This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by MrWhyNot
No, you just didn't understand the I'm spartacus point being made re: W12. Edited by MrWhyNot (15 Oct 2022 10.17pm) Yes I was aware of the reference point. It's just that you're a relative newbie who seems to knows all the nuances & layout of the site as well as some past HOL members
Pro USA & Israel |
|
| MrWhyNot |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
Yes I was aware of the reference point. It's just that you're a relative newbie who seems to knows all the nuances & layout of the site as well as some past HOL members Mattconrov and I are avid longtime fans of the site. Enjoy your weekend
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mattconrov
Most people with a couple of brain cells can work out that the government of the world has certain agendas being pushed. Your liberty is at risk if you question them. These trans or racial agendas have nothing to do with the government caring about those "minority groups ". They are a means to an end to bring in total compliance to the state. It is happening everywhere and it's coordinated. and there seems to be huge enthusiasm in enforcing these new Laws. Whereas, i cannot comment upon the enthusiasm with which the old laws are being enforced. (burglary, vandalism, assault etc) Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Oct 2022 6.14pm)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
Yes I was aware of the reference point. It's just that you're a relative newbie who seems to knows all the nuances & layout of the site as well as some past HOL members Hang on. Since when did both of them get red carded
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I remember a while back people complaining that Russia didn't allow its citizens free speech.....something I agree is bad. However, while not as bad yet, when the counter point was made that this country has its own oppressive and threatening state action on free speech I found that this was largely ignored and diminished. However, I'm seeing Police actions that show that this really isn't the case...the Lawrence Fox incident was one. And today, I saw this: [Tweet Link]
Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Oct 2022 1.48pm) The policeman is wrong about the law, what about if you are Just Stop Oil and have this chap's views , do you get a warning and a cup of tea? This is thought police nonsense, either a crime has been committed or it hasn't. Offending someone is not a crime, yet Edited by HKOwen (20 Oct 2022 11.39am)
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
The policeman is wrong about the law, what about if you are Just Stop Ol and have this cha's views , do you get a warning and a cup of tea? This is thought police nonsense, either a crime ahs been committed or it hasn't. Offending someone is not a crime, yet Yes, the policeman was wrong if what was shown in the video was all he responded to. Regrettably there is no way we can be certain of that. Too often videos get manipulated in ways which present a story which supports a particular narrative. I am not suggesting this was. I am suggesting a degree of caution is necessary. "Non-mainstream" often equals unreliable.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
I've for a while now been against the seeming totalitarianism being showered upon us in the suppression of free speech and the coercive nature of dictating also what we 'must' say - perhaps even more sinister. For me it is the ultimate hijacking of what seems like a reasonable, logical and fair notion (to crack down on the likes of hate speech, terror etc.) however is often taken to far and used to achieve political and ideological ends (the far lefts and rights). The other side to it however is that we live in a society able to communicate to one another, and more importantly, the world en masse which paves the way for anybody and everybody to start promulgating nonsense which by it's nature empowers the misaligned and disturbed but also captures weaker minds. Here's the latest example for me - [Link] The problem is in ensuring certain peoples are not allowed such a platform but then comes the old question of who makes the decisions - 'Who will Police the Police?'. The likes of social media platforms are obviously great for a variety of reasons however an objective and logical review is needed of this IMHO however I question whether such a thing exists or can exist?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I've for a while now been against the seeming totalitarianism being showered upon us in the suppression of free speech and the coercive nature of dictating also what we 'must' say - perhaps even more sinister. For me it is the ultimate hijacking of what seems like a reasonable, logical and fair notion (to crack down on the likes of hate speech, terror etc.) however is often taken to far and used to achieve political and ideological ends (the far lefts and rights). The other side to it however is that we live in a society able to communicate to one another, and more importantly, the world en masse which paves the way for anybody and everybody to start promulgating nonsense which by it's nature empowers the misaligned and disturbed but also captures weaker minds. Here's the latest example for me - [Link] The problem is in ensuring certain peoples are not allowed such a platform but then comes the old question of who makes the decisions - 'Who will Police the Police?'. The likes of social media platforms are obviously great for a variety of reasons however an objective and logical review is needed of this IMHO however I question whether such a thing exists or can exist? I think the "victim" made a valid point. This is not free speech issue when you are accusing someone of faking being disabled. If they are what they say they are then it is libel, this idiot like the one in the US (Sandy Hook) is making a living off other people's misery so they are entitled to sue and I hope they do.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I think the "victim" made a valid point. This is not free speech issue when you are accusing someone of faking being disabled. If they are what they say they are then it is libel, this idiot like the one in the US (Sandy Hook) is making a living off other people's misery so they are entitled to sue and I hope they do. Oh no I totally agree Badger this is (at the very least) harassment and libel, plain and simple. I think what I was more concentrated on is some loser like this getting hooked upon 'conspiracy theories', taking them to an extreme but also being both influenced by and influencing others, I am guessing, online. My thoughts are more around 'anybody being able to say anything' to a virtually unlimited audience. I am inclined to believe half the societal issues we see these days are played out far more online than they are in reality.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
The policeman is wrong about the law, what about if you are Just Stop Oil and have this chap's views , do you get a warning and a cup of tea? This is thought police nonsense, either a crime has been committed or it hasn't. Offending someone is not a crime, yet Edited by HKOwen (20 Oct 2022 11.39am) Offending someone is only a crime when the Police consider it to be. England stopped being England during Blair's time. He destroyed hundreds of years of our traditions in several ways and that was one of them.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Oh no I totally agree Badger this is (at the very least) harassment and libel, plain and simple. I think what I was more concentrated on is some loser like this getting hooked upon 'conspiracy theories', taking them to an extreme but also being both influenced by and influencing others, I am guessing, online. My thoughts are more around 'anybody being able to say anything' to a virtually unlimited audience. I am inclined to believe half the societal issues we see these days are played out far more online than they are in reality. I agree with libel. However, what you have been seeing is political and legal abuse with rewards. As soon as you start agreeing with expansion to the censoring of speech over on what we had before Blair, you have opened to the door to the lunatics who will never stop with, 'what about this?', 'look at the damage done' and all of the rest of the subjective stuff that people have accepted as the price for freedom for centuries. People's lives have already been damaged by activists abusing these laws for their own petty personal animosities. This site itself has been attacked by these people. On a much wider scale comedy has been destroyed from the standards we had and it's down to this.....the knock on effects are everywhere in society. The power has been given to the very worst people....and b0llocks to it. Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Oct 2022 3.02pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I agree with libel. However, what you have been seeing is political and legal abuse with rewards. As soon as you start agreeing with expansion to the censoring of speech over on what we had before Blair, you have opened to the door to the lunatics who will never stop with, 'what about this?', 'look at the damage done' and all of the rest of the subjective stuff that people have accepted as the price for freedom for centuries. People's lives have already been damaged by activists abusing these laws for their own petty personal animosities. This site itself has been attacked by these people. On a much wider scale comedy has been destroyed from the standards we had and it's down to this.....the knock on effects are everywhere in society. The power has been given to the very worst people....and b0llocks to it. Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Oct 2022 3.02pm) Yep, that's exactly my point Stirling. We have seen a rise in ideologues supposedly on the 'left', whom utilise the likes of social media (see next para.) and if granted such powers it is not common sense but power prevailing and to favour those it rests with. Before we had seen it with 'media' (printing press and so on) but now it lies with the many who, as a collective, are downright stupid if not malignant. That's my reasoning behind the argument that much of the nonsense we see today is promulgated by the weak and failures as they can safely and anonymously (both to a degree) utilise platforms to spread their own ideologies which are based on nothing more than a desire to change the world, in which they have failed, to something else in which they might stand a chance. This is of course to the detriment of the many. It was first and foremost but even now most predominantly utilised by the 'far left' but those on the other end of the spectrum will not be far behind in following the same methodology. Look at the fear generated over Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, the left are sincerely fearing a level playing field or sharing that which they have weaponised. Edited by Nicholas91 (31 Oct 2022 3.50pm)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yep, that's exactly my point Stirling. We have seen a rise in ideologues supposedly on the 'left', whom utilise the likes of social media (see next para.) and if granted such powers it is not common sense but power prevailing and to favour those it rests with. Before we had seen it with 'media' (printing press and so on) but now it lies with the many who, as a collective, are downright stupid if not malignant. That's my reasoning behind the argument that much of the nonsense we see today is promulgated by the weak and failures as they can safely and anonymously (both to a degree) utilise platforms to spread their own ideologies which are based on nothing more than a desire to change the world, in which they have failed, to something else in which they might stand a chance. This is of course to the detriment of the many. It was first and foremost but even now most predominantly utilised by the 'far left' but those on the other end of the spectrum will not be far behind in following the same methodology. Look at the fear generated over Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, the left are sincerely fearing a level playing field or sharing that which they have weaponised. Edited by Nicholas91 (31 Oct 2022 3.50pm) Yep, it all comes down to power and they will invent some of the most ridiculous waffle to justify sharing any. I suppose we will see if the Musk effect leads to any freeing up in the public discourse because all the worst people are after him. They turned someone who literally is a libertarian left of centre into some hate figure.....insane. Today we venerate the mentality ill and give them the keys to power. Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Oct 2022 5.13pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yep, that's exactly my point Stirling. We have seen a rise in ideologues supposedly on the 'left', whom utilise the likes of social media (see next para.) and if granted such powers it is not common sense but power prevailing and to favour those it rests with. Before we had seen it with 'media' (printing press and so on) but now it lies with the many who, as a collective, are downright stupid if not malignant. That's my reasoning behind the argument that much of the nonsense we see today is promulgated by the weak and failures as they can safely and anonymously (both to a degree) utilise platforms to spread their own ideologies which are based on nothing more than a desire to change the world, in which they have failed, to something else in which they might stand a chance. This is of course to the detriment of the many. It was first and foremost but even now most predominantly utilised by the 'far left' but those on the other end of the spectrum will not be far behind in following the same methodology. Look at the fear generated over Elon Musk's takeover of Twitter, the left are sincerely fearing a level playing field or sharing that which they have weaponised. Edited by Nicholas91 (31 Oct 2022 3.50pm) It is worth noting here that the idea of total free speech across social media platforms is a fantasy, as long as those platforms a) require advertising to make money and b) require massive user bases to remain viable. Some great quotes from a recent Verge article on the matter Here are some examples: you can write as many polite letters to advertisers as you want, but you cannot reasonably expect to collect any meaningful advertising revenue if you do not promise those advertisers “brand safety.” That means you have to ban racism, sexism, transphobia, and all kinds of other speech that is totally legal in the United States but reveals people to be total assholes. So you can make all the promises about “free speech” you want, but the dull reality is that you still have to ban a bunch of legal speech if you want to make money. 'it turns out that most people do not want to participate in horrible unmoderated internet spaces full of s***ty racists and not-all-men fedora bullies. (This is why Twitter is so small compared to its peers!) What most people want from social media is to have nice experiences and to feel validated all the time. They want to live at Disney World. So if you want more people to join Twitter and actually post tweets, you have to make the experience much, much more pleasant. Which means: moderating more aggressively! Again, every “alternative” social network has learned this lesson the hard way. Like, over and over and over again.' Parler - banning users Truth social – heavy moderation (eg. posts containing 'abortion is healthcare' being shadow-banned) More on Parler, an amusing exerpt from techdirt 'You may recall that last summer, we mocked how Parler was speed running the content moderation learning curve. It seems that every year a new social media service pops up, insisting that it believes in “free speech” and won’t “censor” anything. And then… reality hits. And it realizes that if you do no moderation at all, your website is a total and complete garbage dump full of spam, p***. harassment, abuse and trolling. And just as Parler learned it needed to do some moderation (and its then CEO even bragged about kicking off “leftist trolls”), every new platform learns the same damn thing eventually. Though, amusingly, it seems to happen faster and faster each time.' So context is required when complaining about the lack of free speech on social media platforms. Moderation of content in order to provide a more usable product for audiences is just an inevitable reality. No point moaning about something that is impossible to create, in my view.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I see the public are ignoring the police request not to intervene with these idiot eco protestors. Well Mr Plod if you don't want vigilante action then I suggest you try nicking these idiots instead of asking them if they want food and water. No doubt you will be bringing in out door heaters in case the little darlings catch cold. The public are tired of being held to ransom by a bunch of middle class whites (when do you ever see a black eco protestor). Life is hard enough for working people then you are trying to get around London only to be held up whilst the police stand around and do nothing. Quite frankly senior police officers should be sacked for dereliction of duty. well said.
Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents? |
|
|
I assume the recent Dover incident is a similar reaction by a member of the public who is fed up with inaction by the Authorities. Originally posted by Badger11
I see the public are ignoring the police request not to intervene with these idiot eco protestors. Well Mr Plod if you don't want vigilante action then I suggest you try nicking these idiots instead of asking them if they want food and water. No doubt you will be bringing in out door heaters in case the little darlings catch cold. The public are tired of being held to ransom by a bunch of middle class whites (when do you ever see a black eco protestor). Life is hard enough for working people then you are trying to get around London only to be held up whilst the police stand around and do nothing. Quite frankly senior police officers should be sacked for dereliction of duty.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
I think I should push back on this narrative because I've heard it a lot from various on the left/centre on trying to justify the censorious landscape of the last five/ten years online. Not only have I heard the above arguments before, and finding left media narratives on it isn't hard, but I've heard similar narratives made about Hollywood and other televisual media. I'll try to address these points, though I think we have all been here before: Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
It is worth noting here that the idea of total free speech across social media platforms is a fantasy, as long as those platforms a) require advertising to make money and b) require massive user bases to remain viable. I don't believe anyone was saying that 'total free speech' was a thing. In fact it's never existed officially. I have some respect for the libertarian viewpoint on 'free speech absolutism' just as we can have respect for many aspects of utopianism. However, that isn't the same as saying it's practical....indeed, like many utopian ideals, more damage is done in trying to create them than in dealing with the practical realities and consequences of human interactions. What was being stated was the criticism of deliberate social engineering in the narrowing of free speech that the left and socially liberal government have endorsed and more importantly legislated and regulated for. That's a very important point....it's not a binary concerning a freedom that's never existed but a commentary on a freedom that's been considerable minimalized....and what the consequences of that have been. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Some great quotes from a recent Verge article on the matter Here are some examples: you can write as many polite letters to advertisers as you want, but you cannot reasonably expect to collect any meaningful advertising revenue if you do not promise those advertisers “brand safety.” That means you have to ban racism, sexism, transphobia, and all kinds of other speech that is totally legal in the United States but reveals people to be total assholes. So you can make all the promises about “free speech” you want, but the dull reality is that you still have to ban a bunch of legal speech if you want to make money. 'it turns out that most people do not want to participate in horrible unmoderated internet spaces full of s***ty racists and not-all-men fedora bullies. (This is why Twitter is so small compared to its peers!) What most people want from social media is to have nice experiences and to feel validated all the time. They want to live at Disney World. So if you want more people to join Twitter and actually post tweets, you have to make the experience much, much more pleasant. Which means: moderating more aggressively! Again, every “alternative” social network has learned this lesson the hard way. Like, over and over and over again.' I think SW makes it quite clear where his position is here with these value judgements. However, I think some points can be made on the topic independently of whether we like what someone thinks or not. No advertisers are required to support outlets they have issue with. However, I think SW ignores some points here. When we look at media like Tucker Carlson and Alex Jones (when he wasn't banned) the reality is that those shows were and in Carlson's case are advertised on....it's just who those advertisers are. Evidence: [Link] Anyone who knows about 'media matters' understands that they are massively funded and aimed at war with Fox News and other right wing outlets. Rather than SW's contention that advertisers are freely deciding, out of some moral maze, that right wing opinions are unacceptable to them, the rather more nasty reality is that well funded left wing activist groups use lawfare, threats and pressure to frighten advertisers away from their ideological opponents. They use the same tactic that the American religious right used generations ago. In the modern right wing space, which is less national, advertisers are full and plentiful. That very fact kind of negates the contention that it's just a 'brand safety' moral issue. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
Parler - banning users Truth social – heavy moderation (eg. posts containing 'abortion is healthcare' being shadow-banned) More on Parler, an amusing exerpt from techdirt 'You may recall that last summer, we mocked how Parler was speed running the content moderation learning curve. It seems that every year a new social media service pops up, insisting that it believes in “free speech” and won’t “censor” anything. And then… reality hits. And it realizes that if you do no moderation at all, your website is a total and complete garbage dump full of spam, p***. harassment, abuse and trolling. And just as Parler learned it needed to do some moderation (and its then CEO even bragged about kicking off “leftist trolls”), every new platform learns the same damn thing eventually. Though, amusingly, it seems to happen faster and faster each time.' So context is required when complaining about the lack of free speech on social media platforms. Moderation of content in order to provide a more usable product for audiences is just an inevitable reality. No point moaning about something that is impossible to create, in my view. I think when SW refers to Parler and Truth Social we are talking less about free speech and more about right wing platforms. There are two important aspects to remember here. Firstly that Parler was the fastest growing platform before Apple removed its app from its store...it was popular with users and it was Apple's regulations (which many view as anti-competitive) which did for Parler, not advertisers with moral consciences.....actually that very idea is amusing to me. Secondly Truth Social nor Parler were never 'absolutist free speech' platforms and were never advertised as such. They presented themselves as pro conservative or just more for free speech than Twitter was. In fact, I regard both Parler and Truth Social as rather poor representatives of 'free speech'. I think there is often a conflation between the right and what free speech is. Yes, free speech is far more supported....in the present by the right, however in my youth the left were its champions with really only the religious right (which was far stronger then) as its opponents....but saying that the left were more for free speech back then, than the more prim and proper right of those times, is a fair remembarance....boy has that changed. However, for me I see 'free speech' as independent of the political and more a society issue. I question the increase in restrictions as significant provable downgrades not protections....I point out the considerable scope for abuse of what is and isn't viewed as a 'protection'. Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
So context is required when complaining about the lack of free speech on social media platforms. Moderation of content in order to provide a more usable product for audiences is just an inevitable reality. No point moaning about something that is impossible to create, in my view. I think perhaps you are justifying a 'one size fits all' requirement for social media here that I just differ on. You contended that the market demands that where I think that when you actually look at the market you can see variance that refutes that...Also, I think the laws and regulations need to be considered for their affect on corporate investment, they have been fiddled with considerably since Bill Clinton. I contend that what you are seeing isn't a corporate world with any diversity and that's one that's been deliberately created....the larger the company the larger the pressure to conform. What I think is more the truth is that the larger corporate world is within that space because it is required to be...in many senses they know they are leaving money on the table. There are plenty of advertisers who understand that money is there to be made.....I think the Tucker Carlson point holds this up well as he is the most popular show on news broadcast media yet the attack on advertisers who used it was plain to see....in more normal times his show would not be boycotted by any advertisers. I don't think anyone has an issue with heavily moderated platforms within a market where people are allowed to choose, without political or legal pressure attacking their choices.....Parler for example. I think the area where we might find some agreement is on social media in general and its overall affect upon society. That's a related topic and some might say that similar to p00rn or alcohol, that it serves a natural human need but one that can easily be expressed as an outlet for human vices. There are certainly a lot of rich people who have made a lot of money out of it.....where there is a demand and it's technologically possible, there will be a supply. However, the problem often comes in what is thought of as solutions to these problems......Not that personally I think solutions are ever really possible and that flexible adaptations are more realistic. Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Nov 2022 3.12am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.