You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson Announcement
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson Announcement


Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 May 21 11.08am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Fair enough, maybe that was too direct.

He's definitely a survivor. He's manage to find countless ways negotiate the hostile politics of football for 4 decades, which is a huge personal achievement. Whilst other claims are questionable, there's no flawd rhetoric and no need for any PR spin to prove that point. The lengths he's gone to in order to stay in the game have proved it. From one of his harshest critics, I'll gladly give him that accolade. Truly impressive, on a personal level.

Well done Mr Hodgson, you can be very proud of yourself.

I find it ironic that you state that Westquay '' made several assumptions about me, which are wildly inaccurate, and I take that to be more of a reflection on you than me '' while you continue to peddle your own baseless assumptions about Hodgson.

Some of the personal attacks that you have directed at Hodgson have been way over the top and totally unwarranted.

Which I think is definitely a reflection on you.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 19 May 21 1.02pm

Originally posted by jeeagles


Well done Mr Hodgson, you can be very proud of yourself.

Bit late for this mate. Perhaps you should have posted just these words first time around then you wouldn't have attracted so many, justifiable, negative reactions.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 May 21 5.39pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

A principled man wouldn't have gone to South Africa in the middle of apartheid.

There's been a lot of cult like praise written on here over Hodgson in the last few years. Largely fuelled by the excellent PR work undertaken by Parish. Always remember Parish is a PR guru and can really turn on the mass charm offensive when he needs to. My views are cynical, and in this case direct, but I'd still wager the timing of the announcement on the last Monday before the final home game of the season has been planned for months and month.

The wording of post was in response to months and months of passive abusive comments by one of supporters who's never provided a coherent argument as to why he deserves to retain his highly paid and highly coveted job. Honestly, what did you expect me to do? Roll over and accept defeat like Roy and Dyke following the 2014 world cup draw?

Whilst my post was crass, particular posters deserved that dig. Their reaction to it showed tactical naivety only matched by Roy. If many are wound up that easily, I expect they have never played any sport. Come on guys, think things through. It was like taking candy from a cry-baby. They asked for it.

You've made several assumptions about me, which are wildly inaccurate, and I take that to be more of a reflection on you than me. I'm not shocked, surprised or offended by the responses - it's probably worth considered what a post will achieve before going in all guns blazing.

However, I admire your passion and sticking directly to what you believe in and I think your forthright response was warranted. Seems like many on HoL are more demanding of fellow posters than they are of the management. The poster I was trying to wind up, is a troll who seems to have a fetish for Priti Petal at the moment. He'd never come out that directly. Unfortunately, he'll never learn that if you go round making petty digs at people (but never enough to earn a yellow), they are going to get you back.

As for Roy, he did very well in his two season in charge and then holding the fort until subtle replacements have become available. I hope he enjoys his retirement.

Parish has also done extremely well to show patients and resist calls from the fans to be removed to the detriment of his own popularity. After FdB, Roy was all we could get in. After that season we were always more than likely to stay up (some of the relegated sides where pants). Parish's patients has frustrated whilst he has been willing to let us limp over the finish line, avoiding a payout and showing he's not a trigger happy chairman, and held on until a number of excellent alternative candidates are on the market. He's a cold, calculating man, you can tell how he's become a self made millionaire and excellent chairman.

To be honest I think a lot of the responses to you were a bit hysterical and typical crass football discussion board responses given the content of your post. Indeed I have seen far worse posts in the Politics section which received less vitriolic responses.

This is a board for debating and some will not like what others post. You have your view which I agree with in part but not all. I believe Roy has many good and honourable traits but I have never been a fan of his footballing style and have made that clear on numerous occasions.

I have little to comment on Roy going as I have wanted him out for a while however I do gratefully acknowledge his contribution to the club in keeping us up and out of trouble and wish him a happy retirement if that is what he is going to do. I can get no more excited about him as a manager as his tactics have bored me rigid for about three of the four years in charge.

To sum up for me, nice bloke, competent manager, loved the fact that he was a Palace fan but ultimately pleased that he has decided to call it a day. Bring on the new guy and hopefully some money to back him.

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 19 May 21 7.27pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

A principled man wouldn't have gone to South Africa in the middle of apartheid.

There's been a lot of cult like praise written on here over Hodgson in the last few years. Largely fuelled by the excellent PR work undertaken by Parish. Always remember Parish is a PR guru and can really turn on the mass charm offensive when he needs to. My views are cynical, and in this case direct, but I'd still wager the timing of the announcement on the last Monday before the final home game of the season has been planned for months and month.

The wording of post was in response to months and months of passive abusive comments by one of supporters who's never provided a coherent argument as to why he deserves to retain his highly paid and highly coveted job. Honestly, what did you expect me to do? Roll over and accept defeat like Roy and Dyke following the 2014 world cup draw?

Whilst my post was crass, particular posters deserved that dig. Their reaction to it showed tactical naivety only matched by Roy. If many are wound up that easily, I expect they have never played any sport. Come on guys, think things through. It was like taking candy from a cry-baby. They asked for it.

You've made several assumptions about me, which are wildly inaccurate, and I take that to be more of a reflection on you than me. I'm not shocked, surprised or offended by the responses - it's probably worth considered what a post will achieve before going in all guns blazing.

However, I admire your passion and sticking directly to what you believe in and I think your forthright response was warranted. Seems like many on HoL are more demanding of fellow posters than they are of the management. The poster I was trying to wind up, is a troll who seems to have a fetish for Priti Petal at the moment. He'd never come out that directly. Unfortunately, he'll never learn that if you go round making petty digs at people (but never enough to earn a yellow), they are going to get you back.

As for Roy, he did very well in his two season in charge and then holding the fort until subtle replacements have become available. I hope he enjoys his retirement.

Parish has also done extremely well to show patients and resist calls from the fans to be removed to the detriment of his own popularity. After FdB, Roy was all we could get in. After that season we were always more than likely to stay up (some of the relegated sides where pants). Parish's patients has frustrated whilst he has been willing to let us limp over the finish line, avoiding a payout and showing he's not a trigger happy chairman, and held on until a number of excellent alternative candidates are on the market. He's a cold, calculating man, you can tell how he's become a self made millionaire and excellent chairman.

You are a very sad person,have you got any mates.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 20 May 21 12.39am

Is that supposed to be an apology for being a knobhead?

Originally posted by jeeagles

Fair enough, maybe that was too direct.

He's definitely a survivor. He's manage to find countless ways negotiate the hostile politics of football for 4 decades, which is a huge personal achievement. Whilst other claims are questionable, there's no flawd rhetoric and no need for any PR spin to prove that point. The lengths he's gone to in order to stay in the game have proved it. From one of his harshest critics, I'll gladly give him that accolade. Truly impressive, on a personal level.

Well done Mr Hodgson, you can be very proud of yourself.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 May 21 6.29am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

To be honest I think a lot of the responses to you were a bit hysterical and typical crass football discussion board responses given the content of your post.

This is a board for debating and some will not like what others post. You have your view which I agree with in part but not all.

To sum up for me, nice bloke, competent manager, loved the fact that he was a Palace fan but ultimately pleased that he has decided to call it a day. Bring on the new guy and hopefully some money to back him.

There are ways to debate and discuss and outright insults in a thread where people are paying their respects to a manager that has worked wonders for this club bearing in mind the lack of investment and horrific injury record is not the way to do it.

Posting "Announcing he's jumping ship before the crowd turns on him against Arsenal.

Typical cowardice by Teflon Roy.

Great news for football in England." just shows a complete and utter lack of class from the poster whilst you have similar views but managed to make your feelings known without resorting to childish insults.

It's a shame that the mods felt it necessary to dish out yellow cards at a time when it was obviously an emotional time and certain individuals could have chosen their words a little more wisely I suppose

 

becky Flag over the moon 20 May 21 8.35am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

There are ways to debate and discuss and outright insults in a thread where people are paying their respects to a manager that has worked wonders for this club bearing in mind the lack of investment and horrific injury record is not the way to do it.

Posting "Announcing he's jumping ship before the crowd turns on him against Arsenal.

Typical cowardice by Teflon Roy.

Great news for football in England." just shows a complete and utter lack of class from the poster whilst you have similar views but managed to make your feelings known without resorting to childish insults.

It's a shame that the mods felt it necessary to dish out yellow cards at a time when it was obviously an emotional time and certain individuals could have chosen their words a little more wisely I suppose

Damned if you do and damned if you don't.......

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 May 21 8.47am

Originally posted by becky


Damned if you do and damned if you don't.......

As I well know

I suppose that I could have phrased my post better by changing one word:-

It's a shame that the mods felt it necessary to dish out yellow cards at a time when it was obviously an emotional time but certain individuals could have chosen their words a little more wisely I suppose

 

jeeagles Flag 20 May 21 8.47am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

There are ways to debate and discuss and outright insults in a thread where people are paying their respects to a manager that has worked wonders for this club bearing in mind the lack of investment and horrific injury record is not the way to do it.

Posting "Announcing he's jumping ship before the crowd turns on him against Arsenal.

Typical cowardice by Teflon Roy.

Great news for football in England." just shows a complete and utter lack of class from the poster whilst you have similar views but managed to make your feelings known without resorting to childish insults.

It's a shame that the mods felt it necessary to dish out yellow cards at a time when it was obviously an emotional time and certain individuals could have chosen their words a little more wisely I suppose

I stand by my carefully chosen words.
Yesterday's collapse had the potential to turn nasty for him.
If others can't control their emotions that's not my issue.
You're fully entitled to your opinion of me, I respect your honesty - let's let people say what they feel without getting overly sensitive.
Roy has still done well to survive in football for this long, although his ability to survive has been to the detriment of many teams he has managed.
The club know has a huge marketing team and people should be a little more cynical of the articles they are publishing.

How did you think your response would work out for you? Is this your first day on the internet?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 20 May 21 8.52am

I have often moaned at our tactics and I started a thread on Sunday, which was badly worded, for which I deservedly got criticised. I apologised and will again. I think Roy has done a great job with what he had at his disposal and I genuinely had tears in my eyes last night, listening to his speech. He loves the club and I wish him all the best.
I am both excited and scared as to what comes next, Ezes injury puts a damper on matters and the way the squad paid tribute to Eze ( Trekkers holding up 2 and 5 fingers after scoring, Townsend wearing his shirt) worries me that they know the injury is really bad.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 20 May 21 8.58am

Originally posted by jeeagles

I stand by my carefully chosen words.
Yesterday's collapse had the potential to turn nasty for him.
If others can't control their emotions that's not my issue.
You're fully entitled to your opinion of me, I respect your honesty - let's let people say what they feel without getting overly sensitive.
Roy has still done well to survive in football for this long, although his ability to survive has been to the detriment of many teams he has managed.
The club know has a huge marketing team and people should be a little more cynical of the articles they are publishing.

How did you think your response would work out for you? Is this your first day on the internet?

Have you listened to those in the game? Roy is highly respected for his coaching ability and is adored in Sweden, Switzerland and Milan. Not sure his management had a detrimental effect on Inter or the Swiss national team. I think you could at least acknowledge this and give credit where credit is due, even if you don’t like him

 

PatrickA Flag London 20 May 21 9.50am

I have been a critic of Roy for what
I have perceived as his negative approach to the game,in particular against teams outside the top 6.
And this negativity has not made us more solidly defensive as evidenced by our very poor defensive record this season.
But in fairness the players genuinely seem to think highly of him as a manager and a person.
It should also be acknowledged that none of the players he let go have so far have proved him wrong.
This would seem to highlight problems in the area of recruitment rather than Roy's supposedly erroneous use of them.
This is a tricky time for the club with Eze's injury and Zaha'a seemingly waning influence.


 

eaglesdare Flag 20 May 21 10.38am

I have to say the contrast between both big sam and roy last night has been massive!

Guard of honour by both sets of players. dignified in defeat and level head. the players and football world completely respect roy.

And then big sam...just have to watch his interviews from last night to know the difference.

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 20 May 21 10.48am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

As I well know

I suppose that I could have phrased my post better by changing one word:-

It's a shame that the mods felt it necessary to dish out yellow cards at a time when it was obviously an emotional time but certain individuals could have chosen their words a little more wisely I suppose


yes, I should have used 'total' rather than 'complete' , but I liked the alliteration.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 20 May 21 10.54am

Originally posted by jeeagles

I stand by my carefully chosen words.
Yesterday's collapse had the potential to turn nasty for him.
If others can't control their emotions that's not my issue.
You're fully entitled to your opinion of me, I respect your honesty - let's let people say what they feel without getting overly sensitive.
Roy has still done well to survive in football for this long, although his ability to survive has been to the detriment of many teams he has managed.
The club know has a huge marketing team and people should be a little more cynical of the articles they are publishing.

How did you think your response would work out for you? Is this your first day on the internet?

I think you are the one that can't control your emotions as demonstrated by the personal attacks that you have made on Roy Hodgson these past few months. They go beyond a dislike of his style of play etc., that most on here complain about. Your comments are generally spiteful, irrelevant and unpleasant.

You also like to play fast and loose with actual facts when they don't suit your anti Hodgson agenda. Now I know for a FACT that Roy is held in the highest esteem in Finland, Switzerland and at Fulham. I also understand that extends to Inter, West Brom and Malmo. So maybe you care to provide me with your list of clubs that he managed to their detriment ?

Clearly the show of gratitude and emotion shown by both the fans and the club are viewed by you as a PR exercise. Based upon what I don't know, other than again, it doesn't suit your agenda.

Now I know that you welcome honesty, so I'm going to say that if other posters have called you a '' knobhead / prick / very sad person '' then I tend to agree with them.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

cpfccccc Flag Bromley 20 May 21 11.13am

Jeeagles, please stop, you are making yourself look a bit of an idiot

You are not down the pub with your mates where emotion and pride can sometimes take over in arguments/discussions. You can just take a breath and let it go

You and countless others have repeated your thoughts on Roy over and over again on the numerous Roy in/out posts, so do you really think as Midlands has said that in a thread where people are paying their respects to a manager, that you need to attack Roy?

On a thread where other posters who were Anti Roy, have come out and acknowledged the great job Roy has done, then it shows a real lack of class and judgement to carry on as you are doing

You don't have to agree with the sentiments but can't you just let it go and look forward to a new manager?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 20 May 21 1.32pm

Originally posted by cpfccccc

Jeeagles, please stop, you are making yourself look a bit of an idiot

You are not down the pub with your mates where emotion and pride can sometimes take over in arguments/discussions. You can just take a breath and let it go

You and countless others have repeated your thoughts on Roy over and over again on the numerous Roy in/out posts, so do you really think as Midlands has said that in a thread where people are paying their respects to a manager, that you need to attack Roy?

On a thread where other posters who were Anti Roy, have come out and acknowledged the great job Roy has done, then it shows a real lack of class and judgement to carry on as you are doing

You don't have to agree with the sentiments but can't you just let it go and look forward to a new manager?


Let's wait and see.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 20 May 21 3.01pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

To be honest I think a lot of the responses to you were a bit hysterical and typical crass football discussion board responses given the content of your post. Indeed I have seen far worse posts in the Politics section which received less vitriolic responses.

This is a board for debating and some will not like what others post. You have your view which I agree with in part but not all. I believe Roy has many good and honourable traits but I have never been a fan of his footballing style and have made that clear on numerous occasions.

I have little to comment on Roy going as I have wanted him out for a while however I do gratefully acknowledge his contribution to the club in keeping us up and out of trouble and wish him a happy retirement if that is what he is going to do. I can get no more excited about him as a manager as his tactics have bored me rigid for about three of the four years in charge.

To sum up for me, nice bloke, competent manager, loved the fact that he was a Palace fan but ultimately pleased that he has decided to call it a day. Bring on the new guy and hopefully some money to back him.


Agree with all the above.

Some of the responses to Jeeagles have I agree with, been a bit hysterical.

Jeeagles comments were not my views but this is a forum and as a fellow Palace fan he has his right to express his opinions.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 20 May 21 3.10pm

Originally posted by glazedallover


yes, I should have used 'total' rather than 'complete' , but I liked the alliteration.

A sentiment shared by many. Please rest easy in the sure and certain knowledge that you well and truly took one for the team there.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 20 May 21 3.10pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


Agree with all the above.

Some of the responses to Jeeagles have I agree with, been a bit hysterical.

Jeeagles comments were not my views but this is a forum and as a fellow Palace fan he has his right to express his opinions.

Tom, I have no issues with his opinions. And of course on an internet forum there will be differences.

Personal and unfounded attacks on Hodgson though...for me that's a different matter.

But I am not without blame myself, by responding to an attention seeker.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson Announcement