This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Matov
The thing is that Labour are actually 'winning' in terms of the Tories basically stealing some of their economic ideas. But they are then hitting themselves in the head with a club hammer with all this Trans BS. I genuinely struggle to understand this later part. I have long suspected that being in opposition is far more fun in terms of the political larking and Labour is now so used to it that the dopamine hit from actually being in power is nowhere near as good as when they are losing. The smug, self-righteous 'force' is stronger when you can sneer at the proles who have the audacity to ignore you. Don't even need to pretend to care about the working class if they consistently kick you in the electoral bollocks. Akin to a kind of gambling addiction although I accept it's not a clear analogy. Good point. They are still in "Corbyn mode" it's great fun rubbishing the government just ask CP, less fun when you are the one having to make tough decisions. Corbyn has been a protestor all his life and galvanised the party with new members (protestors) however when it came to be a government in waiting he had feet of clay. Labour need to get out of this mode.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
He was not ruthless enough. That was his problem. But what he achieved in 2017 was stunning. A seriously impressive election result. Labours activists really hit the cobbles and made a huge difference. In 2019 though it backfired, and all down to that second referendum. Championed by a man who not only then took over from Corbyn but then kicked him out of the party. This is proper Shakespearian political theatre. Incredible really.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
I sincerely hope the media will now put this whole, sordid business to bed. Of course they were wrong to show such blatant disregard for the world outside their bubble. But, as I see it, the folk concerned, were all working together, under one roof, as a team, grappling with the issues generated by an unprecedented pandemic. They let off steam and had a few drinks. They should not have behaved the way they did, but the media storm that followed has been an outrageous waste of time and money. Time to let it go Beth, Laura, Robert and Co. PS I did like Boris' reference to 'Sir Beer Korma' yesterday though. The media storm you refer to clearly didn't include the Sun or the Mail which ignored the story - in fact it the Mail that focused on Sir Keir Starmer's one beer for 13 consecutive days?? BTW who owns those papers and who did Johnson's wife date before Boris (Harry Cole, in case you can't join the dots) Boris was so humbled in his apology that he couldn't resist a little joke, that you say you liked, despite using that same rationale as exactly the reason why he didn't deserve a fine. Next you'll be saying he got all the big decisions right - despite over 170k deaths and a boarder in the Irish sea, plus food prices going through the roof (and that's before the Ukraine war started) Edited by palace99 (27 May 2022 11.04am) Edited by palace99 (27 May 2022 11.06am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Good point. They are still in "Corbyn mode" it's great fun rubbishing the government just ask CP, less fun when you are the one having to make tough decisions. Corbyn has been a protestor all his life and galvanised the party with new members (protestors) however when it came to be a government in waiting he had feet of clay. Labour need to get out of this mode. Literally yesterday the government picked up Labour's windfall tax proposal and called it their own. And people seriously question why the opposition wouldn't be more forthcoming with their own policy ideas with no GE in sight.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Literally yesterday the government picked up Labour's windfall tax proposal and called it their own. And people seriously question why the opposition wouldn't be more forthcoming with their own policy ideas with no GE in sight. A windfall tax is hardly original sure Labour suggested it first but it's been around for many years and been used by both parties. Labour can claim they said it first but they can't claim it as their own. Edited by Badger11 (27 May 2022 11.22am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
A windfall tax is hardly original sure Labour suggested it first but it's been around for many years and been used by both parties. Labour can claim they said it first but they can't claim it as their own. Edited by Badger11 (27 May 2022 11.22am) What, so it only counts as being decent opposition if Labour come up with entirely original proposals? Cmon... the Tories voted against a windfall tax a week ago and have now decided it's a good idea. I'd say that's a great example of being effective opposition.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
What, so it only counts as being decent opposition if Labour come up with entirely original proposals? Cmon... the Tories voted against a windfall tax a week ago and have now decided it's a good idea. I'd say that's a great example of being effective opposition. I tend to agree with this. The purpose of an effective opposition is to argue against policies and not individuals (something all sides should concern themselves more with). By getting the conservatives to about turn on the windfall tax is effective lobbying. However I would temper this by saying that Boris is currently getting desperate for public affection so a cynic would say he has only done this to try and win back some voters.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I tend to agree with this. The purpose of an effective opposition is to argue against policies and not individuals (something all sides should concern themselves more with). By getting the conservatives to about turn on the windfall tax is effective lobbying. However I would temper this by saying that Boris is currently getting desperate for public affection so a cynic would say he has only done this to try and win back some voters. I feel like a victim of abuse, being chucked a few beans and told "Sorry about that, It won't happen again" Peter Sutcliffe hasn't murdered anyone for ages now. Why shouldn't he go free, because he seems alright to me ?
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I feel like a victim of abuse, being chucked a few beans and told "Sorry about that, It won't happen again" Peter Sutcliffe hasn't murdered anyone for ages now. Why shouldn't he go free, because he seems alright to me ? He is free. He’s dead !
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
What, so it only counts as being decent opposition if Labour come up with entirely original proposals? Cmon... the Tories voted against a windfall tax a week ago and have now decided it's a good idea. I'd say that's a great example of being effective opposition. What were the reasons against a windfall tax?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
What were the reasons against a windfall tax? Why should landlords be hit for a mode of investment choice which has already received a massive hit in the last few years due to the removal of tax relief on mortgages? I for one will sell up they start attacking the rental market again and then the properties will probably be sold into the owner occupied market. Net result, hey presto, massive shortage of rental properties available and rents will continue to rocket up. Are you sure this idea has been fully thought through?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
What were the reasons against a windfall tax? The main reasons against are that it costs money and doesn't keep your industry donors very happy. I don't think the profit margins of Barry the landlord are comparable to BP.
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Just ask Matov- a CONservative- what he thinks, chuckle, There must be a village missing an idiot somewhere. Why not offer your services.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
What, so it only counts as being decent opposition if Labour come up with entirely original proposals? Cmon... the Tories voted against a windfall tax a week ago and have now decided it's a good idea. I'd say that's a great example of being effective opposition. Wanting to put up taxes, Labour has been singing that song for years now the so called Tories have joined them. I say so called because I don't recognise this Conservative party it's Blair's Labour Party. And before you say it yes the bloody Tories aught to come up with some original ideas they are the government after all.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Wanting to put up taxes, Labour has been singing that song for years now the so called Tories have joined them. I say so called because I don't recognise this Conservative party it's Blair's Labour Party. And before you say it yes the bloody Tories aught to come up with some original ideas they are the government after all. There's certainly truth in what you're saying re the parties - it's telling that the Tories windfall tax proposal was probably more generous than the Labour suggestion. Also worrying from a Labour point of view how painfully centrist they are trying to be, despite the obvious evidence of Corbyn's legacy that there is appetite for genuine left-wing policy amongst the electorate. I see Starmer as just Tory-lite and you see this government as similar to Blair's labour - probably says a lot as to why there are so many dissatisfied voters.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
There's certainly truth in what you're saying re the parties - it's telling that the Tories windfall tax proposal was probably more generous than the Labour suggestion. Also worrying from a Labour point of view how painfully centrist they are trying to be, despite the obvious evidence of Corbyn's legacy that there is appetite for genuine left-wing policy amongst the electorate. I see Starmer as just Tory-lite and you see this government as similar to Blair's labour - probably says a lot as to why there are so many dissatisfied voters. Agreed.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Why should landlords be hit for a mode of investment choice which has already received a massive hit in the last few years due to the removal of tax relief on mortgages? I for one will sell up they start attacking the rental market again and then the properties will probably be sold into the owner occupied market. Net result, hey presto, massive shortage of rental properties available and rents will continue to rocket up. Are you sure this idea has been fully thought through? My point was TIC in relation to you are always going to have people who need money or extra money to survive. Put that alongside the fact we could be in the same position next year and where do we or hmg get the money from.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
My point was TIC in relation to you are always going to have people who need money or extra money to survive. Put that alongside the fact we could be in the same position next year and where do we or hmg get the money from. This logic basically says that the government shouldn't pay for anything, ever, because there will always be a next time - it's so silly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
This logic basically says that the government shouldn't pay for anything, ever, because there will always be a next time - it's so silly. No it doesn’t at all. What it says is actually help who needs help but until our honesty level ups a bit how do you do it. Make everyone a millionaire! I’ve been there and had no help at all and that was 30 odd years ago. I know what it’s like to have no pot!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.