You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy
November 22 2026 2.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy


Page 83 of 174 < 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 >
Stirlingsays Flag 09 Aug 23 5.29am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

I don’t think anyone’s view at the start was correct because no one knew exactly what they were dealing with. So maybe later on sure but the government was managing people as well as the science. Some people don’t like that but that’s what you’ve got to do to keep order. The question is more should it have persisted for so long, with hindsight, maybe not. Hard one to call.

Well at the beginning few were sure what we were dealing with. However, once that initial phrase was over a couple of camps emerged and views remained quite consistent with many....and still do.

In my view some have proven to have been far more accurate than others....for example skepticism on transmission, lockdowns and on risk levels....the hubris of thinking an airborne virus could be controlled (something I experienced from the usual suspects on here) and the folly of spending a generational fortune towards that aim....rather than targeting money on what was possible.

Personally I'm not one for defending in any way the coercion and half truths used by the governmental behavioural units to shape behaviour.....I view it as dishonest and insidious.

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

All the examples I’ve given were at the time widely discussed. Certainly in the Mail over here, and certainly on mainstream news channels.

I admit, no one sees everything that's put into the mainstream but I never saw anything widely publicized that gave anything like a balanced view of the situation. I think what I said about what most people were aware of is accurate. Far more publicised was ridicule and demonisation of any skeptical position at all....that spilled over everywhere including on here. I think publications like the 'Daily Mail' were a part of that process just as any other.


Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Re aliens - my opinion is also subject to change based on proof. So far, none.

Re. Lying to congress, you do know that other people besides corporates and governments lie, right? Or does that only work for you when it’s the people you don’t like vs the people you do have a soft spot for - the military. Don’t let emotion cloud your judgement. Again, many dropped a lot of their outlandish claims when they set foot in the hearings - which says it all.

The fact that private companies lie is obvious due to the profit motive.

However, the fact is that public institutions are paid for by their taxpayers. These are civil servants, not capitalists.

Obviously they lie, however what I'm referring to is culture and the line of acceptability. It's an unfortunate fact of nihilism that a distaste for lying is rarely present if its outcomes are effective.

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

On aliens - you misread the quote - he doesn’t think it’s an active conspiracy (amuse) his point is that if a government was in possession of such things they wouldn’t just be sitting on it all twiddling their thumbs. They’d use it for gain.

Obviously....like stating that oranges are the colour orange.

However, there is a limit to what can be gained from that just as there is with everything else. Who knows what that thinking is at this particular time.

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

I also buy the terrestrial angle (thedrive article) more than the outlandish one. More likely the US govt cocking up than anything else.

Time will tell....or not, obviously.

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Definitely life elsewhere in the universe but is it regularly dropping in here, exceedingly unlikely.

I tend to disagree, but it's currently up for debate. There are many possibilities, some fantastical and fanciful that could explain the phenomenon. All unknowable but fun to speculate upon.

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

On musk - so you’re saying people can’t agree with some things others say and disagree with others? Odd. All or nothing? Doesn’t seem very balanced

For the record I agree with a lot of what he says and does. Just not all of it. Sometimes he can be a complete imbecile despite his intellect, much like some of us. However just because I don’t agree with him on some things doesn’t mean I can’t agree on others. I’m not as partisan as that, not by a long stretch

Fair enough.

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Anyone has the right to question any narratives they like. Being treated fairly - slightly amusing considering the pile ons that come from both angles on this site including you, however, if people present a well put together argument rather than ones with enough holes to sink a battleship or that are clearly the same old copy pasted tropes (ie laziness, no independent thought) most people will enter into more reasoned debate. You usually do so. The parrot less and less. People are more than entitled to take each other out over flimsy opinions or poorly constructed arguments.

Finally yes, totally agree. The debate is there to be had. But don’t go crying if you get counterpunched in the face (politely).

You seem to be slightly amused quite often, which at the very least should be keeping your spirits up.

I tend to find that people who talk about 'pile ons' are usually on the unpopular side of an argument in a political space and dislike it. 'Pile ons' are rarely complained about when they agree with the point....the idea that debates should comprise of fifty fifty contributions is surely unrealistic and unless the debate is genuinely abusive I'm not seeing the issue......perhaps instead of seeing things as 'pile ons' instead you could view it as political 'consensus' considering your strong approval of shared agreement.

I rather agree with your praise for independent thought but I would ask.....as I do tend to read your posts....What positions, this 'aliens are bunk' view aside, have you taken on the site that differed from what's fed to you from the mainstream? Mainly when you do contribute it usually seems to be criticism of those differing in some way from that mainstream.

Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Aug 2023 7.07am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Aug 23 6.31am

Scotland's COVID response addressed. Longer lockdowns and worse figures is not a good result for a country with not much more than half the population of London.


[Link]

 

eaglesdare Flag 09 Aug 23 11.01am

Aliens? Okay now is the time to duck out of this Thread.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Aug 23 2.46pm

It's sad to see that the level of dishonesty and spreading of misinformation present in this thread from the start remains unabated and untouched by the benefit of hindsight.

Nobody ever suggested that the virus could be controlled by the measures being taken. What happened was to find ways, in an unknown and fast-developing, situation, to reduce exposure and mitigate the impact until the more effective impact of vaccination was available. That other "theories" were promoted by sceptics was as inevitable as they are irrelevant. Our government, along with many others, decided not to adopt what looked like a high-risk strategy. They knew the cost would be high, but decided that the cost of not doing it was higher. That information campaigns encouraged cooperation and compliance was hardly surprising or unneeded. It's what a government does to make policy effective.

The alternatives were discussed in the MSM but were quickly dismissed for not being viable, in the circumstances prevailing in the UK. Of course that doesn't stop some still banging on about it now and claiming things would be better if only they had been listened to. We might have won the Champions League if I had been appointed manager 10 years ago. It seems as likely to me but as neither happened we will never know, hence it's irrelevant.

The enquiry is the place to review events and for the lessons to be learned. Cool heads there will deliver some useful guidance for any future similar situations.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Aug 23 3.00pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It's sad to see that the level of dishonesty and spreading of misinformation present in this thread from the start remains unabated and untouched by the benefit of hindsight.

Nobody ever suggested that the virus could be controlled by the measures being taken. What happened was to find ways, in an unknown and fast-developing, situation, to reduce exposure and mitigate the impact until the more effective impact of vaccination was available. That other "theories" were promoted by sceptics was as inevitable as they are irrelevant. Our government, along with many others, decided not to adopt what looked like a high-risk strategy. They knew the cost would be high, but decided that the cost of not doing it was higher. That information campaigns encouraged cooperation and compliance was hardly surprising or unneeded. It's what a government does to make policy effective.

The alternatives were discussed in the MSM but were quickly dismissed for not being viable, in the circumstances prevailing in the UK. Of course that doesn't stop some still banging on about it now and claiming things would be better if only they had been listened to. We might have won the Champions League if I had been appointed manager 10 years ago. It seems as likely to me but as neither happened we will never know, hence it's irrelevant.

The enquiry is the place to review events and for the lessons to be learned. Cool heads there will deliver some useful guidance for any future similar situations.

Why would anyone doubt the government response when it's been so outstanding in every other aspect for the last few years.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 Aug 23 3.15pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It's sad to see that the level of dishonesty and spreading of misinformation present in this thread from the start remains unabated and untouched by the benefit of hindsight.

Nobody ever suggested that the virus could be controlled by the measures being taken. What happened was to find ways, in an unknown and fast-developing, situation, to reduce exposure and mitigate the impact until the more effective impact of vaccination was available. That other "theories" were promoted by sceptics was as inevitable as they are irrelevant. Our government, along with many others, decided not to adopt what looked like a high-risk strategy. They knew the cost would be high, but decided that the cost of not doing it was higher. That information campaigns encouraged cooperation and compliance was hardly surprising or unneeded. It's what a government does to make policy effective.

The alternatives were discussed in the MSM but were quickly dismissed for not being viable, in the circumstances prevailing in the UK. Of course that doesn't stop some still banging on about it now and claiming things would be better if only they had been listened to. We might have won the Champions League if I had been appointed manager 10 years ago. It seems as likely to me but as neither happened we will never know, hence it's irrelevant.

The enquiry is the place to review events and for the lessons to be learned. Cool heads there will deliver some useful guidance for any future similar situations.

I think many of us already know the conclusions they just copy and paste from every other government enquiry.

"Mistakes were made lessons have been learned" (somebody got rich) blah blah until the next time.

Edited by Badger11 (09 Aug 2023 3.16pm)

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Aug 23 4.48pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I think many of us already know the conclusions they just copy and paste from every other government enquiry.

"Mistakes were made lessons have been learned" (somebody got rich) blah blah until the next time.

Edited by Badger11 (09 Aug 2023 3.16pm)

Do you think this level of cynicism is going to help anyone?

I don’t! I don’t think it either justified or helpful. I have no doubt that we both need to improve our system and those who work within it on our behalf, but I refuse to believe that most of those doing so now are only in it for themselves. It’s just not my experience. If change is needed, help to change it!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Aug 23 4.49pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Why would anyone doubt the government response when it's been so outstanding in every other aspect for the last few years.

My previous reply applies equally to this.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Aug 23 5.04pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

My previous reply applies equally to this.

So does mine.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Aug 23 5.33pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

So does mine.

I don’t see how!

Yours was directed at the government. Mine was at cynical posts here.

So it’s truly obscurantic.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Aug 23 5.38pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I don’t see how!

Yours was directed at the government. Mine was at cynical posts here.

So it’s truly obscurantic.

Not sure how when there have been untold posts criticising literally every aspect of the government except how they handled Covid which was above and beyond.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 09 Aug 23 11.25pm

There has been a lot of references to the videos produced by Dr John Campbell in this thread, often with links to them being provided.

One of the most frequent claims being made for him has been that he always uses official statistics and publications as the source for his analyses, thus making them authentic.

I, as will be realised, disagree. I think he started off in a well meaning way to use his teaching skills to inform others about the new danger we all were suddenly confronted with but then came to realise he had stumbled on a rich vein of potential wealth which he could mine by providing nuggets of misinformation to the sceptical. So he has, and in so doing has attracted a huge following which must have made him very rich.

Tonight I stumbled on the video I link below, when looking for something else. I urge everyone, even those who have previously regarded him as a paragon of virtue and bringer of truth, to watch this in full. It takes a while, but it ought to cause a re-evaluation by even the most previously devoted and convinced follower:-

[Link]

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 09 Aug 23 11.36pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

There has been a lot of references to the videos produced by Dr John Campbell in this thread, often with links to them being provided.

One of the most frequent claims being made for him has been that he always uses official statistics and publications as the source for his analyses, thus making them authentic.

I, as will be realised, disagree. I think he started off in a well meaning way to use his teaching skills to inform others about the new danger we all were suddenly confronted with but then came to realise he had stumbled on a rich vein of potential wealth which he could mine by providing nuggets of misinformation to the sceptical. So he has, and in so doing has attracted a huge following which must have made him very rich.

Tonight I stumbled on the video I link below, when looking for something else. I urge everyone, even those who have previously regarded him as a paragon of virtue and bringer of truth, to watch this in full. It takes a while, but it ought to cause a re-evaluation by even the most previously devoted and convinced follower:-

[Link]

Whereas admirers of Neil Ferguson are completely sure of his omniscience.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 10 Aug 23 12.59am

I will check out these claims over the next few days before reporting back.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 10 Aug 23 8.11am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Whereas admirers of Neil Ferguson are completely sure of his omniscience.

That’s unrelated, diversionary whataboutism!

I am unaware of anyone posting comments about Ferguson here, let alone suggesting he is omnipotent or posting links to videos.

In fact he has had a stella career which was blighted by two events during the pandemic. The report he authored in the early days was seen, with hindsight, to under estimate the capacity of people to take avoiding actions themselves and led the government to take some impulsive decisions. This is exactly what the current enquiry will want to examine so that checks and balances are introduced to avoid over reliance on single sources. Ferguson then made a personal error during lockdown which resulted in him quitting as a member of SAGE though his department continues to provide advice to it.

Making an error in good faith is completely different to deliberately spreading misinformation for gain.

As you will realise if you watch, in full, the presentation from Professor Greg Tucker Kellogg that I provided the link to.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Aug 23 9.16am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

That’s unrelated, diversionary whataboutism!

I am unaware of anyone posting comments about Ferguson here, let alone suggesting he is omnipotent or posting links to videos.

In fact he has had a stella career which was blighted by two events during the pandemic. The report he authored in the early days was seen, with hindsight, to under estimate the capacity of people to take avoiding actions themselves and led the government to take some impulsive decisions. This is exactly what the current enquiry will want to examine so that checks and balances are introduced to avoid over reliance on single sources. Ferguson then made a personal error during lockdown which resulted in him quitting as a member of SAGE though his department continues to provide advice to it.

Making an error in good faith is completely different to deliberately spreading misinformation for gain.

As you will realise if you watch, in full, the presentation from Professor Greg Tucker Kellogg that I provided the link to.

Omniscient not omnipotent but seeing the influence he had he might as well be omnipotent. His particular brand of wildly inaccurate guesswork has cost the country dear. Bird flu? Wrong.
SARS? Wrong. Covid? Wrong.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 10 Aug 23 9.32am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Omniscient not omnipotent but seeing the influence he had he might as well be omnipotent. His particular brand of wildly inaccurate guesswork has cost the country dear. Bird flu? Wrong.
SARS? Wrong. Covid? Wrong.

I will be much more interested to know what you think about the analysis that Professor Greg Tucker Kellogg makes in the video I linked to than in again reading very well-known assertions about Professor Ferguson.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Mattconrov Flag 10 Aug 23 9.32am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Why would anyone doubt the government response when it's been so outstanding in every other aspect for the last few years.

Absolutely, plus your comment on Neil Ferguson. They are 100 percent relative to this debate we are having.

Constantly through the "pandemic" we were told to trust in what our experts were doing. Only now can we hold hopefully hold them to account.

It should have been done at the time. However such was/is the corrupt big business/government relationship (the whole world over) that was a closed shop to a second opinion.

Neil Ferguson has made a career out of being wrong.


[Link]


[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

I've seen the rather amusing and predictable fact checks on this.

If they were indeed worse case scenarios; then the government have gone with that scenario everytime and Ferguson doesn't appear to have complained.

My god these fact checkers (who fact checks them) they would tell
us grass is purple if the government said it was.

Yes Wisbech, he had a "Stella career". While he wasn't ballsing up peoples lives.

Edited by Mattconrov (10 Aug 2023 10.23am)

Edited by Mattconrov (10 Aug 2023 10.30am)

Edited by Mattconrov (10 Aug 2023 10.49am)

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

Teddy Eagle Flag 10 Aug 23 11.21am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I will be much more interested to know what you think about the analysis that Professor Greg Tucker Kellogg makes in the video I linked to than in again reading very well-known assertions about Professor Ferguson.

They're not just assertions; they are facts.
To be honest I'm not interested in Dr. Campbell who may well be a complete crank but he isn't a trusted government advisor.

 

Mattconrov Flag 10 Aug 23 11.46am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

They're not just assertions; they are facts.
To be honest I'm not interested in Dr. Campbell who may well be a complete crank but he isn't a trusted government advisor.

Campbell was completely on with the government narrative throughout the pandemic where he built up quite a following. Now he has changed his tune. Better late than never I suppose.

Plenty more experts out there that are not government linked.

If you go back to page 134 and in particular 135 you will see plenty of links.

I'm no fan of Campbell who did a lot of damage in getting people to be experimented on. But he does appear to genuinely feel sorry for what he did.


Edited by Mattconrov (10 Aug 2023 11.52am)

Edited by Mattconrov (10 Aug 2023 12.00pm)

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

Page 83 of 174 < 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy