You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tax on pensioners proposed
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tax on pensioners proposed


Page 7 of 11 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 18 4.17pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

My experience is that the currently retired people were dreadful at looking after their parents. Very selfish generation from just post war. They were also rubbish at looking after their grandchildren


Clearly your experience Maple...not mine though. My parents (post war babies) are extremely family oriented...its my generation that are not (70's children)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 4.18pm

Originally posted by becky

So, by your criteria, if contributions made do not permit retirees to free healthcare after retirement, I would ask where you stand on those who have NEVER made ANY contribution to the welfare system? Non-working spouses, benefit claimants & children - after all if one's contributions do not cover one's own costs why, by your precedent, should your children's be entitled either? Where do you draw the line on eligibility over contribution?

I don't Becky

I just say the argument that people have already paid is spurious.

In my opinion retired people with large incomes should still contribute a part of their income in national insurance, just as they do in income tax. It doesn't matter how that income is earned, nor how old they are. It is an anachronistic anomaly.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 4.21pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Clearly your experience Maple...not mine though. My parents (post war babies) are extremely family oriented...its my generation that are not (70's children)

I sit in between your parents and you. My experience is that my generation uses the benefits of good pensions and decent housing in support of their grandchildren. My mother's generation, however, just couldn't believe its luck. She was brought up during the war and her generation lived for the day, always knowing it could be their last. Despite the constant threats hanging over them, it seems they largely had a good time back then and continued it into their octogenarian years.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 18 4.23pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Yeah, selfish kids. Fancy wanting to prepare themselves to compete in the global market.

Should leave that to Canada, South Korea and Lithuania.


The point I make is a valid one...we ALL have a choice...University (knowing you'll run up a debt) is a CHOICE. So if you make that; you do so knowing that it'll be harder to get on the property ladder as it currently exists.

I believe that University education is overdone though...i never went and my abstinence never did me any harm ...along with thousands of others; and yet,so many people fall into the trap (and backward thinking) that its the ONLY way to get on and, feigning offence at the merest suggestion that its not all its cracked up to be, as they realise it may well be they're looking at the naked empower!

The irony being that now its open to everyone...it's being hoisted by its own petard as it becomes a greater irrelevance; as what once was a guarantee of a job (post qualification) its not...because everyone has one.


Edited by Lyons550 (09 May 2018 4.29pm)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 4.25pm

Originally posted by elgrande

Well for a start the post office screwed over the workers on their pensions,and that's before it was sold off.

I have no doubt you are correct.

It wasn't individual companies, it was the market that dictated the need for DB pensions.

Now any organisation that employed large numbers during e.g. the 1970s has a huge continuing cost hanging around its neck. It is to be expected some will try to duck out of as much as they can, although it may not be ethical.

Meanwhile newcomer organisations like DHL or easyJet make hay given their far lower costs.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 18 4.27pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I sit in between your parents and you. My experience is that my generation uses the benefits of good pensions and decent housing in support of their grandchildren. My mother's generation, however, just couldn't believe its luck. She was brought up during the war and her generation lived for the day, always knowing it could be their last. Despite the constant threats hanging over them, it seems they largely had a good time back then and continued it into their octogenarian years.


So in essence you'd agree then. My parents would do the same (looking after their grandchildren financially) being closer to your age then myself...there's def a clear distinction with the rise of Yuppies and selfishness that's for certain...

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 18 4.58pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Quite so.

I find the argument that people have a right to free NHS treatment when retired - as they contributed all of their lives - risible. The calculation is complex but let's say they mostly paid in - in today's money - around £2,000 to £2,500 per annum.

Currently the NHS spend is around £2,200 per person. 31.5m people are in work of a population totaling 66.5m. So the amount each working person would need to contribute per year to cover current needs is over £4,600.

Alternatively an individual that lives for 80 years and works for 50 would need to pay in £3,520 per annum to have 'banked' enough to pay for their inclusion in the system.

It's a well rehearsed point that our current retirees - if they have pensions - probably have defined benefit ones. These are crippling businesses like British Airways, BT and Royal Mail and allowing competitors to overtake them. Why shouldn't such people contribute for the increasing costs of their healthcare. The cost per head when the NHS started up was approx £230 in today's money. So in real terms it has risen nearly ten fold, including due to an increasingly aging population.


Great work...so if the government say £750 a year on handing out gym membership do you think that'd save more than enough moving forward due to improved health and well being...?

I've always been an advocate of preventative care.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 5.03pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Great work...so if the government say £750 a year on handing out gym membership do you think that'd save more than enough moving forward due to improved health and well being...?

I've always been an advocate of preventative care.

Do I look like a Doctor? i.e. can you read my writing?

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 5.04pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


So in essence you'd agree then. My parents would do the same (looking after their grandchildren financially) being closer to your age then myself...there's def a clear distinction with the rise of Yuppies and selfishness that's for certain...

No, in essence I disagree.

I don't think people currently in their teens and twenties will be nearly as selfish as those in their 70s and 80s.

Or maybe you are saying it comes in waves and there will be dodgy group now in their 40s and 50s?

Edited by Mapletree (09 May 2018 5.07pm)

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 09 May 18 5.08pm

Originally posted by silvertop

By way of clarity, they have paid tax all their life and got public services back in return. Why should they now pay no tax but still enjoy the same services IF (big if) they can afford to pay as much as someone in the working population?

What has chronology got do do with anything?

As a PS, you are aware that recently the average income for pensioners passed the average income for the waged?

Nonsense ... fixed incomes will never outstrip wages unless you are talking about the one off 3% increase this year? It was measured against cpi last September and it was zero the year before.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 18 5.09pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Do I look like a Doctor? i.e. can you read my writing?

Hahaha I was actually asking for your opinion on whether money towards prevention could be the answer to reducing the excellent figures you pulled together above...

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

becky Flag over the moon 09 May 18 5.12pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I don't Becky

I just say the argument that people have already paid is spurious.

In my opinion retired people with large incomes should still contribute a part of their income in national insurance, just as they do in income tax. It doesn't matter how that income is earned, nor how old they are. It is an anachronistic anomaly.

Originally NI contributions were brought in to pay benefits to working people - sick pay and unemployment benefit when they couldn't work and needed some support. Latterly it came to include a retirement pension contributions as most manual workers and those in smaller organisations didn't get any sort of company pension benefit, let alone a defined one.

Surely, the best way to solve the anomaly would be for the government to do away with split Income Tax and National Insurance contributions and have one graduated tax rate starting at 23%. This would solve a lot of problems in that everyone would contribute according to their income, and be so much simpler and cheaper to administer, however..........

Good Luck to the Chancellor who is prepared to stand up and get that one through!

Edited by becky (09 May 2018 5.13pm)

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 09 May 18 5.13pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

No, in essence I disagree.

I don't think people currently in their teens and twenties will be nearly as selfish as those in their 70s and 80s.

Or maybe you are saying it comes in waves and there will be dodgy group now in their 40s and 50s?

Edited by Mapletree (09 May 2018 5.07pm)


Then you clearly missed the point that I suggested its MY generation (born in the 70'80's) that are the problem and not those now...

Re the 'wave' scenario...I guess it stands to reason that a generation brought up in austerity (post war for eg) would then be a more caring generation...and those who are bought up in an age full of opportunity and wealth are more selfish...again see my earlier comments...

...so in essence you DO agree with me...

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 09 May 18 5.14pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


The point I make is a valid one...we ALL have a choice...University (knowing you'll run up a debt) is a CHOICE. So if you make that; you do so knowing that it'll be harder to get on the property ladder as it currently exists.

I believe that University education is overdone though...i never went and my abstinence never did me any harm ...along with thousands of others; and yet,so many people fall into the trap (and backward thinking) that its the ONLY way to get on and, feigning offence at the merest suggestion that its not all its cracked up to be, as they realise it may well be they're looking at the naked empower!

The irony being that now its open to everyone...it's being hoisted by its own petard as it becomes a greater irrelevance; as what once was a guarantee of a job (post qualification) its not...because everyone has one.


Edited by Lyons550 (09 May 2018 4.29pm)

I agree with your point on universities - speaking first hand, it's without doubt the worst value for money service I've come across in my life, and so far, I've seen no tangible difference in earnings within my friendship group in terms of those with and without degrees.

Having said that, the whole education system channels anyone reasonably intelligent into university (I wonder why). Again, speaking first hand, you are made to feel that it's the only viable option for anyone who wants to be successful - as a teenager, if that's the only source of information you have, of course you're going to apply...

So whilst I agree with your point on universities, I think it's quite a stretch to say it's all about choice - you're asking 17 year olds, who's primary source of information on the topic is an entirely biased one, to make a massive life decision based on what their priorities might be in 10 years time as an adult.

And if they make the wrong choice? Tough, you can't own a property until you're well into your 30s.

Hardly fair is it?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 May 18 5.14pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


The point I make is a valid one...we ALL have a choice...University (knowing you'll run up a debt) is a CHOICE. So if you make that; you do so knowing that it'll be harder to get on the property ladder as it currently exists.

I believe that University education is overdone though...i never went and my abstinence never did me any harm ...along with thousands of others; and yet,so many people fall into the trap (and backward thinking) that its the ONLY way to get on and, feigning offence at the merest suggestion that its not all its cracked up to be, as they realise it may well be they're looking at the naked empower!

The irony being that now its open to everyone...it's being hoisted by its own petard as it becomes a greater irrelevance; as what once was a guarantee of a job (post qualification) its not...because everyone has one.


Edited by Lyons550 (09 May 2018 4.29pm)

Actually my daughter DID have to go to be able to follow the path she wanted to.. yes it was her choice. How do you think youngsters today will get on the property ladder without a decent income (which they will not get now without a degree)? Are you saying that if they choose to pursue a career which involves going to University, it's tough that they accrue so much debt? Nice view,

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 May 18 5.30pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I sit in between your parents and you. My experience is that my generation uses the benefits of good pensions and decent housing in support of their grandchildren. My mother's generation, however, just couldn't believe its luck. She was brought up during the war and her generation lived for the day, always knowing it could be their last. Despite the constant threats hanging over them, it seems they largely had a good time back then and continued it into their octogenarian years.

So you thought you would go with sweeping generalisations today eh?

Of course, people make personal decisions about how to behave. The era from which they come from will dictate attitudes but I rarely see everyone agreeing on one attitude or course of action and I expect that it has never been any different.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 May 18 5.38pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Actually my daughter DID have to go to be able to follow the path she wanted to.. yes it was her choice. How do you think youngsters today will get on the property ladder without a decent income (which they will not get now without a degree)? Are you saying that if they choose to pursue a career which involves going to University, it's tough that they accrue so much debt? Nice view,

I would advise any youngster to think about life after university before they make that choice. Too many people have saddled themselves with debt for careers which do not require a degree. If their chosen career does then so be it but sometimes 3 years of work experience may count for more. There are also plenty of careers where an apprenticeship is far more valuable then a degree.

As to the costs the government has got to get tough with the universities who seem to treat students as a necessary evil to fund their personal research. The lack of time that students get with lecturers is a scandal many degrees could be done in 2 years in which case the costs should fall.

 


One more point

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 09 May 18 5.46pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I have no doubt you are correct.

It wasn't individual companies, it was the market that dictated the need for DB pensions.

Now any organisation that employed large numbers during e.g. the 1970s has a huge continuing cost hanging around its neck. It is to be expected some will try to duck out of as much as they can, although it may not be ethical.

Meanwhile newcomer organisations like DHL or easyJet make hay given their far lower costs.

It is not even legal.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

chris123 Flag hove actually 09 May 18 6.25pm

Many above retirement age do not enjoy final salary pensions, which is why they still have to work - so not paying NI if you're over 65 helps a lot.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 09 May 18 6.30pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Then you clearly missed the point that I suggested its MY generation (born in the 70'80's) that are the problem and not those now...

Re the 'wave' scenario...I guess it stands to reason that a generation brought up in austerity (post war for eg) would then be a more caring generation...and those who are bought up in an age full of opportunity and wealth are more selfish...again see my earlier comments...

...so in essence you DO agree with me...

I do I do

I had misunderstood. I thought you meant everyone after the 70s. My mistake

I do enjoy being agreeable.

 

Page 7 of 11 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tax on pensioners proposed