You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread
November 21 2026 11.56am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Holmesdale Fanatics thread


Page 72 of 122 < 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 >
michaelpearce Flag grays 06 Sep 18 12.11pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Or because Parish and the club did nothing but create this situation, which could’ve been avoided if they released the proposals supplied by the HF. Maybe if the club gave it a try they might’ve stayed put in B if the club tried, but they fecked it up instead. Going by the response to the HF statements, proposals and brochure it stood a bell of a better chance than how the club handled it, which was an amateurish joke as per usual.

so its down to the club how you support the team noooo, it down to the individual how they support the team the best way to get the team to win,Palace through thick and thin, not pick and choose

 

simonmdt Flag x 06 Sep 18 12.17pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think the fact that Parish and CPFC have used them in brochures, videos And online promoting the club, match tickets, season tickets and memberships pretty much since they bought the club disproves your opinion that the HF are a financial (business) irrelevance. Your argument using the remaining 25,000 is true, obviously, but actually bollox if you look at it from a real business angle, as Parish has for 8 years.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (06 Sep 2018 9.59am)

Oh dear, oh dear.

a) they are a financial irrelevance, as proved by the original poster is of course true, and not 'actual bollox if you look at it from a real business angle' whatever that is meant to mean.

Seeing as you obviously bunked off most of your GCSE Businees Studies, let me help you, from a real business angle (sic)

What Parish, or mostly likely, the Marketing Director has done is used the HF to help build the CPFC brand.

Now since RMH first attributed a monetary value to their brand on their spreadsheets, a brand can be considerably more valuable than its generic commodity counterpart, but alas, a brand asset i.e. the HF, have no intrinsic financial value to them whatsoever (their value is purely emotional, which of course is not to say, without worth, but I'm digressing from the point

Oh course Parish, or the Marketing Director, was a bit of t*** to attribute their brand to an asset they neither own nor control but they look a positive genius compared to the comments you're leaving here

And you're also on very dodgy grounds if you persist with a financial equation for fans, - purely from looking at it from a real business angle, the fans who are worth more to any club, Palace included , are of course the Corporate ones.

 

simonmdt Flag x 06 Sep 18 12.20pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

im from the days of football violence but we still watched the games while trying not to get lumped, and we wasnt there for the punch up we was there to support and watch

Edited by michaelpearce (05 Sep 2018 7.10pm)

Ok, I'll hold my hand up, I was there for the punch up as well, as well as support the team.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 06 Sep 18 12.22pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Or because Parish and the club did nothing but create this situation, which could’ve been avoided if they released the proposals supplied by the HF. Maybe if the club gave it a try they might’ve stayed put in B if the club tried, but they fecked it up instead. Going by the response to the HF statements, proposals and brochure it stood a bell of a better chance than how the club handled it, which was an amateurish joke as per usual.

There's a few points being missed/ignored though:

1) At the time, the Club was working flat out to get planning for the new stand & this would clearly have an impact on any proposed move around.

2) We weren't exactly safe from relegation which could also have affected the situation.

3) The proposal, in the form it's been released now, could have been made public by the HF to either allay fears or simply clarify all the arguing going on across social media.

It seems to me that the HF & the Club both want the same thing but one wants it immediately & the other sees the problems/bigger picture of such an undertaking.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Aray Flag South London 06 Sep 18 12.30pm

It has been said by a few others in this long thread.
The club's infrastructure is pretty crap.

We cant even get the catering right. I received an email around the time of renewing season tickets stating "sorry you're not renewing...."

I couldn't believe it. I'm one of those mugs that has it automatically renew.

What are the chances of the club getting something like this right? Yup - zero.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 06 Sep 18 12.35pm

Originally posted by simonmdt

Ok, I'll hold my hand up, I was there for the punch up as well, as well as support the team.

well after the match for me as i had a trek through west ham chelsea spurs oh and millwall fun days still supported the team

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Sep 18 12.41pm

Originally posted by simonmdt

Oh dear, oh dear.

a) they are a financial irrelevance, as proved by the original poster is of course true, and not 'actual bollox if you look at it from a real business angle' whatever that is meant to mean.

Seeing as you obviously bunked off most of your GCSE Businees Studies, let me help you, from a real business angle (sic)

What Parish, or mostly likely, the Marketing Director has done is used the HF to help build the CPFC brand.

Now since RMH first attributed a monetary value to their brand on their spreadsheets, a brand can be considerably more valuable than its generic commodity counterpart, but alas, a brand asset i.e. the HF, have no intrinsic financial value to them whatsoever (their value is purely emotional, which of course is not to say, without worth, but I'm digressing from the point

Oh course Parish, or the Marketing Director, was a bit of t*** to attribute their brand to an asset they neither own nor control but they look a positive genius compared to the comments you're leaving here

And you're also on very dodgy grounds if you persist with a financial equation for fans, - purely from looking at it from a real business angle, the fans who are worth more to any club, Palace included , are of course the Corporate ones.

What a load of verbal diarrhoea. I’m well aware of asset valuations and tangible and important intangible assets. If I wanted to I could consult SSAP’s but that’s just a complete load of flannel with this in mind. Parish, like any business today knows, the importance of growth. Growth, not standing still resting on your laurels. Compare that Jordan buffoon who valued season ticket holders and treated casual fans with contempt and effectively priced them away from attending and what Parish is doing. The value of the HF as a marketing tool is highly valuable and Parish knows it. Businesses thrive and survive by how they plan and grow their markets and marketing plans, not by past and immediate financial reports only, but thanks for the snidely GCSE comment. Wouldn’t expect anything else.

 


COYP

20 Spaces Isnt Enoug Flag Bolton 06 Sep 18 12.51pm

Originally posted by bexleydave


Exactly.


I disagree.... If I was one of their supporters

I definitely would not want the HF back

and wouldn't sign

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 06 Sep 18 12.52pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

so its down to the club how you support the team noooo, it down to the individual how they support the team the best way to get the team to win,Palace through thick and thin, not pick and choose

And they're now choosing to support the team like, unfortunately, the majority of the stadium. They don't owe us, the rest of the fans, a top notch atmosphere, and they are still present at games, so I don't really understand your point, mate.

Edited by Dan1994 (06 Sep 2018 12.52pm)

 


[Link]

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Sep 18 12.54pm

Originally posted by Dan1994

And they're now choosing to support the team like, unfortunately, the majority of the stadium. They don't owe us, the rest of the fans, a top notch atmosphere, and they are still present at games, so I don't really understand your point, mate.

Edited by Dan1994 (06 Sep 2018 12.52pm)

Yep. ‘Support how we don’t and takes much more time and effort would you please.’

Well done the club. Sort it out.

 


COYP

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 06 Sep 18 1.07pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

What a load of verbal diarrhoea. I’m well aware of asset valuations and tangible and important intangible assets. If I wanted to I could consult SSAP’s but that’s just a complete load of flannel with this in mind. Parish, like any business today knows, the importance of growth. Growth, not standing still resting on your laurels. Compare that Jordan buffoon who valued season ticket holders and treated casual fans with contempt and effectively priced them away from attending and what Parish is doing. The value of the HF as a marketing tool is highly valuable and Parish knows it. Businesses thrive and survive by how they plan and grow their markets and marketing plans, not by past and immediate financial reports only, but thanks for the snidely GCSE comment. Wouldn’t expect anything else.

Quite right Rudi, what a pompous pr*ck, and im not even in yours and his "debate"

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 06 Sep 18 1.07pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Totally meaningless as no address required so who knows how many fans of Brighton, Watford or any other fans of other clubs that dislike Palace.

completely meaningless. If I could be arsed to make the point I'd start a petition for the opposite and get more signatures.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 06 Sep 18 1.07pm

FFS Rudi do you ever have a good word for the club because all I ever see from you is criticism on almost every issue. Why don't you give this thread a rest because it damages us in the eyes of other clubs fans who must be pissing themselves laughing at us!

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Isley46 Flag Sanderstead 06 Sep 18 1.23pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think the fact that Parish and CPFC have used them in brochures, videos And online promoting the club, match tickets, season tickets and memberships pretty much since they bought the club disproves your opinion that the HF are a financial (business) irrelevance. Your argument using the remaining 25,000 is true, obviously, but actually bollox if you look at it from a real business angle, as Parish has for 8 years.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (06 Sep 2018 9.59am)

Playing devil's advocate - by the same amount Parish has then been also promoting the HF for eight years - and they still only number 100... Which may mean to the majority of in-ground support they are irrelevant (otherwise their membership would already fill the lower Holmesdale and this thread wouldn't exist)

Was also thinking if Palace had won the last two home games say 4-0 would anyone really be overly concerned about what has happened to the HF? Not knocking what the HF have done in the past but it's the results on the pitch that lift the other areas of the ground and raise the noise levels.

Remember the Sunderland silent second half, even the HF had had enough.


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Sep 18 1.26pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

FFS Rudi do you ever have a good word for the club because all I ever see from you is criticism on almost every issue. Why don't you give this thread a rest because it damages us in the eyes of other clubs fans who must be pissing themselves laughing at us!

So you hope the issue disappears?

Actually I’ve said several times in this thread and others how much of a great chairman Parish has been. I just have actually comparing him to the short sighted revenue now Jordan. It’s the club that manage to monumentally c0ck things up. They can’t even provide or make sure the fridges work but I bet their drinks in corporate lounges are at perfect serving temperature. It’s always been the same. Rossi’s refreshments never failed in their service so you could happily eat the burger they had in stock with a cold or hot drink with the Croydon advertiser Family enclose of 9 year olds making the only notable sound in the ground. What times they were... to return?

Edited by Rudi Hedman (06 Sep 2018 1.30pm)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Sep 18 1.30pm

Originally posted by Isley46

Playing devil's advocate - by the same amount Parish has then been also promoting the HF for eight years - and they still only number 100... Which may mean to the majority of in-ground support they are irrelevant (otherwise their membership would already fill the lower Holmesdale and this thread wouldn't exist)

Was also thinking if Palace had won the last two home games say 4-0 would anyone really be overly concerned about what has happened to the HF? Not knocking what the HF have done in the past but it's the results on the pitch that lift the other areas of the ground and raise the noise levels.

Remember the Sunderland silent second half, even the HF had had enough.


You may never get the actual HF membership above about that number and they may not want it to anyway, but it’s about everyone joining in with them. That’s the and their point after all. We’ll see how much better the atmosphere gets if nothing happens about this. I reckon it won’t improve. I thought they could be made up for, but I and others thinking the same were wrong and the signs are there it will remain that way.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (06 Sep 2018 1.37pm)

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Sep 18 1.55pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman


Actually I’ve said thousands of times in this thread

EFA

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 06 Sep 18 1.55pm

I will be releasing a statement at 6 pm!

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Sep 18 2.33pm

does anybody disagree that
1. It's pretty tough on long term season ticket holders to move them if they don't want to be moved* to accommodate fans who sing more

And

2. That the HF have helped improve the atmosphere at Selhurst

?

If so, shouldn't Parish simply induce the HF to return to their corner until the new stand is built?

I'm sure the 35 odd tickets sold in that corner can be sorted out.

* I know I support no automatic seat renewal but we are where we are, and expectations have been created

Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (06 Sep 2018 2.34pm)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

westquay Flag 58 miles from se25 06 Sep 18 3.55pm

Compromise is the answer...
Without question the HF have made a massive impact on the noise and atmosphere at Selhurst and in my opinion are sadly missed....
There is always a way to get things sorted with calm intelligent debate....
Ok .. HF got on their high horse but ffs its not the same without them .. Is it?
Maybe offer them the corner of the "Arfurs" and see how many folk would swap for a seat in the Holmesdale...
Just a thought....
Bitching and slagging each other off isn't gonna solve anything and it makes us as bad as a clowns website/forum
The Hf make noise.. They bring colour.. They got flags.. If I were 30 years younger I,d join them..
What,s not to like...
Needs resolving amicably as things just aint what they used to be...….

Some pride needs to be swallowed on both sides as this lot lift the stadium and lift the team...
So stop squabbling and come up with ideas that can sort this whole situation as surely we don't all want to sound like a bore who repairs bikes... Do we?

 


"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel."
"Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer"
Martin Scorcese, Film director.

Page 72 of 122 < 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Holmesdale Fanatics thread