You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Socialism in action
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Socialism in action


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
derben Flag 12 Jun 15 8.11am

[Link]

"Better to kill an innocent by mistake than spare an enemy by mistake." (Comrade Pol Pot)

 

DanH Flag SW2 12 Jun 15 9.28am

Yes, well done. Use a human tragedy for petty political point scoring on a football message board.

Congratulations, you've won Friday.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jun 15 9.49am

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 8.11am

[Link]

"Better to kill an innocent by mistake than spare an enemy by mistake." (Comrade Pol Pot)

And which country acted to liberate Cambodia from Pol Pot? Wasn't it the US that ensured that a representative of the Khmer Rouge sat on the UN for Cambodia until 1993. The US in the 80s also pressured Thailand into providing safe haven for Khmer Rouge guerillas as a 'national liberation' movement. Finally the CIA was equipping the KPNLF and ANS, allies of the Khmer Rouge, knowing full well that they were in turn selling those arms onto the Khmer Rouge guerillas.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 12 Jun 15 10.00am

and in the early 1980's Margaret Thatcher's government (extreme left wingers in the OP's political spectrum?) sent an SAS team to help train Khmer Rouge guerillas.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Jun 15 10.45am

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 8.11am

[Link]

"Better to kill an innocent by mistake than spare an enemy by mistake." (Comrade Pol Pot)


Someone else on here used to bring up pol pot quite a lot...

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jun 15 10.50am

Quote nickgusset at 12 Jun 2015 10.45am

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 8.11am

[Link]

"Better to kill an innocent by mistake than spare an enemy by mistake." (Comrade Pol Pot)


Someone else on here used to bring up pol pot quite a lot...

It's tough kid, but its life.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 15 11.37am

Socialism doesn't work......No pun intended.

All systems are failures to a greater or lesser extent.....The profit motive of capitalism works but it has to be regulated to avoid its inherent excess and unfairness.

Any system that insulates those with money from losing it isn't a meritocracy and that's what we have now.

We are back to the complete 'rule by elites'.....Except now they are financial elites instead of aristocracy....Now they don't have the easy to mock accents.

But they are ruling all the same.

Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jun 2015 12.04pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jun 15 11.48am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Jun 2015 11.37am

Socialism doesn't work......No pun intended.

All systems are failures to a greater or lesser extent.....The profit motive of capitalism works but it has to be regulated to avoid its inherent excess and unfairness.

Any system that insulates those with money from losing it isn't a meritocracy and that's what we have now.

We are back to the complete 'rule by elites'.....Except now their are financial instead of aristocracy....Now they don't have the easy to mock accents.

But they are ruling all the same.

One could argue that it does work, in that it provides the means by which those regulations and inhibitors of capitalism have come about, and the basis on which that fairness stems. By and large, capitalism has only really proceeded on the basis of compromises made with socialism (capitalism is very good at co-opting models of opposition and criticism into it).

The problem with socialism tends to be it sees capitalist systems as redundant and devoid of value, which is untrue, capitalism has many benefits notably in the capacity to determine value of resources in relation.

Of course its worth noting that in countries where socialism has occurred, it has done so because of the failure of capitalism in the first place. The failure of Russian capitalism to deal with the problems of Russia ultimately led to the Revolutions in Russia.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 12 Jun 15 11.57am

Seriously guys. Sometimes I wonder if scoring points against the "other side" is more important than your principles.

This sort of Internet "sport" is the new Battleships I suppose.

 

Hoof Hearted 12 Jun 15 12.00pm

I'm having a Pol Pot Noodle for lunch....

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Jun 15 12.09pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Jun 2015 11.48am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Jun 2015 11.37am

Socialism doesn't work......No pun intended.

All systems are failures to a greater or lesser extent.....The profit motive of capitalism works but it has to be regulated to avoid its inherent excess and unfairness.

Any system that insulates those with money from losing it isn't a meritocracy and that's what we have now.

We are back to the complete 'rule by elites'.....Except now their are financial instead of aristocracy....Now they don't have the easy to mock accents.

But they are ruling all the same.

One could argue that it does work, in that it provides the means by which those regulations and inhibitors of capitalism have come about, and the basis on which that fairness stems. By and large, capitalism has only really proceeded on the basis of compromises made with socialism (capitalism is very good at co-opting models of opposition and criticism into it).

The problem with socialism tends to be it sees capitalist systems as redundant and devoid of value, which is untrue, capitalism has many benefits notably in the capacity to determine value of resources in relation.

Of course its worth noting that in countries where socialism has occurred, it has done so because of the failure of capitalism in the first place. The failure of Russian capitalism to deal with the problems of Russia ultimately led to the Revolutions in Russia.



I wouldn't disagree with any of that.

Socialism may not work well as a fully implemented system but it definitely has an important role is modifying capitalism so that in fact we have a combination of the two.

Kind of Red Toryism

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

derben Flag 12 Jun 15 12.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Jun 2015 9.49am

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 8.11am

[Link]

"Better to kill an innocent by mistake than spare an enemy by mistake." (Comrade Pol Pot)

And which country acted to liberate Cambodia from Pol Pot? Wasn't it the US that ensured that a representative of the Khmer Rouge sat on the UN for Cambodia until 1993. The US in the 80s also pressured Thailand into providing safe haven for Khmer Rouge guerillas as a 'national liberation' movement. Finally the CIA was equipping the KPNLF and ANS, allies of the Khmer Rouge, knowing full well that they were in turn selling those arms onto the Khmer Rouge guerillas.


Thought it would all be the wicked USA's fault, yet again.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jun 15 12.32pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 12 Jun 2015 12.00pm

I'm having a Pol Pot Noodle for lunch....

The diet version has Year Zero calories


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

derben Flag 12 Jun 15 12.33pm

Quote DanH at 12 Jun 2015 9.28am

Yes, well done. Use a human tragedy for petty political point scoring on a football message board.

Congratulations, you've won Friday.

Ok for the likes of Nick to do it constantly though?


Edited by derben (12 Jun 2015 12.36pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jun 15 12.33pm

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 11.57am

Seriously guys. Sometimes I wonder if scoring points against the "other side" is more important than your principles.

This sort of Internet "sport" is the new Battleships I suppose.

Is that a point scored?


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

derben Flag 12 Jun 15 12.34pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 12 Jun 2015 11.48am

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Jun 2015 11.37am

Socialism doesn't work......No pun intended.

All systems are failures to a greater or lesser extent.....The profit motive of capitalism works but it has to be regulated to avoid its inherent excess and unfairness.

Any system that insulates those with money from losing it isn't a meritocracy and that's what we have now.

We are back to the complete 'rule by elites'.....Except now their are financial instead of aristocracy....Now they don't have the easy to mock accents.

But they are ruling all the same.

One could argue that it does work, in that it provides the means by which those regulations and inhibitors of capitalism have come about, and the basis on which that fairness stems. By and large, capitalism has only really proceeded on the basis of compromises made with socialism (capitalism is very good at co-opting models of opposition and criticism into it).

The problem with socialism tends to be it sees capitalist systems as redundant and devoid of value, which is untrue, capitalism has many benefits notably in the capacity to determine value of resources in relation.

Of course its worth noting that in countries where socialism has occurred, it has done so because of the failure of capitalism in the first place. The failure of Russian capitalism to deal with the problems of Russia ultimately led to the Revolutions in Russia.


Yes, one could argue it, but a look at history shows that it always fails.

 

derben Flag 12 Jun 15 1.35pm

The point is, you would think that the likes of tux, nick and legal, would surely think that the Socialist policies of the Khmer Rouge are just what was needed, and is indeed needed here now.

Their Socialist regime stated that Cambodia should be a classless society of "perfect harmony" and that private ownership was "the source of egoist feelings and consequently social injustices." (Could be tux, nick or legal speaking). They made Cambodia a cashless nation; the government confiscated all currency. Shops closed, and workers received their pay in the form of food rations, because there was no money in circulation. The economic life described by foreign diplomats, by Western visitors, and by Cambodian refugees in Thai, state that Phnom Penh became a ghost town of only about 10,000 people. There were no shops, post offices, telephones, or telegraph services. Frequent shortages of water and of electricity occurred in all urban areas.

Yet this total state control of absolutely everything is just what tux, nick and legal pine after. Surely their policies should have ushered in a glorious, egalitarian new age?

I don't know if they had an NHS, but as they arrested, tortured and eventually killed all professionals and intellectuals, I guess there must have been a shortage of doctors. Almost everyone with an education, people who understood a foreign language and even people who required glasses (which, according to the regime, meant that they spent too much time reading books instead of working) were purged.

But of course, we will now be told it was all the fault of the USA and the wicked Capitalists. If it wasn't for them, Comrade Pol Pot, would have built a utopia; after all his economic strategy was Socialist to the core.

Edited by derben (12 Jun 2015 1.37pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 12 Jun 15 2.02pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 1.35pm

The point is, you would think that the likes of tux, nick and legal, would surely think that the Socialist policies of the Khmer Rouge are just what was needed, and is indeed needed here now.

Their Socialist regime stated that Cambodia should be a classless society of "perfect harmony" and that private ownership was "the source of egoist feelings and consequently social injustices." (Could be tux, nick or legal speaking). They made Cambodia a cashless nation; the government confiscated all currency. Shops closed, and workers received their pay in the form of food rations, because there was no money in circulation. The economic life described by foreign diplomats, by Western visitors, and by Cambodian refugees in Thai, state that Phnom Penh became a ghost town of only about 10,000 people. There were no shops, post offices, telephones, or telegraph services. Frequent shortages of water and of electricity occurred in all urban areas.

Yet this total state control of absolutely everything is just what tux, nick and legal pine after. Surely their policies should have ushered in a glorious, egalitarian new age?

I don't know if they had an NHS, but as they arrested, tortured and eventually killed all professionals and intellectuals, I guess there must have been a shortage of doctors. Almost everyone with an education, people who understood a foreign language and even people who required glasses (which, according to the regime, meant that they spent too much time reading books instead of working) were purged.

But of course, we will now be told it was all the fault of the USA and the wicked Capitalists. If it wasn't for them, Comrade Pol Pot, would have built a utopia; after all his economic strategy was Socialist to the core.

Edited by derben (12 Jun 2015 1.37pm)


Blimey. That's an olympian level of "bonkerness".

Quite apart from the fact that TUX, N Gusset and I do not share identical views (other than firmly not agreeing with your's,I suspect ) ,your point is about as rational as suggesting that, since your views (leave where you live if people of a different religion or ethnicity,or race or move in),placing you as a "rightist" ,means you should surely be an admirer of Hitler and his regime and all their works and actions.

Edited by legaleagle (12 Jun 2015 2.14pm)

 

derben Flag 12 Jun 15 2.13pm

Quote legaleagle at 12 Jun 2015 2.02pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 1.35pm

The point is, you would think that the likes of tux, nick and legal, would surely think that the Socialist policies of the Khmer Rouge are just what was needed, and is indeed needed here now.

Their Socialist regime stated that Cambodia should be a classless society of "perfect harmony" and that private ownership was "the source of egoist feelings and consequently social injustices." (Could be tux, nick or legal speaking). They made Cambodia a cashless nation; the government confiscated all currency. Shops closed, and workers received their pay in the form of food rations, because there was no money in circulation. The economic life described by foreign diplomats, by Western visitors, and by Cambodian refugees in Thai, state that Phnom Penh became a ghost town of only about 10,000 people. There were no shops, post offices, telephones, or telegraph services. Frequent shortages of water and of electricity occurred in all urban areas.

Yet this total state control of absolutely everything is just what tux, nick and legal pine after. Surely their policies should have ushered in a glorious, egalitarian new age?

I don't know if they had an NHS, but as they arrested, tortured and eventually killed all professionals and intellectuals, I guess there must have been a shortage of doctors. Almost everyone with an education, people who understood a foreign language and even people who required glasses (which, according to the regime, meant that they spent too much time reading books instead of working) were purged.

But of course, we will now be told it was all the fault of the USA and the wicked Capitalists. If it wasn't for them, Comrade Pol Pot, would have built a utopia; after all his economic strategy was Socialist to the core.

Edited by derben (12 Jun 2015 1.37pm)


Blimey. Thats an olympian level of "bonkerness".

Actually,I agree (shock horror!) with what the Judge posted.Do you Derben?

Absolutely, sums up nick very well.

So you don't agree that we should be a classless society and that private ownership is a source of social injustices?

 

legaleagle Flag 12 Jun 15 2.16pm

If you'd ever actually read my prior posts, you'd know I'm a good old Attlee-style social democrat, but don't let that stand in your way,my blinkered friend

Off now

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Socialism in action