You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zaha
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Zaha


Page 9 of 57 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 29 May 23 9.34am

There was no waving from him at the end and he kept a pretty low profile so all I can assume is that no decision has been made.
It is clear from yesterdays performance that he is missed but he is now north of 30 and picking up injuries plus has lost an edge of pace. My opinion is let him go and focus on getting a good replacement.

 


Bring back Brolin

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 29 May 23 11.08am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

It seems like half of Europe's top clubs show an interest in Zaha, but that seems to be all. Think most clubs know he is top notch when he's at his best, but those days seem long gone. 30 plus, worryingly injury prone, too selfish and simply not the same Wilf we knew 3-4 years ago.
Probably our most influential player ever, but the club cannot live in the past. Love him to stay, but.....

Has Wilf ever been as good as he was in the past?

I ask that question partly tongue in cheek, but also partly seriously.

There can be no question that he will go down as a Palace legend, having given us some abiding memories. There have been some great goals and we have loved watching him turning opposition defenders inside out.

However, he has, in my mind, always been a inconsistent. He has had purple patches but also periods when he hasn't delivered.

I distinctly remember that in the second half of our promotion season in 2012 2013, after signing for United but staying with us on loan, his form seriously dipped and only really perked up for the play-offs.

I reckon if you could bothered to trawl back over posts about Wilf from 6 or 7 years ago you would find many of the same things being said about him then as now, bemoaning his temperamental side, selfishness, and sometimes going anonymous in games. I very clearly remember a period when there was debate on this site as to who was the better player - Wilf or Bolasie - and there was no clear concensus on this.

Don't get me wrong, I am not slagging the fella off. He has been a great asset for us and on many occasions thrilling to watch. All that I am saying is that he has some frailties, inconsistencies and shortcomings which have always been there, and which have not just emerged in the last 2 or 3 years.I think it can be easy to forget this.

There was never a time in the past when could be relied upon to consistently perform game in game out all season.

In fact I can remember a post of my own from several years back on one of the many "Wilf" threads debating his pros and cons, where I posed the question, "how often is Wilf man of the match"? My answer to my own question was, not very often, and not many respondents disagreed.

 

Zaha127 Flag 29 May 23 11.18am

I can see Arsenal or Spurs buying him. Arsenal especially in UCL next year will need to rotate players playing more games. Newcastle potentially? Rumours are they want to sell Saint Maximin. They will also play more football next season (UCL) need a bigger squad.

 

PatrickA Flag London 29 May 23 11.40am

I think this is a fair and balanced assessment, and I say this even though he is one of my favourite Palace players.I don't have blinkers on where Wilf is concerned and am aware of the weaknesses.
His value to us has been magnified because of the lack of other talented forward options for much of Wilf's time with the club.
My favourite period was the promotion season when some of his footwork on the ball had to be seen to be believed.


Originally posted by Pete53

Has Wilf ever been as good as he was in the past?

I ask that question partly tongue in cheek, but also partly seriously.

There can be no question that he will go down as a Palace legend, having given us some abiding memories. There have been some great goals and we have loved watching him turning opposition defenders inside out.

However, he has, in my mind, always been a inconsistent. He has had purple patches but also periods when he hasn't delivered.

I distinctly remember that in the second half of our promotion season in 2012 2013, after signing for United but staying with us on loan, his form seriously dipped and only really perked up for the play-offs.

I reckon if you could bothered to trawl back over posts about Wilf from 6 or 7 years ago you would find many of the same things being said about him then as now, bemoaning his temperamental side, selfishness, and sometimes going anonymous in games. I very clearly remember a period when there was debate on this site as to who was the better player - Wilf or Bolasie - and there was no clear concensus on this.

Don't get me wrong, I am not slagging the fella off. He has been a great asset for us and on many occasions thrilling to watch. All that I am saying is that he has some frailties, inconsistencies and shortcomings which have always been there, and which have not just emerged in the last 2 or 3 years.I think it can be easy to forget this.

There was never a time in the past when could be relied upon to consistently perform game in game out all season.

In fact I can remember a post of my own from several years back on one of the many "Wilf" threads debating his pros and cons, where I posed the question, "how often is Wilf man of the match"? My answer to my own question was, not very often, and not many respondents disagreed.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 29 May 23 12.30pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

There was no waving from him at the end and he kept a pretty low profile so all I can assume is that no decision has been made.
It is clear from yesterdays performance that he is missed but he is now north of 30 and picking up injuries plus has lost an edge of pace. My opinion is let him go and focus on getting a good replacement.

Absolutely spot on.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 29 May 23 1.42pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

There was no waving from him at the end and he kept a pretty low profile so all I can assume is that no decision has been made.
It is clear from yesterdays performance that he is missed but he is now north of 30 and picking up injuries plus has lost an edge of pace. My opinion is let him go and focus on getting a good replacement.

Seconded.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 29 May 23 1.53pm

I have just watch the clip of the post match interview with Will Hughes. In the background Wilf and Parish are having a very friendly smiley chat in the background. I'm not suggesting there is any significance in this but good to see nonetheless.

 

Bazinda Flag Waddon 29 May 23 1.55pm

However good wilf has been, there’s always been talk on previous seasons of whether we’d better off without him. For all the good memories he’s given me I also remember the games when his attitude just stunk, constant moaning, petulance, not tracking back and getting silly bookings costing us precious points. I think he’s been good for us but we have also been good for wilf, don’t see him achieving success, specially on a cl side. I see his future going the same trajectory as Townsend. The grass is not always greener on the other side.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 29 May 23 2.29pm

We would have won against Forest with Wilf I am sure, we just lacked his extra quality.

One person shouldn't make a team and that is going too far, but he so often has that edge, he is quite unique.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 May 23 2.58pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

We would have won against Forest with Wilf I am sure, we just lacked his extra quality.

One person shouldn't make a team and that is going too far, but he so often has that edge, he is quite unique.

I tend to agree, however, to temper this, he has certainly lost some pace. He's not slow but he is slower. A more standard, crossing winger might do us the world of good when I think about it. For flair and game changing we now have Olise and Eze. Those with a pacy enough winger who creates chances should be pretty good. We might well improve if we get the right kind of player. Ayew and Edouard are not realistic left wingers for the entire season. Ayew can do a job, as we've seen. Edouard has had flashes of being relatively average at left wing but mainly pretty poor. We have to either buy or go with what we've got. We've been linked with Sarr for years. Maybe we'll even sign him now. I wouldn't think he's 20 mil now but could be wrong. Surprisingly decent stats when you look into it. Something like 10 goals this season.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Midlands Eagle Flag 29 May 23 3.03pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

We would have won against Forest with Wilf I am sure, we just lacked his extra quality.

Or indeed a better striker than the two Frenchmen that we have

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 30 May 23 2.38am

Originally posted by steeleye20

We would have won against Forest with Wilf I am sure, we just lacked his extra quality.

One person shouldn't make a team and that is going too far, but he so often has that edge, he is quite unique.

Maybe, but he played when we lost 0-1 to them. With Wilf missing a penalty!

 

pax3908 Flag 31 May 23 12.10am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Maybe, but he played when we lost 0-1 to them. With Wilf missing a penalty!

Win ,lose or draw it doesn't matter now,it is more important Wilf makes his mind up what he wants to do,because his indecisiveness now if he stays or goes is cocking up the decision making,of who or what we need to get in for next season!!!

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 May 23 6.39am

Wilf is still the difference between us and some teams in the League - and he still could be if he wants to stay.
My take on it is that he wants 4 years and we don't.
However - if he made the difference - total difference - as he would have done on Sunday - then he could add 20 points to the total when we play teams below or around us.
He has a quality - still - that we don't possess without him.
I would give him 4 years at £200k/week personally - £40m over 4 years - it will cost us that to buy even a shadow of Wilf, let alone the wages involved.

 

woody6013 Flag Bundaberg Queensland 31 May 23 7.10am

Wilf should consider staying as he has earnt his stripes since Palace came into the EPL. We have seen players move on only to maybe have half a season and not being a starter player. Think of Townsend / Bolasie etc They've all just disappeared, and he loves South London and would be a great asset with the teaching staff. I think he could give the Eagles 2 more years of enjoyment, even with injuries.... and be earning more than enough to get to retirement and be regarded as the best the club has had. I do not think he would make 1st team appearances and just be considered a bench sub to bulk up those European teams that vie for the accolades.
EPL's Top six just buy for the sake of power and do not deserve to manipulate stars like Wilf in their endeavours to dominate with the ugly wealth they have.
Wilf we love you and the joy you bring and have over the past few years

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 31 May 23 7.34am

I have loved Wilf over the years and he still has the x-factor quality that is hard to find. The problem in the past was Palace did not have anyone close to his ability hence why in some previous seasons the game plan was just get the ball to Wilf.
The gap now between Wilf and the rest of our front players has been closed and we no longer look noticeably weaker when he is not playing. Would i like Wilf to be playing for Palace along side the likes of Olise Ayew and Eze then yes but we don't have to break the bank to make this happen.
I think Saar would be a viable replacement and would not cost us the same in wages and would have a potential sell on value where after 4 years Wilf would be close to retirement.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 31 May 23 9.18am

All I hope is that we sort it out soon.

Even though he isn't what he was, he's still better than most of what we've got and better than what we can get. So I'd love him to stay.

But I get the ambition and drive to play higher. Newcastle need some reinforcements, and despite UCL, they are unlikely to be able to attract top top talent as yet. (Same as City, players want to see if this is real before committing). But would Wilf want to relocate out of London, I doubt it.

Arsenal is his club, so I get the feeling that it might be them or us. Chelsea and Spurs are both a mess.


 

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 May 23 9.22am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Arsenal is his club, so I get the feeling that it might be them or us. Chelsea and Spurs are both a mess.

Why would Arsenal want him as they already have Saka

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 31 May 23 9.40am

Saka plays on the right. However they do have Martinelli and Trossard who play left. Again all about timing and doesnt seem quote right again for him and Arsenal. Cant have too many good players I suppose

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 31 May 23 5.03pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Or indeed a better striker than the two Frenchmen that we have

Mystifying, really, as striking is something the French are usually pretty good at.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Page 9 of 57 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zaha