You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Buy Back Clause
November 22 2026 8.02pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Buy Back Clause


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 6.04pm

Should these even be legal?

It obviously stacks the deal in favour of the selling club and only aids super clubs that loan out thirty players at a time.

Now they get to not only loan them but actually sell them. Then if they become better they can buy them back at a fixed price increase.

Utter bollox if you ask me.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 25 Jul 17 6.12pm

It's like anything, no one has to accept it but someone always will and therefore makes it the norm. Hardball doesn't always work, especially when fans want to see certain signings but unfortunately nowadays money talks and the big clubs use theirs in powerful ways.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 6.20pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

It's like anything, no one has to accept it but someone always will and therefore makes it the norm. Hardball doesn't always work, especially when fans want to see certain signings but unfortunately nowadays money talks and the big clubs use theirs in powerful ways.

You do have to accept it if those super clubs have all the talent in their academies and then feed them out to all the other clubs in loans and buy back options. Becuase otherwise you either have to feed of the scraps.

Clubs loaning out dozens of players and selling others with buy back clauses is just monopolising youth development.

It's a way of de-risking there academies.

Sell four players for £10m each all with £20m buy back clause. If one makes it they buy them back and can sometimes sell them on for triple that. (Morata) The smaller (feeder) clubs take all the risk, either have a player who doesn't make it or loose them once they do.

Stinks of unfair trading to me.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 25 Jul 17 6.33pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

You do have to accept it if those super clubs have all the talent in their academies and then feed them out to all the other clubs in loans and buy back options. Becuase otherwise you either have to feed of the scraps.

Clubs loaning out dozens of players and selling others with buy back clauses is just monopolising youth development.

It's a way of de-risking there academies.

Sell four players for £10m each all with £20m buy back clause. If one makes it they buy them back and can sometimes sell them on for triple that. (Morata) The smaller (feeder) clubs take all the risk, either have a player who doesn't make it or loose them once they do.

Stinks of unfair trading to me.

Key is to make sure that you are getting the most out of your academy and giving them the opportunity to progress into the 1st team. Obviously it's hard as, like you say, the big clubs stockpile. It's not right and like you I don't agree with it but unfortunately it's becoming the norm and will continue unless it's either banned or teams refuse to agree.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

beak Flag croydon 25 Jul 17 6.33pm

All the fairness of zero hours contracts.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 7.38pm

This now becoming more common, sides are prepared to sell their younger player but this gives them some protection, in case the player becomes excellent. Imagine Man Utd put a buy back clause in pogba deal, it would of saved them a lot of money.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 7.51pm

Yes but it means they coin the market.

They now don't even have to bring through there academy players. All they have to do is buy a zillion. Then sell them with buy back clauses and watch all the other clubs do the work.

Obviously it's great for United and Chelsea and Madrid but what ever we think about Chelsea having a gizillion loanies... well selling them with buy back clauses crushes the market even more.. it de-risks every player they sell and takes away the upside from smaller teams.

It basically turns every other club in to a proxy feeder club, which last time I checked is illegal.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Jul 17 8.03pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Should these even be legal?

It obviously stacks the deal in favour of the selling club and only aids super clubs that loan out thirty players at a time.

Now they get to not only loan them but actually sell them. Then if they become better they can buy them back at a fixed price increase.

Utter bollox if you ask me.

Could you give a current example of this in practice, the clubs and player involved.
Its seems no different than a sell on %, if the buying club sells the player in the future.
Football finances are not used in the real world ie if you buy a property and sell it in the future, I have never heard of the seller giving the previous owner a % of the sale.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 8.15pm

Example of what?

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 8.21pm

Assuming your asking for example of buy back deals..

Man City are trying to sell Iheanacho and have a buy back clause.

Morata was sold buy Real Madrid to Inter Milan and they had a €20m buy back clause. Brought him back and sold him for £60m to United.

Everton bought a player from Barca they inserted a buy back clause and then bought him back and I think are selling him on.

It's not even that these clubs want the player back. Sometimes they do but also sometimes they just want the buying club to finish the player before they take them back and turn a bigger profit.

If that's not using smaller clubs as proxy feeder clubs I don't know what is.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 25 Jul 17 8.24pm

Originally posted by Painter

Could you give a current example of this in practice, the clubs and player involved.
Its seems no different than a sell on %, if the buying club sells the player in the future.
Football finances are not used in the real world ie if you buy a property and sell it in the future, I have never heard of the seller giving the previous owner a % of the sale.

Actually, selling property and recoup8ng a % of an increase in value where planning consent is secured is quite common. They are called overage clauses. You make the buyer do all the work but both sides benefit if the clause is well drafted.

Likewise, if this provision is properly drafted, why shouldn't we do ok? Say the clause doesnt bite for 3 years and he is the nuts. We get a brilliant player on an extended "loan" and get 50% of what we paid back. Who says he will continue to be that good. And how else would we secure a player who is that good and has that much experience in this league for such a young age for such a price in this crazy market?

The ideal thing, of course, is to stay in this league, continue to grow, develop a well stocked academy and thus become a club that makes use of these provisions.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 25 Jul 17 8.26pm

This is a growing (and worrying) trend. TBH I don't think it will stop (or decline) until there are limits put on the amount of players in the professional leagues that you can have out on loan.

This would curb some of the hoovering up of young talent.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Jul 17 8.33pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Assuming your asking for example of buy back deals..

Man City are trying to sell Iheanacho and have a buy back clause.

Morata was sold buy Real Madrid to Inter Milan and they had a €20m buy back clause. Brought him back and sold him for £60m to United.

Everton bought a player from Barca they inserted a buy back clause and then bought him back and I think are selling him on.

It's not even that these clubs want the player back. Sometimes they do but also sometimes they just want the buying club to finish the player before they take them back and turn a bigger profit.

If that's not using smaller clubs as proxy feeder clubs I don't know what is.

If a club is desperate enough to sign a deal on that basis, well its up to them. Football has a lot of desperate Chairmen, without enough money!

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 8.59pm

Originally posted by Painter

If a club is desperate enough to sign a deal on that basis, well its up to them. Football has a lot of desperate Chairmen, without enough money!

Yeah but that's my point, if they're allowed to buy unlimited amounts of academy players then surely this forces some clubs to go back to them as they aren't able to nurture those players in the first place.

Its all very well saying you don't have to deal win them, but if the buy a zillion teenagers then you have no choice.

It's not cricket.

 

chateauferret Flag 25 Jul 17 9.04pm

These clauses work out OK if you have a decent disguise artist and an acting coach in the backroom team. Stick a false tache on Mutch and shove him in a taxi. Problem Solved.

 


============
The Ferret
============

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 25 Jul 17 9.07pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Yeah but that's my point, if they're allowed to buy unlimited amounts of academy players then surely this forces some clubs to go back to them as they aren't able to nurture those players in the first place.

Its all very well saying you don't have to deal win them, but if the buy a zillion teenagers then you have no choice.

It's not cricket.

Their players will always have a value, like how did Chelsea get 6m for bamford after not even featuring for the club.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 25 Jul 17 10.00pm

Worked well for us with Wilf.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 10.08pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Worked well for us with Wilf.

If Wilf gets sold we pay united a sell on fee which is completely different to a buy back clause.

Unless I've missed your point?

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 25 Jul 17 10.10pm

A buyback clause, is a clause inserted into a player contract that would mean the selling club would have first refusal at a nominated price.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 25 Jul 17 10.29pm

Another idea would be that the FA say that if you insert a buy back clause it has to be for at least double the original transfer price.

So the more the selling club asks up front potentially, the more they pay down the line.

Way fairer than the current system so no chance of it happening!

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Buy Back Clause