You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 69 of 71 < 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Jan 19 9.05am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Hi BarEagle.

I have only used the term whopper once to challenge a post very unlikely to be true, which is as strong as I've been. In actual fact I've had some aggression directed my way, and get regularly insulted, including bringing my family into it, but it doesn't bother me: it's a human reaction when what somebody has what they believe to be an established belief challenged with logic and they can't counter, and anyway: it's only words.

Arguably, your 'warning' could also be seen as an attempt to silence me as it's inaccurate: I have not been aggressive, and would encourage you to report any instance of this to a moderator. Perhaps you just don't like the cut of my jib, or the status quo being challenged, which again is ok.

Why would this be made up? It's as likely (if not more so) to be true than not.
Personally I don't think you have been particularly aggressive but you have to respect others have different opinions to you.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Jan 19 9.09am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Hi BarEagle.

I have only used the term whopper once to challenge a post very unlikely to be true, which is as strong as I've been. In actual fact I've had some aggression directed my way, and get regularly insulted, including bringing my family into it, but it doesn't bother me: it's a human reaction when what somebody has what they believe to be an established belief challenged with logic and they can't counter, and anyway: it's only words.

Arguably, your 'warning' could also be seen as an attempt to silence me as it's inaccurate: I have not been aggressive, and would encourage you to report any instance of this to a moderator. Perhaps you just don't like the cut of my jib, or the status quo being challenged, which again is ok.

As this is my thread, I feel I should respond.

Had you read the thread, I made it clear from the outset that I would do all in my power to avoid moving and explained what I was doing so others could do the same. I have done that successfully. I believe my son and I are unique in that. It took some work.

As you said on another thread that you have followed the HOL for some time, you will know that I am a poster in good standing. It was a foolish thing to do accusing me of lying, as well as a deeply unpleasant thing. I always react to such accusations.

Turning to your following message:

''I've received several private messages commending my posts, one asking if I have a twitter account as they feel I'll be chased out soon by the 'clique' and want to follow my opinions. I've also received some nasty private messages which I'm big enough to ignore and not report. Sticks and stones and all that.

It's a shame that a small minority attempt to shut down debate and freedom of opinion by throwing insults and demeaning posts because they don't agree. Having followed this site as a non member for years it was the driving force to join: a different voice to challenge the status quo.''

As an avid reader of the HOL you will know that on multiple occasions I have argued that the site isn't welcoming enough to new people, especially those that aren't keyboard warriors. In your case, however, you were hoisted by your own petard. You came on here being negative and agressive yet have no history. You neither understood the people to whom you were being bombastic, nor do you have brownie points in the bag so people give you the benefit of the doubt.

I do not believe there is a clique on the HOL, it's a real mixture. Perhaps I am wrong. If there is a clique I sure as hell am not a part of it.

I have never known anyone to get 'run out of town'. A few people have created situations where they innevitably and predictably received red cards.

Finally, it is clear you are erudite and in fact it appears you have now toned down your posts. I would rather not lose any poster but if you make accusations against me again, by gum you will get both barrels.

Edited by Mapletree (09 Jan 2019 9.10am)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jan 19 9.11am

Originally posted by BarEagle

Did a Grimsby fan pay you z tenner to post that dishonest interpretation of the truth?

Sometimes, BarEagle, it's best to take your own advice first...

Classic deflection.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jan 19 9.24am

I'm sorry you feel this way.

I haven't called you a liar or questioned your integrity, I used one word: whopper. I do find your reaction to this inoffensive word fascinating.

Good standing is a term used to describe somebody's position in regards to payment received or outstanding of subcriptions or fees. It's commonly mistakenly attributed to a personal trait, which I think is similar to what's happening here.

My opinions, backed with reason are being taken personally, when they shouldn't. Any counter should be weighed against facts.

You talk about giving both barrels, but I'm not breaking any of the forum rules so I would discourage you from this as I wouldn't like you to get yourself in trouble.

Originally posted by Mapletree

As this is my thread, I feel I should respond.

Had you read the thread, I made it clear from the outset that I would do all in my power to avoid moving and explained what I was doing so others could do the same. I have done that successfully. I believe my son and I are unique in that. It took some work.

As you said on another thread that you have followed the HOL for some time, you will know that I am a poster in good standing. It was a foolish thing to do accusing me of lying, as well as a deeply unpleasant thing. I always react to such accusations.

Turning to your following message:

''I've received several private messages commending my posts, one asking if I have a twitter account as they feel I'll be chased out soon by the 'clique' and want to follow my opinions. I've also received some nasty private messages which I'm big enough to ignore and not report. Sticks and stones and all that.

It's a shame that a small minority attempt to shut down debate and freedom of opinion by throwing insults and demeaning posts because they don't agree. Having followed this site as a non member for years it was the driving force to join: a different voice to challenge the status quo.''

As an avid reader of the HOL you will know that on multiple occasions I have argued that the site isn't welcoming enough to new people, especially those that aren't keyboard warriors. In your case, however, you were hoisted by your own petard. You came on here being negative and agressive yet have no history. You neither understood the people to whom you were being bombastic, nor do you have brownie points in the bag so people give you the benefit of the doubt.

I do not believe there is a clique on the HOL, it's a real mixture. Perhaps I am wrong. If there is a clique I sure as hell am not a part of it.

I have never known anyone to get 'run out of town'. A few people have created situations where they innevitably and predictably received red cards.

Finally, it is clear you are erudite and in fact it appears you have now toned down your posts. I would rather not lose any poster but if you make accusations against me again, by gum you will get both barrels.

Edited by Mapletree (09 Jan 2019 9.10am)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jan 19 9.25am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Why would this be made up? It's as likely (if not more so) to be true than not.
Personally I don't think you have been particularly aggressive but you have to respect others have different opinions to you.



I completely agree, thank you.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 09 Jan 19 10.00am

Originally posted by becky
Well, there has been a review of the decision not to permit safe standing ongoing for some while now, and the government is due to issue a further statement on the review this month, so we shall see......

I think it is very likely a trial will start next season for a period of 5 years. The introduction of all seater stadium has reduced the number of incidents at grounds dramatically, the powers that be will need to be persuaded that introducing safe standing will not be detrimental. As I understand it interested clubs will be able to put forward plans for this trial including detailed risk reduction measures and controls. In another thread another post another poster gave a description of how safe standing was done well elsewhere and this will most likely be a benchmark.

The bad news is that the Block E decision falls outside these descriptions. Coupled with people standing on and breaking seats with no enforcement by club (based on comments on this forum). Both of these are unlikely to help any proposal by the club to take part in a safe standing trial

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Jan 19 10.10am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I'm sorry you feel this way.

I haven't called you a liar or questioned your integrity, I used one word: whopper. I do find your reaction to this inoffensive word fascinating.

Good standing is a term used to describe somebody's position in regards to payment received or outstanding of subcriptions or fees. It's commonly mistakenly attributed to a personal trait, which I think is similar to what's happening here.

My opinions, backed with reason are being taken personally, when they shouldn't. Any counter should be weighed against facts.

You talk about giving both barrels, but I'm not breaking any of the forum rules so I would discourage you from this as I wouldn't like you to get yourself in trouble.

A person or organization in good standing is regarded as having complied with all their explicit obligations, while not being subject to any form of sanction, suspension or disciplinary censure

Alternatively

The status of a person who is known to be of good character and to be trustworthy

[Link]

I have not ever broken the forum rules and don't need discouraging from doing so.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jan 19 11.04am

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

I think it is very likely a trial will start next season for a period of 5 years. The introduction of all seater stadium has reduced the number of incidents at grounds dramatically, the powers that be will need to be persuaded that introducing safe standing will not be detrimental. As I understand it interested clubs will be able to put forward plans for this trial including detailed risk reduction measures and controls. In another thread another post another poster gave a description of how safe standing was done well elsewhere and this will most likely be a benchmark.

The bad news is that the Block E decision falls outside these descriptions. Coupled with people standing on and breaking seats with no enforcement by club (based on comments on this forum). Both of these are unlikely to help any proposal by the club to take part in a safe standing trial

Good point, I hadn't thought of that. Do you have a link regarding the proposed trial? I'd be interested to have a read of that.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Jan 19 11.23am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I'm sorry you feel this way.

I haven't called you a liar or questioned your integrity, I used one word: whopper. I do find your reaction to this inoffensive word fascinating.

Good standing is a term used to describe somebody's position in regards to payment received or outstanding of subcriptions or fees. It's commonly mistakenly attributed to a personal trait, which I think is similar to what's happening here.

My opinions, backed with reason are being taken personally, when they shouldn't. Any counter should be weighed against facts.

You talk about giving both barrels, but I'm not breaking any of the forum rules so I would discourage you from this as I wouldn't like you to get yourself in trouble.

I think you probably did:

Definition of whopper
1 : something unusually large or otherwise extreme of its kind
2 : an extravagant or monstrous lie

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jan 19 11.34am

Originally posted by Mapletree

A person or organization in good standing is regarded as having complied with all their explicit obligations, while not being subject to any form of sanction, suspension or disciplinary censure

Alternatively

The status of a person who is known to be of good character and to be trustworthy

[Link]

I have not ever broken the forum rules and don't need discouraging from doing so.

Sadly, wiki isn't an encyclopedia: how I long for the days of encarta!

"Status of a firm (or member of an organisation) which is current with the payment of statutory dues." is the original intention of the phrase.

I have no doubt that your character is held in nothing but high esteem on this forum, despite how we differ in our view of the moral implications of prioritising seat allocation.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jan 19 11.45am

Originally posted by Spiderman

I think you probably did:

Definition of whopper
1 : something unusually large or otherwise extreme of its kind
2 : an extravagant or monstrous lie

Just because I believe a fib has been told, and I've yet to see anything to challenge that belief, it doesn't mean I believe the teller is a liar as a character.

That's why I used the word whopper, rather than accuse someone of being a liar. As it is improbable that the person in question's statement that they circumvented an official reallocation by phoning Steve Parish directly and 'being persuasive', nor have we any evidence to support this other than a defensive response, I see no need reason for offence to be taken or for my use of the word 'whopper' to be deemed insulting or inappropriate.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Jan 19 11.53am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Just because I believe a fib has been told, and I've yet to see anything to challenge that belief, it doesn't mean I believe the teller is a liar as a character.

That's why I used the word whopper, rather than accuse someone of being a liar. As it is improbable that the person in question's statement that they circumvented an official reallocation by phoning Steve Parish directly and 'being persuasive', nor have we any evidence to support this other than a defensive response, I see no need reason for offence to be taken or for my use of the word 'whopper' to be deemed insulting or inappropriate.

Well I took offense. And you are still implying that I lied.

You seem to have set out to create offense since joining this site and continue to do so.

Just suck it up, wind your neck in and try to understand others on the site.

An apology would have been in order. Instead you continue with your nonsense about 'good standing' and any other way to justify yourself.

By the way, you said: Good standing is a term used to describe somebody's position in regards to payment received or outstanding of subcriptions or fees.

That is not what you are now saying. Your current point appears to relate to historic use. Even if you are correct about the original use of 'good standing' - about which I am not sure - it is certainly not how the term is used now. I gave you two quotes from different sources.

Edited by Mapletree (09 Jan 2019 11.55am)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 09 Jan 19 12.38pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Well I took offense. And you are still implying that I lied.

You seem to have set out to create offense since joining this site and continue to do so.

Just suck it up, wind your neck in and try to understand others on the site.

An apology would have been in order. Instead you continue with your nonsense about 'good standing' and any other way to justify yourself.

By the way, you said: Good standing is a term used to describe somebody's position in regards to payment received or outstanding of subcriptions or fees.

That is not what you are now saying. Your current point appears to relate to historic use. Even if you are correct about the original use of 'good standing' - about which I am not sure - it is certainly not how the term is used now. I gave you two quotes from different sources.

Edited by Mapletree (09 Jan 2019 11.55am)

I did say I was sorry you felt that way and regarding what's in bold, that isn't the case. I'm still saying exactly that.

We've got off topic here, so in summary:

I don't believe that you called Steve Parish and persuaded him not to move you and I'm against the club caving to the boycott.
You support the club's allocation of certain rows in block E as a singing section and feel it's going to great for the club.

Both of the above are personal opinions and do not reflect either person's character and should be equally respected.


 

Midlands Eagle Flag 09 Jan 19 12.39pm

We have a chat room here [Link] where forum members can wave their handbags at each other without trying to dominate threads with personal arguments that are absolutely of no interest to anyone else.

No more personal digs on this thread please

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Jan 19 12.59pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

We have a chat room here [Link] where forum members can wave their handbags at each other without trying to dominate threads with personal arguments that are absolutely of no interest to anyone else.

No more personal digs on this thread please

Very well

I believe I have previously stated that if anyone of the Block E 400 wants me to explain to them what I have done in order to stay put they are welcome to PM me. That offer still stands.

Having stood in the singing section against Grimsby, I felt it worked quite well but I don't think that is all there is. When we have a normal league game in my opinion the influence of the singing section will be felt more.

I didn't have a strong view before this year but I now believe the HF is correct. It was going backwards and not progressing and required a shot in the arm. To me it has become even clearer what a difference it makes.

On the other hand, as I state in the very first post on this thread, the process of setting up the singing section and moving all singers has been handled very poorly. I feel extremely sad about that, knowing many people who have no choice other than to move away from people they have sat with for 23 years. They are also walking away from emotional memories. I hope, but don't trust, that they will move to seats that are good albeit there aren't better seats in the ground than E Block in my opinion. In talking with HF people, they feel similarly.

I don't agree with the many haters of the HF on this site. They have been measured and thoughtful throughout.

Edited by Mapletree (09 Jan 2019 1.00pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Jan 19 3.18pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Very well

I believe I have previously stated that if anyone of the Block E 400 wants me to explain to them what I have done in order to stay put they are welcome to PM me. That offer still stands.

Having stood in the singing section against Grimsby, I felt it worked quite well but I don't think that is all there is. When we have a normal league game in my opinion the influence of the singing section will be felt more.

I didn't have a strong view before this year but I now believe the HF is correct. It was going backwards and not progressing and required a shot in the arm. To me it has become even clearer what a difference it makes.

On the other hand, as I state in the very first post on this thread, the process of setting up the singing section and moving all singers has been handled very poorly. I feel extremely sad about that, knowing many people who have no choice other than to move away from people they have sat with for 23 years. They are also walking away from emotional memories. I hope, but don't trust, that they will move to seats that are good albeit there aren't better seats in the ground than E Block in my opinion. In talking with HF people, they feel similarly.

I don't agree with the many haters of the HF on this site. They have been measured and thoughtful throughout.

Edited by Mapletree (09 Jan 2019 1.00pm)

Good post. As stated in one of my previous posts on this subject, having met some HF before Grimsby and sat in the singing section, I think they have the club at heart but they do need to try to keep the singing to songs everyone knows and can join in.
Having said all that I too have sympathy for those that have to move. I also feel perhaps the whole club needs a shake up

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Jan 19 3.44pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Good post. As stated in one of my previous posts on this subject, having met some HF before Grimsby and sat in the singing section, I think they have the club at heart but they do need to try to keep the singing to songs everyone knows and can join in.
Having said all that I too have sympathy for those that have to move. I also feel perhaps the whole club needs a shake up

They also need to adapt to what others are doing.

They are useless at joining in with spontaneous singing. I suspect they must have a play list to which they stick.

 

bicycle repair man 09 Jan 19 4.13pm

A "play list", I've heard it all now.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 Jan 19 4.17pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

A "play list", I've heard it all now.

Why don't you scrounge a ticket inside the HF area some time and see what the experience is like.

It's very well organised and a great laugh.

I am sure there will be a singing section for the Spurs game

Or do you just want to stand on the side and snipe?

 

dorking Flag 09 Jan 19 4.18pm

Mapletree is still using a long term season ticket purchased during Simon Jordan's tenure. Therefore I have every reason to believe that he could (and has been able to) persuade those in charge at CPFC that he should be allowed to stay within the area to be designated the Singing Section.

After all, a 50% discount on next years season ticket is of no use to him, as he has already paid for next years season ticket!

The SS is circa 400 seats, more than enough to accommodate all of the HF, and then still have room for him.

 

Page 69 of 71 < 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic