You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > It's all gone quite on the left
November 21 2026 11.59pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

It's all gone quite on the left


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Stirlingsays Flag 08 Aug 17 6.52pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

What's happening in Venezuela isn't socialism.

What happened in Venezuela was ideological socialism...Chevez destroyed the private sector and investment and was guilty of many many human rights abuses...even when your mate was praising him to the hills....Just like many praised that murderer Castro.

What's happening now is authoritarianism....which can be independent of left or right.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 08 Aug 17 7.01pm

Whatever political system emerges in Venezuela they will have to cope with their dependence upon oil revenue.

The price crashed which is not too much of a problem with market fluctuations but this time the demand has probably gone forever and that is their oil is just no longer required.

The necessary diversity into other industries during the times of plenty did not happen.

Saudis have been preparing for the time when the oil runs out looks like they didn't here.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Aug 17 7.15pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Whatever political system emerges in Venezuela they will have to cope with their dependence upon oil revenue.

The price crashed which is not too much of a problem with market fluctuations but this time the demand has probably gone forever and that is their oil is just no longer required.

The necessary diversity into other industries during the times of plenty did not happen.

Saudis have been preparing for the time when the oil runs out looks like they didn't here.

According to what I've seen Chavez did try to diversity....but it failed....funny but it turns out that business people aren't that willing to invest their cash when the government is shouting 'revolution' every ten minutes.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

chris123 Flag hove actually 08 Aug 17 7.22pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

According to what I've seen Chavez did try to diversity....but it failed....funny but it turns out that business people aren't that willing to invest their cash when the government is shouting 'revolution' every ten minutes.

They used to big coffee producers.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 08 Aug 17 7.28pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

According to what I've seen Chavez did try to diversity....but it failed....funny but it turns out that business people aren't that willing to invest their cash when the government is shouting 'revolution' every ten minutes.

Why would anybody want to impose sanctions upon Venezuela how could it possibly help the average Venezuelan?

Russia has the right attitude to sanctions, stay strong they can do their worst.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Aug 17 8.38pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Why would anybody want to impose sanctions upon Venezuela how could it possibly help the average Venezuelan?

Russia has the right attitude to sanctions, stay strong they can do their worst.

You should go and live there.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 08 Aug 17 9.12pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You should go and live there.

Did you also blow a raspberry while you typed that?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Aug 17 9.41pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Did you also blow a raspberry while you typed that?

I felt compelled to post that given the poster concerned.

If it had been you I'd have sent a picture of a robot.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Aug 17 5.06am

Originally posted by hedgehog50

Governments on their own can't achieve these things, you need to encourage and support business to create a successful economy and let market forces work out. The Venezeulan government has done the opposite with predictable results.


Edited by hedgehog50 (08 Aug 2017 5.54pm)

Yeah I agree with this to an extent, you can only achieve results if you include all of society pulling together towards a goal - but that also means regulation of industry and business to prevent it becoming exploitive. Business is a part of society not separate to it. If you don't you have the prevalent situation across the world where in business profits only the few rather than all. Prwe Chavez capitalism in the country was also failing to provide for the people of Venezuela resulting in the rise in of socialism.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Aug 17 5.26am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Yeah I agree with this to an extent, you can only achieve results if you include all of society pulling together towards a goal - but that also means regulation of industry and business to prevent it becoming exploitive. Business is a part of society not separate to it. If you don't you have the prevalent situation across the world where in business profits only the few rather than all. Prwe Chavez capitalism in the country was also failing to provide for the people of Venezuela resulting in the rise in of socialism.

I agree to an extent....what was it before Cameron got into power, no one at the top should earn more than...20 to 1...compared to the lowest paid employee.

On an ethical level I think most of us...outside of rabid capitalists could agree with some figure like that.....However, on a practical level how on earth do you enforce that and not have business say....look I'm investing somewhere else where we can have a similar safe environment but our people can earn a lot more?....Where do you think the talent is going to go?

It works in a world with one government or limited choices but it doesn't work in a competitive global economy.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Aug 17 1.33pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I agree to an extent....what was it before Cameron got into power, no one at the top should earn more than...20 to 1...compared to the lowest paid employee.

On an ethical level I think most of us...outside of rabid capitalists could agree with some figure like that.....However, on a practical level how on earth do you enforce that and not have business say....look I'm investing somewhere else where we can have a similar safe environment but our people can earn a lot more?....Where do you think the talent is going to go?

It works in a world with one government or limited choices but it doesn't work in a competitive global economy.

If we take a basic assumption that someone at the bottom is earning 20k a year in a corporate company - then the top bracket is 400k a year - Even with Bonus schemes maybe 1%

And behind them, are any number of 'next generation' high flyers waiting for a chance to replace them

Which isn't likely to create a 'massive exodus of talent', and of course where would they go; the demand for top level executives isn't really going to be well suited by a deluge of individuals.

In truth I think you'd need to make exceptions for legitimate investors, owners and shareholders earnings and tackle that separately.

Sure investors could go elsewhere - but then the government would need to restrict their access to British Markets and profits from the UK.

Its only really those at the very top that are likely to be earning 400k per year....

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

matt_himself Flag Matataland 09 Aug 17 2.52pm

Maradona supports Maduro:

[Link]

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Aug 17 3.06pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

If we take a basic assumption that someone at the bottom is earning 20k a year in a corporate company - then the top bracket is 400k a year - Even with Bonus schemes maybe 1%

And behind them, are any number of 'next generation' high flyers waiting for a chance to replace them

Which isn't likely to create a 'massive exodus of talent', and of course where would they go; the demand for top level executives isn't really going to be well suited by a deluge of individuals.

In truth I think you'd need to make exceptions for legitimate investors, owners and shareholders earnings and tackle that separately.

Sure investors could go elsewhere - but then the government would need to restrict their access to British Markets and profits from the UK.

Its only really those at the very top that are likely to be earning 400k per year....

Nice idea....not going to work.

Can't you see that the moment you restrict that access and profits you are giving out the message....look elsewhere for your next investment. You just aren't going to get the same levels of investment and hence jobs. That then has a waterfall effect..... The lists of competitors for that investment are numerous.

I like the idea of your first paragraph but I know that it doesn't work.

You may support forcing people into silence at the risk of them losing their jobs in companies for whatever 'wrong think' you list...but the moment you tell a company how much they can earn, those jobs aren't going to be there for you to impose your ideology on in the first place.

You might be in a position not to suffer from that....But I come from a council estate and I taught council estate kids and I very much disagree with opportunity being taken away because 'progressives' think fairy land can exist in the business world.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Aug 17 3.51pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Nice idea....not going to work.

Can't you see that the moment you restrict that access and profits you are giving out the message....look elsewhere for your next investment. You just aren't going to get the same levels of investment and hence jobs. That then has a waterfall effect..... The lists of competitors for that investment are numerous.

I like the idea of your first paragraph but I know that it doesn't work.

You may support forcing people into silence at the risk of them losing their jobs in companies for whatever 'wrong think' you list...but the moment you tell a company how much they can earn, those jobs aren't going to be there for you to impose your ideology on in the first place.

You might be in a position not to suffer from that....But I come from a council estate and I taught council estate kids and I very much disagree with opportunity being taken away because 'progressives' think fairy land can exist in the business world.


Like I said, I think you'd need to make exception for people who are investors in companies, shareholders, partners etc. because they have an additional financial commitment to the firm and consequently additional risks.

I like the idea, but you'd need to specifically allow for people to earn income off their investments as being separate from their salary. The commitment of time is different from personal financial risk. I don't think you can see investments in the same light as Salaried income from working - nor should we.

If I earned 200k and then my investment pays me 400k in a year, I don't think it would be fair to consider that 400k salary.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Aug 17 5.37pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

That's not correct Tony Blair did everything possible to avoid war which The USA wanted without the UN.

Sadaam was required by UN resolutions to state that he did not have weapons of mass destruction which he repeatedly failed not to do. Why we don't know as in fact he did not have.

All he had to do was send his representative to cross a NY street and say that.

That would have meant the UK not being at war as he had complied with UN resolutions.

If you don't answer a summons you will be presumed guilty that's true for all of us.

Tony Blair is a lawyer it is his training and what he believes in.

Sadaam was a monster but not cunning just stupid.

Tony Blair also accepted intelligence which turned out to be wrong so be careful Prime Ministers of just accepting what MI5 etc. say.

Although you can't do that as they will say they can't jeopardise their secrecy. Nothing like having your cake and eating it is there.


Hahahhahahahahaha... yeah right. The other one has bells on. The UK and US are in the business of liberating countries from oppressive regimes....

Even if the Iraqi's had sent their representatives and allowed UN weapon inspectors back in, the US was already beating a drum about them hiding weapons of mass destruction.

And then after all that solid convincing evidence turned out to be 'a piles of very selected lies from very bias sources, that even the intelligence agencies were questioning, it was all about regime change.

Iraq was about pushing huge revenues of government capital into private industry, securing oil reserves and distributing very lucrative contracts to private firms.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 09 Aug 17 6.01pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Hahahhahahahahaha... yeah right. The other one has bells on. The UK and US are in the business of liberating countries from oppressive regimes....

Even if the Iraqi's had sent their representatives and allowed UN weapon inspectors back in, the US was already beating a drum about them hiding weapons of mass destruction.

And then after all that solid convincing evidence turned out to be 'a piles of very selected lies from very bias sources, that even the intelligence agencies were questioning, it was all about regime change.

Iraq was about pushing huge revenues of government capital into private industry, securing oil reserves and distributing very lucrative contracts to private firms.


Apart from Kurdish operated fields in the north, most Iraqi oil is state operated. China is Iraq's largest customer by some margin.

Edited by chris123 (09 Aug 2017 6.17pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 09 Aug 17 6.01pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Iraq was about pushing huge revenues of government capital into private industry, securing oil reserves and distributing very lucrative contracts to private firms.


If oil were a major factor for prosecuting war in Iraq, it stands to reason the United States would be getting substantial amounts of it.

In 2013 the overwhelming percentage of American imported oil did not come from the Middle East. Canada and Latin America provide the United States with 34.7 percent of their imported oil. Africa provides another 10.3 percent. The entire Persian Gulf, led by Saudi Arabia at 8.1 percent, provides them with a total of 12.9 percent of their imported oil.

As recently as December 2012, Iraq provided the United States with approximately 14.3 million barrels of oil out of a total of about 298 million barrels imported, or 4.8 percent of their total imports. Rather pointedly for your argument, America was importing the highest amount of oil from Iraq before they went to war to oust Saddam Hussein.

If America went to war in Iraq mostly for oil, it would stand to reason that they would maintain a stranglehold on both their supply and production. Ten years after the war began, China has emerged as one of the main beneficiaries of a relatively stable Iraqi government and a country that, after two decades, is poised to become the world's third largest oil exporter. Trade between Iraq and China has doubled almost 34 times, soaring from $517 million in 2002, to $17.5 billion by the end of last year.

As for the war in Iraq in general, people can disagree about whether removing Saddam Hussein was the right thing to do. And they can certainly question the necessity of nation-building. But it is simply revisionist history to suggest that anti-oil Democratic politicians, weren't every bit as concerned with the danger the Saddam Hussein regime posed as Republicans were. Authorizing the use of force was a bipartisan effort based on a shared if faulty interpretation of the same security intelligence.

As for oil, if getting it was one of the primary reasons the west liberated Iraq, subsequent developments have demonstrated that effort was a colossal failure.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 09 Aug 17 6.07pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Hahahhahahahahaha... yeah right. The other one has bells on. The UK and US are in the business of liberating countries from oppressive regimes....

Even if the Iraqi's had sent their representatives and allowed UN weapon inspectors back in, the US was already beating a drum about them hiding weapons of mass destruction.

And then after all that solid convincing evidence turned out to be 'a piles of very selected lies from very bias sources, that even the intelligence agencies were questioning, it was all about regime change.

Iraq was about pushing huge revenues of government capital into private industry, securing oil reserves and distributing very lucrative contracts to private firms.

Estimates of the cost to the USA of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars are between 1 and 4 trillion dollars, plus the loss of lives of course. Is that covered by your 'lucrative contracts'?

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 09 Aug 17 7.21pm

I was surprised at JM mocking my post and I repeat as it is concise and only pointing out 1 thing which all the reports and inquiries miss.

If Sadaam had complied with UN resolutions and not ignored them all the UK would not have been legally able to go to war.

Sadaam did not have weapons of mass destruction and all that was necessary was to say that at the UN, that would have complied with the UN. resolutions.

The attorney general would have advised that there was no legal basis for war and in fact I am sure it was the govts. position.

Tony Blair is an experienced lawyer he would not go to war if UN resolutions were complied with, as a resulting war would be illegal and he would be responsible.

Why did Sadaam not comply with this simple resolution when he did not have WOMD anyway??

TB prosecuting a war when UN resolutions were complied with? I don't think so.

Ok the USA would have by-passed the UN but Blair took the matter to the UN to make the case for war water-tight.

If you don't reply or acknowledge the law there is no option but to find you guilty.

 

davenotamonkey Flag 09 Aug 17 10.03pm

Originally posted by serial thriller


Poland! Wow...

It's actually funny that you compare the two. The Polish parliament has recently been trying to alter the constitution by electing members to the Supreme Court themselves, rather than having them as independents. Pretty similar to what's going on in Venezuela.

The problem with talking about Venezuela is no one who wants to parade it as a symbol of Socialism gone wrong ever wants to seriously discuss it. Venezuela has a very, very complicated establishment and constitution, with many competing interests vying for position. Arguably, it has never been a Socialist country (the wealth of the richest actually increased under Chavez, even as they were trying to organise a coup against him).

Maduro may be a bit authoritarian, but you would have to ask what the alternative is.
If Venezuela were to switch to, say, a Columbian style of oil ownership, the social security of millions of its citizens would be eradicated.

Could you clarify how Poland's legislative change (which was part of the ruling party's election manifesto) differs from the German* parliament appointing judges to it's highest court? Actually... don't even bother. You're just sucking deep and hard on the pro-EU anti-anything-EUsceptic propaganda that Poland = Bad because Poland = right.

* Or Sweden, or the US, or the Netherlands, or Austria.

Here's an example article of how Germany appoints judges:

[Link]

Poland wants the ability to do the same. This initiative, proposed by a right-wing government, automatically triggers the EUloons, as they cannot stand it if a nation state thus-aligned begins to exercise it's democratic and sovereign rights. Hence all the (on-doubt) Soros et al. funded EUwailing.

I would suggest the EU take Poland to the European Court of Justice, so they can face the judges appointed by... um... oh, member state governments. Oops

As to the rest of your post - the old "it's not really socialism" trope wears a bit thin when Corbyn et al have in the past praised it as the enlightened way forwards. Now listen to the weasel-worded prikc:

[Link]

Swap/replace with his IRA spiel. Same old.

And yeah, Maduro is indeed a "bit" authoritarian, but (silly me) I would ask that the alternative is to NOT "disappear" your political opponents.

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > It's all gone quite on the left