You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Steve Parish thread
November 16 2026 7.06am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Steve Parish thread


Page 7 of 19 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
the.universal 27 Feb 18 10.34pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

As I have said about 87 times - Parish should keep a hold of the club but recognize he is a woefully inept chairman when it comes to transfers and managerial matters.

He is a businessman, and should run the non footballing matters at the club.

Give those other tasks, lock stock, to someone already at the club or bring a fresh face in.

Then we might actually:

Sell some dead wood for once....
Have a proper goalkeeper the manager actually wants to play, and more than 1....
Be able to properly run a transfer window....
Have actual squad depth in key areas like up front

As Parish often says "the sun will come up" even if we go down, but it will hamper the development of the stadium, and all the rest of the things we should be modernizing. I know Parish has done a lot there (an area where he actually does know his a^se from his elbow) but of course more is needed.

Parish inept in managerial appointments?! Whatever he can be accused of it’s not that. Holloway (to get us up) Pulis, Allardyce, Pardew, Hodgson. The good far outweighs the bad.

 


Vive le Roy!

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 27 Feb 18 10.42pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Whats your point? That we had some sh&t players and managers in the past? Yep....

And....?

Ade Akinbiyi was a poor man's Cameron Jerome. Alex Kolinko was poor man's Alex Mccarthy. Trevor Francis was a poor man's George Burley.

I have followed Palace all my life, which stretches back a bit further than 5 years ago (believe it or not )

I have 7 words which might mean something to you:

Steve Parish is a totally inept chairman.

No he is not!

The Oystons,that Cellino chap, Ashley - They're all totally inept chairman.

Steve's better than most - incl. (by some distance) Uncle Ron

But

He isn't learning from his mistakes & (more worryingly) he seems to be too keen to play Russian roulette to ensure we get a good deal, which is just resulting in lost acquisitions (Niasse) & too late acquisitions (Guaita)

The fact that Pulis & Allardyce both jumped ship + the fact Roy will prob do the same after the Guaita fiasco mean SP's tenure is rapidly erasing the credits with debits.

 

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 27 Feb 18 11.52pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Well, simply put, that's silly. It is not supported by the evidence.

Main points in his favor: He purchased the club in 2010; the team got promoted in 2013; we have been to one cup final (only our second proper cup final ever); we have achieved the longest consecutive period in the top flight in the club's 113 years of history; the club has had four of its highest ever league finishes; the club owns its own ground (again); they have improved the facilities (although there is a way to go); they have plans in place to expand the ground (also a ways to go); we have one of our best ever first 11, with only the 1990-91 side clearly better (albeit most of the current lot seem to be semi-permanently injured).

Main points against: consecutive poor transfer windows; over-promises when he should keep quiet; imbalanced squad (albeit one horrifically ravaged by injuries); troubles with FFP (presumably because of some of the dross still on the books); we have struggled to hold onto managers (although that has not always been his fault); hmmm, that's about it.

So, we have had four of our best six (or seven) finishes in the league ever, only our second ever proper cup final, and we have been in the top division for a longer consecutive spell than in our entire history and yet, you claim, he is totally inept.

That is simply put, bizarre.

The above post relieves me the effort of saying it myself...a totally accurate and fair analysis of CPFC 2010's enormous and admirable record. Steve only became chairman at a later stage after the group of Palace supporting businessmen saved us from 10 years of Jordan chaos.

It is hard for a veteran supporter to understand why the whine of criticism still goes on and on here. Yes mistakes have been made...to err is human.

On the whole, the mistakes are small compared with the club's progress and prospective improvements.

Edited by Jamesey (27 Feb 2018 11.55pm)

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 28 Feb 18 12.40am

Originally posted by the.universal

Parish inept in managerial appointments?! Whatever he can be accused of it’s not that. Holloway (to get us up) Pulis, Allardyce, Pardew, Hodgson. The good far outweighs the bad.


you should remove holloway that guy almost cost us getting promoted Freedman was the guy who put us in promotion spot.

the other thing is you are half telling the story pulis and allardyce both walked after 1 season and pardew dont care he got us to cup final that bloke is a joke and we paid newcastle something like 5-6m for him

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 28 Feb 18 2.51am

Originally posted by Jamesey

The above post relieves me the effort of saying it myself...a totally accurate and fair analysis of CPFC 2010's enormous and admirable record. Steve only became chairman at a later stage after the group of Palace supporting businessmen saved us from 10 years of Jordan chaos.

It is hard for a veteran supporter to understand why the whine of criticism still goes on and on here. Yes mistakes have been made...to err is human.

On the whole, the mistakes are small compared with the club's progress and prospective improvements.

Edited by Jamesey (27 Feb 2018 11.55pm)

Second that...wholeheartedly!

 

AppleSource Flag Tel Aviv 28 Feb 18 7.59am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

It seems to be popular consensus to blame Parish for our current predicament, whether it be his appointment of De Boer or his lack of investment in the transfer windows. Whilst there is indeed a reasonable case to be made, those that criticise must recognise that it is only by virtue of Parish that we are in existence and in the PL, let alone enjoying our fifth consecutive season in it. You may point to a lack of managerial stability in recent years, but we simply speculate on reasons for this. Considering the circumstances we have found ourselves in (vis a vis Pulis, Big Sam, etc), I doubt that you would find many chairmen capable of weathering the storm and keeping us up. It is easy to jump on the bandwagon, but I am convinced that Parish is the best man for the job, and although I regrettably predict us being relegated (in no small part due to our unprecedented injury crisis), with Parish we stand as good a chance as anyone of returning to the PL.

 

Bearcage Flag Welling 28 Feb 18 8.04am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

Don’t give up on the PL too early, although I think over the next couple of games we’ll slip into the bottom three, we’ve then a series of very winnable games and players returning from injury, which should enable us to pull clear again.

 

AppleSource Flag Tel Aviv 28 Feb 18 8.19am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

It seems to be popular consensus to blame Parish for our current predicament, whether it be his appointment of De Boer or his lack of investment in the transfer windows. Whilst there is indeed a reasonable case to be made, those that criticise must recognise that it is only by virtue of Parish that we are in existence and in the PL, let alone enjoying our fifth consecutive season in it. You may point to a lack of managerial stability in recent years, but we simply speculate on reasons for this. Considering the circumstances we have found ourselves in (vis a vis Pulis, Big Sam, etc), I doubt that you would find many chairmen capable of weathering the storm and keeping us up. It is easy to jump on the bandwagon, but I am convinced that Parish is the best man for the job, and although I regrettably predict us being relegated (in no small part due to our unprecedented injury crisis), with Parish we stand as good a chance as anyone of returning to the PL.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 28 Feb 18 8.24am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by AppleSource

It seems to be popular consensus to blame Parish for our current predicament, whether it be his appointment of De Boer or his lack of investment in the transfer windows. Whilst there is indeed a reasonable case to be made, those that criticise must recognise that it is only by virtue of Parish that we are in existence and in the PL, let alone enjoying our fifth consecutive season in it. You may point to a lack of managerial stability in recent years, but we simply speculate on reasons for this. Considering the circumstances we have found ourselves in (vis a vis Pulis, Big Sam, etc), I doubt that you would find many chairmen capable of weathering the storm and keeping us up. It is easy to jump on the bandwagon, but I am convinced that Parish is the best man for the job, and although I regrettably predict us being relegated (in no small part due to our unprecedented injury crisis), with Parish we stand as good a chance as anyone of returning to the PL.

Have a day off Steve
Haven’t you got some water skiing to do?

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 28 Feb 18 8.35am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

It's not personal, it's the same old mistakes repeating, unprecedented injuries include players we have bought known to be sick notes, sorry, the " if he can stay healthy " transfer.

Rather than have a chairman who from time to time does an interview asnd wistfully regrets his mistakes, can we have a professional who makes fewer mistakes.

If by luck we stay up this year it will only be delaying the inevitable

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Feb 18 8.42am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by AppleSource

It seems to be popular consensus to blame Parish for our current predicament, whether it be his appointment of De Boer or his lack of investment in the transfer windows. Whilst there is indeed a reasonable case to be made, those that criticise must recognise that it is only by virtue of Parish that we are in existence and in the PL, let alone enjoying our fifth consecutive season in it. You may point to a lack of managerial stability in recent years, but we simply speculate on reasons for this. Considering the circumstances we have found ourselves in (vis a vis Pulis, Big Sam, etc), I doubt that you would find many chairmen capable of weathering the storm and keeping us up. It is easy to jump on the bandwagon, but I am convinced that Parish is the best man for the job, and although I regrettably predict us being relegated (in no small part due to our unprecedented injury crisis), with Parish we stand as good a chance as anyone of returning to the PL.

I still believe we can stay up but I agree with your defence of SP. We all want managerial stability but we are not alone. There are only 5 Premier league managers who have served 3 or more years with the same club. If they are no good they get sacked and if you do get a good one chances are a bigger club will poach them.

 


One more point

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Feb 18 9.23am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Question. If Roy retired and Parish got in a decent manager, would you be happier with Roy completely running the club's transfers and policy than Parish? Or would you rely on Parish learning from this season's mistakes?

No need to claim people want Parish out then, is there?

Anyone? Or is it Parish controls everything or we hang him from the arfur gantry?

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Feb 18 9.28am

Originally posted by AppleSource

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

It seems to be popular consensus to blame Parish for our current predicament, whether it be his appointment of De Boer or his lack of investment in the transfer windows. Whilst there is indeed a reasonable case to be made, those that criticise must recognise that it is only by virtue of Parish that we are in existence and in the PL, let alone enjoying our fifth consecutive season in it. You may point to a lack of managerial stability in recent years, but we simply speculate on reasons for this. Considering the circumstances we have found ourselves in (vis a vis Pulis, Big Sam, etc), I doubt that you would find many chairmen capable of weathering the storm and keeping us up. It is easy to jump on the bandwagon, but I am convinced that Parish is the best man for the job, and although I regrettably predict us being relegated (in no small part due to our unprecedented injury crisis), with Parish we stand as good a chance as anyone of returning to the PL.

This last bit is the most frustrating thing to read on here. We'll have to rebuild the team, almost completely, and play against well oiled opponents. Get used to that when we go down, not straight up to the top 3.

Please try and separate Parish's first few seasons and the last. If I were him I'd definitely concede it's not happening and get someone else to take control of transfers and policy.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Feb 18 9.30am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by HKOwen

It's not personal, it's the same old mistakes repeating, unprecedented injuries include players we have bought known to be sick notes, sorry, the " if he can stay healthy " transfer.

Rather than have a chairman who from time to time does an interview asnd wistfully regrets his mistakes, can we have a professional who makes fewer mistakes.

If by luck we stay up this year it will only be delaying the inevitable

It's at this point someone would hand over transfers to someone else and just step in from time to time.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Feb 18 9.32am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

As I said on the other thread to the copy and pasted post, we won't stand as good a chance as any to get promoted. This is the most misguided view around. We'll be rebuilding virtually the whole team, with, you know what, transfers! This vs teams who've been together years, peaking even more, scoring 3 goals a game, in the top 8 every season.

Get used to new problems if we go down.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Feb 18 9.37am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by HKOwen

It's not personal, it's the same old mistakes repeating, unprecedented injuries include players we have bought known to be sick notes, sorry, the " if he can stay healthy " transfer.

Rather than have a chairman who from time to time does an interview asnd wistfully regrets his mistakes, can we have a professional who makes fewer mistakes.

If by luck we stay up this year it will only be delaying the inevitable

Weren't the only mistakes Steve admitted to Frank and letting Fraizer f'ing Campbell go? In answer to one striker- 'What if the sun doesn't rise tomorrow?' The arrogance of it. If it wasn't for the amazing points Roy earned Parish would look the silliest prem manager ever, but that amazing run has been a factor in these injuries. Fail to prepare and prepare to fail.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Feb 18 9.42am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

As I said on the other thread to the copy and pasted post, we won't stand as good a chance as any to get promoted. This is the most misguided view around. We'll be rebuilding virtually the whole team, with, you know what, transfers! This vs teams who've been together years, peaking even more, scoring 3 goals a game, in the top 8 every season.

Get used to new problems if we go down.

Rudi

We are singing from the same hymn sheet on this subject.

Burnley came straight back up but they never had to undergo a major rebuilding job.As for transfers - they signed Andre Gray who scored 25 goals for them in their promotion season.Also Tarkowski who was signed after they went down has proved a brilliant acquisition - for a fee of £3 Mill.

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 28 Feb 18 9.46am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Anyone? Or is it Parish controls everything or we hang him from the arfur gantry?

Is that why the stadium upgrade has it removed?
Overall SP(+3) has done a very good job; its frustrating that he does not seem to have learnt a couple of lessons along the way; I really hope that the close season will bring a different approach to previous transfer windows. That will be time to judge SP IMHO.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 28 Feb 18 10.03am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

Wouldn't it be nice if the Chairman disclosed each summer and January how much you have in the transfer kitty to spend, which would be very enlightening and utterly transparent for the fans but it would hardly help the powers that be negotiate transfer targets as the other teams will know too and will exploit it to their advantage.

Before too much criticism is laid regarding expenditure at anyone's door and particularly SP's, does anyone on this board know for definite and I don't mean, "I read it somewhere", definite:

a) How much money we had available at the last two windows?

b) What restrictions FFP have had on our dealings?

Both of the above are crucial to understanding our dealings and why some deals struggled to get over the line. For example, Amadou or whatever his name is, wanted to come to the club, the other team wanted to sell him, but we wanted to do a loan with a payment in the summer. Now is this because of FFP, lack of money to outright purchase now, or just poor negotiating. I guarantee that very few people actually know the real answer to this question.

SP is not without his failings and I believe he is a good chairman, although I don't believe that he should be involved in depth in the transfer market. He should give a budget to Dougie and Roy and say anything that falls outside that budget becomes an exceptional purchase and will require full board approval, just like any big company.

He should run the company and it's money and let the rest of the guys do their jobs. Now it may be that this is exactly how Palace is run, but as many have said on here and is probably more likely, he has probably had too much influence in the negotiations.

Overall I think he could do better, however I wouldn't swap him for the Ashley's or Abramovich's of this world.

We are Palace, enjoy it, its a real, not a bought experience being a supporter.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Feb 18 10.09am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'A Passionate Defence OF Steve Parish ' by Midlands Eagle

I think there are issues with our transfer policy, but I also think the insanely over-inflated market for PL clubs looking to buy even fairly average players means it must be really hard to do business. In January, of our relegation rivals, West Ham spent big on an average championship striker and brought in an ageing LB (although Jao Mario looked good against us), West Brom had to pay big wages for a crocked striker, Newcastle had no money to spend and had to rely on loans, Southampton bought a striker but didn't buy a defender (despite getting £75m for Dick van Dyke), Huddersfield signed one centre back...the list goes on. As much as I hate to say it, Brighton actually appear to have done the best business.

My point is, the grass is not greener elsewhere, I just think the reality is that outside of maybe 8 clubs the rest are starting to realise they cannot stay within FFP and cope with the prices in the current market. Parish has tried to get us reasonable deals and has had his fingers burned by his approach, but as I've said in previous posts, I think our signing of younger players and the pre-contract for the Spanish goalkeeper suggests we are taking a slightly longer view, albeit we have to hang on for PL survival. I don't think the club will be making any £20-30 million signings again in the next couple of years (if we stay up) and instead will look to try and build a solid team, rather than an average one with a few stars. That is also the approach I think Roy would want, if he stays on.

When we have one GK and only two senior strikers I think people have a right to ask questions, but I don't think it is simple as we need a GK/striker, we go into Lidl and get one. Rather it's more akin to eBay and you have to wait until the last minute when the stakes are higher. Hopefully there'll be more buy-it-now options in the summer

 

Page 7 of 19 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Steve Parish thread