You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?


Page 1 of 44 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
OhSouthLondon! Flag Mitcham 04 Dec 18 10.22pm

I don’t think you can fault too many of the players efforts. Tomkins had a poor game but he usually gives 110%.

The main problem as we all know is a lack of a striker. BUT we have known about this problem since the summer and yet we didn’t buy a goal scorer. We have absolutely nothing to aim at up top and time and time again it costs us.

Is that Roy’s fault or the boards?

Edited by Midlands Eagle (05 Dec 2018 7.51am)

 


We'reTheRedAndBlueArmyy !

[Link] - Neil Danns Born A Champion [Requested Video From The Man Himself]

SUBSCRIBE to SilverLiningVideos on youtube for more palace videos here - [Link]

1066eagle Flag hastings 04 Dec 18 10.25pm

having been at the play off semi , players got out played tonight + tactics wrong .

 

Matlock Flag matlock Derbyshire 04 Dec 18 10.26pm

How long has Roy got ?

 

YoDougie Flag London 04 Dec 18 10.28pm

I think you can put blame on both if i'm honest.

A good manager should be able to get the best out of any players. Pulis and Allardyce both managed it with us. And being honest, we do have players who we know can be of top top quality on their day. Sakho, Zaha, Luka, PVA, Benteke (despite his injuries, he has been awful under Hodgson) have all been outstanding at times and they are good footballers. So what's happening right now?

On the other hand, we've know about our weak forwards for over 12 months now. But in the summer, we spent £10mill on a defensive mid with Kouyate and nothing else.

Ayew came in on a loan and has been awful. And that was seen as adequate firepower. And here we are, into December and our strikers have scored a total of 0 goals this season.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 04 Dec 18 10.29pm

Don't know any other team that would play 442 with 6 midfielders, sick of it now. Managers fault.

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 04 Dec 18 10.32pm

Roys.....

The team looked ineffectual to say the least.

Tomkin is just one of many to lose his head in that game.

Roy played our team so narrow it was infuriating.

The passing sideways and backwards whilst tapping 1 meter passes to each other until they lose the ball is back again.

The lack of enthusiasm, the lack of pace, the constant moaning at the ref and this constant passing in the oppositions box until they lose the ball is also infuriating.

There is talent in the team, yes we need a striker, Sorloth isn't good enough, the team need to practice set pieces if we can't score from open play and Roy needs to drill them to death in being able to take a shot on target.

 

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 04 Dec 18 10.41pm

I wish they'd give Sorloth a chance to find his feet. He's never had an extended run.

Originally posted by CPFCwetrust

Roys.....

The team looked ineffectual to say the least.

Tomkin is just one of many to lose his head in that game.

Roy played our team so narrow it was infuriating.

The passing sideways and backwards whilst tapping 1 meter passes to each other until they lose the ball is back again.

The lack of enthusiasm, the lack of pace, the constant moaning at the ref and this constant passing in the oppositions box until they lose the ball is also infuriating.

There is talent in the team, yes we need a striker, Sorloth isn't good enough, the team need to practice set pieces if we can't score from open play and Roy needs to drill them to death in being able to take a shot on target.

 

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 04 Dec 18 10.51pm

We've got a worse squad than last year. Meyer is nowhere near loftus cheek or cabaye. Sorloth is poor. The bench today would struggle in the championship

Edited by Dean_CPFC (04 Dec 2018 10.54pm)

 

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 04 Dec 18 10.54pm

Bring back big Sam, the sooner the better.

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

steve1984 04 Dec 18 10.58pm

You could pick any combination of ten men from the eleven that played tonight and add a 20 goal a season striker and we'd still have been out played. woeful.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Dec 18 11.12pm

I have been speaking to someone,not a supporter of our club, who has contacts in the game, and he reckons that in his opinion, our club will relieve Hodgson of his services but I told him he was spouting hogwash.

Hodgson has got a great deal of credit in the bank for engineering our revival last season and as such there is great faith in him to ensure we don't slip through that relegation trapdoor this season.

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 04 Dec 18 11.20pm

Originally posted by YoDougie

I think you can put blame on both if i'm honest.

A good manager should be able to get the best out of any players. Pulis and Allardyce both managed it with us. And being honest, we do have players who we know can be of top top quality on their day. Sakho, Zaha, Luka, PVA, Benteke (despite his injuries, he has been awful under Hodgson) have all been outstanding at times and they are good footballers. So what's happening right now?

The balls up of the tranfer windows is a huge problem but the above, our lack of consistency and Roy's snail's pace reaction to changes in the game (if he reacts at all) are the more worrying problems that may not be solved by a good transfer window. Personally I think there must be something wrong in our training regime somewhere too. I think we're really missing Sammy Lee, letting him go (I don't know the facts tbh so it may have been unavoidable) was a mistake.

I have a worrying feeling that Roy is taking it easy and just working through his last season before retirement (lack of support from the board could also be contributing to this).


Edited by boo909 (04 Dec 2018 11.20pm)

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

PatrickA Flag London 04 Dec 18 11.23pm

Much of the blame this season lies with Hodgson.
One win in ten is representative of where we are and you can’t keep hiding behind so called decent performances or being unlucky.
Palace were second to every ball against Brighton and Hodgson is not getting the best out of his resources.
On paper we have better players than Brighton but it looked tonight that we had ten men the way they dominated.
At 2-0 down with them down to ten men he could have gone 4-3-3 and tried to stretch them but he kept the same formation as if hoping something would change.
Not for the the first time this season he failed to make changes which were crying out to be made.
I am losing confidence in him.


 

Mstrobez Flag 04 Dec 18 11.27pm

Parish is the ultimate problem undoubtedly. The biggest issue with it now is I think, after the Frank de Boer debacle, he’s unlikely to ever change strategy again.

Seen a lot of Palace fans call for Dyche to come in if Roy goes. And sadly, I think that’s exact route he’ll go down. Whilst, on paper, this sounds good considering he got a pretty average team into a European spot last season. There is a reason his Burnley side are struggling this year. The brand of football has and always will hve a sell-by date. We need to stop hiring managers who play a brand of football that has a sell by date.

Dyche will be repeating the same process all over again. Will steady us up. Get us a couple of results against the big boys. We all bow down and worship him for a year. Then the sell by date passes and we need another firefighter to save us.

Sadly, next time, there will almost certainly be none left. As far as the old school English managers go, I actually think Roy is better than anything we’ve ever had by quite a distance. His record may not back this up. But in fairness, Sam & Pardew were properly backed in the transfer window & the money they spent is hardly looking like a good long-term investment at this point.

For now, I still think we should stick with Roy. We were poor tonight, but it’s easy to ignore the fact the first 2 goals were literally gifted to them by the ref.

Edited by Mstrobez (04 Dec 2018 11.30pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

SouthLondonAP Flag Near Earth Orbit 04 Dec 18 11.39pm

This argument is multi-faceted.

First, it's not Roy's fault because he doesn't have the tools to do the job. The squad is thin and we know out of the 11 on the park maybe 3 have a real chance of being dropped if they under perform.

Secondly, it is Roy's fault because tonight they looked like they had no motivation. They looked like they believed their own hype from the weekend. But it's a derby game, the manager shouldn't need to motivate them but maybe he demotivated them?

Thirdly, we know we have no money to spend in January. Is Parish looking for a way out to sell the club? Is he being distracted by his new romance? It can make your priorities change.

Lastly, the scouting team has been abysmal. What does Freedman do all day? It was claimed that Max Meyer was a great signing and he may turn out to be but there was a reason clubs above us turned him down.

We'll get the usual spiel abut wages being high yet we have a keeper on £80k+ a week who is sitting on the bench. Being a free transfer he'll be on a high wage and he turned down that much in Spain so he'll be on a top wedge.

DGMW Hennessey is playing well so I wouldn't swap them around. It just seems we seem to have no direction.

 


South London and Proud - an Crystal Palace blog, podcast and discussion forum. CLICK HERE [Link]

jeeagles Flag 04 Dec 18 11.50pm

Hodgson for me and has been for a while.
He seems unable to play any formation other than 4-4-2 despite not having the players to fit the formation.

His substitutes are rubbish.
Our set pieces are poor.
Once we go a goal down we won't stand a chance.

I've started to wonder if Benteke's dreadful form over the last 18 months is due to Hodgson not understanding how to play him to his strengths?

He's trying to do the same as what he did last season without Cabaye and RLC. It just won't work.


 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 04 Dec 18 11.54pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Hodgson for me and has been for a while.
He seems unable to play any formation other than 4-4-2 despite not having the players to fit the formation.

His substitutes are rubbish.
Our set pieces are poor.
Once we go a goal down we won't stand a chance.

I've started to wonder if Benteke's dreadful form over the last 18 months is due to Hodgson not understanding how to play him to his strengths?

He's trying to do the same as what he did last season without Cabaye and RLC. It just won't work.



Yup me too

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Dec 18 12.02am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Hodgson for me and has been for a while.
He seems unable to play any formation other than 4-4-2 despite not having the players to fit the formation.

His substitutes are rubbish.
Our set pieces are poor.
Once we go a goal down we won't stand a chance.

I've started to wonder if Benteke's dreadful form over the last 18 months is due to Hodgson not understanding how to play him to his strengths?

He's trying to do the same as what he did last season without Cabaye and RLC. It just won't work.


I do get the impression that supporters are rapidly losing faith in Hodgson but I suspect that this is not shared by the Board.

Can anyone see other than a defeat on Saturday at W.Ham ?

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 05 Dec 18 12.09am

Originally posted by jeeagles

I've started to wonder if Benteke's dreadful form over the last 18 months is due to Hodgson not understanding how to play him to his strengths?

Funnily enough I said the same thing a few weeks ago but blamed it more on our training/coaching regime, the whole system these days rather than just in how Hodgson is playing him.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Dec 18 12.18am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Much of the blame this season lies with Hodgson.
One win in ten is representative of where we are and you can’t keep hiding behind so called decent performances or being unlucky.
Palace were second to every ball against Brighton and Hodgson is not getting the best out of his resources.
On paper we have better players than Brighton but it looked tonight that we had ten men the way they dominated.
At 2-0 down with them down to ten men he could have gone 4-3-3 and tried to stretch them but he kept the same formation as if hoping something would change.
Not for the the first time this season he failed to make changes which were crying out to be made.
I am losing confidence in him.


I hear quite a few supporters with the same opinion.
Last season's heroics are being forgotten and his mantra that we are playing well and things will turn for the better is being ridiculed by many.

Another abject performance and defeat against W.Ham and I believe the calls for Hodgson to go will get louder and louder.My belief is that the Board have every confidence in him and not even considered his position.

 

Page 1 of 44 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who’s at fault - Hodgson or the board?