You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Margaret Thatcher
November 19 2026 6.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Margaret Thatcher


Page 62 of 76 < 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 >
JohnyBoy Flag 16 Apr 13 8.51am

Quote Moose at 15 Apr 2013 3.37pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Apr 2013 11.30am

Quote Plane at 15 Apr 2013 9.50am

Quote Ouzo Dan at 15 Apr 2013 8.51am

f*** the belgrano, it was an enemy vessel, when at war you kill the enemy.

I would have been disgusted if Thatcher hadn't given the order to sink it.


...Is the correct answer.

Is the wrong answer - IT WAS NOT A WAR - The UK specifcally declined a declaration of war that was its right, under UN agreement on soverign nations which we signed and help draft.

It was thus designated a conflict with an exclusion zone. It would be a crime to attack any vessel outside of the exlcusion zone.

Tactically, of course it was the right military decision to sink the Belgrano, but that doesn't mean there isn't a case to answer. Much like its tactically astute to utilise black operations against your enemy's - doesn't prevent it being murder.

I agree with her decision, but it was technically a 'war crime' and she should have been investigated for it, and potentially faced trial if there was a case to be answered.



Call me silly, but I can't understand why, when the Argentinians involved in the conflict are happy to admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, so many British are still making a massive deal about it. Sorry for all the Wiki copy / pasting:

Captain Bonzo, Captain of the Belgrano, wrote his memories about the sinking in the book "1093 Tripulantes del Crucero ARA General Belgrano", published in 1992. In this book he wrote that it is "improper to accept that the attack by HMS Conqueror was a treason". During an interview in 2003 he had stated that the General Belgrano was only temporarily sailing to the west at the time of the attack, and his orders were to attack any British ships which came within range of cruiser's armament.

In August 1994, an official Argentine Defence Ministry report written by armed forces auditor Eugenio Miari was released which described the sinking of the Belgrano as "a legal act of war", explaining that "acts of war can be carried out in all of the enemy's territory" and "they can also take place in those areas over which no state can claim sovereignty, in international waters."

La Nación published a reader's letter from Admiral Enrique Molina Pico (head of the Argentine Navy in the 1990s) in 2005 in which Pico wrote that the Belgrano was part of an operation that posed a real threat to the British task force, but was holding off for tactical reasons. Pico added that "To leave the exclusion zone was not to leave the combat zone to enter a protected area".

Methinks if it hadn't been Thatcher who had given the order, the brouhaha might never have been so great...


I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention

 

gambler Flag Kent 16 Apr 13 8.56am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 Apr 2013 12.02am

So Nick, are you "profiteering" out of this then???

I'm sorry Nick, but how can anyone take you seriously if you don't practice what you preach. Your views are utterly irrelevant.

Plus you cannot back up in your own words the countless links to left wing propaganda when challenged. It's all becoming a bit of a joke now.

Absolute rubbish.
So cos he didnt agree with thatchers/tory policy, he shouldn't buy his own home, or at the very least an ex council house?
What nonsense.
His views are "irrelevant"?! Why cos they're not the same as yours?!
You can disagree with policies but you still have to live your life after they are implemented.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Apr 13 9.11am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa.


Well, maybe your father saw himself as 'fighting' for the UN but he's more the exception than the rule.

My family is closely connected to the military since WW2, specifically the 17/21 Lancers before they became apart of the Royal Armoured core. It's been the norm for males down two of our family lines to join up... usually since the seventies choosing that regiment, which one of my uncles was in during WW2. My eyesight was the only thing that kept me out of it.

My older brother has been on several peace keeping missions and I can ensure you.....It's the same as it ever was. He and his unit regard themselves as very much British soldiers not UN soldiers as such...It's a role they are performing. What they are doing is fulfilling a commitment made by their government....Their paymasters.

The structure is the same, your commanders at unit level are the same....The UN are a political/human rights institution....I know those lefties who hate nationalism or flag waving don't like it but the reality is that no one 'fights' for the UN.....Your frigging 'peacekeeping soldiers' are paid by their own Governments...Well, the western ones are.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Apr 2013 9.21am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

DanH Flag SW2 16 Apr 13 9.17am

Quote gambler at 16 Apr 2013 8.56am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 Apr 2013 12.02am

So Nick, are you "profiteering" out of this then???

I'm sorry Nick, but how can anyone take you seriously if you don't practice what you preach. Your views are utterly irrelevant.

Plus you cannot back up in your own words the countless links to left wing propaganda when challenged. It's all becoming a bit of a joke now.

Absolute rubbish.
So cos he didnt agree with thatchers/tory policy, he shouldn't buy his own home, or at the very least an ex council house?
What nonsense.
His views are "irrelevant"?! Why cos they're not the same as yours?!
You can disagree with policies but you still have to live your life after they are implemented.


Penge has a weird thing about "practicing what you preach" in that he believes if you are remotely left wing you should give anything above the median wage you earn away, not profit from anything in the slightest and live life like a communist.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 16 Apr 13 10.06am

Quote DanH at 16 Apr 2013 9.17am

Quote gambler at 16 Apr 2013 8.56am

Quote Penge Eagle at 16 Apr 2013 12.02am

So Nick, are you "profiteering" out of this then???

I'm sorry Nick, but how can anyone take you seriously if you don't practice what you preach. Your views are utterly irrelevant.

Plus you cannot back up in your own words the countless links to left wing propaganda when challenged. It's all becoming a bit of a joke now.

Absolute rubbish.
So cos he didnt agree with thatchers/tory policy, he shouldn't buy his own home, or at the very least an ex council house?
What nonsense.
His views are "irrelevant"?! Why cos they're not the same as yours?!
You can disagree with policies but you still have to live your life after they are implemented.


Penge has a weird thing about "practicing what you preach" in that he believes if you are remotely left wing you should give anything above the median wage you earn away, not profit from anything in the slightest and live life like a communist.


He's turned into a comedy frothing Tory from the 80's somehow in the last few years on here. A Spitting Image like puppet. Very entertaining tho'.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Moose Flag In the sewer pipe... 16 Apr 13 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!

 


Goodness is what you do. Not who you pray to.

JohnyBoy Flag 16 Apr 13 10.29am

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 Apr 2013 9.11am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa.


Well, maybe your father saw himself as 'fighting' for the UN but he's more the exception than the rule.

My family is closely connected to the military since WW2, specifically the 17/21 Lancers before they became apart of the Royal Armoured core. It's been the norm for males down two of our family lines to join up... usually since the seventies choosing that regiment, which one of my uncles was in during WW2. My eyesight was the only thing that kept me out of it.

My older brother has been on several peace keeping missions and I can ensure you.....It's the same as it ever was. He and his unit regard themselves as very much British soldiers not UN soldiers as such...It's a role they are performing. What they are doing is fulfilling a commitment made by their government....Their paymasters.

The structure is the same, your commanders at unit level are the same....The UN are a political/human rights institution....I know those lefties who hate nationalism or flag waving don't like it but the reality is that no one 'fights' for the UN.....Your frigging 'peacekeeping soldiers' are paid by their own Governments...Well, the western ones are.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Apr 2013 9.21am)

I think you will find that all soldiers seconded to the UN represent the UN and not their national governments. They continue to be paid their standard wages + an incentive for overseas duty by their own armies and are most often kept in their companies from which they came from. But the rest of the costs, logistics ETC are paid for by the UN (about 80% funded by the US). However, they are often put on joint patrols, re-organised into joint units mainly for support operations and are explicitly under the control of a UN appointed commander and representative to whom all serving soldiers report to. nb 2400 UN soldiers have been killed in action since WW2......AND I QUOTE
While the term "peacekeeping" is not found in the United Nations Charter, Dag Hammarskjöld, the second UN Secretary-General, found a way to define it within the framework of the Charter, saying that peacekeeping falls under “Chapter VI and a half” of the Charter, somewhere between traditional methods of resolving disputes peacefully (outlined in Chapter VI), on the one hand, and more forceful, less “consent-based” action (Chapter VII), on the other.

Over the years, UN peacekeeping has evolved to meet the demands of different conflicts and a changing global political landscape.

 

JohnyBoy Flag 16 Apr 13 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.
However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 16 Apr 13 10.55am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.


No it isn't - hard to put it more simply than that.

There was considerable debate in the immediate aftermath but, after the facts became known and the dust had settled, it was clear that there is no substantive case to answer.

If you are not a leftie, or an apologiest then my guess is you are a lawyer, since they would be the only people to benefit from an inquiry!


 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Apr 13 10.56am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.29am

I think you will find that all soldiers seconded to the UN represent the UN and not their national governments. They continue to be paid their standard wages + an incentive for overseas duty by their own armies and are most often kept in their companies from which they came from. But the rest of the costs, logistics ETC are paid for by the UN (about 80% funded by the US). However, they are often put on joint patrols, re-organised into joint units mainly for support operations and are explicitly under the control of a UN appointed commander and representative to whom all serving soldiers report to. nb 2400 UN soldiers have been killed in action since WW2......AND I QUOTE
While the term "peacekeeping" is not found in the United Nations Charter, Dag Hammarskjöld, the second UN Secretary-General, found a way to define it within the framework of the Charter, saying that peacekeeping falls under “Chapter VI and a half” of the Charter, somewhere between traditional methods of resolving disputes peacefully (outlined in Chapter VI), on the one hand, and more forceful, less “consent-based” action (Chapter VII), on the other.

Over the years, UN peacekeeping has evolved to meet the demands of different conflicts and a changing global political landscape.


Nothing you've said here really means anything different to what I've said.


The world you live in doesn't really understand that soldiers don't fight for the UN. No one joins an army to fight for the UN. That was my point. But that reality doesn't fit your lefty view of the world.

I've already stated that the UN is a 'role' that soldiers perform for their governments who make commitments to the UN Chapter....I repeat they are still very much British or American or whatever soldiers fighting where their government tells them.

As for the command aspect this is a huge over-egging of the point. Of course there has to be one overall command agreed by the participating nations. But the units themselves are mainly self-contained working within their own structures.

As I've said, the governments pay their own soldiers.

Saying soldiers 'fight' for the UN is a bit like stating that soldiers fought for the 'Allies' back in WW2. Most soldiers don't think like that.

It's an alliance of countries nothing more.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

JohnyBoy Flag 16 Apr 13 11.14am

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 Apr 2013 10.55am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.


No it isn't - hard to put it more simply than that.

There was considerable debate in the immediate aftermath but, after the facts became known and the dust had settled, it was clear that there is no substantive case to answer.

If you are not a leftie, or an apologiest then my guess is you are a lawyer, since they would be the only people to benefit from an inquiry!



Actually I am not a lawyer either although I have run into international law quite a bit as part of my book research (which was a hobby I may add)....would the people not benefit at all from an independent public inquiry? Really? Or is it better to sweep things under the carpet and let our 'free press' like the Daily Mail decide what we think? I think most would choose the former.
Despite other accusations, can I re-iterate I am not a leftie and supported reclaiming the Falklands - I just want to know the truth, is that really asking too much? Considerable debate ....please! That's like the Nazis debating their own war crimes at Nuremberg and deciding that they didn't have a case to answer! Why don't u want the truth to come out, scared it might tarnish Britains image internationally? I am afraid MT did that already, but this is an opportunity to put it right.

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 16 Apr 13 11.30am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 11.14am

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 Apr 2013 10.55am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.


No it isn't - hard to put it more simply than that.

There was considerable debate in the immediate aftermath but, after the facts became known and the dust had settled, it was clear that there is no substantive case to answer.

If you are not a leftie, or an apologiest then my guess is you are a lawyer, since they would be the only people to benefit from an inquiry!



Actually I am not a lawyer either although I have run into international law quite a bit as part of my book research (which was a hobby I may add)....would the people not benefit at all from an independent public inquiry? Really? Or is it better to sweep things under the carpet and let our 'free press' like the Daily Mail decide what we think? I think most would choose the former.
Despite other accusations, can I re-iterate I am not a leftie and supported reclaiming the Falklands - I just want to know the truth, is that really asking too much? Considerable debate ....please! That's like the Nazis debating their own war crimes at Nuremberg and deciding that they didn't have a case to answer! Why don't u want the truth to come out, scared it might tarnish Britains image internationally? I am afraid MT did that already, but this is an opportunity to put it right.


Whether there should be any enquiry should be based upon whether there is a case to answer in the first place.

You have chosen to interpret the facts in a way which suggests an offence may have been committed. That is your right, of course. I, however - together with the vast majority of informed opinion - do not believe that there is any case to answer. I would therefore view an enquiry as a waste of public money.

If this were a British criminal prosecution, I am sure that the judge would dismiss the case at the first opportunity, criticise the CPS for wasting money in bringing the case to court, and suggest that it was both frivolous and vexatious (if that is possible?).

Edited by SloveniaDave (16 Apr 2013 11.30am)

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Apr 13 11.32am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 11.14am

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 Apr 2013 10.55am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.


No it isn't - hard to put it more simply than that.

There was considerable debate in the immediate aftermath but, after the facts became known and the dust had settled, it was clear that there is no substantive case to answer.

If you are not a leftie, or an apologiest then my guess is you are a lawyer, since they would be the only people to benefit from an inquiry!



Actually I am not a lawyer either although I have run into international law quite a bit as part of my book research (which was a hobby I may add)....would the people not benefit at all from an independent public inquiry? Really? Or is it better to sweep things under the carpet and let our 'free press' like the Daily Mail decide what we think? I think most would choose the former.
Despite other accusations, can I re-iterate I am not a leftie and supported reclaiming the Falklands - I just want to know the truth, is that really asking too much? Considerable debate ....please! That's like the Nazis debating their own war crimes at Nuremberg and deciding that they didn't have a case to answer! Why don't u want the truth to come out, scared it might tarnish Britains image internationally? I am afraid MT did that already, but this is an opportunity to put it right.


You don't like Margaret Thatcher do you.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 16 Apr 13 11.37am

Quote chris123 at 16 Apr 2013 11.32am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 11.14am

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 Apr 2013 10.55am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.


No it isn't - hard to put it more simply than that.

There was considerable debate in the immediate aftermath but, after the facts became known and the dust had settled, it was clear that there is no substantive case to answer.

If you are not a leftie, or an apologiest then my guess is you are a lawyer, since they would be the only people to benefit from an inquiry!



Actually I am not a lawyer either although I have run into international law quite a bit as part of my book research (which was a hobby I may add)....would the people not benefit at all from an independent public inquiry? Really? Or is it better to sweep things under the carpet and let our 'free press' like the Daily Mail decide what we think? I think most would choose the former.
Despite other accusations, can I re-iterate I am not a leftie and supported reclaiming the Falklands - I just want to know the truth, is that really asking too much? Considerable debate ....please! That's like the Nazis debating their own war crimes at Nuremberg and deciding that they didn't have a case to answer! Why don't u want the truth to come out, scared it might tarnish Britains image internationally? I am afraid MT did that already, but this is an opportunity to put it right.


You don't like Margaret Thatcher do you.


C'est Clouseau

 

JohnyBoy Flag 16 Apr 13 12.32pm

Quote Plane at 16 Apr 2013 11.37am

Quote chris123 at 16 Apr 2013 11.32am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 11.14am

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 Apr 2013 10.55am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.


No it isn't - hard to put it more simply than that.

There was considerable debate in the immediate aftermath but, after the facts became known and the dust had settled, it was clear that there is no substantive case to answer.

If you are not a leftie, or an apologiest then my guess is you are a lawyer, since they would be the only people to benefit from an inquiry!



Actually I am not a lawyer either although I have run into international law quite a bit as part of my book research (which was a hobby I may add)....would the people not benefit at all from an independent public inquiry? Really? Or is it better to sweep things under the carpet and let our 'free press' like the Daily Mail decide what we think? I think most would choose the former.
Despite other accusations, can I re-iterate I am not a leftie and supported reclaiming the Falklands - I just want to know the truth, is that really asking too much? Considerable debate ....please! That's like the Nazis debating their own war crimes at Nuremberg and deciding that they didn't have a case to answer! Why don't u want the truth to come out, scared it might tarnish Britains image internationally? I am afraid MT did that already, but this is an opportunity to put it right.


You don't like Margaret Thatcher do you.


C'est Clouseau


Actually its not a personal thing...and I really don't want it to come across as such. I was and stand by the fact that I supported Tory economic policy in the late 70's. although I was only 11 when she came to power. Labour to me were unelectable because of their support for ailing industries, union power and defence policy i.e. CND. But I am against the moral choices she made and I honestly don't think that Heseltine, Major or Cameron for that matter would have made the same choices. To me these choices including support for apartheid, Northern Ireland, Pinochet, Khmer Rouge and 'care in the community' were just wrong choices and some of them led directly to the deaths of innocent people including endangering the lives of our armed services.
As much as I seek justice and a recognition of where she fell down I will still honour her funeral, she was like it or not, our democratically elected PM and a great ambassador for women, regardless of what some extreme feminists say. I am just sorting the wheat from the chaff and surely we should all hold our politicians to account regardless of party loyalties, but to me it was a very dark period in British political and moral history

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Apr 13 12.33pm

Quote Plane at 16 Apr 2013 11.37am

Quote chris123 at 16 Apr 2013 11.32am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 11.14am

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 Apr 2013 10.55am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.


No it isn't - hard to put it more simply than that.

There was considerable debate in the immediate aftermath but, after the facts became known and the dust had settled, it was clear that there is no substantive case to answer.

If you are not a leftie, or an apologiest then my guess is you are a lawyer, since they would be the only people to benefit from an inquiry!



Actually I am not a lawyer either although I have run into international law quite a bit as part of my book research (which was a hobby I may add)....would the people not benefit at all from an independent public inquiry? Really? Or is it better to sweep things under the carpet and let our 'free press' like the Daily Mail decide what we think? I think most would choose the former.
Despite other accusations, can I re-iterate I am not a leftie and supported reclaiming the Falklands - I just want to know the truth, is that really asking too much? Considerable debate ....please! That's like the Nazis debating their own war crimes at Nuremberg and deciding that they didn't have a case to answer! Why don't u want the truth to come out, scared it might tarnish Britains image internationally? I am afraid MT did that already, but this is an opportunity to put it right.


You don't like Margaret Thatcher do you.


C'est Clouseau


I thought the pestering was more Columboesque.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Apr 13 12.39pm

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 12.32pm

Quote Plane at 16 Apr 2013 11.37am

Quote chris123 at 16 Apr 2013 11.32am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 11.14am

Quote SloveniaDave at 16 Apr 2013 10.55am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 10.35am

Quote Moose at 16 Apr 2013 10.16am

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am

I have heard it all now - using Wikipedia or the Daily Mail to justify what happened. As has been alluded to that's like using the Widgery report to justify the Bloody Sunday shootings.

Are you suggesting these people didn't say the things attributed to them? Wiki may not be the fount of all knowledge but the article on there is not biased in my view. If you want me to find another dozen reference points for my argument I'm sure I can, but how about arguing your point rather than belittling others?

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
And Mr Stirlings point that no-one fights for the UN HMMM! My father represented the UN during the Congo crisis of 1961, one of a hotch-potch of soldiers from non aligned countries that were sent to establish a peace in central Africa. 'Fighting to keep the peace may be a contradiction but so is an army that refuses to defend itself or civilians....as per Srebenica where Dutch UN soldiers basically stood aside when 700 muslim men and boys were massacred. My fathers UN force were told that they could not fire unless fired upon......and then they were fired on. So they fought back to prevent the civilian population they were serving from being wiped out. It ended up in a 5 day continuous siege (no sleep) and was only ended by a brokered ceasefire when Dag Hammerskjold's plane got shot down. My father was then a POW for 5.5 weeks. During that time they were informed by amnesty international that a suspected 'war crime' had been committed against the Kantanganese army by a group of Indian UN personnel where they allegedly captured three of the soldiers (all boy soldiers) that had 'allegedly' killed one of their brothers' breaking their limbs then throwing them off the 4-storey PO building in Elizabethville....leaving them 3 days to die. My father (who was 17 cos he forged his birth certificate) and the 200 or so others that were imprisoned at the time realised that this put them in incredible danger as an atrocity committed by one side is equally likely to be committed by the other - which in the case of the Congo included male rape and cannibalism - THAT'S WHY THE GENEVA CONVENTION WAS SET UP. In my fathers case they were told they would be shot dead by firing squad. The leaders of the UN and Amnesty pleaded with the Katangan secession leaders (Moise Tshombie) that it was a rogue element that allegedly committed the war crime and would be dealt with by military tribunal - Tshombie eventually backed down as he wanted future international recognition for his Katangan state. I have researched this conflict and indeed WW1 extensively and have indeed written a book about it, interviewing many of those who were caught up in the active service for the UN, also questioning them about the alleged war crime by the Indian UN personnel...nb.its actually quite difficult to find soldiers who have genuinely been involved in active service as it is estimated that only one in 28 sent off to theatres of war actually engages in combat (it was 1 in 23 in the Korean war)

And it sounds as though your father was/is a very brave man. Can't really see what this has got to do with the Belgrano argument, though.


Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
The answers I received and my point is that a war crime or atrocity puts the soldiers at risk and that is why I question Thatcher's rationale and reason for an alleged atrocity as she put British soldiers lives at more risk and arguably extended the war.

Arguably, it shortened the war as it effectively took a large part of the Argentinian navy out of the equation meaning less air support and fewer casualties.

Quote JohnyBoy at 16 Apr 2013 8.51am
When Thatcher was alive it was impossible to bring her to an international court, the UK would just never have allowed it but now that she is dead I think it appropriate that there is an independent judicial review. I am reasonably convinced (85% which is about as sure as you can be in law) that she would be found guilty....and that compensation should be paid to the victims families. Lastly can I just re-iterate that I supported the Falklands war, and was as relieved as anyone when the Falklands were reclaimed, but I will never support a war crime or an atrocity....and although some Holmesdale front or armchair generals may support them I can assure you that any sane soldier sent on active service prays that both sides upholds the Geneva convention.

And I'll reiterate that, if the Argentinians involved admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, it's bizarre that the only major noise to the contrary comes from the UK!


Please look up the comments made at the UN and ever since by the international community in relation to the Belgrano (including the US). You will find its not just a 'British leftie thing', but very much an international outcry.However, rather than let the trial by media decide, lets let a independent judicial review leading to a public inquiry decide. If you are convinced there was nothing wrong, then you have nothing to fear in an open and independent inquiry.
....and I am not a 'leftie' either.


No it isn't - hard to put it more simply than that.

There was considerable debate in the immediate aftermath but, after the facts became known and the dust had settled, it was clear that there is no substantive case to answer.

If you are not a leftie, or an apologiest then my guess is you are a lawyer, since they would be the only people to benefit from an inquiry!



Actually I am not a lawyer either although I have run into international law quite a bit as part of my book research (which was a hobby I may add)....would the people not benefit at all from an independent public inquiry? Really? Or is it better to sweep things under the carpet and let our 'free press' like the Daily Mail decide what we think? I think most would choose the former.
Despite other accusations, can I re-iterate I am not a leftie and supported reclaiming the Falklands - I just want to know the truth, is that really asking too much? Considerable debate ....please! That's like the Nazis debating their own war crimes at Nuremberg and deciding that they didn't have a case to answer! Why don't u want the truth to come out, scared it might tarnish Britains image internationally? I am afraid MT did that already, but this is an opportunity to put it right.


You don't like Margaret Thatcher do you.


C'est Clouseau


Actually its not a personal thing...and I really don't want it to come across as such. I was and stand by the fact that I supported Tory economic policy in the late 70's. although I was only 11 when she came to power. Labour to me were unelectable because of their support for ailing industries, union power and defence policy i.e. CND. But I am against the moral choices she made and I honestly don't think that Heseltine, Major or Cameron for that matter would have made the same choices. To me these choices including support for apartheid, Northern Ireland, Pinochet, Khmer Rouge and 'care in the community' were just wrong choices and some of them led directly to the deaths of innocent people including endangering the lives of our armed services.
As much as I seek justice and a recognition of where she fell down I will still honour her funeral, she was like it or not, our democratically elected PM and a great ambassador for women, regardless of what some extreme feminists say. I am just sorting the wheat from the chaff and surely we should all hold our politicians to account regardless of party loyalties, but to me it was a very dark period in British political and moral history


Your basic premise is flawed because she didn't support any of these things.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 16 Apr 13 1.06pm

Eh? 123

Khmer Rouge and Apartheid granted but the rest....... Of course she did.

Edited by Kermit8 (16 Apr 2013 1.07pm)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


chris123 Flag hove actually 16 Apr 13 1.18pm

Quote Kermit8 at 16 Apr 2013 1.06pm

Eh? 123

Khmer Rouge and Apartheid granted but the rest....... Of course she did.

Edited by Kermit8 (16 Apr 2013 1.07pm)


Well care in the community, as an idea, had been around for many years prior to Margaret Thatcher coming to power and there was a major report from the Audit Commission recommending the approach. So I should have been more specific.

Re Pinochet, I think that was more thanks for help over the Falklands rather than an endorsement for killing your own people.

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 16 Apr 13 1.19pm

Quote Kermit8 at 16 Apr 2013 1.06pm

Eh? 123

Khmer Rouge and Apartheid granted but the rest....... Of course she did.

Edited by Kermit8 (16 Apr 2013 1.07pm)


Well that only leaves 3, and I do not think that 'support for Northern Ireland' is anything to be ashamed of. Support for Pinochet was payback for his support for us during the Falklands campaign - sometimes war makes for strange bedfellows or are we to say that Churchill 'supported' Stalin. Which leaves care in the community as last man standing.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Page 62 of 76 < 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Margaret Thatcher