This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by kuge
If you have a physical action or visual symbol that the people making it clearly state indicates that they are doing it to support a cause and then you refuse to take that action it will be presumed that you hold a different view. If it is the case that De Kock is a racist then the South African’s are better off without him. If on the other hand he is against racism but feels that taking a knee is not radical enough then he should just say so and take firmer action. At present, he has not made his position clear. Now I am aware that you find racism abhorrent and that you are firmly opposed to it, however, you also say that it’s not much of a problem and that we should ignore it. Now I know that many people who experience racism pretty much every day will differ with you on this and as racism is generally, but not exclusively, suffered by people of colour you may have just been lucky and not suffered it yourself. We clearly don’t need to experience suffering ourselves to understand how it might feel and to be empathetic. As regards symbols that indicate support for causes. In the coming weeks many if not the majority of people in the UK will be wearing poppies both to support the Royal British Legion and to signify their recognition of the debt that they owe to the millions that died fighting in two World Wars and other conflicts. Now it might be that you do not support the specific political ideologies that brought many of these conflicts about but you do want to honour the bravery and sacrifice of those that fought. Therefore you might decide to wear a poppy, indeed it will be controversial if you appear in a public context without one in the next three weeks. If poppies and other symbolic ‘gestures’ such as minutes of silence or applause are appropriate and important then why not others such as taking the knee? There is no situation in which an individual should be made to make a political gesture under threat of ruin. Taking a knee will never end what people refer to as racism. You and people like you are happy for this farce to continue because you think it is virtuous, when in fact it is extremely cynical and driven by the usual motives, namely money and power.
|
|
|
Originally posted by kuge
Yes, I agree racism is a component of broader systemic structural oppression throughout society that seeks to maintain power over people through compliance. You clearly understand this and yet you resist this small action that seeks to highlight a specific but very important aspect of this oppression. Discrimination on the basis of gender, race, sexuality, class or for any other reason is wrong. The cohesive happy society that we all desire is only obtainable if equality is available to all. Any action that oppressed people make to expose and diminish their oppression will always be resisted by the oppressors. The force with which the racists struggle against the actions is indicative of their weakness. Racism is wrong, so why oppose fighting against it? If you feel action is unnecessary then it is at most an inconvenience. I fundamentally disagree with you that discrimination on the basis of gender, race, sexuality, class or for any other reason is always wrong....it depends. It's one of those hypocritical statements that all the drones come out with without thinking. I regard it as an absurd statement as people discriminate on all these things daily as discrimination is what humans are designed to do. To vilify if goes against how humans naturally behave....and how you and everyone else behaves. Discrimination is even being practiced here. It's just discrimination that you approve of. People discriminate on gender and sexuality and general genetics when they choose their mates, what they look for and don't...looks they like and looks they don't. No girl can control how long her legs are but that will influence the number of admirers she has. Egalitarianism is BS....I prefer to think of fairness. People discriminate on race when they create organisations specifically designed for them....BLM, MoBO, BPO. People discriminate when they fund black only scholarships and refuse white ones....discrimination on race is actually practiced much more by the left than anyone else. People discriminate on class pretty much all the time....by the bubble of people who are their friends, by their classist attitudes....your middle class attitudes for example. This cricketer deserves the same freedom that people who took the knee were given when it started. You are against his freedom and agree with punishing him for his conscience. Once again, when this started I was told that people were free to express their views without fear. This is proving the exact opposite. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Oct 2021 9.53am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by kuge
Yes, I agree racism is a component of broader systemic structural oppression throughout society that seeks to maintain power over people through compliance. You clearly understand this and yet you resist this small action that seeks to highlight a specific but very important aspect of this oppression. Discrimination on the basis of gender, race, sexuality, class or for any other reason is wrong. The cohesive happy society that we all desire is only obtainable if equality is available to all. Any action that oppressed people make to expose and diminish their oppression will always be resisted by the oppressors. The force with which the racists struggle against the actions is indicative of their weakness. Racism is wrong, so why oppose fighting against it? If you feel action is unnecessary then it is at most an inconvenience. Where in the UK is equality not apparent?
|
|
|
Originally posted by kuge
I am unsure what ‘line’ you are referring to. Perhaps you mean that ‘forcing’ people to wear poppies is wrong? Your inference that resistance is something that the ‘Party’ would have encouraged is classic ‘doublethink’. Orwell’s book is far more complex than it is popularly portrayed. He recognised that the control of societies through the media is prevalent and that it should be resisted. Nobody is forced to wear a poppy. Some, Jim Davidson for instance, does not wear a poppy because of issues he has with the British Legion, yet he does a great deal for other armed services charities. Supporting BLM is a political statement, wearing a poppy is not. Edited by georgenorman (27 Oct 2021 10.59am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Nobody is forced to wear a poppy. Some, Jim Davidson for instance, does not wear a poppy because of issues he has with the British Legion, yet he does a great deal for other armed services charities. Supporting BLM is a political statement, wearing a poppy is not. Edited by georgenorman (27 Oct 2021 10.59am) Taking the knee is not political, the players taking a knee have said that they are doing it to highlight racism in society. The origin of the action was outside of politics. If you want to consider it political then you must concede that all actions are in some way political and that therefore wearing a poppy is political. All political parties other than the extremists oppose racism.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Nobody is forced to wear a poppy. Some, Jim Davidson for instance, does not wear a poppy because of issues he has with the British Legion, yet he does a great deal for other armed services charities. Supporting BLM is a political statement, wearing a poppy is not. Edited by georgenorman (27 Oct 2021 10.59am) Tell that to James Mclean who gets dogs abuse every year for not wearing one. It's been explained so many times that the gesture is not in support of BLM.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Tell that to James Mclean who gets dogs abuse every year for not wearing one. It's been explained so many times that the gesture is not in support of BLM. When they started doing it here they were literally wearing the BLM logo.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by kuge
Taking the knee is not political, the players taking a knee have said that they are doing it to highlight racism in society. The origin of the action was outside of politics. If you want to consider it political then you must concede that all actions are in some way political and that therefore wearing a poppy is political. All political parties other than the extremists oppose racism. Rubbish. Poppies represent the remembrance of dead soldiers. They serve no other purpose except perhaps to remind us of the cost of war. You are trying to be 'right' while knowing full well that what you claim is nonsense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Where in the UK is equality not apparent? Where to start. In nearly every part of society, the UK governments own data clearly demonstrates the inequality present in our society.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Tell that to James Mclean who gets dogs abuse every year for not wearing one. It's been explained so many times that the gesture is not in support of BLM. Except that the goal posts get shifted every time it comes under scrutiny. What exactly is taking the knee meant to achieve again? I'm still unsure.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
When they started doing it here they were literally wearing the BLM logo. And before that it was done by Colin Kaepernick with no affiliation to any political organisation, and was chosen as a particularly inoffensive way of making his point. And since then, specific to English football it's been explained hundreds of time that they are not supporting the political organisation - we've hit a point where people can witness a protest, ask the protestors what they're protesting about, and when they answer, we tell them they're wrong and they're actually protesting something different.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Except that the goal posts get shifted every time it comes under scrutiny. What exactly is taking the knee meant to achieve again? I'm still unsure. If you're that unsure you could consider listening to the people partaking in the protest, that's normally a good starting point in trying to understand their cause. Luckily in this case there's tens of published interviews you could check out, although I've no doubt you'd still conclude you know better than them what they are protesting.
|
|
|
Originally posted by kuge
Where to start. In nearly every part of society, the UK governments own data clearly demonstrates the inequality present in our society. Equality of outcome is different to equality of opportunity. What the government is concerned with is fully utilizing immigrant labour in all sectors by trying to counter the disadvantage they have simply by being a minority. People look after their own, and no one does that more than immigrants.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
If you're that unsure you could consider listening to the people partaking in the protest, that's normally a good starting point in trying to understand their cause. Luckily in this case there's tens of published interviews you could check out, although I've no doubt you'd still conclude you know better than them what they are protesting. I have, and they talk in riddles. There is no substance. All I hear is the parroting of meaningless platitudes. What has it achieved so far? I'm keen to know. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (27 Oct 2021 11.30am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I have, and they talk in riddles. There is no substance. All I here is the parroting of meaningless platitudes. What has it achieved so far? I'm keen to know. The idea that you assess the validity of a protest based on what it achieved is silly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by kuge
Taking the knee is not political, the players taking a knee have said that they are doing it to highlight racism in society. The origin of the action was outside of politics. If you want to consider it political then you must concede that all actions are in some way political and that therefore wearing a poppy is political. All political parties other than the extremists oppose racism. Of course it is political. It is one of the most discussed political issues of the last year or two.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
And before that it was done by Colin Kaepernick with no affiliation to any political organisation, and was chosen as a particularly inoffensive way of making his point. And since then, specific to English football it's been explained hundreds of time that they are not supporting the political organisation - we've hit a point where people can witness a protest, ask the protestors what they're protesting about, and when they answer, we tell them they're wrong and they're actually protesting something different. Kaepernick supports all the same black political movements that push this agenda. I just think it's disingenuous to claim that this has nothing to do with BLM when it's an action they were doing and that they support and that the players and FA copied. If I started doing the Hitler salute and told you it was just nationalism and unrelated to the Nazis or disliking Jews I expect you wouldn't believe me....especially if previously I was doing it in a brown shirt. This is repeating the 'argument on the boards previously....kind of pointless as none of us are going to agree. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Oct 2021 11.36am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
The idea that you assess the validity of a protest based on what it achieved is silly. The validity of opposing racism is not in question. The question is why we are persisting with a useless gesture, and why anyone thinks that we need a constant barrage of supposedly anti racist propaganda in Britain where racism is not a significant issue.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Kaepernick supports all the same black political movements that push this agenda. I just think it's disingenuous to claim that this has nothing to do with BLM when it's an action they were doing and that they support and that the players and FA copied. If I started doing the Hitler salute and told you it was just nationalism and unrelated to the Nazis or disliking Jews I expect you wouldn't believe me....especially if previously I was doing it in a brown shirt. This is repeating the 'argument on the boards previously....kind of pointless as none of us are going to agree. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Oct 2021 11.36am) But when the gesture existed as an anti-racism gesture long, long before BLM as an organisation even existed, that logic doesn't make sense. If there are tens of example of the Nazi gesture being used by other nationalist organisations, over decades, without any links to Nazis, then the comparison might be apt.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Rubbish. Poppies represent the remembrance of dead soldiers. They serve no other purpose except perhaps to remind us of the cost of war. You are trying to be 'right' while knowing full well that what you claim is nonsense. Taking the knee asks us to remember that racism is a cancer on our society. It serves no other purpose than to remind us of that. I agree that poppies remind us of the human cost of war but they also serve another additional purpose in that they raise money for the support of injured veterans. This was the original purpose of the poppy. As I am sure you know it was the idea of an American woman Moina Michael, inspired by a poem by the Canadian soldier John McCrae, to make and sell poppies to raise money to support returning troops. It was a French woman, Anna Guérin, that introduced the idea of selling poppies as a money-raising campaign to the UK in 1921.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.