You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf
November 21 2026 1.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wilf


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Jan 22 11.15am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I think in general the current incumbents have done a good job, they have been lucky or clever to get Textor onboard, but the transfer policy over the last 4/5 years has been a shambles, no thought at all to sell on values. i think this last window was excellent, but that is down to Textors money, it seems to have taken a long time to learn it is a business.

I think you need to look at the bigger picture.

As a Club, it's generally accepted that we were only ' treading water ' for a few years under Roy. We have not been financially able to spend significant sums in the transfer market every year. The objective was to be competitive and stay in the Prem - which we did. I don't think there are any lessons to be learned at all as the business was deliberately being run according to plan.

Steve Parish gets offers of either investment or out right take overs all the time. Attracting or identifying the right people is not a simple matter. John Textor has already been more visible than the other American investors, and I think his continued input will be of great benefit.

Edited by NEILLO (07 Jan 2022 11.16am)

 


Old, Ungifted and White

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 07 Jan 22 11.49am

Yep, in reality we have spent very little in the last couple of years. Quite remarkable really that we have done as well as we have done.

Its very easy to say that we should have been buying with sell on value in mind. But these players are either going to be really young, and potentially not ready to step in and do a job, or really expensive.

Broadly the guys have been pretty shrewd, money spend on Andros, JT, PVA, Jeff, , Kouyate, Ayew all have been low fees for the impact then have had.

And some great free transfers, Guaita Sako etc.

We also spent some big money (Benteke, Sakho) that didn't provide excellent value.

Its not been perfect, but given our limitations the guys have done an amazing job. I'm sure there are lots of other fans that look at us with envy

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 07 Jan 22 3.55pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Yep, in reality we have spent very little in the last couple of years. Quite remarkable really that we have done as well as we have done.

Its very easy to say that we should have been buying with sell on value in mind. But these players are either going to be really young, and potentially not ready to step in and do a job, or really expensive.

Broadly the guys have been pretty shrewd, money spend on Andros, JT, PVA, Jeff, , Kouyate, Ayew all have been low fees for the impact then have had.

And some great free transfers, Guaita Sako etc.

We also spent some big money (Benteke, Sakho) that didn't provide excellent value.

Its not been perfect, but given our limitations the guys have done an amazing job. I'm sure there are lots of other fans that look at us with envy

It is not just transfers fees you need to consider but the whole transfer fee/salary package.

There is no such thing as a free transfer at the top level of football - Sako for example was a championship player who we paid £55k a week, at the time one of our highest earners despite never being a regular. Max Meyer is another classic example - 3 years of £125k a week is the same as buying a £15m player and paying them £40k a week (similar to Eze).

Sakho and Benteke were financial disasters from from a wage and transfer fee perspective which impacted our spending for the next 4 or so years.

Of the players you list as good cost effective purchases all are a certain age so it is unlikely any of them will have any resell value and this was known by the selling club when we bought them - West Ham with both Tomkins and Kouyate in particular were happy to take some money at 27/28 years old as the value in 3 or so years would be nearer zero


Edited by palace99 (07 Jan 2022 3.56pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 07 Jan 22 4.37pm

Originally posted by palace99

It is not just transfers fees you need to consider but the whole transfer fee/salary package.

There is no such thing as a free transfer at the top level of football - Sako for example was a championship player who we paid £55k a week, at the time one of our highest earners despite never being a regular. Max Meyer is another classic example - 3 years of £125k a week is the same as buying a £15m player and paying them £40k a week (similar to Eze).

Sakho and Benteke were financial disasters from from a wage and transfer fee perspective which impacted our spending for the next 4 or so years.

Of the players you list as good cost effective purchases all are a certain age so it is unlikely any of them will have any resell value and this was known by the selling club when we bought them - West Ham with both Tomkins and Kouyate in particular were happy to take some money at 27/28 years old as the value in 3 or so years would be nearer zero


Edited by palace99 (07 Jan 2022 3.56pm)

Yes of course there are no free transfers in reality. But if we are honest Sako was a v good Champs player, so for 8 mill salary and fee for 3 years is pretty good business.

I didn't mention Max for a reason, it was right to take a risk on him, but it never really worked out.

On cost effective, I'd still put them both in the cost effective bracket. No, there is no resale, but with limited money to spend, both have made significant contributions to us staying in the league. If we'd have bought either of them in their early 20's it would have cost us double or more.

Regardless, whilst there have been some mistakes, and some expensive players that haven't worked out the board have broadly done a really good job given the money available.

Even in this last window with Hughes, Olise, and OE. We are picking up guys who are cheaper than they probability should be due to contract length or clauses.

We just now need to hope that this new strategy works, and the guys continue to develop.

 

Oxford Don Flag North West of SP 07 Jan 22 4.44pm

This really seems to have drifted off subject. Can we either get back to it or create another thread?

 


You can't change the way things are but you can change the way you are with the way things are.

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 07 Jan 22 4.48pm

Originally posted by Oxford Don

This really seems to have drifted off subject. Can we either get back to it or create another thread?

Welcome to the 'HOL'

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 07 Jan 22 6.45pm

Originally posted by Oxford Don

This really seems to have drifted off subject. Can we either get back to it or create another thread?

I’d like to see what Willo’s take on this is first

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 07 Jan 22 9.04pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I’d like to see what Willo’s take on this is first

Why?

 

redshift Flag Toronto 08 Jan 22 12.35am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I’d like to see what Willo’s take on this is first

To be honest, I have found in the past Willo to be pretentious (my only problem with him) but now... I kind of miss him.

I hope he and Mrs W are doing well and he is not giving her too much grief. Best to you both.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Jan 22 7.30am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops


Why?

Because it was his favourite saying as he would post off topic stuff then ask everyone to get back on topic

 

YT Flag Oxford 08 Jan 22 8.25am

Originally posted by redshift

To be honest, I have found in the past Willo to be pretentious (my only problem with him) but now... I kind of miss him.

I hope he and Mrs W are doing well and he is not giving her too much grief. Best to you both.

Clearly you aren't paying attention, because Willo has been posting regularly of late on other threads. So there is no longer any need to miss him.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Croydon-Trucker Flag 26 Jan 22 9.10pm

Looks like Wilf is on his way back as The Ivory Coast have been knocked out of the Africian Nations . I wonder will he walk straight back into the starting lineup . Not bashing the guy but we wernt doing too bad without him .

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 26 Jan 22 9.14pm

I haven’t missed him one bit and not having his tantrums, sulks and theatrics has been a welcome relief.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 26 Jan 22 9.41pm

Agreed. He is in the latter half of his career now, so needs to underline his legacy. He is earning great money, the fans have loved him up to now, but I think he has reached a junction in the road. Needs to knuckle down and show everyne what he can do, work hard to counter the impact of aging. Other option, the same old nonsense we saw at Spurs on Boxing Day and we will all be pleased to see the back of him. Time to grow up methinks.

 

YT Flag Oxford 26 Jan 22 9.49pm

Interesting that he was only a bit-part player in Ivory Coast's AFCON campaign (now ended). You'd think that a regular starter in a team competing in "the best league in the world" would be a shoe-in for a minor international side. Presumably therefore his adopted nation doesn't think he's as good as he does.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Putitout Flag Oxford 26 Jan 22 9.51pm

Well he has to be a decent option, either on the pitch, or on the bench. Good to have him back. It is changed days and we don’t rely on him as we did not so long ago, but he still carries a threat. So come on Wilf, show us what you got, and maybe we still make the top ten.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 26 Jan 22 9.53pm

Happy to have him back. I feel like we needed some time apart...hopefully he now comes back reinvigorated and ready to contribute instead of whinge.

 

Jacey Flag 26 Jan 22 10.16pm

Originally posted by sprites

Happy to have him back. I feel like we needed some time apart...hopefully he now comes back reinvigorated and ready to contribute instead of whinge.

All very true.Unfortunately,he has almost become a bigger whining ,whinger than that well known loser,Sir Keir Starmer!!

 

beak Flag croydon 26 Jan 22 10.20pm

Originally posted by Jacey

All very true.Unfortunately,he has almost become a bigger whining ,whinger than that well known loser,Sir Keir Starmer!!

He won't lose the next election after we ditch Boris the liar.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 26 Jan 22 10.30pm

It wasn’t long ago that people were saying that Wilf should be playing in the champions league for Barcelona/Real Madrid. Also that It was a big miss for England that we never capped him in a proper game.
Decent Palace Player for me , would possibly get in my best ever Palace team, worst ways on the bench.
Glad to have him back though.
Completion for places is important.

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf