Quote Moose at 15 Apr 2013 3.37pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Apr 2013 11.30am
Quote Plane at 15 Apr 2013 9.50am
Quote Ouzo Dan at 15 Apr 2013 8.51am
f*** the belgrano, it was an enemy vessel, when at war you kill the enemy.
I would have been disgusted if Thatcher hadn't given the order to sink it.
...Is the correct answer.
Is the wrong answer - IT WAS NOT A WAR - The UK specifcally declined a declaration of war that was its right, under UN agreement on soverign nations which we signed and help draft.
It was thus designated a conflict with an exclusion zone. It would be a crime to attack any vessel outside of the exlcusion zone.
Tactically, of course it was the right military decision to sink the Belgrano, but that doesn't mean there isn't a case to answer. Much like its tactically astute to utilise black operations against your enemy's - doesn't prevent it being murder.
I agree with her decision, but it was technically a 'war crime' and she should have been investigated for it, and potentially faced trial if there was a case to be answered.
Call me silly, but I can't understand why, when the Argentinians involved in the conflict are happy to admit that the Belgrano was a legitimate target, so many British are still making a massive deal about it. Sorry for all the Wiki copy / pasting:
Captain Bonzo, Captain of the Belgrano, wrote his memories about the sinking in the book "1093 Tripulantes del Crucero ARA General Belgrano", published in 1992. In this book he wrote that it is "improper to accept that the attack by HMS Conqueror was a treason". During an interview in 2003 he had stated that the General Belgrano was only temporarily sailing to the west at the time of the attack, and his orders were to attack any British ships which came within range of cruiser's armament.
In August 1994, an official Argentine Defence Ministry report written by armed forces auditor Eugenio Miari was released which described the sinking of the Belgrano as "a legal act of war", explaining that "acts of war can be carried out in all of the enemy's territory" and "they can also take place in those areas over which no state can claim sovereignty, in international waters."
La Nación published a reader's letter from Admiral Enrique Molina Pico (head of the Argentine Navy in the 1990s) in 2005 in which Pico wrote that the Belgrano was part of an operation that posed a real threat to the British task force, but was holding off for tactical reasons. Pico added that "To leave the exclusion zone was not to leave the combat zone to enter a protected area".
Methinks if it hadn't been Thatcher who had given the order, the brouhaha might never have been so great...