This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
It seems like half of Europe's top clubs show an interest in Zaha, but that seems to be all. Think most clubs know he is top notch when he's at his best, but those days seem long gone. 30 plus, worryingly injury prone, too selfish and simply not the same Wilf we knew 3-4 years ago. Has Wilf ever been as good as he was in the past? I ask that question partly tongue in cheek, but also partly seriously. There can be no question that he will go down as a Palace legend, having given us some abiding memories. There have been some great goals and we have loved watching him turning opposition defenders inside out. However, he has, in my mind, always been a inconsistent. He has had purple patches but also periods when he hasn't delivered. I distinctly remember that in the second half of our promotion season in 2012 2013, after signing for United but staying with us on loan, his form seriously dipped and only really perked up for the play-offs. I reckon if you could bothered to trawl back over posts about Wilf from 6 or 7 years ago you would find many of the same things being said about him then as now, bemoaning his temperamental side, selfishness, and sometimes going anonymous in games. I very clearly remember a period when there was debate on this site as to who was the better player - Wilf or Bolasie - and there was no clear concensus on this. Don't get me wrong, I am not slagging the fella off. He has been a great asset for us and on many occasions thrilling to watch. All that I am saying is that he has some frailties, inconsistencies and shortcomings which have always been there, and which have not just emerged in the last 2 or 3 years.I think it can be easy to forget this. There was never a time in the past when could be relied upon to consistently perform game in game out all season. In fact I can remember a post of my own from several years back on one of the many "Wilf" threads debating his pros and cons, where I posed the question, "how often is Wilf man of the match"? My answer to my own question was, not very often, and not many respondents disagreed.
|
|
|
I think this is a fair and balanced assessment, and I say this even though he is one of my favourite Palace players.I don't have blinkers on where Wilf is concerned and am aware of the weaknesses. Originally posted by Pete53
Has Wilf ever been as good as he was in the past? I ask that question partly tongue in cheek, but also partly seriously. There can be no question that he will go down as a Palace legend, having given us some abiding memories. There have been some great goals and we have loved watching him turning opposition defenders inside out. However, he has, in my mind, always been a inconsistent. He has had purple patches but also periods when he hasn't delivered. I distinctly remember that in the second half of our promotion season in 2012 2013, after signing for United but staying with us on loan, his form seriously dipped and only really perked up for the play-offs. I reckon if you could bothered to trawl back over posts about Wilf from 6 or 7 years ago you would find many of the same things being said about him then as now, bemoaning his temperamental side, selfishness, and sometimes going anonymous in games. I very clearly remember a period when there was debate on this site as to who was the better player - Wilf or Bolasie - and there was no clear concensus on this. Don't get me wrong, I am not slagging the fella off. He has been a great asset for us and on many occasions thrilling to watch. All that I am saying is that he has some frailties, inconsistencies and shortcomings which have always been there, and which have not just emerged in the last 2 or 3 years.I think it can be easy to forget this. There was never a time in the past when could be relied upon to consistently perform game in game out all season. In fact I can remember a post of my own from several years back on one of the many "Wilf" threads debating his pros and cons, where I posed the question, "how often is Wilf man of the match"? My answer to my own question was, not very often, and not many respondents disagreed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dynamicdick
There was no waving from him at the end and he kept a pretty low profile so all I can assume is that no decision has been made. Absolutely spot on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dynamicdick
There was no waving from him at the end and he kept a pretty low profile so all I can assume is that no decision has been made. Seconded.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
We would have won against Forest with Wilf I am sure, we just lacked his extra quality. One person shouldn't make a team and that is going too far, but he so often has that edge, he is quite unique. I tend to agree, however, to temper this, he has certainly lost some pace. He's not slow but he is slower. A more standard, crossing winger might do us the world of good when I think about it. For flair and game changing we now have Olise and Eze. Those with a pacy enough winger who creates chances should be pretty good. We might well improve if we get the right kind of player. Ayew and Edouard are not realistic left wingers for the entire season. Ayew can do a job, as we've seen. Edouard has had flashes of being relatively average at left wing but mainly pretty poor. We have to either buy or go with what we've got. We've been linked with Sarr for years. Maybe we'll even sign him now. I wouldn't think he's 20 mil now but could be wrong. Surprisingly decent stats when you look into it. Something like 10 goals this season.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
We would have won against Forest with Wilf I am sure, we just lacked his extra quality. Or indeed a better striker than the two Frenchmen that we have
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
We would have won against Forest with Wilf I am sure, we just lacked his extra quality. One person shouldn't make a team and that is going too far, but he so often has that edge, he is quite unique. Maybe, but he played when we lost 0-1 to them. With Wilf missing a penalty!
|
|
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
Maybe, but he played when we lost 0-1 to them. With Wilf missing a penalty! Win ,lose or draw it doesn't matter now,it is more important Wilf makes his mind up what he wants to do,because his indecisiveness now if he stays or goes is cocking up the decision making,of who or what we need to get in for next season!!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Arsenal is his club, so I get the feeling that it might be them or us. Chelsea and Spurs are both a mess. Why would Arsenal want him as they already have Saka
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Or indeed a better striker than the two Frenchmen that we have Mystifying, really, as striking is something the French are usually pretty good at.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.