You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 12.08pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 66 of 122 < 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 >
croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 05 Sep 18 3.28pm

Originally posted by palace_in_frogland

Your meds aren’t working properly, are they?

I thought it was a wonderful display at wembley monsieur!

 

Islington Eagle Flag North of the River 05 Sep 18 3.30pm

So much typical middle england NIMBY attitude on display in this thread. It is a joke. Why this country is going down the pan because whenever change is suggested there is always some dullard who will bitch and moan about how things should stay the same and how unfair it all is.
People digging up a great grandparent who supported Palace before your dad was even born and therefore being much more important than some one else who only has an uncle twice removed who came to the ground even when there wasn't a match.
It's like a monty python sketch. Get over yourselves.
We are in a computer age. Technology can be employed to re-arrange everyone as fairly as possible to accomodate a couple of hundred people in the centre of the lower holmesdale. I'm sorry if you will be affected but sometimes people have to be a little bit inconvieninced in the name of progress.

 


Palace Fan

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Sep 18 3.34pm

Originally posted by Islington Eagle

So much typical middle england NIMBY attitude on display in this thread. It is a joke. Why this country is going down the pan because whenever change is suggested there is always some dullard who will bitch and moan about how things should stay the same and how unfair it all is.
People digging up a great grandparent who supported Palace before your dad was even born and therefore being much more important than some one else who only has an uncle twice removed who came to the ground even when there wasn't a match.
It's like a monty python sketch. Get over yourselves.
We are in a computer age. Technology can be employed to re-arrange everyone as fairly as possible to accomodate a couple of hundred people in the centre of the lower holmesdale. I'm sorry if you will be affected but sometimes people have to be a little bit inconvieninced in the name of progress.


Technology can indeed sort out seating plans, unfortuanetly Current Ground Regulations cant(as per mine & Willo's post before)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

AERO Flag 05 Sep 18 3.35pm

Agreed , Your Seat is only rented

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Sep 18 3.36pm

Originally posted by Islington Eagle

So much typical middle england NIMBY attitude on display in this thread. It is a joke. Why this country is going down the pan because whenever change is suggested there is always some dullard who will bitch and moan about how things should stay the same and how unfair it all is.
People digging up a great grandparent who supported Palace before your dad was even born and therefore being much more important than some one else who only has an uncle twice removed who came to the ground even when there wasn't a match.
It's like a monty python sketch. Get over yourselves.
We are in a computer age. Technology can be employed to re-arrange everyone as fairly as possible to accomodate a couple of hundred people in the centre of the lower holmesdale. I'm sorry if you will be affected but sometimes people have to be a little bit inconvieninced in the name of progress.

Scaremongering again!

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 05 Sep 18 3.40pm

Originally posted by Leftfield

I very rarely post as I prefer to lurk & read others opinions but this is one subject I feel passionately enough about to bother to join in. I'm 57 and have been going to SP since I was a young lad living in Beulah Hill, so I've seen 50 years worth of ups & downs at Palace.

We've always had a mixed fan base with the middle classes from the Surrey suburbs complemented by the rougher tougher London lads & it seems the arguments pretty much are defined by which tribe you come from

I'm actually normally thought of as middle class, but when it comes to football, I don't want to sit there clapping politely, I want to get involved in the whole matchday atmosphere (like it was in the 70's for example). This isn't Rugby or cricket, this is football & that should mean showing some bloody passion !!

To use a musical analogy we have one group wanting it to be like Glyndbourne & the others wanting it to be like going to a Prodigy Gig........and I'm a big Prodigy fan so you can see which appeals to me

To my mind there's plenty of places to sit quietly and appreciate a good bit of play with a smattering of applause but traditionally behind the goal on the Holmesdale terrace (or at the back of the Arfur) were the places to make some noise

I just cannot see why people would want Palace to go back to the bad old days before the HF got involved. We have recently got a reputation for being the loudest home support in the PL & that made me bloody proud of my club & my fellow fans

Back in the seventies when we were all packed onto the terraces it was relatively easy to get a chant going as we just moved to the most vocal area behind the goal, but now with seating it's so much harder. I mainly stand at the back of the Arfur with the other older lads and at least there we can make some noise, but in more open Holmesdale it's much much harder to get the songs going without a singing section being organised.

I can see why the HF want it to be allocated centrally as that would get people joining in from both sides & hopefully from the upper tier too.

Is it really that big a deal for some people to shuffle along a bit if they really just want to sit and "support" their club silently ?

Surely even those that don't want to sing and chant miss the passion that that engenders ?

God help us if we end up like most of the other London clubs with their sterile stadia & lack of noise

I for one am embarrassed at how bad the atmosphere has been this season & how others now see us as a set of supporters who without the HF are as quiet as the rest

It's not just the HF that want to inject some passion to supporting our beloved club, there's thousands of others like me I'm sure but until safe standing is introduced we've got to do something to make it easier for those of us who want to make plenty of noise & getting a central singing section has to be the answer

I think you should post more often Leftfield

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 05 Sep 18 3.42pm

Originally posted by Islington Eagle

<snip>

I'm sorry if you will be affected but sometimes people have to be a little bit inconvieninced in the name of progress.

Progress, what progress?

 

Mstrobez Flag 05 Sep 18 3.46pm

Originally posted by Islington Eagle

So much typical middle england NIMBY attitude on display in this thread. It is a joke. Why this country is going down the pan because whenever change is suggested there is always some dullard who will bitch and moan about how things should stay the same and how unfair it all is.
People digging up a great grandparent who supported Palace before your dad was even born and therefore being much more important than some one else who only has an uncle twice removed who came to the ground even when there wasn't a match.
It's like a monty python sketch. Get over yourselves.
We are in a computer age. Technology can be employed to re-arrange everyone as fairly as possible to accomodate a couple of hundred people in the centre of the lower holmesdale. I'm sorry if you will be affected but sometimes people have to be a little bit inconvieninced in the name of progress.

Again 6 of 1 half a dozen of the other, init?

I think plenty could legitimately redirect the “get over yourselves” straight back at the HF.

It seems the only way the staunchest HF supporters in this can get their message across is by demonising other Palace fans. This whole thing is becoming a joke, and it’s of the HF’s own accord.

And that’s why I’m with the club on their decisioning and reasoning behind their decisioning. Thank f*** you’re not the one running it.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 3.47pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Progress, what progress?

I’d say we’ve regressed in the stadium, no?

The HF are correct in that the atmosphere is declining with the current setup.

 


COYP

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 05 Sep 18 3.49pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

[Link]

1,700 signatures now.

It's not very many is it? Doesn't really show much support for HF when you take into account our entire fanbase and that the HF and their supporters have been pushing the campaign hard.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 3.59pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

It's not very many is it? Doesn't really show much support for HF when you take into account our entire fanbase and that the HF and their supporters have been pushing the campaign hard.

2,000 now [Link]

It’s only been 2 days. We’ll see. The longer this rumbles on with an atmosphere Fulham or Wigan can better it’ll keep growing, because most don’t want that, until you’re left with 1,000 who claim they don’t mind.

 


COYP

Mstrobez Flag 05 Sep 18 4.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I’d say we’ve regressed in the stadium, no?

The HF are correct in that the atmosphere is declining with the current setup.

I’d say in the season we were first up. There were times I sat at the back of the Arthur and the made more noise than block B. And that’s not to be controversial, it was a general observation I made at the time sitting in both places across the season.

Imagine the Arthur coming out and saying actually we wanna occupy this segment of seats because we’re louder than everyone else and then to release this stuff that either do it now, regardless of other fans, or we’ve lost an opportunity that will never come back?

The point is, supporting palace means different things to different individuals. And I just still cannot get behind this idea that a group, an albeit fantastic group on the most part, can dictate to others what they should have to do.

I know people, for example, who attended every single game last season - home and away. The HF haven’t ever done that, which is also fine. But don’t those supporters have an as legitimate, if not more legitimate claim to special reservations? What if they sit in Block E and have done for many years and don’t want to move?

Ahh sorry mate, you may of covered more distance for the club, spent more of your hard-earned money and done it for a longer period of time. But this takes precedence over you.

I just can’t see how people fail to recognise the slippery slope of imposing movement on other fans.

As I and others have said many times, if they got proper consent without a witch hunt or pressure being placed on other people. Then that’s great, and let’s be honest they probably would’ve got it eventually. But now we’re in a situation where any resolution is effectively forcing season ticket holders in Block E to move. Because the idea that they can make an unpressurised decision without being accused by the self righteous that they are “not buying into the vision” is now a fantasy.

None of this is right.

Edited by Mstrobez (05 Sep 2018 4.04pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 05 Sep 18 4.03pm

Put the HF by the players tunnel, so they can give 5hlt when the results don't go our way.

Give the HF their own away section, so they don't hassle families and pensioners out of their allocated seats.

When the songs 'are wrong' by other fan groups, let the stadium sit in silence.

200 'fans' out of 23,000. fcvk 'em

I was at Selhurst for the midweek match (in the pl55ing rain) against Crewe in 2003-4, which Palace lost. I didn't boo the players, and I didn't leave early. Nor did I give 5hlt to the other 10K palace fans.

I donated money to the HF for displays. I'd like my money back, because my money has been used as leverage to try and secure preferential status for 'the few'.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

laddo Flag london 05 Sep 18 4.09pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Put the HF by the players tunnel, so they can give 5hlt when the results don't go our way.

Give the HF their own away section, so they don't hassle families and pensioners out of their allocated seats.

When the songs 'are wrong' by other fan groups, let the stadium sit in silence.

200 'fans' out of 23,000. fcvk 'em

I was at Selhurst for the midweek match (in the pl55ing rain) against Crewe in 2003-4, which Palace lost. I didn't boo the players, and I didn't leave early. Nor did I give 5hlt to the other 10K palace fans.

I donated money to the HF for displays. I'd like my money back, because my money has been used as leverage to try and secure preferential status for 'the few'.

I was also at Crewe hand. It was dire, including atmosphere. I want the HF to thrive.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 4.12pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I’d say in the season we were first up. There were times I sat at the back of the Arthur and the made more noise than block B. And that’s not to be controversial, it was a general observation I made at the time sitting in both places across the season.

Imagine the Arthur coming out and saying actually we wanna occupy this segment of seats because we’re louder than everyone else and then to release this stuff that either do it now, regardless of other fans, or we’ve lost an opportunity that will never come back?

The point is, supporting palace means different things to different individuals. And I just still cannot get behind this idea that a group, an albeit fantastic group on the most part, can dictate to others what they should have to do.

I know people, for example, who attended every single game last season - home and away. The HF haven’t ever done that, which is also fine. But don’t those supporters have an as legitimate, if not more legitimate claim to special reservations? What if they sit in Block E and have done for many years and don’t want to move?

Ahh sorry mate, you may of covered more distance for the club, spent more of your hard-earned money and done it for a longer period of time. But this takes precedence over you.

I just can’t see how people fail to recognise the slippery slope of imposing movement on other fans.

As I and others have said many times, if they got proper consent without a witch hunt or pressure being placed on other people. Then that’s great, and let’s be honest they probably would’ve got it eventually. But now we’re in a situation where any resolution is effectively forcing season ticket holders in Block E to move. Because the idea that they can make an unpressurised decision without being accused by the self righteous that they are “not buying into the vision” is now a fantasy.

None of this is right.

Edited by Mstrobez (05 Sep 2018 4.04pm)

The back of the Arfur louder than blocks A,B,C and D. Thanks, I needed a laugh.

Block E and any other long term supporter will have the pick of 95% of lower tier seats so calm down a bit. Loads of people want this and/our atmosphere to stay and those with good views will still have them. Stop being so precious over a move across of 2 blocks.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 4.14pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Put the HF by the players tunnel, so they can give 5hlt when the results don't go our way.

Give the HF their own away section, so they don't hassle families and pensioners out of their allocated seats.

When the songs 'are wrong' by other fan groups, let the stadium sit in silence.

200 'fans' out of 23,000. fcvk 'em

I was at Selhurst for the midweek match (in the pl55ing rain) against Crewe in 2003-4, which Palace lost. I didn't boo the players, and I didn't leave early. Nor did I give 5hlt to the other 10K palace fans.

I donated money to the HF for displays. I'd like my money back, because my money has been used as leverage to try and secure preferential status for 'the few'.

Count you out as a level headed mediator and negotiator then.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 4.18pm

Marketing for this year’s membership campaign and likely new or lapsed fans:

[Link]

I highly doubt Parish is thinking ‘fvck em, they’re not needed. More the opposite.’

(It’s been removed. Too embarrassing for the club)

Edited by Rudi Hedman (05 Sep 2018 4.19pm)

 


COYP

Mstrobez Flag 05 Sep 18 4.19pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The back of the Arfur louder than blocks A,B,C and D. Thanks, I needed a laugh.

Block E and any other long term supporter will have the pick of 95% of lower tier seats so calm down a bit. Loads of people want this and/our atmosphere to stay and those with good views will still have them. Stop being so precious over a move across of 2 blocks.

I sat in both places in that season. And it just was. So you can either deny the experience by saying you needed a laugh or you can listen to someone literally telling you their experience.

Most people want it, including me. But if it was as simple as your attempting to make out, as always, it would already be done.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 05 Sep 18 4.21pm

Thing ive noticed is, apart from the so-called 'statements', nobody from the HF has piped up & said whats going on from their POV. I don't believe that Rudi is part of them just an ardent supporter of them.

I know an HF lad as my missus was his(& wife) employer, he is shall we say, non-british. Ive asked him about this & his answer was, he's not allowed to say anything coz their top dogs said so.


IMO, all HF are equal, but, some HF are more equal than others. . . . Remind you of something(under 35's google it)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Sep 18 4.21pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I sat in both places in that season. And it just was. So you can either deny the experience by saying you needed a laugh or you can listen to someone literally telling you their experience.

Most people want it, including me. But if it was as simple as your attempting to make out, as always, it would already be done.

Never said it was simple but it is possible and still possible. They didn’t bother and were a cause of the mess.

 


COYP

Page 66 of 122 < 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread