You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 63 of 65 < 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 >
PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 24 May 19 8.50am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

For what we have spent under Roy he has done exactly what is expected of him. Aside from Watford all the teams above us have invested heavily in the last few years and the fact we finished so close to the likes of West Ham and Everton after they bankrolled their managers says a lot. As much as it can be unexciting to watch Roy is very good at grinding out ugly results when needed. Had we not been flirting with relegation we may seen more expansive football like in the last couple of games, but to be honest we were flattered by coming up against two of the league's worst defences. When you consider that Roy missed Zaha for a number of games and didn't have a fit, scoring striker until January then it seems a bit unfair to be too critical. A small improvement in our home form and we'll be circling the top 8.

That's to sensible an answer for this thread. Nothing you can say will alter the fact that there are certain conceited know alls that will never admit that Hodgeson is one of the best managers we have had in our last 6 years in the Premiership.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 9.09am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

That's to sensible an answer for this thread. Nothing you can say will alter the fact that there are certain conceited know alls that will never admit that Hodgeson is one of the best managers we have had in our last 6 years in the Premiership.

I agree, he is one of the best managers we've had.

That's what you get with a negative policy of 17th place or higher every year.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 9.10am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

You're the one with the yellow card.

Good spot. Didn't break the rules though, I'm just not liked.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 May 19 9.18am

Originally posted by Painter

Still nobody has been unable to explain, how they come to the conclusion that Roy is negative.

After a season, where we got more points than ever before and scored more goals than ever before in the last six seasons in the Premier.

You won't get an answer to that one.

Not an educated one anyway.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 9.20am

Originally posted by NEILLO

You won't get an answer to that one.

Not an educated one anyway.

3 defensive, sitting midfielders every game no matter the opposition.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 9.22am

Originally posted by NEILLO

You won't get an answer to that one.

Not an educated one anyway.

Like for like substitutions on 75 minutes no matter the situation.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 9.23am

Originally posted by NEILLO

You won't get an answer to that one.

Not an educated one anyway.

Choosing players on obedience rather than form or talent (see interview with Lewington)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 9.24am

Originally posted by NEILLO

You won't get an answer to that one.

Not an educated one anyway.

Persisting with PVA until mid April when he should've be dropped in October after Bournemouth away

 

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 24 May 19 9.25am

The fact is that there are queries around imbalance of home and away performance. 6th in the table for away games and 18th in the table for home games. In case home performance would end around 11. or 12, overall position would be obviously 7th and this is not a big ask (being 11. or 12 for home performance).

I really like the way Palace play structured and nearly never knocked down at any game. However, grabbing only one point from tops 6 games at home (exclude last minute counter attack goals, all or one goal margin defeat) and additional having only one point from Brighton, Southampton, Cardiff is not acceptable.

I believe team has potential to make better if they can show that brilliant performance at away.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 9.32am

Originally posted by NEILLO

You won't get an answer to that one.

Not an educated one anyway.

Only taking the handbrake off when we're were mathematically safe (about 4 games from the end) and afterwards we were smashing the opposition to absolutely pieces, demonstrating a negative policy up until that point...

Yeah, you won't get an educated answer. Let's all stick with "I wuv Croydon Roy innit, e's one of our own coz da club told me so. You're all fick if you don't agree"

That's a solid, insightful approach and will in no way enable the powers that be to eventually relegate us as the fans aren't holding them to account beyond this "6/7/8/9 seasons in the premier league is good enough" nonsense.

It isn't. We should have been progressing to top 8 and would have done so easily this year if Roy's negative tactics hadn't managed only 1 point from fixtures against Brighton, Southampton and Watford. We'd have relegated Brighton to boot.

Wake up.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 May 19 9.34am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Persisting with PVA until mid April when he should've be dropped in October after Bournemouth away

Why are you replying to me ?

It's Painter that asked the question.

Anyway, looks like you're in for another season of discontent next year...

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 9.43am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Why are you replying to me ?

It's Painter that asked the question.

Anyway, looks like you're in for another season of discontent next year...

It's a forum in the public domain mate, Painter can see it too.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 May 19 12.32pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Only taking the handbrake off when we're were mathematically safe (about 4 games from the end) and afterwards we were smashing the opposition to absolutely pieces, demonstrating a negative policy up until that point...

Yeah, you won't get an educated answer. Let's all stick with "I wuv Croydon Roy innit, e's one of our own coz da club told me so. You're all fick if you don't agree"

That's a solid, insightful approach and will in no way enable the powers that be to eventually relegate us as the fans aren't holding them to account beyond this "6/7/8/9 seasons in the premier league is good enough" nonsense.

It isn't. We should have been progressing to top 8 and would have done so easily this year if Roy's negative tactics hadn't managed only 1 point from fixtures against Brighton, Southampton and Watford. We'd have relegated Brighton to boot.

Wake up.

'' Wake up '' ?? - Just because I don't agree with you ?? I can understand why people find your writing style offensive.

And you don't seem to get it - just because I'm pro Hodgson doesn't mean that I think he's perfect and that I'm blindly following some club propaganda.

'' Smashing teams to pieces '' at the end of the season - hardly. A dull 0-0 with Everton and then we edged out Arsenal, Cardiff and Bournemouth. Lots of goals yes, at both ends.

At the risk of repeating what I and others have been saying, we finished where we deserved to be. Periods without Zaha and a decent striker certainly hampered things but all clubs have injuries just that some have stronger squads.

As for the Brighton and Watford results - totally disappointing. But if we had beaten Brighton home and away and lost ( as most would expect us to ) at Arsenal and Man City, we would have the same number of points come the end of the season.

The club's objective next year is to finish in the Top 10. If that's not enough for you then as I said before, you're in for further disappointment.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 1.37pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

'' Wake up '' ?? - Just because I don't agree with you ?? I can understand why people find your writing style offensive.

And you don't seem to get it - just because I'm pro Hodgson doesn't mean that I think he's perfect and that I'm blindly following some club propaganda.

'' Smashing teams to pieces '' at the end of the season - hardly. A dull 0-0 with Everton and then we edged out Arsenal, Cardiff and Bournemouth. Lots of goals yes, at both ends.

At the risk of repeating what I and others have been saying, we finished where we deserved to be. Periods without Zaha and a decent striker certainly hampered things but all clubs have injuries just that some have stronger squads.

As for the Brighton and Watford results - totally disappointing. But if we had beaten Brighton home and away and lost ( as most would expect us to ) at Arsenal and Man City, we would have the same number of points come the end of the season.

The club's objective next year is to finish in the Top 10. If that's not enough for you then as I said before, you're in for further disappointment.

I've not seen it mentioned that our target is top ten.

Anyway, I shan't be disappointed as I expect us to finish 14th next season after a disappointing summer in the transfer window and Hodgson slogging out his final year. This year was our chance to build and we f***ed it. I can see Brighton building and progressing now they've sacked their negative manager, we'll further regret giving them 6 points.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 May 19 1.56pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I agree, he is one of the best managers we've had.

That's what you get with a negative policy of 17th place or higher every year.

We are at very best ninth to tenth in league placings down to eighteenth at the worst ..much the same as all the other teams in and around us, we finally finished the season a lot better with regards to results due to good finishing which if we had been able to do earlier in the season may have provided us an eighth placing at the death, all in all it was a good effort in the end but you're right and wrong about the home form ....certainly in four of the games we deserved nothing at all due to being outmanoeuvred by much better players on the day and followed up by managers who had fantastic benches to totally take the piss, which I'm sure you are well aware of as we don't possess much in return and then the games where we really honestly should have got results by just simply sticking the silly ball where it belonged..and you know that too don't you

Hodgson is not negative, he is pragmatic.

Edited by Tickled pink (24 May 2019 2.01pm)

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 May 19 1.56pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I've not seen it mentioned that our target is top ten.

Anyway, I shan't be disappointed as I expect us to finish 14th next season after a disappointing summer in the transfer window and Hodgson slogging out his final year. This year was our chance to build and we f***ed it. I can see Brighton building and progressing now they've sacked their negative manager, we'll further regret giving them 6 points.

I really think you should be "supporting" a top 6 side.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 24 May 19 2.02pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I really think you should be "supporting" a top 6 side.

I think Man.C personally.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 May 19 2.09pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I really think you should be "supporting" a top 6 side.

And I think that you should post something positive for a change instead of just insulting people. Simon Jordan and Mattteo yesterday and now ChrisGC today.

Please give it a rest

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 3.21pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

We are at very best ninth to tenth in league placings down to eighteenth at the worst ..much the same as all the other teams in and around us, we finally finished the season a lot better with regards to results due to good finishing which if we had been able to do earlier in the season may have provided us an eighth placing at the death, all in all it was a good effort in the end but you're right and wrong about the home form ....certainly in four of the games we deserved nothing at all due to being outmanoeuvred by much better players on the day and followed up by managers who had fantastic benches to totally take the piss, which I'm sure you are well aware of as we don't possess much in return and then the games where we really honestly should have got results by just simply sticking the silly ball where it belonged..and you know that too don't you

Hodgson is not negative, he is pragmatic.

Edited by Tickled pink (24 May 2019 2.01pm)

So you think we're good enough for ninth, but I'm getting consistently hammered for thinking 8th is a realistic target?

That seems reasonable.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 24 May 19 3.35pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

I think Man.C personally.

It doesn't make sense that I should seek to follow another team when I'm the one with the positive ambition for the club I love.

Perhaps it is you and Bexley Eagle that should look for a club that matches your ambitions? Millwall perhaps?

 

Page 63 of 65 < 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread