You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 11 of 44 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >
7mins Flag In the bush 07 Dec 16 3.37pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Quelle surprise.... yet more childish insults in response to my backing of your Industry Regulators position as opposed to your random reasons.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (07 Dec 2016 11.24am)

Random reasons?

Let's not forget... you said guards are obsolete then admitted you didn't know what they're trained to do!

You're a old proud man, you probably are the man of the house, dinner on the table when you get home, kids are seen and not heard... this has meant you're not used to having your views challenged. If ya chat s***, expect to be called out on it. Every days a school day Hoof... we never stop learning.

Knowledge is power, after your first post I realised you were out of your depth.

Back on topic:

Been told court case is key... Southern have a plan if the case doesn't go their way.

My 2 cents is... they will let drivers strike once... if it's a good turn out they'll negotiate. If enough cross the line, they will try to break the strike.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Dec 16 3.41pm

Although 94% voted for action, I would guess by the turn out, that about 170 drivers didn't vote

 

Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 07 Dec 16 4.04pm

I reckon the drivers will be offered an offer of an 5k+ pay increase to accept the Doo plan, what ever the outcome of the High court case they'll be a lot of pain for us travelers

All I know is the atmosphere working for Southern in almost all depts has gone thro the floor from being a good ish company to work for to a totally shlt one.


Edited by Barcelona Based Fan (07 Dec 2016 4.06pm)

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

Hoof Hearted 07 Dec 16 4.55pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Random reasons?

Let's not forget... you said guards are obsolete then admitted you didn't know what they're trained to do!

You're a old proud man, you probably are the man of the house, dinner on the table when you get home, kids are seen and not heard... this has meant you're not used to having your views challenged. If ya chat s***, expect to be called out on it. Every days a school day Hoof... we never stop learning.

Knowledge is power, after your first post I realised you were out of your depth.

Back on topic:

Been told court case is key... Southern have a plan if the case doesn't go their way.

My 2 cents is... they will let drivers strike once... if it's a good turn out they'll negotiate. If enough cross the line, they will try to break the strike.


Wrong yet again.... show me where I said I did not know what guards do onboard trains.

You have been asserting that notion (with your ridiculous test using acronyms for tasks that you wanted me to comment on) whereas I have steadfastly supported the view of your Regulatory body that Guards are not needed to control the doors and trains would run better under DOO.... and I have provided a link to that report as well.

If that is how you interpret messages at work, it is no surprise that your Industry has big problems.

As for your assumptions about me, my lifestyle and behaviour.... well.... you are pretty wide of the mark again.

I guess every day really is a school day for you and I pity you wearing short trousers in winter time... your imaginary world of being senior management in the Rail Industry is a nice dream to have when you've left school.

Grow up, stop making things up and listen to those people more qualified than you - starting with your regulatory body who have listened to all sides of the argument and have published their findings.

As I keep saying I am only quoting the findings of an Independent body more qualified than you, or RMT and I cannot understand why this upsets you so much.

Have you tried counselling or an anger management course?

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Dec 16 5.57pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted


Wrong yet again.... show me where I said I did not know what guards do onboard trains.

You have been asserting that notion (with your ridiculous test using acronyms for tasks that you wanted me to comment on) whereas I have steadfastly supported the view of your Regulatory body that Guards are not needed to control the doors and trains would run better under DOO.... and I have provided a link to that report as well.

If that is how you interpret messages at work, it is no surprise that your Industry has big problems.

As for your assumptions about me, my lifestyle and behaviour.... well.... you are pretty wide of the mark again.

I guess every day really is a school day for you and I pity you wearing short trousers in winter time... your imaginary world of being senior management in the Rail Industry is a nice dream to have when you've left school.

Grow up, stop making things up and listen to those people more qualified than you - starting with your regulatory body who have listened to all sides of the argument and have published their findings.

As I keep saying I am only quoting the findings of an Independent body more qualified than you, or RMT and I cannot understand why this upsets you so much.

Have you tried counselling or an anger management course?

Name the safety procedures guards are trained in?


Simple question... If you don't answer... You leave me with no choice but to think you're a thick old man.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Dec 16 6.10pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

That was the 60's.

You have proved my point - A guard is as much use as balls on the Pope.

We now have a system that actually closes the doors and ensures that they stay shut.

They don't rely on some fat 55 year old w*nker in a uniform with shiny arsed trousers and egg down his tie to "oversee" matters from his Guards van (whereas we all knew he was doing fcuk all! ).

And as for your examples above.... how would the Guard have spotted these and dealt with them?

He wouldn't have.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (04 Dec 2016 11.31am)

Hmmmm

This doesn't seem to be the view of a regulatory board. This seems to be your nasty point of view.. You silly old man

 

Hoof Hearted 07 Dec 16 6.55pm

This is hilarious.... I've really rattled your cage.

I now am pretty certain that I'm dealing with a disgruntled guard here!

Your communication skills are nowhere near sharp enough for you to be a senior manager at MacDonalds, let alone a TOC.

Be honest I got under your skin with my first post saying you were talking bollocks. You know it I know it.

I don't think you are ever going to back down as your pride has been hurt and I represent every thing you hate.

I won't be back on here till the morning, so fill your boots with your next response..... I shall look forward to reading it after a good night's sleep.

Don't have nightmares about me.....

Oooooohhhhhhhh..........BOO!

The Nasty Old Man
X

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 07 Dec 16 7.08pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted


Wrong yet again.... show me where I said I did not know what guards do onboard trains.

You have been asserting that notion (with your ridiculous test using acronyms for tasks that you wanted me to comment on) whereas I have steadfastly supported the view of your Regulatory body that Guards are not needed to control the doors and trains would run better under DOO.... and I have provided a link to that report as well.

If that is how you interpret messages at work, it is no surprise that your Industry has big problems.

As for your assumptions about me, my lifestyle and behaviour.... well.... you are pretty wide of the mark again.

I guess every day really is a school day for you and I pity you wearing short trousers in winter time... your imaginary world of being senior management in the Rail Industry is a nice dream to have when you've left school.

Grow up, stop making things up and listen to those people more qualified than you - starting with your regulatory body who have listened to all sides of the argument and have published their findings.

As I keep saying I am only quoting the findings of an Independent body more qualified than you, or RMT and I cannot understand why this upsets you so much.

Have you tried counselling or an anger management course?

To be fair, he has explained what the acronym means.
You keep banging on about independent research but I bet you wailed when independent judges were picked for the current Brexit case.

You complain of childishness yet call one poster 'japseye' which if you'd followed matthews tete a tetes with me you would know is insulting to those of Japanese origin.

Is he making things up? Really. Standard fingers in ears la la la I can't hear you I don't believe you stuff.

You need to raise your game.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 07 Dec 16 7.33pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

To be fair, he has explained what the acronym means.
You keep banging on about independent research but I bet you wailed when independent judges were picked for the current Brexit case.

You complain of childishness yet call one poster 'japseye' which if you'd followed matthews tete a tetes with me you would know is insulting to those of Japanese origin.

Is he making things up? Really. Standard fingers in ears la la la I can't hear you I don't believe you stuff.

You need to raise your game.

Cheers Nick.
I'm a convert, hated unions.,. Then got out of HR and realised they do so much for the common man. Really wish everyone was in a union.

 

IMpalace Flag London 07 Dec 16 10.06pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Name the safety procedures guards are trained in?


Simple question... If you don't answer... You leave me with no choice but to think you're a thick old man.

Surely you realise the general public are not going to know this level of detail. That doesn't mean we're automatically ruled out of having an opinion or that that opinion is by definition wrong.

An independently appointed regulatory body has said this is safe. Employees of the business decide it isn't and strike leaving the public stuck and unable to travel on a monopolised transport route for months and months.

If nothing else can you see why the public are extremely frustrated with those striking? Can you see why striking over safety concerns which an independent regulator doesn't recognise appears like bollo*ks to those on the outside?

 

7mins Flag In the bush 08 Dec 16 5.25am

Originally posted by IMpalace

Surely you realise the general public are not going to know this level of detail. That doesn't mean we're automatically ruled out of having an opinion or that that opinion is by definition wrong.

An independently appointed regulatory body has said this is safe. Employees of the business decide it isn't and strike leaving the public stuck and unable to travel on a monopolised transport route for months and months.

If nothing else can you see why the public are extremely frustrated with those striking? Can you see why striking over safety concerns which an independent regulator doesn't recognise appears like bollo*ks to those on the outside?

Loads of sympathy for the public, and I don't expect them to know the inner workings of the railway. If this isn't about safety, what else is it about? Two different departments have now voted to strike, and turned down ££££'s in bonus payments to accept changes. Southern have gone to court when they should have gone ACAS.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 08 Dec 16 5.59am

Strike Strike Strike.....

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 08 Dec 16 7.50am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Strike Strike Strike.....

Yes. A general one.

 

Hoof Hearted 08 Dec 16 9.54am

Originally posted by nickgusset

To be fair, he has explained what the acronym means.
You keep banging on about independent research but I bet you wailed when independent judges were picked for the current Brexit case.

You complain of childishness yet call one poster 'japseye' which if you'd followed matthews tete a tetes with me you would know is insulting to those of Japanese origin.

Is he making things up? Really. Standard fingers in ears la la la I can't hear you I don't believe you stuff.

You need to raise your game.

You need to butt out... there are moderators to ensure fair play and limit abuse.... but as usual you ignore your own failings and only comment upon instances that go against your union agenda.

Yes he is/was making stuff up and he upped the ante on the level of abuse so I upped my game... and I will continue to if he wants to play that game.

as for Jap's eye... he has been sniping away at me and others on multiple threads and deserves the abuse back quite frankly.

 

Hoof Hearted 08 Dec 16 9.59am

Originally posted by IMpalace

Surely you realise the general public are not going to know this level of detail. That doesn't mean we're automatically ruled out of having an opinion or that that opinion is by definition wrong.

An independently appointed regulatory body has said this is safe. Employees of the business decide it isn't and strike leaving the public stuck and unable to travel on a monopolised transport route for months and months.

If nothing else can you see why the public are extremely frustrated with those striking? Can you see why striking over safety concerns which an independent regulator doesn't recognise appears like bollocks to those on the outside?

EXACTLY the points and conclusions I have made repeatedly in this thread.

Surprised that you were let off without a torrent of childish abuse for suggesting it.... LOL

 

Ted the eagle Flag Waddon 08 Dec 16 10.13am

How the feck are 25,000 bods supposed to get to/from Selhurst next Wednesday night? Madness.

 

npn Flag Crowborough 08 Dec 16 12.37pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Yes. A general one.

Really? Can you explain why?

Given that 7mins has been defending his point of view on the back of clearly having knowledge of the industry, why do you propose postmen, for instance, should go on strike in support of a dispute they don't understand? Fundamentally it would be "we are going on strike because our friends have asked us to" which carries no merit at all, and smacks of just "sticking it to the man" for the sake of it.

I'm a Southern commuter, and just want it over - I really don't care who 'wins'. Southern are a crock of sh*t, but then I certainly see the argument for "why should we cancel a service because the guard is sick / stuck elsewhere, when the driver could do the doors, so he's not actually required to do anything on a normal journey"

Edit: just for clarity - I accept the safety argument, but as someone stated, we compromise safety in every walk of life every day, which is why we don't have a guard on every carriage or a fire station on every street. I don't know enough to know when an acceptable risk becomes an unacceptable one. That's just to caveat the idea of running a train without a guard in exceptional circumstances (i.e. when the guards are on strike, or when a particular guard has called in sick or been unable to meet the correct train)

Edited by npn (08 Dec 2016 12.43pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 08 Dec 16 1.37pm

Originally posted by npn

Really? Can you explain why?

Given that 7mins has been defending his point of view on the back of clearly having knowledge of the industry, why do you propose postmen, for instance, should go on strike in support of a dispute they don't understand? Fundamentally it would be "we are going on strike because our friends have asked us to" which carries no merit at all, and smacks of just "sticking it to the man" for the sake of it.

I'm a Southern commuter, and just want it over - I really don't care who 'wins'. Southern are a crock of sh*t, but then I certainly see the argument for "why should we cancel a service because the guard is sick / stuck elsewhere, when the driver could do the doors, so he's not actually required to do anything on a normal journey"

Edit: just for clarity - I accept the safety argument, but as someone stated, we compromise safety in every walk of life every day, which is why we don't have a guard on every carriage or a fire station on every street. I don't know enough to know when an acceptable risk becomes an unacceptable one. That's just to caveat the idea of running a train without a guard in exceptional circumstances (i.e. when the guards are on strike, or when a particular guard has called in sick or been unable to meet the correct train)

Edited by npn (08 Dec 2016 12.43pm)

I may have had my tongue in my cheek.

 

Barcelona Based Fan Flag No longer Barcelona, now living in... 08 Dec 16 3.22pm


Aslef news


Mick Whelan, general secretary of ASLEF, the train drivers' union, has written to the Daily Telegraph today in response to a piece the paper published written by Nick Herbert, Tory MP for Arundel & South Downs.

Mr Herbert seeks to blame everyone for the failings of Southern Railways except those who are really to blame – the management team at the company, known to long-suffering passengers as Southern Failways.

We have done our best to reach a sensible and workable compromise with Southern in the interests of passengers and management) as well as of staff. We have always been happy to talk, and we have always believed it is, or should be, possible to do a deal – just as we did with ScotRail in Scotland –­ but it takes two to tango and the company has never been prepared to negotiate with us.

Because the company cares only about profit, and not about passengers. The company knows, as we know,that there are serious problems with the platform/train interface and that DOO,on these lines, is inherently unsafe.

It has been our policy for more than 15 years to try to eradicate driver only operation. DOO is old, not new, technology, designed for four-car 317s on the Bedford to St Pancras line in the early 1980s when it was all about managed decline at the fag end of British Rail. But an increase in the number of passengers we are carrying on the railway every day means there are 1,100 passengers on a 12 car train in peak travelling time and just two seconds to check 24 sets of doors and that’s simply not adequate to deal safely and properly with the travelling public.

 


TaxiMark
Sheffield Wednesday Fan
Posted 23 February 2013 - 07:49 PM
I don't mind palace to be fair. Much better club than tinpot Charlton and Brighton

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 08 Dec 16 3.28pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

You need to butt out... there are moderators to ensure fair play and limit abuse.... but as usual you ignore your own failings and only comment upon instances that go against your union agenda.

Yes he is/was making stuff up and he upped the ante on the level of abuse so I upped my game... and I will continue to if he wants to play that game.

as for Jap's eye... he has been sniping away at me and others on multiple threads and deserves the abuse back quite frankly.


I don't need to butt out. It's a public forum. If you don't want people to call your views to account on a public forum, then use the PM system.

Blimey, can't raise a point on a forum. Are these the sort of British Values you hanker after?

 

Page 11 of 44 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong