You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?
November 16 2026 11.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?


Page 8 of 12 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
paperhat Flag croydon 25 Oct 16 11.33am

Originally posted by cpj

LC's squad last season cost about £54m to assemble. We had players who cost us over £80m in the XI on Saturday. Either they are better at signing players than we are or their manager is better.

Or, they bought their players before we were all thrown into the vastly overpriced market we are currently in.

as an example, were Leciester to have purchased Vardy and Mahrez this season rather than prior to last, you may well have seen both those players indiviually priced closer to the £54 million that their squad cost to assemble.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 16 11.42am

Originally posted by cpj

According to that logic we should lose to all the teams who finished above us last season and beat all those who finished below. Yeah, like that will happen.

LC's squad last season cost about £54m to assemble. We had players who cost us over £80m in the XI on Saturday. Either they are better at signing players than we are or their manager is better.

Steve Walsh who was their 'Head of Recruitment' was hugely influential in terms of their player acquisitions and one can only assume their recruitment infrastructure is excellent.
Walsh is now at Everton as their 'Director of Football'.

 

eagle6764 Flag Quilty 25 Oct 16 11.54am

Of course we're allowed to criticise Pardew, we're fans of the club and want it to succeed and as always poor performances ultimately are the responsibility of the manager. The stats for 2016 speak for themselves. A poor start to this season, a decent little run and then another blip. He bought well but the team is inconsistent or gets outplayed because Pardew got his tactics wrong and didn't have a plan B. He also sold or loaned out nearly all our young players who should have been at least in the squad.

All that said it's too early to give him the boot but 3 or 4 more games like the last 2 and I will have lost my belief that he's the man for the job. I would love to know who is coaching the defence. Ward was Pulis's go to man - filled in at left back or midfield and did a great job - where did that top defender go? We need a top number 10 Punch isn't consistent enough - goes from good to poor to often. All of this is down to the manager - he may have got us to a cup final but our league form overall has been awful.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 12.13pm

Originally posted by eagle6764

Of course we're allowed to criticise Pardew, we're fans of the club and want it to succeed and as always poor performances ultimately are the responsibility of the manager. The stats for 2016 speak for themselves. A poor start to this season, a decent little run and then another blip. He bought well but the team is inconsistent or gets outplayed because Pardew got his tactics wrong and didn't have a plan B. He also sold or loaned out nearly all our young players who should have been at least in the squad.

All that said it's too early to give him the boot but 3 or 4 more games like the last 2 and I will have lost my belief that he's the man for the job. I would love to know who is coaching the defence. Ward was Pulis's go to man - filled in at left back or midfield and did a great job - where did that top defender go? We need a top number 10 Punch isn't consistent enough - goes from good to poor to often. All of this is down to the manager - he may have got us to a cup final but our league form overall has been awful.

Nail on head that post fella! Can't believe people just want to dismiss our overall league form in 2016 and just wipe the slate clean like it never happened ... madness!

 

laddo Flag london 25 Oct 16 12.18pm

A very sad indictment of what premier league football has done to the game. Everything is short termism. I guarantee the original poster and people like him would do the following.

1. Hound Pardew out.
2. Blame the board for lack of ambition for not appointing someone within 20 mins of Pardew sacking.
3. Hail the new manager when he arrives, applauding the often inevitable upturn in results before suggesting we have the messiah at the helm.
4. Go quiet for a few games when results go down.
5. Results continue to reflect the club's stature but not deemed good enough by said 'fans'. Return back to number 1 and repeat.

I actually want Palace to do things differently. I want them to build a legacy. When building anything of substance there will be ups and downs along the way. I'm happy with this. I see the bigger picture, that it's not just about the here and now, it's also about generations after me supporting an established premier league club. I just wish others had the brains to work this out for themselves.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

cpj Flag Kent 25 Oct 16 12.30pm

Originally posted by paperhat

Or, they bought their players before we were all thrown into the vastly overpriced market we are currently in.

as an example, were Leciester to have purchased Vardy and Mahrez this season rather than prior to last, you may well have seen both those players indiviually priced closer to the £54 million that their squad cost to assemble.

No, because they were relatively unknown - Vardy was at Fleetwood. They are only worth a lot now because of what they have done at Leicester. We've signed our equivalent of Vardy in Anderson, Ladapo and Appiah but have not given them a chance.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 16 12.42pm

Originally posted by cpj

No, because they were relatively unknown - Vardy was at Fleetwood. They are only worth a lot now because of what they have done at Leicester. We've signed our equivalent of Vardy in Anderson, Ladapo and Appiah but have not given them a chance.

Anderson and Ladapo have been signed whilst we are in the PL so it makes it that much harder to break into the team.Was hoping to see Anderson come on for Bolton last night but he was left on the bench.

Appiah played some games whilst we were in the Championship but he has had his injury problems besides it's a judgement call by managers as to whether players are good enough to be given their chance.

Edited by Willo (25 Oct 2016 12.43pm)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Oct 16 1.29pm

Originally posted by laddo

A very sad indictment of what premier league football has done to the game. Everything is short termism. I guarantee the original poster and people like him would do the following.

1. Hound Pardew out.
2. Blame the board for lack of ambition for not appointing someone within 20 mins of Pardew sacking.
3. Hail the new manager when he arrives, applauding the often inevitable upturn in results before suggesting we have the messiah at the helm.
4. Go quiet for a few games when results go down.
5. Results continue to reflect the club's stature but not deemed good enough by said 'fans'. Return back to number 1 and repeat.

I actually want Palace to do things differently. I want them to build a legacy. When building anything of substance there will be ups and downs along the way. I'm happy with this. I see the bigger picture, that it's not just about the here and now, it's also about generations after me supporting an established premier league club. I just wish others had the brains to work this out for themselves.

Why do people have to be lacking brains just because they don't buy into your vision of Nirvana with Pardew at the helm?

Perhaps it's everyone else that sees the bigger picture who want to build for the future but don't see us doing that under the present management.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 1.55pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why do people have to be lacking brains just because they don't buy into your vision of Nirvana with Pardew at the helm?

Perhaps it's everyone else that sees the bigger picture who want to build for the future but don't see us doing that under the present management.

Sounds like someone's fallen for Pardew's clap trap which is nothing more than a mechanism to buy himself more time in the role.

Modern day football is a results game and on that basis Pardew should be judged on results in 2016 ... it's really that simple. Conversely, I can't believe some people don't have the brains to see that!!!

 

rikz Flag Croydon 25 Oct 16 2.44pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Sounds like someone's fallen for Pardew's clap trap which is nothing more than a mechanism to buy himself more time in the role.

Modern day football is a results game and on that basis Pardew should be judged on results in 2016 ... it's really that simple. Conversely, I can't believe some people don't have the brains to see that!!!

So you think burnley should sack dyche ?

No because his a good manager and even after relegation find themselves in a much better position than what they would be if they sacked him.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 25 Oct 16 3.33pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Sounds like someone's fallen for Pardew's clap trap which is nothing more than a mechanism to buy himself more time in the role.

Modern day football is a results game and on that basis Pardew should be judged on results in 2016 ... it's really that simple. Conversely, I can't believe some people don't have the brains to see that!!!

What has Pardew done that is so wrong? Since he came here nit some random date plucked to suit your argument?

Of course he has made some bad decisions, all managers do, no he isn't a great manager but what have we done to deserve a "great manager"? Pardew's record indicates that he is decent, world beater? no but certainly decent.

As for results, they are of course important but for a club like Palace there is so much more that he must be judged on too. Not unlike Wenger and before you get all arsey, I know Wenger is better than Pardew. However the need to balance the books, have relative success and still push the club forward makes the situation comparable. We are still a 20th Century club in so many ways


 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 4.35pm

Originally posted by rikz

So you think burnley should sack dyche ?

No because his a good manager and even after relegation find themselves in a much better position than what they would be if they sacked him.

Think you'll find they got promoted last season not relegated fella

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 4.48pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

What has Pardew done that is so wrong? Since he came here nit some random date plucked to suit your argument?

Of course he has made some bad decisions, all managers do, no he isn't a great manager but what have we done to deserve a "great manager"? Pardew's record indicates that he is decent, world beater? no but certainly decent.

As for results, they are of course important but for a club like Palace there is so much more that he must be judged on too. Not unlike Wenger and before you get all arsey, I know Wenger is better than Pardew. However the need to balance the books, have relative success and still push the club forward makes the situation comparable. We are still a 20th Century club in so many ways



Where have you been in 2016 fella? It’s November in 2 weeks time. I’d encourage you to perhaps look at all of our league results since the 1st January 2016 before you come in wind milling eh!

What people have to realise on here is that people remarking on Pardew not being good enough is based solely on form over a 10 month period … yes. 10 months FFS!

Yes, he’s brought in some ½ decent players but f*ck me it’s our 4th season in the Prem and we have the funds finally. Yes, we have a lot of Championship players in the squad still but these were the same players he was lording it about when we had some form a year ago! The same players who were getting results! It rapidly starts going sideways and he hasn’t known what to do since then. Yep, we have won a few games against ‘lesser’ opposition and so we should bearing in mind we bought heavily in the summer. But, that has been like sticking a plaster on a gaping wound for most of us who see the world differently to the ‘Super Alan Pardew’ brigade!!!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 25 Oct 16 4.49pm

Originally posted by KAOS


Where have you been in 2016 fella? It’s November in 2 weeks time. I’d encourage you to perhaps look at all of our league results since the 1st January 2016 before you come in wind milling eh!

What people have to realise on here is that people remarking on Pardew not being good enough is based solely on form over a 10 month period … yes. 10 months FFS!

Yes, he’s brought in some ½ decent players but f*ck me it’s our 4th season in the Prem and we have the funds finally. Yes, we have a lot of Championship players in the squad still but these were the same players he was lording it about when we had some form a year ago! The same players who were getting results! It rapidly starts going sideways and he hasn’t known what to do since then. Yep, we have won a few games against ‘lesser’ opposition and so we should bearing in mind we bought heavily in the summer. But, that has been like sticking a plaster on a gaping wound for most of us who see the world differently to the ‘Super Alan Pardew’ brigade!!!

Funnily enough I was here before 1st January which is why I look at his record as a whole not a random date that suits

As for spend heavily, what was the net spend again?
Also like I said, decent manager, not great, or did you chose to ignore that point too?

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (25 Oct 2016 4.51pm)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 16 4.58pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Funnily enough I was here before 1st January which is why I look at his record as a whole not a random date that suits

As for spend heavily, what was the net spend again?
Also like I said, decent manager, not great, or did you chose to ignore that point too?

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (25 Oct 2016 4.51pm)


Pre-season, not counting the add-ons for both Benteke and Bolasie, I believe the net spend is in the region of £16 Mill.

Maybe the poster is inferring that having spent in excess of £50 Mill on players (Gross spend) excluding the add-on, we should be doing somewhat better.

Edited by Willo (25 Oct 2016 5.01pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 25 Oct 16 5.10pm

Originally posted by Willo


Pre-season, not counting the add-ons for both Benteke and Bolasie, I believe the net spend is in the region of £16 Mill.

Maybe the poster is inferring that having spent in excess of £50 Mill on players (Gross spend) excluding the add-on, we should be doing somewhat better.

Edited by Willo (25 Oct 2016 5.01pm)


Yes I know but the point I am making is that we still have a relatively cheap squad. That will obviously change over time but that;s the key, time.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

rikz Flag Croydon 25 Oct 16 5.19pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Think you'll find they got promoted last season not relegated fella

before being relegated the season before

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 16 5.30pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch


Yes I know but the point I am making is that we still have a relatively cheap squad. That will obviously change over time but that;s the key, time.

With respect, I wasn't arguing against you, just giving some figures relating to our spending.

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 25 Oct 16 5.32pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Funnily enough I was here before 1st January which is why I look at his record as a whole not a random date that suits

As for spend heavily, what was the net spend again?
Also like I said, decent manager, not great, or did you chose to ignore that point too?

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (25 Oct 2016 4.51pm)

His record as a whole is still impressive - after 73 games he's at 1.44 pts per game for his complete tenure - BUT the average points per game
trendline is trending heavily downward from 2 pts / game in the first half of his tenure, to 1 pt per game in 2016 (very close to NW's level of points return).

As pointed out elsewhere, 1 point per game gets you v. v. close to relegation.

He needs to be turning that trendline around & soon.

The net spend is good, but that does include selling Gayle & Yala, as much as I think AT & CB are improvements on the outgoing 2 as a package - it's still a net increase of zero premiership class players in the squad for your £16m. (Note Gayle had a better minutes to goals stat that Vardy last year).

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 16 5.37pm

Originally posted by Dancer Cat

His record as a whole is still impressive - after 73 games he's at 1.44 pts per game for his complete tenure - BUT the average points per game
trendline is trending heavily downward from 2 pts / game in the first half of his tenure, to 1 pt per game in 2016 (very close to NW's level of points return).

As pointed out elsewhere, 1 point per game gets you v. v. close to relegation.

He needs to be turning that trendline around & soon.

The net spend is good, but that does include selling Gayle & Yala, as much as I think AT & CB are improvements on the outgoing 2 as a package - it's still a net increase of zero premiership class players in the squad for your £16m. (Note Gayle had a better minutes to goals stat that Vardy last year).

One can discuss "Net Spend" in terms of transfer activity but there are also wages to consider.Last season our wage bill was @ £54 Mill and I think it was the 4th lowest in the PL. It will be more this year but we might still only be in the 'Bottom 6' on this front.

 

Page 8 of 12 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?