This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Im surprised our so-called 'ultras' chose the back of E(or were they told). You cant see them(great) you can just about hear them(not so great) they cant wave flags about(too far back & ceiling too low) & its far too far to the front to 'rush'.
Edited by eagleman13 (07 Jan 2019 3.13pm) I had no idea it's from row 17 back, that's obviously not going to last long. The HF aren't going to stand for not being able to be seen on telly during key moments, or god forbid, not be front row to give over their little under 9s football trophy to their player of the season. Those from 17 to 1, get ready to be shipped out. It's enevitable.
|
|
|
Singing section part 2 vs Spurs presumably? Edited by Dean_CPFC (07 Jan 2019 10.29pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
Absolute whopper. No. It’s your problem if you don’t believe me. Come and visit me in row 19 next year. And by the way you regularly make truly unpleasant and arrogant posts. Not bad in just over two weeks on the site. Edited by Mapletree (07 Jan 2019 10.54pm)
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
No. It’s your problem if you don’t believe me. Come and visit me in row 19 next year. And by the way you regularly make truly unpleasant and arrogant posts. Edited by Mapletree (07 Jan 2019 10.54pm) Praise from Cesar.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
Praise from Cesar. No. Criticism And that is how I see most of your posts. Pure dog food.
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
No. Criticism And that is how I see most of your posts. Pure dog food. You must just live under a bare frame surrounded by shattered glass given the size of that boulder you just launched through your roof!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Second and final warning. Any further personal attacks will result in yellow cards
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
Shouldn't worry about it, there's loads of season ticket holders on here in the surrounding rows and blocks that will happily sacrifice their seat for the greater good, or at least I assume they will by their support of the current seat grab. Then again, they could just ask Maple who can put in a good word with his mate Steve Parish. They'll be top boys in the chorus, maybe one can actually keep time and take on drum banging duties.
Sarcasm isn’t funny. Safe standing in the lower Holmesdale will keep everyone happy. Those who want to sit will move to different parts of the ground, hopefully the new stand. Likeminded people who want to stand/bounce/chant for 90 minutes will gradually form closer to block E, thus extending the ‘singing section’. If we don’t accommodate the HF/try to be progressive, we’ll end up, as the other poster said, like Everton. Worryingly there are many people, like yourself, who would be happy for us to continue sliding in that direction. The majority enjoy watching matches live with a good atmosphere. Edited by Goal Machine (08 Jan 2019 8.18am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
Praise from Cesar. Isn't that a cat food?
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Isn't that a cat food? Aptly, Dog food.
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Sarcasm isn’t funny. Safe standing in the lower Holmesdale will keep everyone happy. Those who want to sit will move to different parts of the ground, hopefully the new stand. Likeminded people who want to stand/bounce/chant for 90 minutes will gradually form closer to block E, thus extending the ‘singing section’. If we don’t accommodate the HF/try to be progressive, we’ll end up, as the other poster said, like Everton. Worryingly there are many people, like yourself, who would be happy for us to continue sliding in that direction. The majority enjoy watching matches live with a good atmosphere. Edited by Goal Machine (08 Jan 2019 8.18am) When is safe standing being installed?
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Sarcasm isn’t funny. Safe standing in the lower Holmesdale will keep everyone happy. Those who want to sit will move to different parts of the ground, hopefully the new stand. Likeminded people who want to stand/bounce/chant for 90 minutes will gradually form closer to block E, thus extending the ‘singing section’. If we don’t accommodate the HF/try to be progressive, we’ll end up, as the other poster said, like Everton. Worryingly there are many people, like yourself, who would be happy for us to continue sliding in that direction. The majority enjoy watching matches live with a good atmosphere. Edited by Goal Machine (08 Jan 2019 8.18am) I agree with you with everything other than in bold. You are absolutely right: we don't want to be like Everton or the other prawn sandwich brigade supporters. Football is almost like a crowd participation sport and to lose the 12th Man would be a travesty. I resent other teams where it's like a theatre show. The HF are a massive part of this and deserve every credit for their displays and voice through tough times. Personally, I'd like to see them mix the songs up more rather than repeating the same couple all game long and try to keep their personal political messages out of displays. I hadn't considered it, but I think you're right: safe standing is the answer. I wasn't aware it had been approved for use though. If it hasn't, sadly, it's irrelevant. As soon as the HF demanded to be moved, to the point of boycotting our boys, for me (and it's only an opinion) they killed their entire movement. You cannot give in to these gun to the head tactics as they will roll it out every time they want something. Also, I don't see it as morally right. It wouldn't matter if it was just one fan being sacrificed 'for the greater good' it simply isn't fair. I really don't like the arguement of "shut up and get on with it for the club's sake" as realistically, it would be a different tune if it was your seat being snatched. I'm shocked at SP caving to the boycot and can only see it leading to trouble in the future (long term).
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
I agree with you with everything other than in bold. You are absolutely right: we don't want to be like Everton or the other prawn sandwich brigade supporters. Football is almost like a crowd participation sport and to lose the 12th Man would be a travesty. I resent other teams where it's like a theatre show. The HF are a massive part of this and deserve every credit for their displays and voice through tough times. Personally, I'd like to see them mix the songs up more rather than repeating the same couple all game long and try to keep their personal political messages out of displays. I hadn't considered it, but I think you're right: safe standing is the answer. I wasn't aware it had been approved for use though. If it hasn't, sadly, it's irrelevant. As soon as the HF demanded to be moved, to the point of boycotting our boys, for me (and it's only an opinion) they killed their entire movement. You cannot give in to these gun to the head tactics as they will roll it out every time they want something. Also, I don't see it as morally right. It wouldn't matter if it was just one fan being sacrificed 'for the greater good' it simply isn't fair. I really don't like the arguement of "shut up and get on with it for the club's sake" as realistically, it would be a different tune if it was your seat being snatched. I'm shocked at SP caving to the boycot and can only see it leading to trouble in the future (long term). Regarding safe standing, its surely only a matter of time before it is passed, pressure for it is growing and it’s completely nonsensical to not have it. Currently football is more dangerous where people don’t use their seats. I suspect this was part of the HF’s long term vision of how they hope it will pan out. For that reason, I don’t think it’s irrelevant. I don’t necessarily agree 100% with the boycott, but it appears that Steve Parish backtracked on his promise over moving them to block E. The HF, through their commitment, passion and efforts, rightly or wrongly have earned themselves a status within the club, whereby they can, to an extent, put a gun to Steve Parish’s head and make demands, as has been proved. The difference in the stadium during the boycott was staggering, it was a miserable place and I don’t think anyone wants to return to that. That said, I genuinely believe they have the clubs best interests at heart and it’s not all about themselves. Everyone is unanimous in agreement that it’s not fair on those being turfed out of block E, but the simple answer to that is to offer those effected a suitable compensation package. Political messages are not needed, they are bound to separate people. Although, I’ve not seen any of these for a while.
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Regarding safe standing, its surely only a matter of time before it is passed, pressure for is growing and it’s completely nonsensical to not have it. Currently football is more dangerous where people don’t use their seats. I suspect this was part of the HF’s long term vision of how they hope it will pan out. For that reason, I don’t think it’s irrelevant. I don’t necessarily agree 100% with the boycott, but it appears that Steve Parish backtracked on his promise over moving them to block E. The HF, through their commitment, passion and efforts, rightly or wrongly have earned themselves a status within the club, whereby they can, to an extent, put a gun to Steve Parish’s head and make demands, as has been proved. The difference in the stadium during the boycott was staggering, it was a miserable place and I don’t think anyone wants to return to that. That said, I genuinely believe they have the clubs best interests at heart and it’s not all about themselves. Everyone is unanimous in agreement that it’s not fair on those being turfed out of block E, but the simple answer to that is to offer those effected a suitable compensation package. Political messages are not needed, they are bound to separate people. Although, I’ve not seen any of these for a while.
I wouldn't be so certain. I completely agree that it's logical and I would love to see it, but there's too many jobs on the line if it goes wrong. (Which it wouldn't) No MP, FA exec or premier league board member will ever risk having another Hillsborough on their CV. The police will never support it because it might mean they have to earn their crust: it's a lot easier to watch and control People sat down and a lot harder for perpetrators to escape. The counter arguement to the safety aspect of seating, of course, is that a seat is the safest option when actually used as a seat. I realise that we all jump about when a goal goes in and I've toppled over plenty, I think safe standing would be much safer. Bureaucrats, however, are never going to appreciate the reality. Edited by ChrisGC (08 Jan 2019 9.28am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
I wouldn't be so certain. I completely agree that it's logical and I would love to see it, but there's too many jobs on the line if it goes wrong. (Which it wouldn't) No MP, FA exec or premier league board member will ever risk having another Hillsborough on their CV. The police will never support it because it might mean they have to earn their crust: it's a lot easier to watch and control People sat down and a lot harder for perpetrators to escape. The counter arguement to the safety aspect of seating, of course, is that a seat is the safest option when actually used as a seat. I realise that we all jump about when a goal goes in and I've toppled over plenty, I think safe standing would be much safer. Bureaucrats, however, are never going to appreciate the reality. Edited by ChrisGC (08 Jan 2019 9.28am) Well, there has been a review of the decision not to permit safe standing ongoing for some while now, and the government is due to issue a further statement on the review this month, so we shall see......
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
| .TUX. |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by becky
Well, there has been a review of the decision not to permit safe standing ongoing for some while now, and the government is due to issue a further statement on the review this month, so we shall see...... That's the state of the world we live in, the world we've allowed. That aside, really looking forward to next season and the new 'layout' Edited by .TUX. (08 Jan 2019 11.40pm)
Buy Litecoin. |
|
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
I wouldn't be so certain. I completely agree that it's logical and I would love to see it, but there's too many jobs on the line if it goes wrong. (Which it wouldn't) The counter arguement to the safety aspect of seating, of course, is that a seat is the safest option when actually used as a seat. I realise that we all jump about when a goal goes in and I've toppled over plenty, I think safe standing would be much safer. Bureaucrats, however, are never going to appreciate the reality. Edited by ChrisGC (08 Jan 2019 9.28am) Have a look at modern ‘safe standing’ - a far cry from Hillsborough. It’s in at Celtic & Shrewsbury (I think) but many German clubs have done it in recent years. Technically, everyone has a ‘seat’ and every row has safety rails to stop surging etc.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
Have a look at modern ‘safe standing’ - a far cry from Hillsborough. It’s in at Celtic & Shrewsbury (I think) but many German clubs have done it in recent years. Technically, everyone has a ‘seat’ and every row has safety rails to stop surging etc. Yes, well aware of it chap and support it's introduction. My post was my opinion on why it won't happen in England.
|
|
| ChrisGC |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by BarEagle
ChrisGC, You’re overly aggressive in the posts you have put up in such a short time. My I suggest politeness and a concerted effort to give opinions rather than question honest people’s integrity? Alienating oneself in the first two weeks as a poster is rather unhelpful. Hi BarEagle. I have only used the term whopper once to challenge a post very unlikely to be true, which is as strong as I've been. In actual fact I've had some aggression directed my way, and get regularly insulted, including bringing my family into it, but it doesn't bother me: it's a human reaction when what somebody has what they believe to be an established belief challenged with logic and they can't counter, and anyway: it's only words. Arguably, your 'warning' could also be seen as an attempt to silence me as it's inaccurate: I have not been aggressive, and would encourage you to report any instance of this to a moderator. Perhaps you just don't like the cut of my jib, or the status quo being challenged, which again is ok.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.