You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I Love Croydon-Roy
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

I Love Croydon-Roy


Page 6 of 12 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Plaistow Eagle Flag 16 Jan 21 7.28pm

Originally posted by Ketteridge

To some extent I agree with if we are only ever treading water then at some point we will go down, but it is how we balance ambition and make sure it is sustainable. Goldberg had ambition but it wasn’t sustainable and it wasn't very realistic either. At the moment we are treading water hoping that the development of the ground and the academy will be the lifeboat to take us to the next level. If in 4/5 years time we have upped the capacity and adding by10k to the crowd and £25-30m to our turnover that takes us to the level of West Ham and Newcastle . If the latest batch of Ruben Loftus-Cheeks, Jadon Sanchos and Calum Hudson Odois are lining up to represent their local club then I would be a lot more comfortable with taking risks and potentially going down because there is a lot more chance we are coming straight back up at this moment if we go down we could be left with just happy memories.
If Roy can help us tread water to that point when we are at the next level fine by me

After Man city we have 7 games that are all individually winnable and getting 10 pts and virtually being safe wouldn’t be unforeseeable. Then it might be nice to see Jairo getting more games and Banks and others get a chance


Edited by Ketteridge (16 Jan 2021 6.12pm)

Mate

That is all very utopian and all that - in that let's tread water, build the infrastructure, academy etc..

If we do that and go down we can bounce back up in a much stronger position..!! As unpalatable as it is as an option - I get it..!!

Problem is that the Gulf in terms of finances is so great between the Prem and Championship - is that you run the risk of doing an Ipswich or a Sunderland.

So for me you have to deal in the here and now, whilst progressing at the same time.

That's the reality..!!

COYP

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Jan 21 7.30pm

Originally posted by doombear


When Eze arrived he said he was happy with the role he was being asked to play which was to be on the left with freedom to move inside.

Hodgson presumably doesn't see the squad as suitable for a 4-2-3-1 formation (which would allow Eze to play in a no 10 role). I suspect that he sees our DMs as being either too slow or not equipped to play in that system.

More a fact I feel.

Our players would have to be able to pass a lot better including movement to be able to get away with that formation.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Jan 21 7.45pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

More a fact I feel.

Our players would have to be able to pass a lot better including movement to be able to get away with that formation.

Would you care to elaborate on that stroke of tactical genius you have just come up with? “Pass a lot better including movement” WTF

You do realise that 4-2-3-1 is no different in practice from 4-5-1 which is what we played with 3 DMs last season. It would still have the same players with Wilf left, Andros right, the only difference would be Eze playing in that central position of 5 supporting the lone striker and 2 DMs instead of 3.

It would work just fine, but I think we have produced better football with a 4-4-2 even if Wilf does appear more on the left than he should during the course of the match.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Jan 21 8.06pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Mate

That is all very utopian and all that - in that let's tread water, build the infrastructure, academy etc..

If we do that and go down we can bounce back up in a much stronger position..!! As unpalatable as it is as an option - I get it..!!

Problem is that the Gulf in terms of finances is so great between the Prem and Championship - is that you run the risk of doing an Ipswich or a Sunderland.

So for me you have to deal in the here and now, whilst progressing at the same time.

That's the reality..!!

COYP

I don't feel Ketteridge was aiming for perfection just the next level especially one where we have an improved stadium and one where our academy will attract suitable youngsters to seriously help with our next level, we are not as it stands in any situation to be looking at the next level I feel because these issues desperately need addressing first.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 16 Jan 21 8.19pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Mate

That is all very utopian and all that - in that let's tread water, build the infrastructure, academy etc..

If we do that and go down we can bounce back up in a much stronger position..!! As unpalatable as it is as an option - I get it..!!

Problem is that the Gulf in terms of finances is so great between the Prem and Championship - is that you run the risk of doing an Ipswich or a Sunderland.

So for me you have to deal in the here and now, whilst progressing at the same time.

That's the reality..!!

COYP

Might be unpalatable but relegation is a certainty in the long run for team like us as it is for all teams bar the top six and Everton. The difference is if Newcastle or West Ham go down you are pretty certain they are coming straight back within a season or two for Leeds ,Palace Sheff united , Burnley Brighton etc you are not so sure. That’s the level we need to get to.
So for me it is the complete opposite, be cautious now to build for the future. Hodgson is a tried and tested manager with years of experience proven at this level and I really can’t see who else we could get that would give us that level of dependability to be honest. Dyche maybe but not greatly different from Hodgson Howe may be but more of risk . Could bring in someone with out the premier experience but risk the transportability of their methods and ability you might end up with David Wagner rather the Hasenhuttl.
Ambition doesn’t come risk free so sorry, you would need to define what you mean by ambition because I’m not sure what you are after.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 20 Jan 21 1.18pm

in my opinion, those who criticize Croydon-Roy are either deluded or Brighton Trolls.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Jan 21 1.28pm

Originally posted by Ketteridge

Might be unpalatable but relegation is a certainty in the long run for team like us as it is for all teams bar the top six and Everton. The difference is if Newcastle or West Ham go down you are pretty certain they are coming straight back within a season or two for Leeds ,Palace Sheff united , Burnley Brighton etc you are not so sure. That’s the level we need to get to.
So for me it is the complete opposite, be cautious now to build for the future. Hodgson is a tried and tested manager with years of experience proven at this level and I really can’t see who else we could get that would give us that level of dependability to be honest. Dyche maybe but not greatly different from Hodgson Howe may be but more of risk . Could bring in someone with out the premier experience but risk the transportability of their methods and ability you might end up with David Wagner rather the Hasenhuttl.
Ambition doesn’t come risk free so sorry, you would need to define what you mean by ambition because I’m not sure what you are after.

The last time that Burnley were relegated from the PL, Dyche brought them straight back up and this is their 5th season back at the pinnacle.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 20 Jan 21 1.53pm

People talk about realities, but what are the realities for Palace?
Only ,”Big clubs,” can go forward and stay there.
Big in every sense,. Ground, high capacity, enormous finances, to call on, playing staff of high international quality. The best of Training facilities. It all has to be there in place. If you want the big time and keep it.
So is it realistic to expect , Palace, minus much of that , because in the main we can’t afford it, to progress beyond , being good at staying top or near the top of a group of teams in the lower Premier and upper Championship. Many of which yo yo . ? That for me is the reality.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Jan 21 2.04pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Yep point well made and I don't disagree with you in that our central DM's being too slow and now not up to the grade.

On that that's where I see a young DM is where we must make at least one acquisition this window - does anyone know where Flynn Downes is in terms of recovering from injury - think he is a real talent and would be great for us - and available at a "snip" if all you read is correct..!!

COYP

Flynn Downes has featured in Ipswich's last 2 games.
He came on as a sub against Swindon and started in the 1-0 win at Burton A at the weekend.

Ipswich have signed Josh Harrop on loan from Preston and in order to adhere to the £2.5 Mill salary cap a player has to leave the club.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jan 21 3.38pm

Originally posted by Willo

Flynn Downes has featured in Ipswich's last 2 games.
He came on as a sub against Swindon and started in the 1-0 win at Burton A at the weekend.

Ipswich have signed Josh Harrop on loan from Preston and in order to adhere to the £2.5 Mill salary cap a player has to leave the club.


Interesting. Will we bite I wonder and pay what Ipswich were asking for?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 Jan 21 3.43pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

in my opinion, those who criticize Croydon-Roy are either deluded or Brighton Trolls.


You are clearly busting for a verbal punch-up. Now I'm neither 'Roy out' nor 'Roy in' but I well understand the 'Roy out' arguments (at least from those who put up proper arguments as opposed to silly swipes at Hodgson). AS for the verbal punch-up, I'll leave that to others.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Jan 21 4.39pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

in my opinion, those who criticize Croydon-Roy are either deluded or Brighton Trolls.

Surely you're the troll as you are just insulting everybody that doesn't agree with you

 

jeeagles Flag 20 Jan 21 5.50pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

in my opinion, those who criticize Croydon-Roy are either deluded or Brighton Trolls.

You're entitled to your opinion.

It just always seems to be wrong.

 

jeeagles Flag 20 Jan 21 5.53pm

Originally posted by Willo

Flynn Downes has featured in Ipswich's last 2 games.
He came on as a sub against Swindon and started in the 1-0 win at Burton A at the weekend.

Ipswich have signed Josh Harrop on loan from Preston and in order to adhere to the £2.5 Mill salary cap a player has to leave the club.

Given he's the same height as Meyer, but about a stone lighter, and hasn't played for a top European league, or in Europe, or internationally, I can't currently see why we would release Meyer early, only to sign Downey.

Not seen him play thought. He might be amazing, but it just doesn't seem logical on the face of it.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 20 Jan 21 7.35pm

Ok so I may have been a bit flippant in talking of the sun light future of 35,000 capacity and Jadon Sancho coming through the academy, but the point is still the same, finance has huge impact on the likely finishing position in the league. I had a look at final league position in every year since we were promoted and the size of the club, I appreciate I probably need to get out more. The top six is obvious, the next level I categorised as tradition premier league clubs, Everton, Newcastle, Aston Villa, West Ham and Southampton. Yes, some have been in the championship and lower, but most have spent longer in the premier then they have out of it. Every other club is down as the rest, regardless of rich owner etc. Leicester are odd as they are the one club that have genuinely made the leap from the rest of us to the next level, up to winning the league I have them as the rest from that next season they are traditional premier.
I’ve attached a graph to show these categories and leagus position , the dark grey is big six, mid grey historical premier and light grey the rest of us. It is a simple and stark as this, if you are small club you have about a 1 in 5 chance of finishing in the top ten, Stoke managed it three times Wolves twice, Bournemouth once all have/had rich owners. Burnley have managed it twice, Sheff U, Swansea, West Brom and us have all managed it once. If Villa, Newcastle and West Ham used their cash effectively it would be even worse.
That is the reality, we have been in the premier longer then any other small club we don’t have rich owners.We have built a basis of team from players that are over looked they are not going to excite supporters let’s leave that to Newcastle. We spends out money on undervalued or over looked players yep Tomkins, Kouyate , Ayew, McCarthy , MacArthur, Clyne etc. Nothing exciting nothing I am going to be able to gloat about the day after transfer deadline dead and boost to the Brighton supporter in the office but 6 months later when their latest hot shot Eredivise signing is looking rubbish then I fell smug.
Yep we need to bring down the age of the squad but as with have signed Eze, Ferguson and Meteta that looks like it has been identified.

Finance and league position.png Attachment: Finance and league position.png (16.65Kb)

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 20 Jan 21 9.03pm

it's not pie in the sky, if we have a mainly modern stadium with 35k capacity we can aim to be in the Leicester, Wolves, Southampton, Newcastle, West Ham bracket whereas right now this aim is unrealistic, this could take ten years though (and may involve a relegation and promotion along the way).

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 20 Jan 21 9.14pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

it's not pie in the sky, if we have a mainly modern stadium with 35k capacity we can aim to be in the Leicester, Wolves, Southampton, Newcastle, West Ham bracket whereas right now this aim is unrealistic, this could take ten years though (and may involve a relegation and promotion along the way).

Do you think we might have a new manager by then though

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jan 21 7.12am

Originally posted by Ketteridge

Ok so I may have been a bit flippant in talking of the sun light future of 35,000 capacity and Jadon Sancho coming through the academy, but the point is still the same, finance has huge impact on the likely finishing position in the league. I had a look at final league position in every year since we were promoted and the size of the club, I appreciate I probably need to get out more. The top six is obvious, the next level I categorised as tradition premier league clubs, Everton, Newcastle, Aston Villa, West Ham and Southampton. Yes, some have been in the championship and lower, but most have spent longer in the premier then they have out of it. Every other club is down as the rest, regardless of rich owner etc. Leicester are odd as they are the one club that have genuinely made the leap from the rest of us to the next level, up to winning the league I have them as the rest from that next season they are traditional premier.
I’ve attached a graph to show these categories and leagus position , the dark grey is big six, mid grey historical premier and light grey the rest of us. It is a simple and stark as this, if you are small club you have about a 1 in 5 chance of finishing in the top ten, Stoke managed it three times Wolves twice, Bournemouth once all have/had rich owners. Burnley have managed it twice, Sheff U, Swansea, West Brom and us have all managed it once. If Villa, Newcastle and West Ham used their cash effectively it would be even worse.
That is the reality, we have been in the premier longer then any other small club we don’t have rich owners.We have built a basis of team from players that are over looked they are not going to excite supporters let’s leave that to Newcastle. We spends out money on undervalued or over looked players yep Tomkins, Kouyate , Ayew, McCarthy , MacArthur, Clyne etc. Nothing exciting nothing I am going to be able to gloat about the day after transfer deadline dead and boost to the Brighton supporter in the office but 6 months later when their latest hot shot Eredivise signing is looking rubbish then I fell smug.
Yep we need to bring down the age of the squad but as with have signed Eze, Ferguson and Meteta that looks like it has been identified.

The bit you have missed is that we do have super rich owners, they just don’t spend any of it on our club.

 

jeeagles Flag 21 Jan 21 9.10am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

The bit you have missed is that we do have super rich owners, they just don’t spend any of it on our club.

Firstly, it's their money to decide what they invested in. They've already made the stupid decision to invest in a football club, they aren't going to throw good money after bad.

Secondly. FFP.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 21 Jan 21 9.36am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Firstly, it's their money to decide what they invested in. They've already made the stupid decision to invest in a football club, they aren't going to throw good money after bad.

Secondly. FFP.

It sounds like you approve of their investment strategy. I know I don’t. As far as I’m concerned they can cough up or clear off.

As for FFP we seem to be the only club hampered by it. All the other teams just pay the fines for breaching it.

 

Page 6 of 12 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > I Love Croydon-Roy