and it's worrying that he's making "pub fan" comments and doesn't seem able to see that the players around him had the touch of a trampoline.

This is akin to people saying Townsend is having a s*** season, when you see him putting in 2-3 crosses a game that any half-decent league two striker would be on the end of.


Edited by Mr Fenandes (12 Nov 2018 10.15am)

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

Mr Fenandes Flag 12 Nov 18 10.17am

Originally posted by Painter

Sorry but Meyer was highlighted on BT last night for continually passing sideways or backwards, when a ball over the top of their defence was needed for Ayew and Townsend to run onto. RLC dint hold the ball up, not his game, its Benteke we are missing up top, regardless of his scoring woes, he holds the ball up and offers a target.
Meyer is being bullied in this league, not strong enough.

If you're a good team who can use the break effectively, passing backwards or sideways works well because the dimensions of the game/position of the opposition can be exploited. Also, he never has any options to move forward because our movement is awful. What midfielders do we have who get in to space? I only see PVA and Townsend moving in to space on a regular basis, there are no other outlets to release to.

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

Bangell Flag Oxford 12 Nov 18 11.15am

Originally posted by Mr Fenandes

Amazing the variety in opinions, including that from Roy:

[Link]

It's incredible he should say this, Meyer played several killer through balls that our dopey front line weren't aware of, I can't remember him playing a duff pass and he was being played well out of position.

It surprises me someone with Roy's experience would come out and make statements like this, and it's worrying that he's making "pub fan" comments and doesn't seem able to see that the players around him had the touch of a trampoline.

This is akin to people saying Townsend is having a s*** season, when you see him putting in 2-3 crosses a game that any half-decent league two striker would be on the end of.


Edited by Mr Fenandes (12 Nov 2018 10.15am)

It does seem like Roy isn't a fan of Meyer at all. More evidence for the theory that this was a signing thrust upon him.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 12 Nov 18 12.03pm

Originally posted by Mr Fenandes

Amazing the variety in opinions, including that from Roy:

[Link]

It's incredible he should say this, Meyer played several killer through balls that our dopey front line weren't aware of, I can't remember him playing a duff pass and he was being played well out of position.

It surprises me someone with Roy's experience would come out and make statements like this, and it's worrying that he's making "pub fan" comments and doesn't seem able to see that the players around him had the touch of a trampoline.

This is akin to people saying Townsend is having a s*** season, when you see him putting in 2-3 crosses a game that any half-decent league two striker would be on the end of.


Edited by Mr Fenandes (12 Nov 2018 10.15am)

I find it even more concerning that Roy has used the word 'instrumental' in the same sentence as the name Jeff Schlupp...

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Nov 18 1.27pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I find it even more concerning that Roy has used the word 'instrumental' in the same sentence as the name Jeff Schlupp...

Reckon that means schlupp will bd taking meyes place next game then..

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 12 Nov 18 1.27pm

Originally posted by herefordeagle

He's not strong enough? A bit like Pedro and David Silva!?

This is exactly the problem.

Meyer may be too good for us, in a way:

If he was playing at Man City for example he wouldn’t have a lot of defensive duties, and every pass that would come into him would be perfectly weighted and into space. He would the have runners in and around and high quality players in all directions to build an attack with.

He would probably look sh*t hot in that setup, and the German Messi stuff would pop up again. He is the type of player that can look amazing in possession based football with world class players around him.

Trouble is, well, you can guess the rest.

Signing him as a defensive mid in the Cabaye mold was a mistake, as he has nowhere near enough in the tackle. Signing him as an RLC type operating wide was also a mistake as he doesn’t play wide.

He needs to play centrally in front of 2 holding midfielders for us to see anything like his best output. However RH is a 442 man.

Begs the question why did we sign him but we know the answer, because he was free.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Aray Flag South London 12 Nov 18 1.34pm

Originally posted by Mr Fenandes

Amazing the variety in opinions, including that from Roy:

[Link]

It's incredible he should say this, Meyer played several killer through balls that our dopey front line weren't aware of, I can't remember him playing a duff pass and he was being played well out of position.

It surprises me someone with Roy's experience would come out and make statements like this, and it's worrying that he's making "pub fan" comments and doesn't seem able to see that the players around him had the touch of a trampoline.

This is akin to people saying Townsend is having a s*** season, when you see him putting in 2-3 crosses a game that any half-decent league two striker would be on the end of.

Edited by Mr Fenandes (12 Nov 2018 10.15am)

He thrown Meyer under the bus hasn't he? Wow. Play the poor sod out of position without an outlet - Ayew isn't a target man - and say he's not played well?

The reason why the crowd booed was because we could see Meyer was playing quite well. Schlupp did have a good 20 mins whether that was because of purely his own play or the different dynamic after Sorloth it is hard to say.

I've not been impressed with Roy this season, the reluctance to make subs, playing two cloggers in midfield (though actually I thought they played ok on Saturday).

I would be surprise if Meyer started to wonder whether he should get a transfer to a team willing to play him in the middle - either deep or further forward.

Edited by Aray (12 Nov 2018 1.34pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 12 Nov 18 1.40pm

Originally posted by palace99

whilst Max is being played out of position he is now reminding me of Barry Bannan, but with less creativity.

He is too small and not overly fast so the game seems to pass him by.

If we had more possession he might start having an influence on the game but this will rarely happen.

Either play him in the middle or not at all

I agree with this

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 25 Nov 18 3.57am

Thought Meyer was super against Man U - by far his best game. Think the bigger pitch gave him a bit more room and he linked up great with Zaha and Townsend. Given he is only young i think we have ourselves a proper premiership player.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 25 Nov 18 5.59am

Originally posted by viveasheagle

Thought Meyer was super against Man U - by far his best game. Think the bigger pitch gave him a bit more room and he linked up great with Zaha and Townsend. Given he is only young i think we have ourselves a proper premiership player.

I think he'll get better and better,people forget he has to adapt to a new country as well as a new football club,it won't happen overnight.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 25 Nov 18 6.34am

Originally posted by black eagle.

I think he'll get better and better,people forget he has to adapt to a new country as well as a new football club,it won't happen overnight.

totally agree to many fans want instant results we are building just need to find a 15 goal a season striker that he can feed, does link well with Wilf

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 25 Nov 18 8.22am

he is starting to develop into the player we thought we had signed, it qas always. going to take a few months for. young foreign lad to adapt to the PL.

we genuinally could have a future star on our hands.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Jefroc Flag Crete 25 Nov 18 9.12am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

he is starting to develop into the player we thought we had signed, it qas always. going to take a few months for. young foreign lad to adapt to the PL.

we genuinally could have a future star on our hands.

Absolutely! He played really well in a more advanced position yesterday. Not everything worked but most did. He is beginning to settle in to the team and I can see him and Wilf developing a good rapport; but these things take time. If you don’t make mistakes you don’t get better!

How many Eagles fans would switch him for Pogba?

 


Always remembering walking from the Holmesdale to the Whitehorse end at half time!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Nov 18 9.27am

I missed the game. What was his position and role in what formation?

 


COYP

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 25 Nov 18 9.58am

He’s quality end of...

 

ozziex99 Flag London 25 Nov 18 10.13am

I thought he was incredible yesterday. He played on the left when defending and more centrally when we had the ball.

I've been saying since the Bournemouth match (where I thought he controlled the game in the middle) that he should be playing more centrally, but for some reason he has been stuck on the left where he doesn't look comfortable at all.

But credit to Roy, I thought it was genius yesterday how he ensured that Meyer defended on the left but was given a license to move more central when we had the ball - and I feel it made all the difference yesterday. It also allowed PVA to push up more than he usually would.

Brilliant game yesterday, it has given me a positive feeling going forward. We wouldn't have been at all surprised yesterday if United blew us off the park with the quality they had on show - but it was us, and us only who made them look ordinary.

 


[Link] - please support our matched betting site run by two Palace fanatics!

Page 6 of 27 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread