This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
There is sense in this. I've said it before but although the board are well within their rights to sack Roy if he continues to lose games 2-0, 3-0, the way we are currently playing is BECAUSE of the players we have. More importantly the age of said players, especially the defence. We cannot play a higher line because we have geriatric defenders who can't run fast. This means the whole team suffers as everyone has to sit back more, track back more to cover the weakness. Unless we get a couple of younger, faster defenders in it won't matter what manager we have, or how many youthful attacking players we buy. Although it could mean we draw more games 2-2, 3-3. At least it would be entertaining. Anyone who thinks a team playing a pensioner/Dann at the back with a midfielder can afford to play free flowing positive football doesn't understand how football works. If anything it's the boards fault for not investing in the defence more – buy all the strikers you like. Won't make any difference. Edited by SW19 CPFC (19 Feb 2021 11.11am) Exactly. Roy works with what he has at his disposal. Currently that is a centre back pairing with a combined top speed of about 1mph. Whilst that remains the case, we are not going to play a high tempo attacking game as Premier League opposition will have a jolly up against us & we will be relegated. This isn't even an attack on Parish as I believe maintaining our Premier League status for now will be significant in the clubs long term future. I don't want to come out and attack the fans (although I have no issue with taking digs at the HF) but the turning on Roy is disappointing beyond belief and puts any myths about our "special" fanbase to bed. Roy is a good manager & has done well for us whilst feeding off scraps. And the attacks on him is childish & ridiculous.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by GujiMadDog
You'll need the whole bottle on Monday I think.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Exactly. Roy works with what he has at his disposal. Currently that is a centre back pairing with a combined top speed of about 1mph. Whilst that remains the case, we are not going to play a high tempo attacking game as Premier League opposition will have a jolly up against us & we will be relegated. This isn't even an attack on Parish as I believe maintaining our Premier League status for now will be significant in the clubs long term future. I don't want to come out and attack the fans (although I have no issue with taking digs at the HF) but the turning on Roy is disappointing beyond belief and puts any myths about our "special" fanbase to bed. Roy is a good manager & has done well for us whilst feeding off scraps. And the attacks on him is childish & ridiculous. He's not exempt from criticism though. He may not have the players he had at the beginning of his tenure but we should not be losing games to Burnley 3-0. The question is more what is realistically achievable with these players, I'd argue getting slapped by three goals at home to them is below what they're capable of. On the other hand, winning games like that with free flowing football like some seem to suggest is possible? Not realistic.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Exactly. Roy works with what he has at his disposal. Currently that is a centre back pairing with a combined top speed of about 1mph. Whilst that remains the case, we are not going to play a high tempo attacking game as Premier League opposition will have a jolly up against us & we will be relegated. This isn't even an attack on Parish as I believe maintaining our Premier League status for now will be significant in the clubs long term future. I don't want to come out and attack the fans (although I have no issue with taking digs at the HF) but the turning on Roy is disappointing beyond belief and puts any myths about our "special" fanbase to bed. Roy is a good manager & has done well for us whilst feeding off scraps. And the attacks on him is childish & ridiculous. That is your opinion. Attacking Roy on every possible level is arguably wrong to the same extent as it is to try an absolve him of any responsibility or criticism. I've stated before that I would consider what Roy has achieved in keeping us in the Premier League as worthy of respect if not high praise. Does not mean people can't have differing opinions on the scales or merits of any achievements, that's the nature and beauty of football. It also doesn't mean that a manager is permanently shielded from criticism in the here and now. As it stands, we are not factually safe from relegation, have seen some awful performances this season (some may say many), have lost the last two without even a whimper, looking terrible in the process and have an abysmal record without Zaha under Hodgson, which is the situation we now find ourselves in. We've always scored highly in polls of 'best fans', as a season ticket holder I am accustomed to hearing the chant 'where's your famous atmosphere' on less entertaining days/nights and I believe even FIFA (the video game) have included commentary lines to note the passion of our fans. It's a bit too self indulgent for me to harp on about it but its worthy of recognition. I can't understand why a Palace fan would be so quick to defend our manager from any criticism yet insist on criticising the clubs fans within the same breath.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
There is sense in this. I've said it before but although the board are well within their rights to sack Roy if he continues to lose games 2-0, 3-0, the way we are currently playing is BECAUSE of the players we have. More importantly the age of said players, especially the defence. We cannot play a higher line because we have geriatric defenders who can't run fast. This means the whole team suffers as everyone has to sit back more, track back more to cover the weakness. Unless we get a couple of younger, faster defenders in it won't matter what manager we have, or how many youthful attacking players we buy. Although it could mean we draw more games 2-2, 3-3. At least it would be entertaining. Anyone who thinks a team playing a pensioner/Dann at the back with a midfielder can afford to play free flowing positive football doesn't understand how football works. If anything it's the boards fault for not investing in the defence more – buy all the strikers you like. Won't make any difference. Edited by SW19 CPFC (19 Feb 2021 11.11am) Isn’t this the reason why we have to go back to three central defensive midfielders in front of the back four with two wide midfielders either side of those three? Have Ayew working his socks off as a lone striker and hope we get a break to hit the opponents against the run of play. Hodgson was doing this until trying to fit in Eze and it’s gone Pete Tong badly? Let’s scrape together the points to keep us up.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
He's not exempt from criticism though. He may not have the players he had at the beginning of his tenure but we should not be losing games to Burnley 3-0. The question is more what is realistically achievable with these players, I'd argue getting slapped by three goals at home to them is below what they're capable of. On the other hand, winning games like that with free flowing football like some seem to suggest is possible? Not realistic. He's definitely not exempt from criticism. I am just certain that anyone expecting a better net show from the current crop of players we have at the club over the course of a full season is naive beyond belief.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Isn’t this the reason why we have to go back to three central defensive midfielders in front of the back four with two wide midfielders either side of those three? Have Ayew working his socks off as a lone striker and hope we get a break to hit the opponents against the run of play. Hodgson was doing this until trying to fit in Eze and it’s gone Pete Tong badly? Let’s scrape together the points to keep us up. mmm – fair, but I think all the injuries are hampering his plans a bit as well... Quite a few key players that fit into that system are not available. He can't revert to 4/3 as he doesn't have the players for it currently. I also think if Schlupp was fit he'd be ahead of Eze as he is basically the key to that system alongside Zaha. Townsend is waning rapidly and PVA can't play the Schlupp role so his hands are tied a bit. Again though, should we be losing 3-0 to Burnley at home? No. Am I giving a balanced opinion rather than an overly emotive or partisan one? Yes.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
He's definitely not exempt from criticism. I am just certain that anyone expecting a better net show from the current crop of players we have at the club over the course of a full season is naive beyond belief. I am very much on your 'Wavelength' on this issue in terms of the expectancy levels with the current group of players. Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2021 1.20pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
That is your opinion. Attacking Roy on every possible level is arguably wrong to the same extent as it is to try an absolve him of any responsibility or criticism. I've stated before that I would consider what Roy has achieved in keeping us in the Premier League as worthy of respect if not high praise. Does not mean people can't have differing opinions on the scales or merits of any achievements, that's the nature and beauty of football. It also doesn't mean that a manager is permanently shielded from criticism in the here and now. As it stands, we are not factually safe from relegation, have seen some awful performances this season (some may say many), have lost the last two without even a whimper, looking terrible in the process and have an abysmal record without Zaha under Hodgson, which is the situation we now find ourselves in. We've always scored highly in polls of 'best fans', as a season ticket holder I am accustomed to hearing the chant 'where's your famous atmosphere' on less entertaining days/nights and I believe even FIFA (the video game) have included commentary lines to note the passion of our fans. It's a bit too self indulgent for me to harp on about it but its worthy of recognition. I can't understand why a Palace fan would be so quick to defend our manager from any criticism yet insist on criticising the clubs fans within the same breath. Forget opinions. This isn't based on opinions. Roy Hodgson is one of the most successful managers in the clubs history. Fact. For the majority of his time at the club we have received more in transfer funds than we've dished out. Fact. He is the only manager we have had since we've been in the Premier League who hasn't had us involved in a relegation scrap. Fact. We are closer to the top half (right now, as large chunks of fans descend into meltdown) than we are to the relegation spots. Fact. Nobody is suggesting Roy Hodgson is beyond criticism, not least me. He can be frustrating as anything and the last couple of performances were very poor. But to suggest there is a manger out there who would take the current squad further than Roy is bordering on deluded. It's like we've got so used to literally not signing anyone that we signed Eze in the summer and everyone started acting like we rebuilt the squad and should be pushing for Europe. We are nowhere near that standard yet. And if we want to reach it, maintaining our status in the Premier League for now is paramount. If we are to push on, Roy's role in (comfortably) keeping us afloat will be vital. Even if a bunch of spoilt brats in the HF and their disciples aren't grateful for it. Edited by Mstrobez (19 Feb 2021 1.18pm)
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
He's definitely not exempt from criticism. I am just certain that anyone expecting a better net show from the current crop of players we have at the club over the course of a full season is naive beyond belief. You're easily pleased them if that's the best you expect from this group of players, our performances for most of this season have been absolutely pathetic and wasn't even worth them turning up. Southampton first game of the season so was a coin toss, we played utd at the right time, Leeds were unlucky with a close var decision and then a freak own goal, west brom looked the better team till the sending off, a poor wolves without jimemez, scoring on our first shot on target after 60 mins. Tbh can't even remember our Fulham wins as our performances have been so underwhelming and forgettable this season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by rikz
You're easily pleased them if that's the best you expect from this group of players, our performances for most of this season have been absolutely pathetic and wasn't even worth them turning up. Southampton first game of the season so was a coin toss, we played utd at the right time, Leeds were unlucky with a close var decision and then a freak own goal, west brom looked the better team till the sending off, a poor wolves without jimemez, scoring on our first shot on target after 60 mins. Tbh can't even remember our Fulham wins as our performances have been so underwhelming and forgettable this season. It's like you don't even read a word I say & are just blinkered by an obsession with getting Roy out at this point that's it's not even worth having a debate about it. It's like the kids on Twitter. What I want is not the point. The points is that if you are expecting more from a squad of players whereby the first choice centre half is 35, in the top flight of English football, then you are deluded mate. It's not about what you or I want for the club. But if you're disappointed that we're not Champions League yet, you ought to look at our transfer business since Roy took over & perhaps direct your grievances elsewhere. What is it you are expecting over the course of a season that another manager would achieve that Roy hasn't? Edited by Mstrobez (19 Feb 2021 1.28pm)
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
It's like you don't even read a word I say & are just blinkered by an obsession with getting Roy out at this point that's it's not even worth having a debate about it. It's like the kids on Twitter. What I want is not the point. The points is that if you are expecting more from a squad of players whereby the first choice centre half is 35, in the top flight of English football, then you are deluded mate. It's not about what you or I want for the club. But if you're disappointed that we're not Champions League yet, you ought to look at our transfer business since Roy took over & perhaps direct your grievances elsewhere. What is it you are expecting over the course of a season that another manager would achieve that Roy hasn't? Edited by Mstrobez (19 Feb 2021 1.28pm) So you're literally excusing everything else down to the fact we have one centre back in our squad who is 35, what a load of rubbish. Let's look at Brighton away on Monday, every other team in this league would identify that fixture as one they could pick up 3 away points from albeit win lose or draw. We will look at it as a fixture we can get a decent away point from and will set up to do exactly that from the first minute and hope for the best. If we go a goal down then game over as Hodgson has no plan b and his subs are usually too late and completely baffling.
|
|
|
Originally posted by rikz
So you're literally excusing everything else down to the fact we have one centre back in our squad who is 35, what a load of rubbish. Let's look at Brighton away on Monday, every other team in this league would identify that fixture as one they could pick up 3 away points from albeit win lose or draw. We will look at it as a fixture we can get a decent away point from and will set up to do exactly that from the first minute and hope for the best. If we go a goal down then game over as Hodgson has no plan b and his subs are usually too late and completely baffling. Excusing "everything else"? What is this "everything else" you are talking about? He delivered our highest ever points tally in the Premier League. I'm not blaming Gary Cahill for the fact we're not challenging for Europe. For the most part, he's actually been very good. I'm saying that having your first choice centre back as a 35 year old who can barely run anymore, in the top flight of English football, is a pretty good indicator of the level of squad you have. Relatively speaking, ours is not very good. That's the point. You, like the vast majority of the Roy out mob, are talking out of your arse at this point mate. It's become a cult. Criticise the bloke by all means but calling for his head is ridiculous and will achieve nothing.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Forget opinions. This isn't based on opinions. Roy Hodgson is one of the most successful managers in the clubs history. Fact. For the majority of his time at the club we have received more in transfer funds than we've dished out. Fact. He is the only manager we have had since we've been in the Premier League who hasn't had us involved in a relegation scrap. Fact. We are closer to the top half (right now, as large chunks of fans descend into meltdown) than we are to the relegation spots. Fact. Nobody is suggesting Roy Hodgson is beyond criticism, not least me. He can be frustrating as anything and the last couple of performances were very poor. But to suggest there is a manger out there who would take the current squad further than Roy is bordering on deluded. It's like we've got so used to literally not signing anyone that we signed Eze in the summer and everyone started acting like we rebuilt the squad and should be pushing for Europe. We are nowhere near that standard yet. And if we want to reach it, maintaining our status in the Premier League for now is paramount. If we are to push on, Roy's role in (comfortably) keeping us afloat will be vital. Even if a bunch of spoilt brats in the HF and their disciples aren't grateful for it. Edited by Mstrobez (19 Feb 2021 1.18pm) You can roll out facts all day for various sides of an argument, such as our record under Roy without Wilf, how many times we even score without Wilf under Roy Hodgson, how many goals we've conceded in games this season, how miserable some of our performance have been, how we still are at threat of relegation etc etc. I'm not saying your points or opinion is wrong but your insistence that everyone else is wrong and pointing to facts, of which football is awash with and can be used for near enough any argument, is not convincing. To suggest that of all the managers in world football, we are so extremely lucky as to have the one, the only one in the entire realms of possibility, who could keep us in the Premier League is 'bordering on delusional'. If you dislike the HF fair enough, I've always had mixed feelings but no real strong emotions towards them, but it seems like you're feeding off that to go on a tirade which has included deriding our own fans.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Excusing "everything else"? What is this "everything else" you are talking about? He delivered our highest ever points tally in the Premier League. I'm not blaming Gary Cahill for the fact we're not challenging for Europe. For the most part, he's actually been very good. I'm saying that having your first choice centre back as a 35 year old who can barely run anymore, in the top flight of English football, is a pretty good indicator of the level of squad you have. Relatively speaking, ours is not very good. That's the point. You, like the vast majority of the Roy out mob, are talking out of your arse at this point mate. It's become a cult. Criticise the bloke by all means but calling for his head is ridiculous and will achieve nothing. My view,for what is is worth,and I am cerebrally challenged, is that the squad has its limitations and that another manager could not suddenly get them to perform with much greater aplomb. I appreciate that this viewpoint does not resonate with many on HOL but the smorgasbord of opinions is all part of it's rich tapestry.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
You can roll out facts all day for various sides of an argument, such as our record under Roy without Wilf, how many times we even score without Wilf under Roy Hodgson, how many goals we've conceded in games this season, how miserable some of our performance have been, how we still are at threat of relegation etc etc. I'm not saying your points or opinion is wrong but your insistence that everyone else is wrong and pointing to facts, of which football is awash with and can be used for near enough any argument, is not convincing. To suggest that of all the managers in world football, we are so extremely lucky as to have the one, the only one in the entire realms of possibility, who could keep us in the Premier League is 'bordering on delusional'. If you dislike the HF fair enough, I've always had mixed feelings but no real strong emotions towards them, but it seems like you're feeding off that to go on a tirade which has included deriding our own fans. People are entitled to dislike Roy and want him out. And they are by far the most vocal section of fans at the moment. I am merely pointing out that they are not representative of the entire fanbase. There are plenty of us out there who are grateful for the job he's done & the manner in which he's gone about his business. Where I suggest that people are categorically wrong is where they make out that the club hasn't progressed under his leadership. That's just factually incorrect. We have gone from a club who routinely survived by the skin of our teeth - spending millions in the process - to a club that is never really in any danger of relegation, without breaking the bank. That's progress. We have gone from a club who hadn't brought through a single academy prospect since Wilf to a club that has given 3 academy players their Premier League debuts. 2 of which have established themselves as Premier League players. 1 of which is now a global star. We have made progress, and a lot of that is down to Roy. Small progress, but progress nonetheless. We are on the brink of pushing to the next level. Sacking the guy who has established us as a semi-respectable Premier League outfit, midway through another season of almost guaranteed safety, because we have a couple of poor results, would be absurd. Fortunately, Parish isn't a moron. So at the very least, I can take solace in the fact that it's not going to happen. I'm just disappointed in the fans and the way they've behaved to someone who has carried out a job for the club with dignity. And the drum w***ers turning up to the training ground fresh from Rymans (is that even open during lockdown?) with some shiny banners they made with glitter is just the tip of the iceberg. They can get f***ed. How anyone still gives them the time of day after what they did to season ticket holders in Block E is beyond me.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
My view,for what is is worth,and I am cerebrally challenged, is that the squad has its limitations and that another manager could not suddenly get them to perform with much greater aplomb. I appreciate that this viewpoint does not resonate with many on HOL but the smorgasbord of opinions is all part of it's rich tapestry. Well I'm not sure why in all honesty Willo. I had a look at one of our lineups towards the start of last season and I couldn't actually believe we were seriously fielding a team that poor in a Premier League game. We've made a couple of signings since then but with Wilf injured the only player in the squad who provides a real threat is Eze. Admittedly, I'd like to have seen him take up the Wilf position just off the centre forward in his absence.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
mmm – fair, but I think all the injuries are hampering his plans a bit as well... Quite a few key players that fit into that system are not available. He can't revert to 4/3 as he doesn't have the players for it currently. I also think if Schlupp was fit he'd be ahead of Eze as he is basically the key to that system alongside Zaha. Townsend is waning rapidly and PVA can't play the Schlupp role so his hands are tied a bit. Again though, should we be losing 3-0 to Burnley at home? No. Am I giving a balanced opinion rather than an overly emotive or partisan one? Yes. Kouyate, Luka and Reidewald in the midfield central 3 could be done with present injuries?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
People are entitled to dislike Roy and want him out. And they are by far the most vocal section of fans at the moment. I am merely pointing out that they are not representative of the entire fanbase. There are plenty of us out there who are grateful for the job he's done & the manner in which he's gone about his business. Where I suggest that people are categorically wrong is where they make out that the club hasn't progressed under his leadership. That's just factually incorrect. We have gone from a club who routinely survived by the skin of our teeth - spending millions in the process - to a club that is never really in any danger of relegation, without breaking the bank. That's progress. We have gone from a club who hadn't brought through a single academy prospect since Wilf to a club that has given 3 academy players their Premier League debuts. 2 of which have established themselves as Premier League players. 1 of which is now a global star. We have made progress, and a lot of that is down to Roy. Small progress, but progress nonetheless. We are on the brink of pushing to the next level. Sacking the guy who has established us as a semi-respectable Premier League outfit, midway through another season of almost guaranteed safety, because we have a couple of poor results, would be absurd. Fortunately, Parish isn't a moron. So at the very least, I can take solace in the fact that it's not going to happen. I'm just disappointed in the fans and the way they've behaved to someone who has carried out a job for the club with dignity. And the narcissistic drum w***ers turning up to the training ground with some glitter is just the tip of the iceberg.
I'd argue however that it is completely within football fans prerogatives to voice opinions especially when there are concerns but this doesn't make them right nor wrong. I'm not talking about the HF's banner and statement here for clarity, I'm talking about the 'Roy Out' contingent of Palace fans. I don't buy into the theory that there is some enormous gulf between fans knowledge and that of chairmen or even managers when it comes to footballing matters. Most chairmen are just football fans and well, look at FdB, what a player and career he had but half of us could have foreseen his downfall were we privy to his thinking. Pirlo was a genius on the pitch but is hardly setting the world alight with Juventus. There will always be facts, anecdotes and evidence for all sides. Track records or historical facts do not guarantee anything in football and I don't think the anti-RH crowd is going off a 'couple of poor results'. You can argue of course that's the fun but to completely dismiss other opinions is a tad absurd in most circumstances.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.