You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?
November 16 2026 11.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?


Page 9 of 12 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 16 6.03pm

I'm not calling for his head purely down to the risk of a new man taking us a few places higher or relegation. Seen too many times us feck up our potential and unless SP gets someone lined up Southampton style then I can put up with what might be below average home record and better away results.

I see what he's trying and no doubt there's little other choice in British managers but there no doubt is better abroad. But that takes research and I don't see that happening any time soon.

I recommend if you don't like his spin of losses to switch it off. Means sh1t anyway.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 16 6.13pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I'm not calling for his head purely down to the risk of a new man taking us a few places higher or relegation. Seen too many times us feck up our potential and unless SP gets someone lined up Southampton style then I can put up with what might be below average home record and better away results.

I see what he's trying and no doubt there's little other choice in British managers but there no doubt is better abroad. But that takes research and I don't see that happening any time soon.

I recommend if you don't like his spin of losses to switch it off. Means sh1t anyway.

On the subject of "Heads rolling", today Zenga and Caldwell were sacked.This season the following have also departed : Feeney, Robinson, Di Matteo, Guidolin, Hessenthaler, Mellon, Mowbray, Pearson, Stubbs and Trollope.That's 12 and the season is barely 2 months old !

Edited by Willo (25 Oct 2016 6.14pm)

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 25 Oct 16 6.16pm

Originally posted by Willo

On the subject of "Heads rolling", today Zenga and Caldwell were sacked.This season the following have also departed : Feeney, Robinson, Di Matteo, Guidolin, Hessenthaler, Mellon, Mowbray, Pearson, Stubbs and Trollope.That's 12 and the season is barely 2 months old !

Edited by Willo (25 Oct 2016 6.14pm)

I wonder if those that want rid of AP would like any of those as our new manager. Still have not seen any of them suggest an alternative yet.

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 25 Oct 16 6.22pm

Originally posted by sickboy

I wonder if those that want rid of AP would like any of those as our new manager. Still have not seen any of them suggest an alternative yet.

You are aware that it's possible to both believe Pardew isn't good enough & also accept that there are no better alternatives out there ???

Just asking because you seem to imply that just because my ilk can't
suggest an alternative, our view regarding Pardew's ability is invalid.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 25 Oct 16 6.26pm

Originally posted by Dancer Cat

You are aware that it's possible to both believe Pardew isn't good enough & also accept that there are no better alternatives out there ???

Just asking because you seem to imply that just because my ilk can't
suggest an alternative, our view regarding Pardew's ability is invalid.


Kind of makes the moaning irrelevant if you cant come up with a solution. Might be best to keep your council until a viable option comes to light.

 

Mstrobez Flag 25 Oct 16 6.37pm

Originally posted by Hambo

Stop insulting people. If you have a point to make it gets lost when you behave like that.

There's nothing wrong with questioning a manager but people have as much of a right to disagree with you as you have to make your point.

I've been in moderator slumber for ages, and you've woken me up. Reign it in.

I get abused, insulted and patronised every time I have an opinion on this site that's against the grain. When someone consistently tells me I'm a plastic who doesn't have a clue about football amongst many other snide comments and doesn't even have anything to back up the point they're making, I feel entitled to call them an imbecile!

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 16 6.38pm

Originally posted by sickboy


Kind of makes the moaning irrelevant if you cant come up with a solution. Might be best to keep your council until a viable option comes to light.

Counsel.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 16 6.40pm

What's your opinion Hambo? Sometimes you can close a thread or bring 2 parties closer.

 


COYP

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 6.41pm

Originally posted by rikz

before being relegated the season before

Of course! So based on that, let's f*ck this season off, get relegated and marvel at how amazing he is as we go up as Champions and come back to the Prem wiser & stronger &#128563;

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 16 6.47pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Of course! So based on that, let's f*ck this season off, get relegated and marvel at how amazing he is as we go up as Champions and come back to the Prem wiser & stronger &#128563;

SP would boot Pardew out before January if there was a points danger of relegation. Last season there wasn't and several reasons for that awful run which kept his job.

Because of that I'll probably accept the frustrations. Any bad runs from here will no doubt see him go so in SP he won't go all ostrich on it.

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 25 Oct 16 6.48pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Of course! So based on that, let's f*ck this season off, get relegated and marvel at how amazing he is as we go up as Champions and come back to the Prem wiser & stronger &#128563;

Now your just being stupid ain't you.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 6.48pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Funnily enough I was here before 1st January which is why I look at his record as a whole not a random date that suits

As for spend heavily, what was the net spend again?
Also like I said, decent manager, not great, or did you chose to ignore that point too?

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (25 Oct 2016 4.51pm)

I think it's fair to reflect from 1st Jan mate as it's been a sustained run of poor form and managers usually live/die by a run of form eh! All the pro Pardew brigade have to reference results over a year ago + so their argument for sticking him him stand up eh

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 6.49pm

Originally posted by rikz

Now your just being stupid ain't you.

Maybe a little yep but you get my point I'm sure now

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 16 6.57pm

Originally posted by KAOS

I think it's fair to reflect from 1st Jan mate as it's been a sustained run of poor form and managers usually live/die by a run of form eh! All the pro Pardew brigade have to reference results over a year ago + so their argument for sticking him him stand up eh

Wigan were promoted as Champions last season under Caldwell and he has been sacked after 14 league games this season.Similarly, Zenga has only lasted 14 league games.Trollope took over Cardiff this year after they finished 8th last campaign and he was sacked recently after 11 games with the club in 23rd place.


 

rikz Flag Croydon 25 Oct 16 6.59pm

Originally posted by KAOS

I think it's fair to reflect from 1st Jan mate as it's been a sustained run of poor form and managers usually live/die by a run of form eh! All the pro Pardew brigade have to reference results over a year ago + so their argument for sticking him him stand up eh

And you don't think the fact we had pretty much secured our position in the league by Christmas, was under no real pressure to achieve anything other than premiership survival and a cup run taking us to the fa cup final had any impact on our form over the second half of the season.

And tbf to pardew his only been here just under 2 years and inherited a pretty poor squad in the first place. We are only here because we was lucky enough pulis was out of a job.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 7.10pm

Originally posted by rikz

And you don't think the fact we had pretty much secured our position in the league by Christmas, was under no real pressure to achieve anything other than premiership survival and a cup run taking us to the fa cup final had any impact on our form over the second half of the season.

And tbf to pardew his only been here just under 2 years and inherited a pretty poor squad in the first place. We are only here because we was lucky enough pulis was out of a job.

Agree with 1st paragraph but find it unacceptable. A manager, with his 'experience', should be able to weather the storm in that time and I can't believe he was under no real pressure to sort it! This is business at the end of the day ...

As I said before, any references I make are based on the time we have sustained continual wobbly / questionable league form. If we had not one a few games recently I think he's now he the 1st management casualty in the Prem ... and that wouldn't be unwarranted either after 10 months of pony league results!


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Oct 16 7.10pm

Clearly the "Anti-Pardew" voices will reach a crescendo if we lose to Liverpool on Saturday.This of course will be a 3rd consecutive defeat !

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 25 Oct 16 9.08pm

People who want pardew out are entitled to their opinion. those who are happy with our league position are likewise entitled to their happiness. All I ask is for people to remember it is just a forum and does not lay down the rules for deciding if you are worthy of supporting of the club.

However I would just suggest that after the signings that have been made at palace and looking at the teams we have played I personaly would have expected more points, and thus be higher up the table.
Yes , sorry to break it to some people but we are still to play most of the big boys and if we dont bang a few goals past the likes of hull we are not going to progress let alone cement a place in the premiership.

What doesnt help pardews cause is the comments he makes post game when we lose such as " if we had scored first we would have won" ( no one could ever say if this is true) or "we didnt play our normal game today" (when we clearly have).

To sum up I am frustrated with pardews handling of the manager role but dont sack him now its far,far too early.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 25 Oct 16 9.24pm

Originally posted by KAOS

I think it's fair to reflect from 1st Jan mate as it's been a sustained run of poor form and managers usually live/die by a run of form eh! All the pro Pardew brigade have to reference results over a year ago + so their argument for sticking him him stand up eh

Why not go from the beginning of the season then? We were 5 unbeaten at one point and we are still mid table.

He deserved criticism last season, of course he did but to ignore his successes is hardly fair.

We are a million miles behind most if not all premiership clubs and a fair way behind a lot of championship clubs. We are in the first real stable period for as long as I can remember. Mid table should be considered success and anything beyond that a bonus.

As for Pardew being judged on results, as has been mentioned before he has the best win rate since Bruce and is one of our most successful managers in modern times.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

KAOS Flag In a tree 25 Oct 16 9.42pm

Ok! I'll agree to not comment anymore unless we lose the next 2-3 games!!!

Speak in a couple of weeks yeah?! -.-'

 

Page 9 of 12 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?