You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Let's criticise our managers.eh?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Let's criticise our managers.eh?


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
billtheglazier Flag twickenham 14 Apr 19 5.28pm

Ive been viewing, and occasionally been posting topics on this forum for many years and as I get older I must admit to memory failure at times, but one thing i have noticed is the common theme that has been a regular topic or comment,for many,which is regular criticism of our managers.
This in my memory goes back years to the days of Neil Warnock/Peter Taylor/ Iain Dowie from memory.
Before then I didnt use computers.(Parish is also an object of negativity)
Yes I agree its what forums are for but,you know what,I think Roy has done an excellent job to keep us in the 'First tier' of English football.I have spent most of the years I have supported Palace watching us in the lower divisions.
I do wonder whether many of those who criticise his management are also in the habit of attacking others in authority positions outside of football.
It can be quite addictive!
Just a thought.

 


[Link]
Following The Palace since 1956,
Rocking the Blues since 68.!!

davehuggins Flag 14 Apr 19 5.49pm

RH for me has and is doing a brilliant job, today we played one of the best sides in the world so get OFF his back.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 14 Apr 19 5.52pm

I have attacked many in positions of authority over the years especially those who have somehow found themselves in such positions more by luck than anyones good judgment .
I do think Roy has been great for our club though .A stable and calm man who has steadied the ship that could quite easily have fallen apart after the de Boer fiasco .
I would remind detractors of what happened to Stoke City whos fans demanded more expansive football after about the same number of years of 'boring' premiership football .
Ill take boring thanks .

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 14 Apr 19 5.55pm


There was a French rugby coach, might have been Lievremont, who came out after they’d been well beaten and said “do you think I told them to play like that?” A lot of sports coaches and managers will have empathised with him.

 

YT Flag Oxford 14 Apr 19 5.58pm

Originally posted by Elpis

I have attacked many in positions of authority over the years especially those who have somehow found themselves in such positions more by luck than anyones good judgment .
I do think Roy has been great for our club though .A stable and calm man who has steadied the ship that could quite easily have fallen apart after the de Boer fiasco .
I would remind detractors of what happened to Stoke City whos fans demanded more expansive football after about the same number of years of 'boring' premiership football .
Ill take boring thanks .

Progress in life very often comes down to luck. Why should someone in authority through good fortune be open to your attacks? I don't understand your point.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Apr 19 5.58pm

Yep all good comments I feel.

As has been said, this is what forums are for and so that's fine but I appreciate the fact that many recognise the reality that teams like Palace live with in this division.

We are lucky to have a manager like Hodgeson and just because he isn't a miracle worker or very imaginative doesn't mean that he doesn't deserve accolades for the sterling job he has done.

We are a couple of signings and retentions away from moving away from lower mid table to top ten.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Apr 2019 5.59pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 14 Apr 19 6.12pm

Dunno where you're getting this from. Seems to me that the majority on here blindly defend Hodgeson to the point of personal embarrassment. The few amongst us who show dissatisfaction quickly get insulted off the thread.

 

jeeagles Flag 14 Apr 19 6.18pm

Another Roy Hodgson thread.

We were expected to stay up.
Roy has kept us up.
He's met the minimum expectation of him this season.
He's average at best.
He's shown a lack of ambition. He'd rather a narrow defeat than to role the dice to try and win a game.

Players and fans are fed up.

Let's say thank you and let him go over summer.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 14 Apr 19 6.19pm

Yes, let's. Sets up to have no ambition at all and just to limit the score but still concedes 3 and give up enough chances to be 6 down.

the myth that we are playing well just cause we sat back and had no wish to attack at all, thereby forcing City to open us up with ease is just laughable. Shows that people don't actually watch the game. No attempt to adapt to them having 3-5 players in between the lines all game, no pressure on the man in the ball making it easy for them to find said players btl, no attempt to support Benteke who was our one outball to relieve pressure and start counters, no creativity, subs too late

he gets away with absolute murder does Roy. But at least we only conceded 3 while killing the atmosphere, not giving City a thing to worry about when it is clear they panic when their rhythm is disrupted and they can't just go through the rehearsed patterns for 90 mins and have to defend. What a guy.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Apr 19 6.20pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Dunno where you're getting this from. Seems to me that the majority on here blindly defend Hodgeson to the point of personal embarrassment. The few amongst us who show dissatisfaction quickly get insulted off the thread.


If you can't moan on a forum then you can't moan anywhere.

But I certainly think that holistically he's done a good job keeping us up.

But if we lose Zaha and Wan-Bisakka next season could be beyond him.....mind you....why he puts up with the stress of being a football manager at his age I've no idea.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 14 Apr 19 6.20pm

RH has got things wrong this season but I don't think he did much wrong today. I'll be happy if he stays another season.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 14 Apr 19 6.52pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Yep all good comments I feel.

As has been said, this is what forums are for and so that's fine but I appreciate the fact that many recognise the reality that teams like Palace live with in this division.

We are lucky to have a manager like Hodgeson and just because he isn't a miracle worker or very imaginative doesn't mean that he doesn't deserve accolades for the sterling job he has done.

We are a couple of signings and retentions away from moving away from lower mid table to top ten.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Apr 2019 5.59pm)

That’s my take. We are close to being a top 10 side, but not quite there.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 14 Apr 19 7.08pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Dunno where you're getting this from. Seems to me that the majority on here blindly defend Hodgeson to the point of personal embarrassment. The few amongst us who show dissatisfaction quickly get insulted off the thread.

I'm annoyed with myself for responding to this as I'd decided I'd had enough of your predictable anti Hodgson posts and should just ignore them.

You talk about personal embarrassment - you should be well acquainted with that given some of the rubbish you spout on here.

As for getting insulted off of threads, well that's rich coming from somebody that's only been on HOL a short time but has already managed to get a yellow card.

Have a go back if you like. I won't be responding again.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 14 Apr 19 7.26pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I'm annoyed with myself for responding to this as I'd decided I'd had enough of your predictable anti Hodgson posts and should just ignore them.

You talk about personal embarrassment - you should be well acquainted with that given some of the rubbish you spout on here.

As for getting insulted off of threads, well that's rich coming from somebody that's only been on HOL a short time but has already managed to get a yellow card.

Have a go back if you like. I won't be responding again.


Oh but you will Neilly my friend, you can't help yourself.

After all, you've got to police the interweb in case an anonymous person hundreds of miles away dares to express dissatisfaction with the Greatest manager of all time, Roy "pre written resignation letter as plan B" Hodgson.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 14 Apr 19 8.20pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Dunno where you're getting this from. Seems to me that the majority on here blindly defend Hodgeson to the point of personal embarrassment. The few amongst us who show dissatisfaction quickly get insulted off the thread.

I think the point you are missing is, Hodgson is being compared to previous Palace managers by a lot of the longstanding fans. He actually stacks up very well against all of them except Coppell, the rest by and large have had serious flaws, Bruce, Dowie and Pulis were good, but sh_t people, the rest weren't very good.

The new fans expect us to be pushing for Europe, beating all the top teams etc, the reality is it isn't going to happen as we haven't the financial resources of the top teams. The older fans still cant quite believe we are still in the Premier after years of being a yoyo club and see staying here as progression and are happy with Hodgson as he can keep us in there.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Apr 19 8.33pm

Originally posted by Painter

I think the point you are missing is, Hodgson is being compared to previous Palace managers by a lot of the longstanding fans. He actually stacks up very well against all of them except Coppell, the rest by and large have had serious flaws, Bruce, Dowie and Pulis were good, but sh_t people, the rest weren't very good.

The new fans expect us to be pushing for Europe, beating all the top teams etc, the reality is it isn't going to happen as we haven't the financial resources of the top teams. The older fans still cant quite believe we are still in the Premier after years of being a yoyo club and see staying here as progression and are happy with Hodgson as he can keep us in there.

I'm one of these "Older fans" being 66 years old and supporting our team through thick and thin since the 60s.Being in in the PL is far removed from those dark days when our supporters used to get soaked to the skin before crowds of around 6,000.Long may it continue and I am rather relieved season on season when we have avoided the dreaded drop.

 

Brasilian Eagle Flag Londres 14 Apr 19 8.47pm

To quote from Painter I believe that Hodgson should be compared to previous Palace managers and he also should stack up very well against them as this is possibly the best team we have ever had. The exceptions being the Team of the Eighties who finished 10th and Coppell's early 90's side who remarkably finished 3rd.

Roy has a top ten team who manage to stave off relegation with a little to spare and isn't that the issue in question. If that is the best we can hope for, then I concede.

Before the "be care what you wish for" comments begin, both Stoke and Charlton were consistent top ten teams when their fans wanted more. Despite six seasons we are still nowhere near that and I would have hoped that we had become more than perennial relegation strugglers by now.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Apr 19 9.01pm

Originally posted by Brasilian Eagle

To quote from Painter I believe that Hodgson should be compared to previous Palace managers and he also should stack up very well against them as this is possibly the best team we have ever had. The exceptions being the Team of the Eighties who finished 10th and Coppell's early 90's side who remarkably finished 3rd.

Roy has a top ten team who manage to stave off relegation with a little to spare and isn't that the issue in question. If that is the best we can hope for, then I concede.

Before the "be care what you wish for" comments begin, both Stoke and Charlton were consistent top ten teams when their fans wanted more. Despite six seasons we are still nowhere near that and I would have hoped that we had become more than perennial relegation strugglers by now.

With respect, in the PL Charlton were not a consistent top ten team.They only finished twice in the top ten in 8 PL seasons.

Stoke in their 10 seasons in the PL prior to being relegated they only finished in the top ten 3 times.

Edited by Willo (14 Apr 2019 9.05pm)

 

westnorwoodeagle Flag 14 Apr 19 9.12pm

It’s so frustrating watching Palace with such an incredibly gifted individual such as Wilf and us playing such mediocre football. We are failing Wilf and Hodgson is the culprit. Not only Wilf though we have a French international Cb in Mamadou we have a rising german star in Meyer who Hodgball refuses to start, but why?! He’s clearly a positive influence on the game he moves the ball quickly and links up with Wilf brilliantly. Don’t get me started about Roy and substitutions we are massively under achieving and wasting the talent of Zaha in his prime. Move on Roy please!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 14 Apr 19 9.17pm

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

Yes, let's. Sets up to have no ambition at all and just to limit the score but still concedes 3 and give up enough chances to be 6 down.

the myth that we are playing well just cause we sat back and had no wish to attack at all, thereby forcing City to open us up with ease is just laughable. Shows that people don't actually watch the game. No attempt to adapt to them having 3-5 players in between the lines all game, no pressure on the man in the ball making it easy for them to find said players btl, no attempt to support Benteke who was our one outball to relieve pressure and start counters, no creativity, subs too late

he gets away with absolute murder does Roy. But at least we only conceded 3 while killing the atmosphere, not giving City a thing to worry about when it is clear they panic when their rhythm is disrupted and they can't just go through the rehearsed patterns for 90 mins and have to defend. What a guy.

VAR would've only awarded them two and considering how much money City players are bringing home each week compared to our players we scared them pretty well and actually could've forced a draw without the help of the officials to kill us off.

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Let's criticise our managers.eh?