This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by DanH
So you think what Owen Paterson did was wrong then? Well it's fairly obvious that if he has indeed broken Parliamentary rules, then he is guilty of that misdemeanour. I know this is all you socialists have, but you really need to move on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
The only way that they can convince themselves that they are right in their own heads is to believe the entire system is against them - the law, the courts, the media. It takes a special type of leap of faith to get to the point that they’ve got to, and they think they’ve been ‘red pilled’ once they have and had some sort of epiphany once they do, but it’s just a cultish belief that the world is against them because they don’t know how to fit in to modern society. It takes a certain level of conditioning to be blind to what is going on in modern Britain.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I have been before the courts may times over many years and have experienced bias on only one occasion. It was a case about a damaged car where the claimant had full expert evidence to support the case but the judge dismissed the case as the claimant had spent time in choky 4 years earlier for dealing dope! That judge was subsequently criticized openly by the Lord Chief Justice on another matter and later quietly retired. Bad apple. It used to be the case that the bench was pro insurer and pro finance. Not any more. Decades ago, if you had a title or were a celebrity you were more or less bullet proof. Not any more. The Stephen Ward summing up would not happen today. I am told that in matters of personal injury and medical negligence, there are judges who are seen as pro claimant and others as pro defendant. Similarly judicial review. However, I suspect those judges would be appalled by that label and the bias is probably unconscious and informed by their personal experience in practice. True, most judges are from very narrow socio-economic origins but I believe they genuinely try to get out of their narrow, clubbed culture and understand the lives of us plebs. Otherwise, the myth of judicial bias is just that. Something concocted by drama to make good telly. However, if you have clear evidence of judicial partiality, perhaps you could spell it out and we can chat again.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Another difference in approach. I don't want to derail this thread but you are absolutely right, 8 weeks is ridiculous for a racist rant on Facebook, he should have been given community service. I'm not going to feel sorry for the t*** but it does seem disproportionate to the crime.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses. |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I have been before the courts may times over many years and have experienced bias on only one occasion. It was a case about a damaged car where the claimant had full expert evidence to support the case but the judge dismissed the case as the claimant had spent time in choky 4 years earlier for dealing dope! That judge was subsequently criticized openly by the Lord Chief Justice on another matter and later quietly retired. Bad apple. It used to be the case that the bench was pro insurer and pro finance. Not any more. Decades ago, if you had a title or were a celebrity you were more or less bullet proof. Not any more. The Stephen Ward summing up would not happen today. I am told that in matters of personal injury and medical negligence, there are judges who are seen as pro claimant and others as pro defendant. Similarly judicial review. However, I suspect those judges would be appalled by that label and the bias is probably unconscious and informed by their personal experience in practice. True, most judges are from very narrow socio-economic origins but I believe they genuinely try to get out of their narrow, clubbed culture and understand the lives of us plebs. Otherwise, the myth of judicial bias is just that. Something concocted by drama to make good telly. However, if you have clear evidence of judicial partiality, perhaps you could spell it out and we can chat again. Tommy Robinson and others....for example that guy sent to jail because of his views and legal books he bought on Amazon, but I really don't have a desire to write numerous posts on this topic again.....it's just going around in circles. Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Nov 2021 10.41am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It takes a certain level of conditioning to be blind to what is going on in modern Britain. While I think your anti Labour posts on here are odd, there is some truth in this post. Then again, we would not be the first aging generation who begin to feel a bit lost and out of time. That said, the kids are very different from us. When my daughter is with her school mates it resembles a UN meeting. When she talks about her mates, I hear their names mentioned at home and try to prize out their ethnicity, just out of curiosity. Her look is not one of judgment but incomprehension. It isn't that she doesn't care or is right-on. She simply doesn't know. They are just other kids. And this is not home indoctrination. No woke learning in this household! It just... is. They are growing into this culture as we grew into ours. Not many generations before yours we were getting rich on slavery, hanging 12 year old boys for pick-pocketing and visiting underage prostitutes using a legal, openly published guide book. While not universally accepted, they were features of the prevailing social mores. I know it's hard and my wife looks at me like I am a dinosaur every time some woke crud is mentioned on the media and I explode. But times change.
|
|
|
Originally posted by topcat
I don't want to derail this thread but you are absolutely right, 8 weeks is ridiculous for a racist rant on Facebook, he should have been given community service. I'm not going to feel sorry for the t*** but it does seem disproportionate to the crime. I agree. I'm not a fan of judicial punishment for saying the wrong words, it's nuts. At the same time, it is hard to have sympathy for someone who appears to be completely obnoxious. I won't lose any sleep for this guy, but a jail sentence is disproportionate relative to other crimes. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Nov 2021 11.09am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Tommy Robinson and others....for example that guy sent to jail because of his views and legal books he bought on Amazon, but I really don't have a desire to write numerous posts on this topic again.....it's just going around in circles. Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Nov 2021 10.41am) Oh I have not visited that thread. From what I understand, the act TR committed was clear and obvious criminal contempt. As discussed in this thread on the Paterson affair, the law is known; yet he did it anyway. Flagrantly. No ignorance; no argument. The sentence, I suspect, was to set example to discourage others. The judiciary do not like others interfering with their process especially when the perpetrator amplifies his act to give it higher public profile. That is the area where there is ample room for debate, in my view, and I can see there have been a large number of folk posting on that thread what are likely to be very firmly held views. However, judicial partiality? In whose favour, or against which groups? It was the act PLUS the cock-a-snook attitude to judicial process that caused the tariff, not his politics. If you have a person who punches someone in the face compared to another who punches an MP in the face and then posts it on social media to make a political point, you can guarantee the latter will earn a much heavier sentence.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I agree. I'm not a fan of judicial punishment for saying the wrong words, it's nuts. At the same time, it is hard to have sympathy for someone who appears to be completely obnoxious. I won't lose any sleep for this guy, but a jail sentence is disproportionate relative to other crimes. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Nov 2021 11.09am) Was this his 1st offence? What is his criminal history? Is he currently on remand/parol/suspended for another offence? Did he show remorse? How bad was the post? BTW, lock-up for a 1st offence for a person of good character would be outrageous regardless of the post. More example setting.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
While I think your anti Labour posts on here are odd, there is some truth in this post. Then again, we would not be the first aging generation who begin to feel a bit lost and out of time. That said, the kids are very different from us. When my daughter is with her school mates it resembles a UN meeting. When she talks about her mates, I hear their names mentioned at home and try to prize out their ethnicity, just out of curiosity. Her look is not one of judgment but incomprehension. It isn't that she doesn't care or is right-on. She simply doesn't know. They are just other kids. And this is not home indoctrination. No woke learning in this household! It just... is. They are growing into this culture as we grew into ours. Not many generations before yours we were getting rich on slavery, hanging 12 year old boys for pick-pocketing and visiting underage prostitutes using a legal, openly published guide book. While not universally accepted, they were features of the prevailing social mores. I know it's hard and my wife looks at me like I am a dinosaur every time some woke crud is mentioned on the media and I explode. But times change. You don't seem to realize that 'growing into the culture' and being unknowingly conditioned amounts to the same thing. There was a time when the move towards tolerance, equality and justice was a fine and worthy cause, but it is being perverted into something sinister and one that will serve no one except the elite.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Oh I have not visited that thread. From what I understand, the act TR committed was clear and obvious criminal contempt. As discussed in this thread on the Paterson affair, the law is known; yet he did it anyway. Flagrantly. No ignorance; no argument. The sentence, I suspect, was to set example to discourage others. The judiciary do not like others interfering with their process especially when the perpetrator amplifies his act to give it higher public profile. That is the area where there is ample room for debate, in my view, and I can see there have been a large number of folk posting on that thread what are likely to be very firmly held views. However, judicial partiality? In whose favour, or against which groups? It was the act PLUS the cock-a-snook attitude to judicial process that caused the tariff, not his politics. If you have a person who punches someone in the face compared to another who punches an MP in the face and then posts it on social media to make a political point, you can guarantee the latter will earn a much heavier sentence. Honestly you could just read the thread. I have respect that you are a genuine voice on the left and that it would be a fair minded discussion but I'm just tired of going over it again in any real depth. Maybe I'm just getting old.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Was this his 1st offence? What is his criminal history? Is he currently on remand/parol/suspended for another offence? Did he show remorse? How bad was the post? BTW, lock-up for a 1st offence for a person of good character would be outrageous regardless of the post. More example setting. For me, the bottom line is whether it is in the public interest to jail people for saying nasty words.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
This thread is about the Tories, how they operate at senior levels as individuals and how they close ranks if your face fits It isn't yet another opportunity to rant about immigrants. Please use other threads, of which you have very many, to discuss your views on such points. Your hatred of 'other' is well known, you add nothing by constant repetition. When discussing the misdeeds of MPs, it is entirely appropriate in the adversarial world of party politics to compare various examples. You need to read threads properly. I know you want to bash the Tories but some of us have another view. Hatred? What a ridiculous statement. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Nov 2021 12.34pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
When discussing the misdeeds of MPs, it is entirely appropriate in the adversarial world of party politics to compare various examples. You need to read threads properly. I know you want to bash the Tories but some of us have another view. Hatred? What a ridiculous statement. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Nov 2021 12.34pm) Ah, you didn't comment on race. My mistake, I thought the insanity of which you spoke was losing the right to be 'critical' of people from another race. No matter. Please comment on the Tory sleaze issue, the other examples you seem to believe comparable clearly are not and are simple diversions.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It takes a certain level of conditioning to be blind to what is going on in modern Britain. And you have to convince yourself that others that do manage to fit in fine and get along in the modern world are ‘conditioned’ because they couldn’t possibly be independent, free thinking and thriving in the real world.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Ah, you didn't comment on race. My mistake, I thought the insanity of which you spoke was losing the right to be 'critical' of people from another race. No matter. Please comment on the Tory sleaze issue, the other examples you seem to believe comparable clearly are not and are simple diversions. What are you talking about? 'Tory sleaze' is just a stupid Leftist slogan and when it is a subject on here, I will challenge it to demonstrate that sleaze is universal in politics and always has been. You might not like that because you like to be blinkered, as with may other subjects.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
And you have to convince yourself that others that do manage to fit in fine and get along in the modern world are ‘conditioned’ because they couldn’t possibly be independent, free thinking and thriving in the real world. Fit in? Interesting phrase. Sort of Orwellian in its passive aggressive suggestion.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.